So after reading at least one comment beating KPMG up every 2-3 days on here, I’ve finally decided to ask: Can someone please objectively articulate why KPMG is not in the same league as the other B4?

likehelpfulfunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Court ordered. Goes back to the tax shelter days. Part of SEC's settlement with KPMG was it "shall be subject to great mocking and ridicule among the Great Accounting Houses." In fact, EY had to agree to participate in the said mocking. I think all the firms did.

like

Who cares? At the end of the day, you get paid to do work. If the company forces you to do more work in excess of what you make, you get unhappy and leave.

I can’t understand why you peeps get so crazy with the whole “big 4” dominance crap. News flash, you aren’t that important and neither is your firm.

likeupliftingsmart

Honestly I think it’s just a joke and maybe because they bring in the least amount of revenue compared to other b4. I’ve had worse EY experiences as far as competency and quality are concerned

likesmarthelpful

If you haven’t figured this out by now you were probably born to be tier 2 (**aka working at kpmg**)

like

@PwC2, possibly. But I believe Deloitte actually has the lowest per headcount revenue by a healthy margin of about $25k/head (comparing the US practices of each firm). So to me that would seem to be more indicative of prestige than size. I would say the same to EY 1. Regional firms are touted as low cost providers. Yet KPMG does not appear to be the cheapest of the big four. Regarding EY1’s point about bad press, did you know if you read the wiki page about accounting scandals, you’ll see that EY (or its ancestor firms) have been indicated as the auditor in ~1.4x the number of accounting scandals where KPMG (and its ancestor firms) were indicated?

likesmart

Lol it’s a funny joke KPMG OP.

like

I think you’re right, EY2. I just get annoyed because it’s clearly unwarranted and not data-driven.

likeuplifting

Says the dude who works for the firm who can’t even figure out what their name is... D? DT? DTT?

likefunny

I'm pretty sure that they are rated pretty low by the pcaob quality standards. Also, Kpmg people always get mad about all of the bullying that they receive on this app and so it just feeds the fire.

like

Based on the way KPMG teams consistently conduct audits of poor quality and competency. I can attest to multiple regions where clients don’t know what else to do but laugh and feel beyond frustrated with KPMG, and continue to hear how they feel misguided or not up with the times. KPMG in recent years has also been greatly undercutting everyone else in the market in order to win work. AC’s and Boards like the numbers and have previous ties/relationship to KPMG but business leaders and day-to-day client contacts deal with more shit with KPMG than other firms generally, at least that’s the trend. I’ve personally worked with each of the firms countless times and don’t have anything against any one firm, and don’t feed into the competitiveness. All are great firms to work for; however, KPMG just has that rep nearly anywhere you go.

like

Yeah I don't think anyone actually cares other than inner big 4 rivalry. A tired joke.

like

In my experience it’s just one of those running jokes that continued rolling, like the nickelback of accounting. I think kpmg is perfectly fine, no worse than any of the others, just if you gotta hate on a competitor, kpmg became an easy target

like

I think that it's kind of a regional thing too. In the west, KPMG is similar to a regional firm but I know that in Asia for example they are very dominant. It's also because KPMG is always in the news for bad stuff.

like

Wtf does KPMG stand for anyways? Anyone know? There’s your answer...

likefunny

Smaller headcount, smallest revenue (not sure about overall profits), involvements in recent scandals like the the hiring of former PCAOB staff to get advantage for upcoming reviews and yet still lagging behind other firms in review comments, last firm to get digital work papers, gets new market share by being the price leader vs winning on quality and innovation, etc. I admit, some of these are subjective, but thats been my experience in my market

likehelpful

Smallest of the 4 globally but agree with the regional comment. I think ey is close to number 5 in the uk. I do think said more in jest probs because someone started it once and got a reaction so just kept doing it

like

D&T bruh...

like

Which regional would be 4 in uk then?

smart

It’s funny because the same people here would say “oh high growth startups you learn so much, when consistently the highest growing”. Deloitte Consulting was by mistake as they failed to sell it after EnRon (so enjoy passing it off as “we stuck with our people”). EY4 everyone hates auditors period, go roll forward some spreadsheets. PwC, got a lot of friends there, almost went there myself, you’re nice, but not above scandal either. We’ll take our sponsoring a golfer (lol the idea of mascots and theme songs for firms is great eh?). At the end of the day this is all a convo to make everyone feel superior, world is better when we recognize equals. Don’t make generalizations based on 1-2 experiences (that’s what people seem to get in trouble for in the news today).

Happy Thursday everyone!

helpful

@Deloitte 1

From wiki:

The name "KPMG" stands for "Klynveld Peat Marwick Goerdeler." It was chosen when KMG (Klynveld Main Goerdeler) merged with Peat Marwick in 1987.

like

Related Posts

What are your thoughts on Wiley? Pros/cons?

like
like

Any info on WLB at NielsenIQ.. and pay ballpark figure for 7.5 YOE?

like

Does Accenture IN provided anything in Diwali as a gift or party or bonus ?

funny

How much does Accenture and Deloitte pay a consultant in Germany and Netherlands?

like

When does a person get promotion from manager to senior manager in cognizant?

like

Can someone tell what would be the night shift allowance in CTS for Associate designation. @cognizant

like

Trying to decide between an offer at Deloitte and a counter-offer at Booz. Deloitte has the name recognition and better benefits but I have a really supportive team at Booz and good work-life balance. Any insight is appreciated! I would be starting at Deloitte as a Consultant in GPS. Currently a Senior Consultant at Booz.

like

I was laid off from Deloitte in the 18th. I have an interview with Amazon for a Senior Program Managers Non Technical position with Amazon hiring manager on Monday. Any advice would be much appreciated. I would love to get into Amazon. I hear their interview process is brutal.

like

Anyone on here worked with Edelman? Pros? Cons?

like
like

I am an incoming Associate at Strategy& Dubai office. I am a bit worried right now and wanted to know whether Strategy& will be honouring the full time offers? Is the firm doing well?

like

How many round of interview happen for Schlumberger?

like

Got an offer of 8LPA from JPMC for the role of Test Analyst. YOE - 1.4 years, Location - Malad, Mumbai.
I would like to know how much I can negotiate with the HR on this offer.
I don't have any other offer in hand.

like

Hi All,

What would be the inhand salary for 6 LPA in Accenture?

like

I currently do planning system implementation at SC level. Quite technical stuff and less PMO. What are my future career possibilities from here onwards? Can I keep progressing in the standard ladder and keep doing implementations, or is it automatically going to end up becoming more are more sales oriented and less actual implementation work? Especially interested in the SM level and above. I’d prefer staying at Big 4 and avoid the supplier side.

like
like

Anyone have comp insight for Citi - Clean Energy Transition IB Analyst in Houston? Houston IB culture overall?

like

Is HSBC or Credit Suisse or for matter of fact, any account in EY is asking EY employees to work from office or to work in hybrid manner. Any account in EY which offers permanent WFH?

like

More Posts

I’ve heard the culture at Salesforce is considerably more chill than Big D…can anyone speak to this?Deloitte Salesforce

like

How will be work life balance for Software Engineer in consumer and community banking
Profile for Salesforce Developers in jpmc?

like

How do you approach a stinky middle school kid or their parents with hygiene suggestions? I don’t know how to politely tell anyone that they smell bad.

like

See the George Floyd trial verdict will be announced in the next hour.

How are you counseling clients around this? Or, are you not counseling clients on this?

Curious to hear from the bowl.

likesmart

Who let the dogs out??????

like

My wife just passed her echo sonography boards in NY and looking for entry level roles in Bergenfield NJ area. Anyone here have recruiter info ?

like

Is anyone in this group spent 4 years in public accounting audit still waiting for his/her employer to start Labor petition perm process? I have only 2 years left with my h1b now, during this unprecedented time I am worried if the firm may not be willing to incur additional cost? Please let me know if anyone in this group have faced the similar situation?

like

Where did people have success with stamping? I’m a Russian citizen and trying to get an H1B stamp to visit my family. Been close to 2 years since I haven’t travelled abroad and hate it

like

We submitted DS160 for H4 Dropbox few months ago, since then unable to find appointments. Meanwhile, primary applicant’s I797 new extension approved. How do we use this I797 for H4 Dropbox? During doc submission can we just give new I797?

like
like

HSBC I have an offer for Consultant Specialist GCB5. Not sure what the role is..is it a team lead role or is it a junior role? I have 10 yoe .. is it apt? Pls help Thanks

HSBC India

like

Does anyone do short term investing in the stock market (short term meaning 1day - 2 week trades) if so, what has been your best tool for research? Have you found this strategy to be worth it?

like

Hi fishes,

This annual appraisal I have got a good % of appraisal increment on my salary but I was not promoted to a senior developer (although I have been mentoring a junior dev in my team and been part of building the project by implementing new technologies and tweaks) and my total YoE is 3.5+ years. What could be the reasons? What should I do now?

Thanks in advance!!

like

For those of you with immediate family members who are at high risk, how are you doing? I find myself being very anxious and stressed about my father getting sick.

like

Has anyone successfully established some boundaries with FDD? Or tried to communicate with your team a better work schedule? i.e. start earlier but get off earlier?

likefunny

Is anyone know why the wipro extending joining date ? Is it safe to wait till the extended date.?

like

Any recommendations for recruiters? NY RR second year. I prefer to stay in NY.

like

Anyone from Deloitte in Houston have issues with their cell phone in the office? The place is like a giant intermittent faraday cage…

like

Can someone help me, a junior ux designer, with some referrals? Possible companies: Samsung, Accenture, American Express, Google? Or any others?
*certification from Grow with Google and portfolio completed

like

Do you guys think Phoenix will ever become a major tech hub? I feel like the most we're known for is deserts and drugs smh

like

Additional Posts in Accounting

Exit opportunities for two years financial services?

like

What industries is the CFE certification used for? How does it compare to CPA in the length of the material and difficulty? Do most firms pay for It?

like

I did audit in 2 hours for the whole exam did I fail ...

like

What level is the easiest to get a job at in public accounting?

like

Can anyone share recent sign on bonus trends among big 4 firms for experienced senior audit hires?

like

What is a reasonable raise plus promotion increase to manager in the tax practice in Chicago? Numbers are up in a few days so trying to get a good idea what is reasonable.

like

How do i see my utilization?

like

It's refreshing to see RBC's committment to no 2020 layoffs. Anyone know if any other banks are following suit?

like

What has attrition been like for new hires at your office? Been hearing some pretty bad numbers from some of our larger offices.

likefunny

Found that pwc reimburses Becker for CPA review course but I used Roger. Will i still get reimbursed?

like

Does anyone have experience or know of someone who went on a FWA (part-time) but didn't have kids? I'm unmarried and no kids but considering a move to 30 or so hrs/week for my sanity.

like

Does anyone feel so depleted after busy season/filing that you can’t move for the whole weekend after? How do you bounce back after finally crashing? I’ve been sleeping so much I can’t shake it.

like

If you have 4 days PTO, would you rather use it together in one week or take 1day off for 4 weeks ?

like

Deciding between PWC Core Assurance or KPMG Internal Audit for associate role. Any advice guys ?

like

When you tie out all the numbers after working 80 hours this week.

Post Photo
like

Anyone here a manager in PI at EY? Could you please PM me? Looking to talk more about the practice.

like

Does anyone else feel like their anxiety levels are high? I feel like I have so much work but I just want to have a chill summer and relax before things pick up again in the fall. But it’s causing me anxiety knowing that I have so much to do.

like

other than Big 4, what other firms have good FDD groups??

like

Going to easily hit A List Preferred this year. That's a lot of flying.

like

When is the best time to leave and go to another big4? I am at PwC and I knew the reputation they had and Some people said It may not be for me because of it. Ive been here a year and I feel as there right. My busy season is starting and I want to leave (not just because of my team) but as some of you may know getting along with the people you work with is a big part of wanting to stay at your job. I want to try to quit end of December and hoping to start a new position February.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal