How successful have you been in negotiating salary upon a job offer?

For background, Blackrock and Citi offered me a job but salary is about the same of what I currently get at GS...

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I started my career at 42k, then 80k then finally 120k. This was all within a 4 year span. I’ve always negotiated my salary before accepting the offer.

like

It takes practice to get comfortable with negotiation. Negotiation also has to be fair for both parties: they won’t hire you if you’re too expensive and you won’t work for them if they’re too cheap.

Every situation with a negotiation will be different. No one size fits all. Also just because then say no to your counteroffer doesn’t mean you’re not successful at negotiation.

If they say no to an increase, ask for a paid week or two upfront.

If it’s a 3-5% increase with external offer you tell them no way because you can get that just by sitting there at your current job. Negotiations is an art and every situation will be different. Sometimes you have to go as far as turning down the offer only to have employer scramble back with a great offer.

Moving externally is a risk so don’t do it if it doesn’t make sense in both purpose and compensation. Yes pay is very important but it’s not the only thing that is important. The job opportunity should be the right projects with the right kind of people and if you have that, you’ll be very happy.

likehelpful

If they really want you ( i.e. you were the best candidate ) they will meet you. I’ve also seen higher ups try to be budget conscious and take the 2nd best person if they can save money on payroll . Good luck

likesmart

I agree - I think it's worth a shot to ask but you can't push too much. The market is active, you should definitely keep applying

like

Market is active.
Unless the role is too attractive, you should move with some bump atleast.
I also have offers from both of these firms, and I am still evaluating what to do.
But Citi is weird as they won’t tell me what to expect their bonus % but definitely stretched their base. So that’s possible.
Blackrock gave me an offer to the lowest end of my demand and then they refused to negotiate.

But overall both are still over my current and in this market, I would say, with a GS brand name and more people leaving after bonus payouts, you shouldn’t make a flat move.

Very rarely do you have finance markets so active so make use of it :-)

likesmart

What role arr you saying 30% for?

Tell them that your current salary is the same as the offer. They should increase it if they really want you. Then, you can pick whoever gives you more if all else is equal

like

A firm offered 20% above my salary and i was able to get them increase their offer 15% more but things didn’t work out

likesmart

Someone I knew told me about it and gave me a few contacts of people who worked in his team. I contacted them and they had similar thoughts.
He interviewed me 3 times in a span of 2 weeks, which says a lot about him. And i was looking for an associate role. It would make sense if I was interviewing for a much senior role.

like

How is negotiating with GS? Im expecting an offer soon

like

Do they know what your current salary is? It would be fairly unreasonable to expect you to move between companies for the same exact pay.

like

GS increased my salary last week. Blackrock and Citi knew my salary and told them I was probably getting a raise in mid-January.

like

Anyone know the salary range for control and reporting analyst in the Tampa area? I’m with GS is salt lake and I feel like they are low balling

like

You just have to document evidence for why you would want a raise. They can always have 10-15% buffer room in case of negotiations

It depends if working 96 hours at GS vs 84 at BlackRock or Citi plus are you actually functional working like that or would it make sense to join an RIA if you want more time to yourself maybe only working 47 to 54 hours a week generally?

I’m assuming registered investment advisor. (E.I. Firm)

likehelpful

Related Posts

My Current CTC is 18.5 LPA. YoE 12yrs.
How much CTC can I ask during an HR interview for a BIGDATA engineer in UST global. What should be the expected CTC per current standard. Can you please let me know based on your experience in negotiating.

like

What is the ballpark in-hand salary of a 1 yr. BOC transferring to the US from IN?

like

I’m looking for a new job!! It has been impossible to build a good relationship with my manager, he isn’t transparent with me and never provides any constructive feedback so I have no idea how I’m performing. I recently asked for a raise since I completed all my assigned projects for this year plus a few that I took on due to resignations and was denied with no reason. I’m so checked out and looking for a new job and manager that I can learn from and will help me grow, any help is appreciated!

like

Hi fishes! To those of you who moved from UK (or elsewhere) to Dubai for work - is it the standard norm to get an expat package when you move to Dubai? Just trying to understand how it works. Thanks!!

like

I'm curious, how much do MBA student ambassadors make?

like

Sharing about a Patient Experience Consultant position salary range of $80k-95k depending on education and experience in Washington DC

like

Any raise freezes at other B4? Deloitte has remained silent thus far.

like

When salary will get credited in globant. Is it last working day of month?

Tata Consultancy I am a manager in Capgemini... have an offer frm TCS. the designation being offered is Assistant Consultant.. 9.8 years experience( 5 yrs with Cap) Even though I am getting a package of 25Lakhs.. it seems like a demotion in designation.. Cg has offered to match upto 23.5 lakhs.. Is it worth moving to TCS on this grade? My primary reason for moving out of Cg is i m bored of beauocracy and WLB at current project. Is it a good idea to still switch with the counter offer from Cg Capgemini Tata Consu

like

How much stock do you put on benefits? I have two offers with stark differences in benefits. Job 1: role I want, but benefit sucks (2 weeks paternity leave, 20% coinsurance). Job 2: role is okay but higher level and great benefits (16 weeks paternity, 0% coinsurance, 5 more days of vacation). Total comp is the same though. I wonder if I should just focus on role but Job 2 is a large company, so I can move around after 2-3 years I’d expect. Thoughts?

like

Hi all,

Can anyone share some insights on the Associate managing consultant role at Mastercard? I am curious to understand the culture, the projects and the salary as well.

I can't DM yet as I am new so please feel free to DM me.

like

Recently started my role as a Wealth Management Specialist, does anyone have any tips or insight on what I should do to make the most out of my role? What are ways to go above and beyond in order to make the most compensation?

With the various RTO rumors/fear out there and in the absence of spring/summer/fall(?) bonuses. Would you consider coming into the office more if your firm offered bonuses linked to days in the office (coupled with billable targets, of course)?

likefunny

Hello All,

I have got an offer from one company with a 32L + 15% variable. Now I got two other offers with 36L. Should I go for it?

like

Hi Fishes,

I am a software specialist having 8+ yoe, currently working at Mastek with a CTC of 17lpa. Can anyone help me with the current market CTC considering the below:
Current Role: Tech Lead
Tech Stack: Full Stack in Java, Springboot, Angular, Mobility, AWS beginner.
Your responses will be much appreciated.

like

Hi Fishes,

How much hike relaince jio gives to employees every year?

like

Hi Fishes,

I have been offered 37.5 lacs ( fixed ) plus 20% variable for the associate director level . My current fixed CTC is 29 Lacs .

Can you please let me know if this a good offer or I can get more?

Please also let me know what is the salary range for associate directors?

like

If we are billable on project in nagarro do we need to worry about recession for now .
One more question:
What is nagarro planning how to handle recession:
Lay offs or salary cut or stop increment.

Please anyone from leadership reply

LTI or EY GDS
OFFERED SALARY SAME

More Posts

In KGS, what exactly this DA Core - AAS stat accounting profile and gurgaon team is??

like

Hello! I'm currently getting my Bachelor's Degree and I'll be graduating in May 2023. My major focuses on Spanish Translation, I have a minor in Japanese, and I'll be receiving a certificate in Spanish for Professions when I graduate.

Does anyone know of any companies that are hiring in-house Spanish Translators?

Does google have office in Dubai? I am curious!

Hi,

Can someone help me with the inhand salary for the below mentioned.

Post Photo

Do creative directors have the power to ignore their copywriters and go with their own ideas?

like

What do u prefer

Post Photo
helpfullike

What brands do you recommend for linen suits?

like
like

What's the safest area to live in Dallas as a young, single female?

like

Hi All,
Can anyone give me some insights about the NATWEST group(formerly RBS) project in Accenture gurgaon.
How is the work and the environment and about the management of the project???

like

Is getting back together with an ex always a bad idea?

like

What’s the max umbrella policy coverage y’all have seen offered by insurance providers? Looking to get one for the first time. Anything I should consider/ask the insurance company?

like

I’m looking for constructive chats around generating high quality Health Insurance leads at scale. Open to share some of our findings

like

I’m 25 years old, totally healthy, working from home. My parents want me to come visit for a few days given the uncertainty with the virus. Is it safe for me to visit? Both are 60 and in good health

like

Anyone else catching up on CEs while they're stuck at home?

like

Hi Fishes,

What is the average salary in Germany for SAP Integration Architect with 11 Years of Experience

like

How do Atlanta peeps like their Forensics practices? Trying to gauge which firm has the most interesting work

like

Do PwC and KPMG allow Mega Back Door Roth with their 401K plan? Wanted to confirm.

like

Could someone share job security in tiger analytics at all level??

like

Anyone gave interview for manual test in IHS Markit IHS Markit

Please help with the interview questions IHS Markit IHS Markit

Additional Posts in Finance

God damn I'm too young to be balding already. Should I shave it? I'm relatively fit and stylish.

like

How many of you have had to list DUIs on your job application? It's always an embarrassing moment for background checks.

like

How many sq ft is your place?

Guggenheim healthcare reputation?

like

Is getting back together with an ex always a bad idea?

like

Financial advisors—how do you prepare for a meeting with a new client? What information do you need to gather? What information is useful for your pitch? Where do you find this information?

like

What's Charlotte, NC like? Moving from international so I'm looking at different options. I know it's not as good as NYC...

like

Can I still get a job if I struck out of recruiting this year but got a balling review and a third year?

like

Which PE firms in Boston have the best reputations?

like

I decided to call in sick and play Battlefield 1 all day. Because, fuck it.

likeuplifting

Besides working, how do you finance pros typically spend the weekend?

like

Look like a million bucks. Feel like shit.

like

I have been working remotely since covid getting nothing but positive reviews. My company is not remote friendly and is now telling me I have to return to the office or I lose my job. I just found out a co-worker had a remote position created for them, without a job posting, without an interview and without the experience required (normally a license or certification would be mandatory). I understand life isn’t fair but is there an ethical problem with this?

like

Maybe I'll avoid bounce tonight, maybe not

like

How risky is going to a startup which is currently going through Series A? Have just received an offer.

like

NFT’s... no interest in buying them but very interested in buying into whatever it is that makes tick. I think there’s a lot of money to be made off of such a ridiculous investment. Any ideas on what to buy to take part in the business of NFT’s, without having to pay $69 million for a drawing of a cat?

like

How frowned upon are crew neck undershirts?

like

When you realize the greatest value add you can bring to the deal today is picking up everyone's lunch

like

Kind of surprised that Bieber is only worth 265 mil

like

Most awkward Uber stories? My uber driver showed me a picture of her baby. Um, it was a doll.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal