How do you reinforce your child's good behavior? Sometimes it seems like my kiddo is helping us out solely because he's expecting some kind of reward. When he doesn't get one, he's super grouchy with us. We're really struggling to find a balance.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I listened to audiobook Punished By Rewards by Alfie Kohn. It's really interesting and backed by research. It's worth a read/listen.

The core i got out of it is that extrinsic motivation (rewards/carrot or punishments/stick) doesnt have long term and overall positive results versus intrinsic motivation.

He has examples for children development (his focus area) as well as corporate for adults.

Eg. Kids were given rewards for playing math computer games. The game play increased at first but eventually decreased to less than before the reward was introduced.

Or sales performance quotas for overall company sales. With and without incentives.

I recommend checking out the book

like

Thanks for the recommendation. Downloading now.

like

Maybe try lottery tickets

funny

How old? I have 2 boys under 10. So our rule for reward is that it can’t be: candy, toys, or tv time. We just started a year ago and it’s been amazing but before…it was solely good behavior for one of those 3. Transition suuuucked but it’s been amazing. Usually they want our individual attention apart from their sibling whether is playing chess or basketball or hide/seek.

like

SC1's comment literally brought back a memory of a song I've had in my head as an inner voice since childhood Sunday school. I can't find it on the internet but the lyrics are about doing things because you love each other, not because you want a reward. That's the lesson to teach. Deeds are acts of love for relatives and strangers.

like

Withhold your love from them and give it as a reward.

Ha, seriously though, I have 4 kids between 9 and 5 and I have no idea. I worry about the same thing. They’re little psychopaths unless there is a reward attached.

likefunny

That’s normal behavior. If you do something you expect something in return, do you attend church regularly maybe put them into a Sunday school then you start getting them into the reward of doing the good deed instead of receiving something in return.

like

Age is important context here. When they were little, I talked about how everyone has jobs in the family and our kids jobs were x, y, z. We also tried to set the expectation of helping if they see someone else struggling with a task and then we would reinforce that going the other way (they are struggling so we offer help). Mostly lots of conversation about how we all need to pitch in. When they got older, fussing about not being fished over for doing basic crap was met with a different response: this is what we expect you to do and what you should do to be a good person. You don’t get rewarded for doing the minimum. But that was more of a preteen/teen thing.

like

Sometimes the reward can be as simple as a sincere thank you to a goofy new way of doing a high five.

I'm probably going to get a lot of hate for this...but based on very limited experience with two kids and a cat, I have found that when they are young and you can't really explain things to them verbally, that pavlovian conditioning works really well. Basically, good and bad actions are rewarded or punished as immediately as possible, respectively. All mammalian brains are wired like this, and as long as the reward or punishment comes quickly enough, a natural connection is made.

This helped my kids to learn to always ask for things with please, and respond thank you/you're welcome etc. Also helped me teach my cat how to do tricks - which also brings up another interesting point. Different people(and animals) have varying levels of receptiveness to positive and negative reinforcement. Cats, I've noticed, don't have a great concept of negative reinforcement. Anyway there's no silver bullet here, but this is how I've approached it.

Related Posts

Wiproites anybody joined wipro through a conversion from vendor payroll?how does contract to hire work in wipro?my wife works for wipro, but on 3rd party payroll. She was told by wipro manager that even if her parent company doesnt agree, wipro has the clause to automatically convert contractors into permanent hires. Whats the procedure?pls throw light

like

How to deal with a relationship trauma? Especially when your ex has moved on.

like

My relationship just ended yesterday because he wanted to “focus on myself and figure things out.” My relationship before that ended (~2 years ago) because he wanted to focus on himself. I can’t help but feel like it’s because something is wrong with me. What am I doing wrong?

like

From a financial standpoint in this market, which would be a better approach in Austin -

1. Buy a ~8-850k house that meets most of our ideal criteria (size, schools, interiors etc) to stay long term

2. Buy a ~5-550k house that’s not ideal with the plan of moving into an ideal home in 4-5 years when kid is ready for school.

How easy is it to get a mortgage for the second home?

Household income - 300k

Happy to add more details as needed

Thanks

like

I felt like a walking zombie during thanksgiving, barely eating and barely talking. My family is small and I told them ahead of time my relationship ended. I focused on my niece and nephews, cried when I wanted to and slept from 8pm-noon for the last 5 days. Showered once or twice. That’s the best I could do and that’s OK right now. I’m back in my apartment, just trying to take it one day at a time, and not re read his texts too much. My birthday is Thursday 🙄

like

Why do we always tell people “Be the best version of yourself before starting a relationship?”
I feel this is wrong…first, if you’re someone who constantly wants to be better, this doesn’t work. Also, what happens when you’re going through things and you’re not the best version? What happens is…the going gets tough and then one person leaves the other.

like

Anyone else find themselves getting extremely stressed at work during pregnancy? It’s like my emotions are just off and I get so stressed so easily. I want to be calm for baby but it’s hard to not get worked up!

like

How do you approach a stinky middle school kid or their parents with hygiene suggestions? I don’t know how to politely tell anyone that they smell bad.

like

Any consulting moms in the area? Desperately in need of in town friends.

like

Since the firms have improved their benefits for parents/child care, don't you wish that they also provided some benefits for single and ready to mingle employees?

likefunny

Are the ideas that hit you right away ever better than the ideas that come through hours of banging your head against the wall with your partner?

like

Anyone know how much a full time nanny in the Austin area would cost?

like

Been having trouble moving on since girlfriend ended relationship 3 weeks ago after 2+ years of dating. Before ending it she came over 3 weeks prior to basically give me a chance to work things out and we had a good discussion but then I went back into our routine and didn’t really fight for it or have serious follow up convos that we needed. Now I just have so many regrets that I let her go. I know we still love each other and left on “good” terms but can’t forgive myself for my lack of action.

like

Question for married family men at MBB,

how do you balance work and family life?

like

Are there any well-off suburbs around Chicago where there's a significant amount of black or mixed race people? Significant meaning 40-50%+. I've seen a lot of nice black suburbs in southern and eastern cities but less in the midwest. In an interracial relationship and want to get an idea if there are any suburbs where our kids would feel represented or if we'll need to move down south for that.

like

I used to be so devoted to my academics that I kind of forgot to make some close friends. How do you reignite your social life after college?

like

What do you do about your house plants if both you and your SO are out of the house for an extended period? I could move some of the smaller ones to friends, but there are planters that are attached to balcony and patio. Any ideas 🐠?

like

Does anyone feel bad seeing friends when you’re job hunting? Just feel like I don’t deserve a dinner out and will feel bad comparing myself since they are all doing fine.

like

More Posts

Yesterday i got resignation acceptance mail from hr with lwd mentioned.

My TL called me that need to go office else they will extend your notice period.

Will that possible or else he is scaring me?

likefunny

McKinsey & Company Is McKinsey London looking for experienced hires similar to US offices? McKinsey & Company

like

Any EY-Parthenon folk willing to discuss an opening I came across? Senior Consultant in EYP strategy London

like

Avoiding US fishes who live in a different reality. How do the london fishes earn (level, company). What % are you able to save monthly?

My own
~10 years total with ~2 years consulting
Pay 100k base + bonus
Realistically saving 40% net take home for house in future

like

Rising senior here. Interviewed for McK today and my parents (who I’ve tried to explain the importance of these interviews to) burst into my room in the middle asking me to do a task, right in front of the interviewer, and spent a minute arguing with me when I said I couldn’t. Just found out I didn’t move on to the next round and while I’m sure some of it was my performance, hard to not just be absolutely livid with my parents here who still don’t get it. Sorry, just wanted to vent.

likefunny

My office chair stinks even though I wash it with carpet cleaner every few weeks. Fellow 24/7 WFH workers, how do you keep your office chair clean?

likefunny

Recs for getting art framed? I know the MFA sends their stuff to Stanhope but I don’t think I really need museum quality framing.

like

How much do CCOs make? Mid to large size agency in a major city?

like

Please let me know the process of H1B amendment. Does it requires slot booking and stamping again?

What do I say and resign to get released early? Cant wait for 3 months notice period to get over.

like

Recently got an offer for 80k at Morgan Stanley as a customer service associate. Can anyone provide some insight on where this offer lands (high low) in the entry level/csa marketplace? Located in a major city

like

Hi Fishes, Almost through with all the formalities. Who thinks Omnicron virus could delay offers at one of the BIG4 management consulting offers in India?

like

What do you all think of fundrise and start engine Real estate Reit ? Any experience? Would you invest here if you didn’t have the time to actually buy and rent properties? Any insight is welcome.
Thanks

like

Interviewed for Deloitte S&A Tech Strategy SC and got a verbal offer for Consultant instead. I negotiated the offer to 120K salary and 10K signing bonus. I’m a boomerang with 4 years ERP consulting but this past year I’ve been doing DEI Consulting. Spoke with former colleagues who rejoined Deloitte and got a much higher offer for SC. How do I go back to the recruiter to negotiate further? I suggested that I’d probably sign but need time to think. Now I’d like to go back and request 140k salary.

like

Anyone aware of the interview process for DAZN frontend role ?

like

What are some good marketing seminar techniques to use? What are good things to add in a marketing campaign to get new clients to attend?

like

Have an explorative call tomorrow with Amazon for a Sr Financial Specialist, Catalyst - FSI Angler. Anyone know the comp range on this?

likesmart

If you’re a Canadian looking for a Junior accountant role (0-2 years of experience in accounting) in tech, shoot me a DM

Primarily remote roles

Why associate consent is necessary if he/she is got SA project?

like

Just got engaged and I want to get my fiancé a watch. He has an Explorer II and a Date-just. My budgets is ~$3000. I don’t really know anything about watches. Help!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal