My CD didn't mince his words when he told me that my topical social ideas are "childish" and "forced". Something his 15-year-old niece would think.

I want to get better. If you can pass on some tips or resources, I'll be EXTREMELY grateful.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Good chance the 15yo niece actually has better social ideas than your CD

like

Honestly that seems like a pretty cruel way of giving feedback.

The best way to get better is volume. Think of as many ideas as you can. Take a long break. Then look at your ideas again with fresh eyes and narrow it down to a select few.

like

Helping you get better is what your CD should be doing.

like

True but they are posting here for a reason if something isnt already happening

Horrendous feedback from your CD. Others have already said it — your CD is hurtful. And your CD isn’t guiding you or teaching you anything.

An idea based on something topical is called “borrowed interest.” It means that you are relying on something else that is interesting to drive the target’s attention, rather than the brand itself.

The biggest problem with borrowed interest is that it distracts from the brand. Your target audience might not even notice the brand at all.

Borrowed interest also tends to be the first ideas that advertising students or amateurs do. This is likely because untrained people don’t know how to use the brand itself to generate an idea, so they instead try to find ideas anywhere.

To get better at using the brand to be your starting point for ideas, use prompts. You can find prompts at https://deckofbrilliance.com

When going through prompts, don’t censor yourself. Allow yourself to think of the dumbest ideas ever. The goal is to get a massive volume of dumb idea seedlings. Try to challenge yourself to write down 5–10 dumb idea seedlings for each prompt. YES, THIS TAKES HOURS.

So after a few hours, you should have written down 200–300 bad idea seedlings. You’ll notice you can put them in buckets. Probably 5–7 buckets or so.

Boom, your brain will start to connect dots and piece together some of those seedlings. Now pick the best ideas under each bucket.

Congrats, you have 7 ideas. Now flesh them out a little bit. Pick the best 3–5. Flesh those out a little more. These ideas will almost always be decent.

This is about 100X easier if you do all of this with your art director partner, and your ideas will wind up being 5X better.

That’s how you do it. That’s the big trick to being consistently good at generating solid ideas — you have to put in the hours.

Good luck.

likehelpful

I respectfully disagree. It takes a master to do borrowed interest well. It’s more often a sign that the creative doesn’t want to do the hard work of making a boring product benefit interesting.

What’s the target audience demo?

likesmart

Dance challenge!

funnylike

Depending on the client your social may want to seem like it was created by your 15-year-old niece.

like

Also spend more time on social and see what actually works for other brands. Look at the brands that are crushing it, look at the comments to see how their followers are responding. Also look at how the (good) brands have different strategies and approaches for different platforms. Make your social ideas platform-specific and also something that makes sense for the brand. Not every brand needs to jump on every trend.

like

Honestly those are the best kind of ideas.

like

What are your topical ideas and what are they for?

I mean, did they at least give you an explanation for their comments… and well, you know, a direction to work in?

Do more research on your audience and the opportunities

CD sounds like a real knob.

Related Posts

Fishes, about to get an offer from JPmC ,how much should I quote ?
cctc- 31lpa
Tech stack-big data,hadoop,Spark,aws,docker
Currently working with fortune 5

like

Gave interview sometime back, Initially they did not agree to the ask, since I already have offer from other org which is much greater than what Tavisca is offering.....Difference is around 4lakhs in both of them, the other org is mid sized company which gave higher offer... What to do in this case... Go for JPMC?? Or other org?? Tavisca JPMorgan Chase

Hi Fishes,
What are the ideal places/societies to stay near
Tavisca office? And what’s the average rent of a 2bhk for a family?Tavisca

like

Do we get any confirmation mail, once we complete our probationary period of 03 months ?

like

**Can I take retirement?**
Hi All,
I have around 29 Lac savings + 5 Lac gold.
And my wife has 28 Lac gold(wedding gift) + 80 Lac(ancestral) Land.
We have a child, his current age is 2 years+
Currently our monthly expenses are around 22k(max), and my CCTC is 15 LPA+ with 8+ YOE.
My age is 29! I don't feel like working anymore.

like

Greetings, Ghosted! bowl members. As 2019 concludes, people who posted here: please let us know if you ever heard back from your ghosters.

like

Can anyone refer me in Amazon ?Amazon

like

Ctrl+C , Ctrl+V

Post Photo
likefunny

Asalamualaikum! How’s it going?

like

Anyone have recs for best tax law training resources?

like

How much prof liability coverage should a solo plaintiffs attorney carry.

like

What’s a decent amount of stock options when joining a series B startup probs about 3-5 years from exit? Salary is £75k shares expected to sell for £3-4 a share

like

Associates - Care to share your rough budgets (income, spousal income/family support, rent, monthly spending, student loan payments, savings, etc.)?

like

I joined Nagarro as a trainee at 3.5 LPA how much hike could i expect??

like

Hi fishes... I am confused with the below offers.. Can anyone please let me know which company is better to join in terms of wlb and quality of work. Cts - pune - 18 fixed + 70k variable + 1L jb Wipro - Bangalore - 18 fixed + 2L variable + 50k jb Atos - Pune - 20 fixed + 1L variable +1L joining bonus EY - Bangalore - 22 fixed + 3L variable Yoe - 7 years Skill - plsql and Unix shell scripting

like

Larsen & Toubro Infotech Hi Fishes, Optum or Larsen & Toubro Infotech !! Which one to choose ? Both are offering same package. Skill Set :MSBI YOE:9+

likesmart

I have an accounting degree and am looking for something where I spend most of my time using excel. Surprisingly, audit —at least at my company— doesn’t really do that. Any suggestions would be helpful.

I’m not sure if this is the right place to post, it’s my first time so please excuse me!

like

Is there any tv work worse than the State Farm Chris Paul and his agent unfunny turds? It’s like the creatives watched the Footlocker basketball work and tried to do that. WTF agency does this?

like

I am in the process of transitioning to a Junior RM role at a mid market bank in the Bay Area. I wanted to know what is a salary + bonus range that I can expect and/or request. Any help is greatly appreciated!

like

which is better EY India or EY GDS ? Want to know in terms of hike , variable bonus, perks and benefits. Not bothered about client exposure and all.

Additional Posts in Advertising

Saturday night live is getting good again.

like

What agencies in Boston should I check out?

like

How do you talk to your boss when your job has evolved to something very different from what you were hired to do and you’re not happy without getting fired or phased out?

like

My browser history is failing me and hope y’all can help! I recently stumbled upon a website where some ad folks had compiled a bunch of idea/conceptual thinking approaches and if you clicked through there were past spots that had utilized that idea / way of thinking. I wanted to share it with a mentee and can’t track it down. It was a simple layout: grid of images w/headline naming the idea … Sound familiar?

like

Is there any tv work worse than the State Farm Chris Paul and his agent unfunny turds? It’s like the creatives watched the Footlocker basketball work and tried to do that. WTF agency does this?

like

Any other integrated agencies working in Agile across the full agency? Trying to understand how this plays out as we roll it out.

like

Wieden guys, what's your opinion on the non american/non european W+K offices. How offices like tokyo, shangai and sao paulo are perceived within the network?

like

How’s life in Layoffland today?

like

Question: we have an art director who is pretty senior, really good, but is now lazy as hell, avoiding projects and collecting a paycheck. What does the team do?

like

Looking for agencies in the Bay Area and I'm not super familiar with the names at play. Places to check out? Places to avoid?

like

A little humor sprinkled in a resume. Yay? Nay?

like

New Cheerios work is 🔥

like

Marcel here. So instead of talking behind my back, how about saying it to my face? Here I am, ready to answer questions, concerns, or just talk sports. So what would you like to know? 🤖

like

Nice Ronald McDonald spot, Subway. Enjoy your cease and desist letter tomorrow morning!

like

I got a verbal offer from a WPP agency today. The role's budgeted salary is 5k less than my desired salary.
The recruiter can get me closer but still not at my desired salary. Otherwise - it would have to go through a long approval process with no guarantee that the salary would even be OK'd.
I'm coming from a small agency, so I could be wrong - but I don't want to sell myself short by accepting the first salary they offer. Do I have any room to negotiate? Or is that risky?

like

Is it okay to call a sick day as freelancers?

like

I’m currently interviewing for an AS role which would be a bit of a pay cut, but I’ll get to learn a lot so I’m interested. Any tips on how to approach the negotiation convo if/when that comes, besides asking to at least meet me halfway re:salary? They already provide unlimited PTO and free health benefits(which is nice).

like

Just found out there’s an ECD in a big NYC agency who claims to have won awards, but the name doesn’t pop up in any of the archives.

How do they get away with it?

like

If you live in LA, dm me for secret wineries in SB county that will blow your mind. I’ve literally been to all and give you the goods and they are so close and life’s too short to drink crap wine!

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal