{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Anyone work at both MBB and Big 4 in their career (i.e. the McDeloitte combo)? How drastically different was the average level of talent? Were there any dumb McK's you thought would struggle at McD's?", "post_id": "5d9d32c3721343001c9457df", "reply_count": 3, "vote_count": 2, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting" }

Anyone work at both MBB and Big 4 in their career (i.e. the McDeloitte combo)? How drastically different was the average level of talent? Were there any dumb McK's you thought would struggle at McD's?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Extremely different (in my humble and personal experience). I haven’t met anyone dumb in BCG yet - but quite a few at PwC. That being said, although PwC variance is much higher, the top brass is the same calibre

like

(And by same calibre I would clarify as top at PwC = top at BCG, and happens across tenure)

like

Related Posts

We all know consulting/advisory jobs in big 4 and mbb are tough and high burn ones. Expectations of high stress and long working hours are there. Why would people still want to work and stay in those jobs and expecting the companies to bend with their low stress tolerance.

like

Have any B4 new hires been able to use the $300 WFH credit that all other employees got this past year?

like

I see a lot of consultants leaving for FAANG. But if the grass is truly more green, what drives some folks from FAANG to move into consulting? Especially a Big 4…

likefunny

Has anyone made the move from Big 4 to DHG? Care to share about the culture at DHG risk advisory practice?

like

How hard would it be (if even possible) to switch from Big 4 Deal Advisory to MBB? Just started a few months ago and can tell this is not for me long term.

like

How good is your firm at helping you to acquire new technical skills and business knowledge? I am at a big four, and there is 0 appropriate technical training. I have to pick up stuff on the go and honestly feel like an amateur, just pulling solutions out of my ass..I hate to look back and realize how I could’ve produced better quality work. Is MBB like that, as well? Also, most managers and higher are so abstracted from tech that I don’t even know a single good expert to ask for advice

like

How impacted are summer ‘20 internships for current students? Any cancellations or still moving forward at FAANG, F100, and MBB/B4?

likehelpful

I’m a 2nd year Consultant currently with a Big 4 firm. I have been working on my masters (MS, non-MBA) part-time and I will complete it May 2021. If I want to apply to MBB after obtaining my MS, do I have a chance applying as an Associate? Or should I apply as an Analyst?

like

Is part time / exec mba worth pursuing when you are a manager with big 4

like

How bad is EY's technologies? Can people who worked at another big 4 and EY share what you think?

like

MBB is known for fastest progression to Partner in 6-7 years and SIGNIFICANTLY better comp compared to Big 4. That said seeing some of my Big 4 friends make it to SMs in 7 years so MBB needs to amp up the meritocracy based promotions. Curious what would be the comp for a 1st year consulting partner in Big 4?

like

What roles do associates with 2 yoe at MBB exit to when they join FAANG?

like

Fish who exited MBB or T2 into PE, is there any WLB difference? (For better or worse)

like

If Carlyle Group led the spinoff of Booz & Co and left it weak and undercapitalized, who did the DD and strategic plan? Deliberate attempt by MBB to cripple competitor? 🤔 #alt-consulting conspiracy

like

Does MBB, Strategy&, LEK, ATK etc allow rotational programs in different countries (London, UK, etc)? How competitive are those rotations to get into?

likehelpful

ACN S&C 🐠: have you guys also had a pay revision similar to MBB and T2 firms..?

like

MBB associate with undergrad degree in economics. Loved the degree, though didn’t do much with it outside of class (spent summers on internships, didn’t write a thesis). If I want to do something related to economics, how can I best leverage my current background to do so? Would MS in Econ make more sense than an mba? Maybe MS in stats or data science? Does the MBB background help in any way?

like

Currently a 2nd yr audit manager in Dallas, non B4, $110k/yr. Hours are not too bad, but can’t take any more fake and politics from upper management, and have no aspiration to be in leadership group.

like

FAANG good MBB bad, am I doing it right

likefunnyhelpful

Would you jump from Big-4 Manager to MBB Senior Business Analyst level?

like

Additional Posts

EY fish, is it ok to take a week long pre planned vacation 2.5 months into the job? I start on Monday and forgot to mention to the recruiter about this.

like

What % raise should you expect going from AE to SAE?

like

Anyone able to give a referral for a role at LinkedIn?

like

What is the salary for EY-TAS in Toronto? For a senior consultant post MBA?

We all know consulting/advisory jobs in big 4 and mbb are tough and high burn ones. Expectations of high stress and long working hours are there. Why would people still want to work and stay in those jobs and expecting the companies to bend with their low stress tolerance.

like

Top consulting firms hiring right now?

like

Hi - any suggestions for a counselor who can do remote sessions, please? Someone who can guide me understand myself a little better and put me on a path to improve confidence.

like
like

What is the best books and resources about tracking advertising return of investment for restaurants?

like

Hi I’m pregnant and due in august. I’m scheduled for the vaccine in two days and reading about (1) the side effects with the second dose and (2) lack of testing for those who are pregnant has me nervous about potential effects to my baby. Any thoughts on whether to get/not get the vaccine? Already consulting my doctor on this but figured y’all might be good to ask, as well.

like

Hello I am working in indiàn healthcare insurance sector looking for refferal in healthcare consulting company.

like
like

Hi! We are looking for Account Supervisor and Director level candidates in NY or LA. Agency experience required and experiential and digital content experience are a plus. We are remote for time being. If you’re interested pls dm me for more details!

like

What are some of the best mid-cd level AD portfolios you've seen lately?

like

Doing a technical interview for a transactions group involving SQL and Power BI. I've brushed up on the two, but wondering if anyone has suggestions for practice cases or practical applications? Any sample cases would be very helpful, thank you in advance

like

Seeking advice for moving from industry leadership role (dr of training) into HC consulting. 20+ years in TD (L&D, PC, OCM). Industry roles for last 5 years but spent most of my career in small consulting orgs. CPTD but no degree (long story, about 15 cr shy). Would you suggest addl cert (CCMP, SHRM-C)? Will the lack of degree a no-go or is there a way in while I finish? A Sr director role is being dangled. Would the title bump help with the transition or do I risk missing a hot market?

like

2 days in London. Any Marriott recommendations and must do things ?

like

Have any B4 new hires been able to use the $300 WFH credit that all other employees got this past year?

like

Does anyone here work in tech? Looking for a referral to a Finance or Business Operations role.

like

How valuable is the AWS cloud practitioner and AWS solution architect certifications if I’m coming from a consulting role where it wasn’t applied much practically, even though company is Health IT . I have a high technical aptitude but I’m wondering how much weight do they hold as far as new opportunities if I haven’t used them in work but understand them well enough to speak through the information and pass the certs. Any insight is helpful only been in a consulting 1.5 yr and want to expand

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal