Just got offered a role at MorganFranklin consulting as a manager in Strategy. Then I got offered a role in as a senior consultant at Deloitte in Strategy. MFC is offering 128k and Deloitte is offering 155k. Which one would you take?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Deloitte

like

Deloitte

like

I wouldn’t touch Deloitte with a long long pole ... 150k is really solid for SC though but you will have absolutely no work like balance.

like

Why not? Trying to determine which to go with....

Manager at Deloitte is 6+ YOE (normally 7/8). SCs coming out of MBA make 160-170 base. WLB is what you make of it. You can choose projects that are poorly scoped, or work on those that inherently have balance. Obviously biased, but would choose Comp and scope over title.

likehelpful

D1 and SC 2 thanks for the feedback! Overall, noone said MorganFranklin so I guess that answers my question

You'll have a nicer and chiller life at MFC

like

Right - I’ll also be paid substantially less (30k) with less brand name recognition. 🤔... #ToughDecisions

like

D then jump in 2 years

like

I would take the Deloitte offer.

like

I would also take the D offer. Did either one provide a sign up bonus?

like

A3 thanks for the feedback. Curious - how much does ACN pay its Managers that are promo’d internally? What group are u in GPS or commercial?

Hey - I have been at MFC for the past 6 months. Boutique PE-backed firm that is growing aggressively, and your comp package should give you solid bonuses for BD activity. If you want to test yourself selling work to new and current clients then there is considerable upside. If you are early career and still learning, Deloitte may be a better developmental oppy.

like

Wow I’m a manager and don’t make close to what Deloitte is offering (not in Strat tho, I think it would be comparable there)

Interesting. What area are u in and how much do you make as an M at Accenture? Was considering applying there as well

Deloitte for sure. Then leave if you hate the WL balance

Never heard of MorganFranklin

Deloitte... never even heard of MFC and have very closely followed the consulting industry for years. Leave with better brand and comp if you don’t like it

Related Posts

Currently pregnant with baby 2 and a start-up which I was really keen on about 9 months ago came back around to offer me a position. I am about 4.5 months away from leave with my current firm. Am terribly nervous about accepting an getting more even half of the leave I could have gotten before. To top it all off they are offering 50% salary until they raise their target (about 30% to their goal right now). This position is in my dream field and a great fit for me, but the timing couldn’t be wors

like

PHR or SHRM? I am looking to get more certifications related to HR vs recruiting, but I am unsure on which one is "better" or will help me grow into more of a strategic HR role. Help!!!

like

Anyone from Siemens Energy? Need referral

like

Interviewing for Director role at an unknown fed consulting firm with 80M in revenue/250 employees. What should I expect/negotiate as far as profit sharing, commission sharing for winning work?

like

Plan to go to B-school in 3 years (1 year out of UG now). Long term goal is entrepreneurship. Have offers at a MBB firm for a generalist consultant role and at FAANG for a strategy role. FAANG offer is slightly higher (though both are a 50+% bump on my current comp). Both would have me reset to entry level. Which one should I take?

like

Opinions Wanted My Dad passed away recently and my Mom finally heard back on the value of his Deloitte pension. Around 350k. Combined with life insurance and retirement this puts my Mom in a much more comfortable position than she was expecting and mentioned she wants to use some of the money to pay down my siblings and my remaining student loan debt as she holds a lot of guilt that we had to take loans at all. Between 25-50k for each of us. Would you take the money?

like

FDD exit ops?

like

Any openings for informatica powercenter EOY 10. Location :Chennai

like

Just interviewed with Google for an analyst role and the questions were pretty freaking tough.... Not feeling great. Any advice?

like

PWC fish Recruiter reached out for M/SM role in Ops practice. What are the levels/cohorts in M/SM and what's the base/bonus target for each? TIA

like

Interviewing at Salesforce right now for a Solutions Engineer role. I have an interview with the VP tomorrow. Anyone have any advice? I keep getting the feedback that I am too “structured” and too much of a consultant. 💩 Oh the irony.

like
like

Any tips for negotiating your severance for a non-partner role? Many good years at the firm—it’s just not working out of late and both me and my firm are looking to part ways.

like

Would you take a 40% cut from your last salary for an industry role if you were out of job for >6 months ? (Same location)

like

I was laid off from a resource management role, working with employees approaching or on the bench, working with managers to staff projects, and support functions like report creation, scheduling, etc. Roles like this are few and many large consulting firms have frozen internal hiring. Do you think it would be beneficial to get a SHRM cert? Would that help get a "talent related" HR role? Worth the money? I have a background in recruitment as well.

like

First real program leadership role - any tips?

like

A company offered a role, but then went back to the legal team to see if they can do H1 transfer. The job is not aligned with my degree but my past 9 years of work ex has been. How do I try to convince them?

like

Netlink is hiring for below positions, let me know if you need referral Location: Pune, Chennai, Bhopal

Post Photo
like

Is TAS/FDD just glorified audit? What exactly is it like working in this line of business? I’m considering applying to jobs to transition into it but I don’t want to be falsely sold into it the way I was with audit. Also, does it provide better exit ops than audit?

like

Hi Everyone! I’m wondering if any consulting firms are actively hiring right now? I’ve decided I want to leave my current company in search of more opportunity. Particularly because it seems as though my promised promotion will be indefinitely cancelled due to COVID (@hiring freeze). Would appreciate advice / tips and if graciously offered, referrals!

like

Additional Posts

95% +Utilization, got a 4 of 5. (no raise, no bonus). I was benched last year due to awaiting my clearance (missed utilization) and got a 3 of 5 with a raise and bonus.

Anyone else join a new project and realize you will never know what tf the client is doing. I’m very confused right now.

likeuplifting

About to wrap up a week+ vacation and instead of feeling well-rested and ready to work again, the thought of going back gives me so much dread. I’m not sure if I’m burnt out or depressed or just over where I work. Does anyone else feel like this? If I wasn’t saving for a down payment, I think I would want to take a leave of absence.

like

Does anyone know of any remote opportunities for elderly Indian folks? Like language training or teaching? My mom used to be a teacher at Kumon and bc of COVID, she stopped as my dad is high risk and her boss won’t let them work remotely. Would love to help her find a new job, but Kumon was her first and only job. Anyone have any leads? She lives in Chicago for reference.

like

Advisory Managers that left EY for another big 4…when you gave your 2 weeks notice (or 4 weeks), were you let go effective immediately or did they allow you to continue to work despite the fact you were going to a competitor?

like

Any ideas on how much raise I can expect on promotion to Manager? Currently make 122K as senior.

like

Interview help - gotten to the offer stage 2x in the past 3-4 months, but have lost the coin flip vs other candidate. Any guidance? Feeling pretty down in the dumps…

like

Client mentioned they were trying to internalize me and my team after project end. Has anyone ever had this happened to them / how did you go about it? Are there legality issues in our contract I should be careful of or after contract is up - I am ok?

like

What are your thoughts on RSM consulting? Specifically on compensation, WLB, exit opps, and types of work.

like

What is the cohort salary for senior 3 in FCU advisory?

like

A Deloitte AM&C (Advertising, Marketing & Commerce) recruiter reached out to me today to schedule an interview. Can someone provide some insight to the Team and Deloitte’s culture?

like

My SO had an interview on Tuesday, how soon is too soon to follow up?

like

Good morning, I work for Solugenix placing top notch candidates at companies throughout the US. I just started at Solugenix so anyone who needs any assistance either finding a job or looking for candidates please let me know. Thanks and have a great day.

like

How many rounds of interviews are normal for a small, independent agency? I’m in the process of interviewing for an associate account executive (entry level) position if that helps! I’ve had a phone screen and one virtual interview with the co-founders so far.

like

One of my biggest pet peeves is when I see people referring to their kids as 30 months or 36 months. No, you're kid is 2.5 or 3. What are some of your biggest pet peeves?

likefunnysmart

Can someone share candidate portal link for download offer letter? Actually I received mail that Congratulations!! Your offer for the role in HCL Technologies Ltd. has been posted on to your candidate portal. You can access it by clicking on the below link: [] I dropped a mail to hr but they have not replied.

4th year going into my 5th year and am leading discovery and case management on a case with a $5 million budget (yeah!) with a rocket docket. Starting to understand why partners have no time to do substantive work: it’s all answering client questions and managing staff, associates, and reviewing partners. Any tips for the transition? I’ve never been too demanding from my colleagues and usually just pick up any slack myself. Now I need to motivate others and give direction.

like

Can anyone opine on NY 529 plans? Have one kid and debating if it is beneficial. I like the tax benefits it provides but not sure if the advantages go away if I end up relocating outside US after 4-5 years, or if my kid decides to not study in US or NY in future. Any opinions would be really helpful.

like

Is a MBA necessary / helpful to move up in product management if you don’t have a tech background? Considering making the jump from consulting to PM and want to know if I’ll have issues not having one

like

How did you say no or scale back for extra firm building stuff? Between covid and pregnancy I just don’t have the energy right now but don’t wanna burn bridges

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.