I work as a first year Senior Associate at RSM. I asked for a $3k raise during compensation discussions this year, but was denied, so I interviewed at BDO. They offered me $7k + $2k bonus. I am wondering if this would be a good switch.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

BDO is a dumpster fire. Stay far away. Honestly RSM sounds like the best option these days.

like

EY too

funnylike

9k might not be worth building new relationships and a reputation if you’re already respected at RSM. You will move up faster at RSM. That being said, you might make 80-120k more if you switch to A&M.

funnylike

@EY 1 this is why you use accounting to exit into consulting

Recent IconRecent

Yes definitely switch

like

Yea. If you leave, you can boomerang back and make $10k more, minimum. The comp here is stupid low

like

Warning: BDO has a toxic environment

like

Were you at RSM for a full compensation cycle (typically, a year or something close to a year) before your comp discussions? If so and assuming non-poor performance, that is really odd that you wouldn’t get at least $3k as a comp adjustment (which is probably only 3-5% increase)…

Now, if you were only there a few months before comp reviews, it generally makes sense that you wouldn’t be adjusted during the first review.

like

Sorry I didn’t explain that well. I had high performance and was given a $7k raise. I asked for $3k more because the salary seemed low and the raise was lower than the prior year even though my performance rating was higher.

BDO is so bad. They have to pay to poach because they are bleeding out. RSM is respected. This coming from someone at Big 4 with friends at the top 8 firms.

like

I worked for a BDO alliance firm, and their standards were pretty high. I don't know BDO intimately, though

like

You’re nickel and dimeing over nothing, in my opinion. Do what’s best for your career, but don’t make a meaningful decision because of $5k.

likehelpful

Agree with Grant Thornton 1, BDO is a hot mess. But if you plan it out, you can be there for 1-2 years and then move on to the next thing for another jump in compensation. The fastest way to increase comp is to switch I think

like

BDO culture has been horrible lately. Read their bowl.

like

Definitely not if the other aspects of your role pans out, like being a high performer, good teams, boss who supports you. This is minimum for long term (your current company might have strings on flexibility and can’t give you a raise) but by staying you will make more money much faster, assuming the other aspects are working

like

It’s not about loyalty, for those who disagree. It’s about ability and having institutional knowledge and gaining trust with people up there. If you jump around and make money, chances are you are either at a lower level or just not THAT good (but the other company doesn’t know yet; or possibly values other abilities than your current company). For example, at director level, you can’t jump and make partner at the same timeline unless nobody at your current company wants to support you for partnership. You have to bring revenue to be able to jump and make partner, which is much much harder than staying. But of course if it’s a dead end at your current company, jump, but it’s never about money

I’m raking $300k at BDO. This so-called dumpster fire is nice and toasty 🔥

like

Role and how is WLB? I have an offer coming for an advisory manager role.

You’re seeing what everyone talks about that the best raises come from job hopping. Since you’ve only been in your current job for a year, if you take the new job plan on being there for a few years or you’ll risk being looked at as just a job hopper.

like

If you want to stay, you can use your offer to negotiate and see what the firm can do to keep you.

like

Switchity switch switch baby

like

Negotiate a higher salary with bdo. Demand 20-25k more

like

That would put me in a 6 figure salary in MCOL as a first year audit senior associate. I don’t want to push my luck lol

like

That’s a big jump. How does the bonus compare with what you’d get soon at your current firm? When I jumped I failed to understand that I missed a major milestone bonus.

like

The bonus from BDO will be prorated, so potentially will miss out on 1-2k

Do it. BDO has an ESOP program.

like

If no one owns the firm, the PE firm with the 2B debt does!

We need to aim higher here

What niche are you in

Audit. For the past 2 years, I primarily worked on public clients, but I relocated this year, and the area I live in doesn’t have public middle market clients for the industry I serve. So all new jobs and teams this year, except for one.

You should probably leave. $3k raise after tax and FICA is roughly $75 per paycheck. If you’re debating leaving for this you’re probably in the wrong career

It’s closer to $180 per paycheck and the bonus is about $1,500. The total annual raise would be about $6k

Related Posts

like

Hi All, Which one should I joined
Tech-python developer
YOE-5 years
Capgemini 21 LPA including variable
Wipro 24 LPA including variable
Tech Mahindra 24 LPA including variable
Synechron Inc. 24 LPA fixed

like
like

Hii
How is dbs project in ibm in term of wlb, carrier growth etc.

like

One of the company asked if i could join as early as in 1.5/2 months where I have 3 months NP and haven't put papers yet .. i asked one of my senior in my team about this who's already resigning...and she has told about this to the entire team 😶. I realise it's my mistake asking her :p
Now that I'm not hearing back from the company which I gave interview and my environment at current project is a mess atm...Should I just put papers or bear with it till I fine another one..??

like
like

Hi EY folks,

My DOJ at EY IN Chennai is 25th Jan 2023. Is this the correct time to join?
Should I try to prepone my joining in the last week of Dec 2022.?

SAP SD, Pune, Infosys
4 YOE.
OFFERED CTC - 13.61 LAKHS
Fixed 11, 2.61 variable.
I am not given any joining bonus. It will be applicable if i join within 60 days.

Hi Fishes,

Please help me in choosing in between:
Uber Business Analyst (Data Analytics Specialist III) 10 fixed+20% variable.
Tiger Analytics Business Analyst 10 fixed + 1jb.

YOE: 1.2 Business Analyst Tata Consultancy

Thanks

like

Hi Fishes,

Can anybody please help me out with the market corrected salary of Associates in PWC India (Tax Tech Stack).

like

What's the average salary for RN-BC with 8 years experience in ER in the Cleveland area?

like

How much does Amazon pay a Salesforce developer with 5 years of experience?

like

Hi, I'm looking forward to work at Wipro London as a Salesforce developer and want to know how much can i negotiate the salary in B2 band?

like

Hi fishes,
I wanted to know the work culture also considering package for maantic for 2 year devolopment and 1 year support in salesforce

like

Does anyone know what the Short Term Incentive program at Avanade is? Also, is it separate from the annual bonus?

likehelpful

Hello people . I have 4.10 years of experience in Audit . I have worked with deloitte and now working in McKinsey . My package is 5.25 . I feel its low . McKinsey low balled me . What should I do ? How much is the package I can demand going forward ? Please help.

Anyone have insights on what it’s like to work at Aetna right now, with all the CVS merger activity going on in the background? Got pinged by an Aetna recruiter and trying to gather intel. TIA!

like

Current CTC: 19
Exp: 7.1
Stack : Fullstack with angular and java
What salary I can expect from VMware any suggestions?

like

Hi all,

I am a lateral joinee in accentureat level 11 with 3 yrs of exp .In sep 2022 I have completed 1 yr at accenture. Do I get hike now?

like

I had my final round with Accenture. How long it takes for the HR's to get back and roll the offers ??

like

More Posts

Any politics story in msft India.

likefunny

UK Only please.

Digital Consultant to Tech Company (e.g. FAANG PM, Palantir Deployment, Databricks Solution Architect). What would you use to determine your total comp package?

At the moment, I just take the average TC i'd expect over the next 3 years at my consulting firm (EM levels)

like

A small part of me wish I would get laid off and be forced into freelancing so I can make 💰 💰 💰

like

Do you ever wonder if the person in the stall next to you can see your shadow, even tho you can't see theirs?

like

Hasta lunes, Miami

Post Photo
like

Doing a federal clerkship and thinking of my options after. Anyone in NJ/NY/PA biglaw lit group with collegial and pleasant work environment? I do not care about billable requirements/workload, just salary and don’t want to be treated like shit.

like

Are salesforce (Bangalore) employees working from home or hybrid?
If still WFH (all days)? How many months will it extend?
If hybrid has started, how many day per week is mandatory?

like

I'm doing a NFT giveaway. Post your eth address and I will send you one

Post Photo
like

To all my data engineering friends out there, do you all feel like trash sometimes? Like people dont understand shit about what you do, and clients just want to see some bs ml model/pretty but useless dashboards?

likefunny

Should people be fired for lack of people skills?

like

Are you a female?

SAP Cloud

All! Does anyone have experience with SAP cloud ? Please share any experience with SAP cloud

like

Any charismatic churches with a decent group of young professionals in Philly?

I know that the general advice is not to cut your own time, but if you think you took WAY TOO LONG on something should you? I don’t want partners to think of me as inefficient.

like

Hi Fishes,
I have an experience of 6 years in Production and Application Support. I have worked as middleware administrator as well for Jboss and Weblogic.
But due to the diminishing demands of the role in IT industry , I am planning to switch my career in Devops or AWS which would help me grow.
But I am not sure without any practical knowledge, will I get a job at this many years of experience in a different profile.
Do companies hire for AWS profiles with good packages at beginners level?

like

Barclays or Citibank which company is more better at AVP role?

like

So should I buy Tesla or too late ?

like

Just did my baseline testing and got results. My appointment to discuss the results with my RE is in mid January. Any guides / ways I can start to interpret them on my own before then?

like

Sometimes I struggle with the balance between “pushing myself out of comfort zone” and “being comfortable with who I am”. Anyone feel the same way?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal