How do you respond when you come across something in a textbook that is clearly wrong? Do you teach the lesson as it is printed or do you try to override the information? I teach history and this happens to me a lot.

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I just address it and move on while teaching the correct information. In science, it is expected that we will learn more and move on from previously held theories and overturn prior ideas that are proven later to be erroneous or incomplete. So this is easy for me. I try really hard to make sure that students understand that dogma and science should have nothing in common. But it’s hard, especially right now when social media is feeding them crap all of the time and the culture has shifted to a point where we can’t believe what we see anymore. Remember that old saying?

Plus culture also has shifted to make adults untrustworthy and teachers have a very low level of authority with young people now, due to the Marxist-style approach taken by many activists to further their own agenda.

As to other approaches for the classroom, it’s a good opportunity to talk about how history is recorded, I guess?

likehelpful

Can you give an example of something you’ve had to address in science class?

It you know the information is wrong, prove it with other sources and move on.

likesmarthelpful

Crazy interesting! Can you show them both sides and then a T Graph- graphic organizer? Let them be the judge…such a great lesson using critical thinking skills

likehelpful

I taught for 42 years and a lot has changed in 4 plus decades but I’ve always taught what is factually proven even if it contradicted what the textbook said but I never pushed my opinion if I disagreed with what the textbook stated. Today everyone seems to put their spin on everything and interject their opinion into the story. The show Dragnet in the 1960’s had a saying, “just the facts please” and that’s what I always tried to convey. My job was always to teach you how to think not what to think.

like

A textbook?

I remember those...

funnylike

They weighed a ton. Each major subject area teacher handed one to you and threatened you w your life if you don’t return it. Walking home was so much fun carrying all those books in your arms- no backpacks. Ppl did not carry backpacks don’t know why. Blast from the past lol

like

I tell them correct information but also try to contextualize misinformation.

So let's say it is factually incorrect information about Columbus, I would explain the bias against Italian-American immigrants and the push to create and promote curriculum in schools that would highlight a "hero" to generations of American school children, changing the narrative surrounding the identity of Italian-Americans.

likesmart

I don’t really use text books anymore! I find errors in our curriculum all the time, but these are more editing errors rather than content errors. I tell my students that everyone makes mistakes when they pick them out. Sometimes I can tell my curriculum is glossing over some finer details - but I teach 3rd grade. I personally don’t think it’s developmentally appropriate for me to dive deep into subjects surrounding violence and other non age appropriate topics. I’ll let you high school social studies tackle those types of things once their brains are a little more developed. That’s got to be tough!

likehelpful

Oh wow, this is interesting! I've never come across this, since my kids are quite young and they aren't learning things like history and science yet. I'm honestly not sure what I would do, to be honest.

like

https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/store/the-reading-and-math-workshop-by-miss-c
Take a peek! report any errors to author!

like

Correct the wrong in your book, the books that your students are reading. Tell others and email the publisher.

like

Absolutely override. And, it’s called history… intended to be added to as events take place.

like

The most common place for me to see things that are not best practices is in my computer apps class. It is just points of formatting.

I use the SEC Plain English Handbook and the MLA Writers guide. Sometimes there is a difference between those two and how a lesson is presented. I point out the difference and then do the assignment according to the two mentioned above. At the same time, if a student does exactly what is in the book, I don't mark them down for it.

In programming, I tend to declare my variables in a different way than is in the material. I generally show them how I would have done it, and then use the approach that is in the lesson material.

like

I would most likely point out the difference and move on

like

Obviously what’s in the textbook has to be addressed. If it’s since/math related and involves something concrete like a formula that’s wrong- that has got to be corrected.

What subject is the textbook?

Related Posts

High school special class (self-contained) teachers: What do you use for planning? I’ve always been an inclusive teacher, so I followed the plan book of my co-teacher. I can’t even decide if I should go digital or paper-based let alone make a final decision! I’ll be teaching 9-11th grade math and 11th grade science. The 11th grade classes I can very much do whatever I (or the student) want/need…there isn’t a set curriculum

likehelpful

I would greatly appreciate some fun/engaging/stimulating lesson plan ideas for high school students.

We know our students the best, so what’s your best substitute lesson plan?

I’m looking for a creative lesson to go with this standard. Any suggestions?

Post Photo
like

Have you ever taken a career slow down? I am feeling burnt out from COVID and the incremental responsibilities thrown my way over the last 5+ years. I feel like my health has deteriorated. I like my company, but I want to do less. I don’t need to be a HR Director, CHRO, etc. With a career slowdown, I am prepared for a lower compensation and would want decent benefits. Any lessons learned or success stories about career slowdowns?

likehelpful

How do you best support your students who do not speak English? I have four ELL’s in my 6th grade ELA class and they don’t receive push-in or pull-out Bilingual support during my class. Do you pull them for small group to provide instruction separately or do you just try to use google translate to translate your lessons and the work? Any best practices? I’d love some help.

likehelpful

What are your favorite suppliments to give students for lessons covering Civil Rights?

Take a look at Lessontrader.com. An online marketplace for teachers to buy and sell resources. All of your hard earned work for virtual learning can be posted on lessontrader and make you some extra money! FREE membership with discount code “vipfree”. Once you upload a lesson there is nothing else needed. Just wait and collect once someone buys your stuff.

Post Photo
like

Hello! I work in change management and am assigned to an IT POM transformation. I’m still in my fact finding/change readiness analysis phase, but struggling with the senior leadership team. Does anyone have any lesson learned or best practices in eliciting feed back from senior leaders? think SVP and above? I thought about focus groups, but their time is limited. Also, survey response rate tends to be low for these guys. Any ideas???

like

What has been the best lesson you’ve ever taught?

like

Anyone else crazy and buying a house right now? Part 2, does anyone have new construction experience and any important lessons learned? Much appreciated!!

like

I taught the math lesson so abominably that the vice principal (who was observing at the back of the classroom) took over my lesson. How do you recover after a terrible day at work?

like

 I heard a commercial on the radio for Verizon that said something to the effect that parents are now learning how to lesson plan. Are any of you off the hook for lesson planning? Just wondering because I’m over here busting my butt!

funnylikehelpful

Any suggestions or ideas on working with teachers who are less than enthusiastic about utilizing technology as a means to bring “more” to their lessons?

like

I teach Economics and Personal
Finance at a specialty school. I use NGPF for personal finance but I am seeking Economics lessons for G&T

How do you come up with your labs to make sure they are aligned with the unit.? I feel like I am doing well on EOC scores but I feel like my class is a drag because we just drill concepts and the labs are not making the connections I’d like between the lesson and the activity. It becomes them just following my instruction and not much scientific processing or troubleshooting to come up with the conclusion. I want to make scientist not just students that pass the EOC.

I got an email last night from a 7th-grade parent because her son said I mentioned the words "male privilege" in class, and she is very concerned about how that is related to ELA (she said "reading"), and she is concerned about this being taught in public schools. To be clear, I didn't do a lesson on this subject but we did discuss rights versus privileges. I've had multiple parents contact the school/get upset with me because of things like his. It's exhausting... Thoughts?

like

What is your favorite library skills lesson or activity to welcome K-2 students back to school?

More Posts

My MOH is probably not going to be able to attend my wedding bc of covid restrictions. Freaking out slightly because I don't have someone close enough to replace her / I don't know how viable her zooming in would be? Any advice / tips?

like

Tux budget NYC?

like

Help- my SIL showed me two dresses she rented for my shower, and I think they are super bridal/not very appropriate to wear as a guest or bridesmaid. I have asked others and they agree. I feel like my own outfit, a simple jumpsuit, pales in comparison to how over the top these dresses are. What can I say or do? I feel really down but also don’t want to start WW3 by saying something to her. I feel like I now need to rush to buy a new outfit.

like

I recently joined IBM Kolkata for mainframe. Is there any project available for 7B ? 9.4 years exp.

How do my male counterparts get away with doing so little yet they get so much praise from above?

like

I have joined BNP in June Month. I heard the bonus will be given on prorated basis. How much bonus and hike % I can expect for my first appraisal

like

Heard that ny agencies are less likely to pay for relocation because if you want to move to ny you will. Is this true?

like

What will be the in hand salary for CTC of 25 in Citi, given normal deduction in tax.

like

Dating a teacher. He’s broke. He’s hot. He cares about his community. Dump him or keep him?

likesmart

Anyone done lofoten islands or the kungsleden trail? Would love some more info. Thinking of sept date to avoid crowds.

Interviewing for FTI Consulting Forensic Litigation consulting in 1 month. Anyone work for this firm and have any thoughts on them?

like

Any idea about google project in HCL ?

like

I can’t anymore I can’t 😭

Shameless company plug, sorry y’all. But Morgan Stanley just rolled the FRM Experienced Professionals Program. This program is designed to recruit and develop diverse professionals regardless of whether they have a background in Finance or Risk Management. Lmk if you’re interested and I’ll make sure to forward you the information.

Post Photo
likehelpful

Does anyone have any recommendations for where to get a made to measure suit in Dubai? Would need to keep prices below 5k for a 2 piece.

like

How long you guys waited or would wait for receiving the offer letter from HR (be it any company) post submitting the documents like payslips etc.

like

Hi, I am an Infosys alumni. They had an email for background checks which I can't find on google. Can someone help with this please? Thanks

Infosys

like

www.pivotcitizenship.com A brighter future is aviating😃 Having a second passport is the best way to ensure a safe and flexible future for yourself and your family as well as securing a high paid job with low tax rate. Why be at the mercy of a single Government to control your destiny? As countries continue to close their borders to specific passport holders, dual citizenship is now necessary, and having two passports means always having more options. Visit our website today to get started.

Post Photo
like

Looking for some UGC gigs. I can do unboxing and demos. Rates start at $100 for a video, and $20 per photo. which is significantly lower than others in the market. Just trying to get more content creation under my belt. I specialize in social media as a director in a marketing agency, so I know what will perform. Give me a holler if you need UGC for your brands! :)

like

We bought a property and the house next door fence post is on our property line. We’re planning on putting a fence on our vacant lot. What do we do about the fence post? Since no one owns the house? It was foreclosed on and I think a bank owns it now.

Additional Posts in Teachers

Who thinks Betsey should resign?🙋‍♂️

likesmartupliftingfunny

 I heard a commercial on the radio for Verizon that said something to the effect that parents are now learning how to lesson plan. Are any of you off the hook for lesson planning? Just wondering because I’m over here busting my butt!

funnylikehelpful

What are y’all thinking about Kanye West/Ye?
Adidas following others dropped him today for his consistent anti-Jewish stance.

Are your students talking about it?

likefunny

Today Pfizer announced that trials show that their vaccine is 100% effective for teens ages 12-15. Do you think most of our students will get it for next year?

likehelpful

Anyone here ever been to RCA? Is it worth it ?

like

Has anyone done online teaching with VipKid?
I’m considering it as a side job.
Any other ideas/suggestions would be great

like

I am the president of our school board at Franklin Country School Corporation in Brookville, In. I would like to start a NASA Stem project starting in school year 2022-2023. Does anyone know where I need to start?

likehelpful

I read this super interesting article about how big companies like Toyota are investing in social-emotional training for their employees and seeing massive benefits. I actually think this could be a whole separate class for students of all ages. Learning about conflict resolution, growing your own self-regulation skills...it's really important.

likeupliftingsmart

I want to get middle school cert (for ELA) My degree is K-8. My current cert. & EdTPA is K-5. What's the quickest & easiest path to middle school certification?! (I'm in TN, specifically Sumner Co.)

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal