McKinsey & Company Could someone who worked at both McKinsey and BCG let me know what the differences between both companies are (e.g., working mode, culture, staffing), please?McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Had offers at both, chose McK. Know people at both, did really extensive research as well. Here is why I chose McK.

1) Staffing: McKinsey has global staffing BCG has regional, meaning I can much more easily work on another coast or in another country than a BCGer - in fact I’ve done both of those many times and it is just as easy as being staffed in my local city. This also adds a second benefit in my opinion which is that because it is so easy for me to choose any study anywhere, managers/partners are forced to be really good to their junior people because it is so easy to select against them.
2) Promo Speed: We get promoted faster from the undergrad level (BA—>EM in ~2.5 years vs A—>PL in ~4 years), and there’s also a small differential in path to equity partner (BCG you have to do principal —> partner —> MDP vs McK just AP —> Partner, which is a roughly 6 month difference in average timing). So, overall 2 years average faster path to partner at McK (~7 years vs ~9 years)
3) Firm Thought Leadership: this is more subjective, but I have close friends at BCG and we compare notes and it appears our supporting resources/thought leadership is much better.
4) Brand: just overall a tad better, no argument there obv
5)Less commercial emphasis: McK has a super strict anti-selling culture, the word “sell” itself is taboo here, whereas BCG is much more focused on “how much meat you bring to the table.” Not super important to everyone but I appreciate this.
6)Firm revenue composition: we have conscientiously trended less deep into the realm of PMO/implementation than BCG has, and that might be noteworthy for someone who is really interested in strategy. When we do, I tend to think we also silo it away from our core consulting team better.

In terms of cons for McK:
1) Amount of work: I tend to think we work ~a little~ harder but it isn’t massive, it’s only really super noticeable compared to my friends in GP at Bain.
2) Hardos: It seems like we overall are the place to go for the extreme hardos who live and die by their work, which isn’t bad necessarily, but you can assume that more “chillers” would prefer Bain over us and thus go there, and the inverse for hardos. I don’t mind at all and think 95%+ of us are super friendly, but worth noting.

likehelpfulfunny

I agree more with B4, and in small parts with B2 - on pay transparency. Other than that, I don’t recognize any of the comments by B2. It appears like a different firm (and that’s not bad; I just don’t recognize any to be accurate in my experience). But also acknowledge that the true picture is the median of our collective experiences. So none of us is wrong. I would not even know “eat what you kill” as an MBB expression so I am surprised at this usage.

like

One tidbit to add to get things started:

At McKinsey, you need to network for your own engagement. Not so at BCG

Source: idk, I don't work at either. Just what I've heard from the people I've talked to at both

funnylikesmart

It’s part of the “preference-based staffing model”

Well one sells opioids and the other one is full of nerds

likefunny

Just wanted to comment on regional vs global staffing. As a former MBB myself, this is a topic that makes sence to adress more holistically than just based on the fact "which countries do I want to see". Typically your projects are your chance to position yourself with partners you work with, so ensure that those partners who are relevant to your development process are covered

like

Never worked at McK, but from the people I know who did those differences are relatively marginal compared to office culture and home city.

If you have offers from both I'd say you should either optimize for 1) pathing for a specific exit, or 2) who you vibed with more in interviews.

like

I’d be curious in this as well

like

Related Posts

Grant Thornton strives to be “middle of the road” as far as comp from what I’ve heard at recruiting events. True/false?

like

Hi,
I had given tye assessment of Axtria and got selected for the tr round, after that I gave the hr round. It's been 10 days but I haven't heard back from them.
What's the longest that I can wait to receive a reply from them ?

S&P Global Hi Fishes, how much salary can be expected for 12 Y exp guy in proposal management S&P Global Market Intelligence

Pepsico PepsiCo or S&P Global....
Please suggest.
Roles:- Product Analyst - PepsiCo. Product owner - S&P Global India

CTC is very similar

EY Interview - Business Consulting - Technology Risk - Senior

Hello All,
I applied and ended up getting an interview for a Business Consulting Technology Risk Senior interview at EY. I have a call with the recruiter tomorrow to discuss opportunities within the service line. Can you please help if anyone has been through this process? What should I expect in the call tomorrow as well as the process? Is it going to be difficult for me to get the job? I really want it!

Thank you.

like

Hi all, I completed three rounds including hireview test in jpmc and HR has asked for last payslips but post that i haven't heard from them,. Could anyone let me know should I wait for them or they will come back anytime soon

Hello! Does any one have any insight/advice for a McKinsey interview? I have a call with a McK recruiter next week to discuss my background, which will hopefully lead to official interviews. Any advice would be greatly appreciated, I’m new to exploring the mgmt consulting world.

Can someone help me with 6.7 years experience which designation offered at DXC the Hr told me Max he can give is professional level2 and fixed 20LPA that is Max budget for this role...
Please someone guide me if I can negotiate more on this ..

like

What’s the Sal and yoe for level 6 and level 7 in DXC? Any pointers pl

Hi All,

In
EY GDS offer letter it's mentioned consulting service line.

Does anyone know, how is the consulting service line in EY GDS?

Yoe -3.5

Tech stack - SharePoint, power platform developer

EY

like

Hi people, my offer for HERE Technologies seems to be on hold. As per my discussion with hr, in 2-3 weeks I can get the offer itseems. Can anyone confirm on this? Is there any hiring freeze or such kind going in HERE Technologies ?

like

Hello fishes .. can anyone let me know how is @OPTUM Gurgaon and @Mindtree Noida. I have to choose between these two. Please help Optum Mindtree

like
like

So are the layoffs at Deloitte over ?

What's the probation period in LTI?

Hi,
Can anyone suggest the better option between Finastra and HSBC Technologies? Both are for BA payments. From the perspective of a BA which will be the better option to grow and learn?

like

Please tell me how is insurance vertical in coforge@

like

Nagarro or accenture?

like

Hi Fishes,

I wanted to know if project change is smooth in
Nagarro after finishing 1.5years in allotted project.

Also anyone working in good angular/ionic based projects ?

like

More Posts

Has anyone here been able to make keto work with running (20+ miles a week) and a consulting lifestyle? I feel great on keto (kills inflammation) and great when running regularly

like

Rookie question: Can you get ahold of financial information for Canadian and US private companies for light DD/early screening?

like

Is it mandatory to share the PF number when asked by companies along with all required documents?
What are your suggestions.

like
like

Does Deloitte provide cab facility?

like

Can anyone refer me for the post of Business Analyst in @Amazon India
YEO-1.5
CCTC-4.8+bonus

like

Hello,
I am about to finish my notice period working as a SOC L1, yeo 2 please help me with how much I should ask for salary in next company, ctc 4.26 total year of exp 4

like

How is the citi project in virtusa?

My tech stack: Java, spring boot, microservices, react

Is there any framework used ?

Please suggest

Thanks

like

The stress of this job ruined my life.
The stress has lead to an eating disorder that I can’t get control of. I’ve lost 25 pounds since starting at the firm two and a half years ago. I am 20 pounds less than I was in high school... I don’t know how to get control again. Even when the stress lays off I can’t eat more due to being used to being busy for almost 9 months out of the year...

like

I’m looking into cyro banks to bank my eggs for long term storage. Has anyone had any experience with California Cyrobank, Reprotech, or Fairfax Cyrobank?

like

What are some good product based companies to work as Data Engineer?
Good in terms of learning, interesting work and good work culture.

like

Anyone know what TC is approximately for Bus Dev Manager role at DraftKings?

like

IAPP is such trash. Why does everyone recommend getting the CIPP certs when they mean nothing??

like

The turkeys nest is where you find inspiration

like

Hi Fishes,🐠🐟🐬🦈🐳🐋🐡
Let's hear about your journey, how did you land in US/UK/EU/Canada etc. from India? preferably direct hire with Visa sponsorship.
Pls do share company name & country, Job portals.
Also it would be great to hear some do's and don'ts
Hopefully it will help someone who is/are planning for migration and will help him/her to plan better.
TIA

like

How was your tax season?

like

Anybody here a FTB in London, UK?
If so what kind of mortgage rates are you expecting?

Aristocrat or motherson sumi, which one should join ... kindly suggest
Package approximately same

like

Publicis Sapient is hiring for multiple roles please mail you resume or DM for referral
Dikshabhatia201197@gmail.com

Roles:
Big Data
Scala
Java
GCP
AWS
DEVOPS
Azure
Technical Analyst
Performance Engineer
Gatling
Dynatrace
AEM
React
Sterling Developer

like

How many hours do you actually work at job and for interview preparation?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Given the Facebook (Meta) layoffs, how likely is it to have an offer rescinded? Starting in mid June which now seems far away but have an offer from another FAANG (higher TC too). Was going to decline but now I’m worried.

likehelpful

Getting back to the travel is like going for a new job. Can't believe I left my child behind again.

like

Gift ideas for a close guy friend that got promoted to manager?

like

The size of someone's moleskine is the best predictor of their tenure (with an inverse relationship).

like

Anyone ever get an Indochino suit? Thoughts on quality/value?

Any tips from moving out of advisory and into consulting? I've helped with SAP implementation and have my AWS CCP. Really desperate to get out of risk compliance world tbh

like

Any good books or recommendations on sales? Sales tactics trips and tricks?

like

I feel like these “incredible” exit opportunities consulting gives you is only applicable to MBB (i.e, companies only value MBB experience vs others). Any successful exits from Big 4 folk?

like

Good nonfiction book recommendations? What are you all reading?

like

Why is empathy so emphasized for a leader in this digital era?

like

Tried and true methods for getting your girlfriend to give more oral?

like

Considering the FRM certification. Those who’ve taken it, how quant heavy is it? I have a compliance risk background and don’t have a deep math or statistics background. However, I want to expand my skillset. Any thoughts?

like

Looking to get into Facebook privacy legal team. Have experience as a consultant at another FAANG company. Anyone willing to provide a referral or discuss further?

like

Best business-oriented, but novel-style books with good writing, style, & interesting characters? Not really self-help/advise focused, more of actual literature with business themes/plots. Any recs?

like

Any recommendations on books to get up to speed on leading/managing teams as a new manager in consulting? Preference towards tangible case studies etc. vs. high level concepts.

like

Are any top consulting firms hiring for experienced analysts currently? I know ACN and some others are cyclical for resources 2-3 years out of college, but I’m looking to make a move sooner than fall

like

Can you still succeed in your career after getting laid off?

like

So the Russians are hacking our travel companies lol

like

Planning to do a PRM or FRM qual. How useful is it to move from Big 4 Risk and reg consulting to industry? Finding it hard to get anything other than non-PM roles

like

BCG folks, what differentiates you guys from other consulting firms? What do you like best about working there?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal