{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Tips on negotiating an offer? Percentage increase if the role is a step up? (e.g. Senior Art Director?) I'm always scared of them not wanting me enough and retracting the offer", "post_id": "59c4fd700ccc840012d31648", "reply_count": 8, "vote_count": 7, "bowl_id": "5565cfca8b2b9a03009acf57", "bowl_name": "Advertising" }

Tips on negotiating an offer? Percentage increase if the role is a step up? (e.g. Senior Art Director?) I'm always scared of them not wanting me enough and retracting the offer

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Ask for more than you think you'll get. Ask for a number that makes you uncomfortable. They'll counter. Their job is to get you as cheap as possible, but that doesn't mean there isn't money for your salary. If they are making you an offer, they like you.

like

Find out the max that is reasonable pay for the title in your city, ask for that. Cindy gallop says ask for the biggest number you won't laugh about.

like

I asked for 20% and got it. But no clue if I lowballed myself.

like

I was desperate to get out of my old job and totally lowballed myself. Don't make that mistake and don't settle too early. But thankfully my boss made some adjustments 6 months after I was hired, but you might not get so lucky with your future boss.

like

I just set a hard number and said if you don’t want it ok. But up to you. (I was freelance at the time and they had to lure me though)

like

Just remember that it is their job to get you in as low as possible. They expect you to ask for something higher than they want to pay, and they're going to counter with something lower. What's more, their initial offer is going to be lower than what they can actually pay, for the same reason that your initial ask SHOULD be higher than what you can actually accept. Negotiation is going to happen, that number is going to change. Don't be afraid to play the game they are all too happy to play themselves.

like

I usually factor in the market average and cost of living to get the initial salary I would be willing to accept then I add 10%. I think this puts you in a good position to get a counter offer that is still higher than the salary you were willing to change jobs for. I have only worked at 3 agencies in my 5 years in this industry and my salary increases have been 35-45% bumps between jobs

like

Same as above with IP1. As long as you’re satisfied and it’s within range for that level, then you should be good. If you don’t like how you or they lowballed the salary, you can leave after some time. You’re still not losing in the end unless the work is drastically more and does not justify the salary.

Related Posts

What's the general consensus on how to handle an exit? Do I warn my team and my mentor(s) that I'm going to be putting in my two weeks, or do I put in my two weeks and then inform my team and mentor(s) that I did? Excited to be moving on, but I really don't want to burn bridges or step on toes.

like

i just had an excellent review with my supervisors. we are aligned i am ready to be promoted. i will be moving from project manager to senior project manager. the catch; my company has laid off 75% of its staff, and cut our salaries by 25%. timing is unclear, since we work in the live entertainment space. what is fair to ask for? i have 7 years work force experience, am the only one in my position, touch every creative deliverable the agency makes, and updated and streamlined 10+ processes.

like

I am having 5 years of experience in Endpoint and Data Security. Looking for a change currently. Can anyone help me with any relevant openings?

like

Taking initial actuarial exams and hoping to switch into the field. Looking for any advice/referral from consulting firm recruiters...

like

Anyone looking for a referral to Accenture? Burner email inside

like

I lost my last job a few weeks before Christmas last year and it took me a long while to find a new one. Ultimately I ended up moving to a new city for a job I was really excited about. However, within the first few weeks I suffered a major medical setback which led to a crippling bout of depression. I am finally starting to feel like a person again but I'm afraid the ship has sailed on my having success in my new role.

like

Anyone have insights on the pay bands for AbbVie? Looking at a grade 20 position. Chicago-based. Associate Director level. Thank you.

like

I was just laid off. Any agencies hiring currently for account management roles?

likehelpful

Anyone here who made the exit from Big 4/MBB consulting to a VC? If so, I’d love to hear about how the experience is so far. (Not to mention the WLB and comp!) I’m considering a career change but have no one in my network I can go to for insights. Thx! 🙏🏾

like

Got stood up for a final round for a large tech firm. Interviewers didn't show and the calendar invite was sent a week in advance. Also noticed that the original position I was recruiting for was removed from the company's career section. Does this mean they moved on? Really wanted this role. Feeling down.

like

Can anyone help me with a referral in Accenture Strategy? Is MBA mandatory or 4 YOE in Consulting domain works fine?

like

Can someone explain why I have to do a 4th round interview with the same person that I did the 2nd round with (hiring manager)? We already spent an hour in the first interview I don’t get what else they are trying to accomplish by doing this.

like

Currently working as a Manager in Risk Services. Acquia offered a Partner Manager role. Thoughts ? Would it be a lateral switch ? Worth it ?

like

Anyone from Citi here who could help with a referral for a role. I have the job req ID too. Thanks in Advance

like

I have an interview scheduled for this Friday but I’m feeling very unprepared. I need more time to think through my professional experiences and how that translates to the role in question. How does it look if I move the interview to next Friday? Would that raise eyebrows?

like

Struggling with anxiety...anyone gone to a medical professional for this? Do you just go to a primary care doc first and then get a referral?

like

I got laid off during the beginning of the pandemic. Since then I’ve been struggling with drug use and finances. Deloitte hired me out grad school. I’ve been unable to find a job in IT Controls. Any help? I did IT Controls Audit Readiness for a couple years. The market is so niche and being black makes it twice as hard to find work. I really need some help landing a new role folks. I’m 22 days clean!

likehelpful

Does anyone here work at NextEra Energy Resources in Florida? I’m going to apply to an Associate Data Scientist position there? How is the company culture? What is your experience like there?

like

Thoughts on exiting to a FAANG L6 Strategy role or waiting until July for my impending promotion to manager? Do we think I can push the start date out to August?

like

Additional Posts

Is anyone else starting to get nervous about the supposed return to normal pay at Deloitte? I can't see it happening. I think there will be more excuses and more cuts. I'll have to leave. I can't afford or justify trying to raise a family on an APS4 wage with over 10 years in the professional workforce working 55 hour weeks.

like

My company is looking for Sr. Product Designers with 3+ Years of experience. Anyone who wants to apply as a Product Designer (1+ Years of Experience) is also welcome to apply. Scaler Academy is one of India's top ed-tech company and has been growing exponentially since the past few years. I have been working here myself for almost an year now and I love the company ethics, the design team is full of talented people. Anyone interested in applying may please reach out to me on LinkedIn/Instagram.

What's the general consensus on how to handle an exit? Do I warn my team and my mentor(s) that I'm going to be putting in my two weeks, or do I put in my two weeks and then inform my team and mentor(s) that I did? Excited to be moving on, but I really don't want to burn bridges or step on toes.

like

Can anybody recommend a great piece of technology that helps write scopes? Preferably one where I can input rates and it does the sums based on hours, and % FTE based on project period and year... but

like

Brands that have successfully become a part of culture through their marketing efforts and why? Bonus for tech or b2b. ✨

like

Just bought the new HP Spectre x360! What insurance/extended warranty should I get? HP Care Pack, Geek Squad, Square Trade, or WorthAve?

like

Which meme coin are you all gambling on next? How many millions or billions are you buying? I used to fantasize about traveling somewhere for work and never getting back on the airplane but now that my daydreaming has had to stay in my 'home office' this is all I have...

likefunny

I am having 5 years of experience in Endpoint and Data Security. Looking for a change currently. Can anyone help me with any relevant openings?

like

I was asked to take on formal supervisor duties without a promotion or raise for at least 1 year. Tips on how to negotiate this?

If you sent a subordinate an article that you thought might be related to their current project and they responded with, “Thank you. Very Interesting.” Would you consider that rude? Edit: I am the replyer in this scenario

likefunny

What are everyone's thoughts on going for an MBA or masters? Is it worth the time and money? If so, how did you make it happen/where did you go??

like

Can any senior consultants talk about what their salary bump was from associate consultant or consultant 1 to senior consultant? Thanks!

like

Is sharing recruiter email on compensation with Google recruiter breach of NDA ? How have others shown proof of offer to google recruiters in case of competing offer?

like

Best office chair for 200 or less? (On a budget)

like

What's the salary range for Senior Experience/UX Designers in the Denver/Boulder area?

What supplements did you take during your baby journey besides prenatals?

like

For moms in California - can anyone explain to me how the FMLA/Paid Leave works in coordination with EY’s sixteen weeks? It seems that all the new moms take 6 months and I’m trying to figure out how that works if we’re only given 16 weeks. My husband and I are currently waiting for an adoption placement so I have no idea when I’ll need to use it, but I’m hoping it’s sometime soon :) Since I’m not actually pregnant, asking these questions feels weird, but I keep reminding myself it’s okay. TIA!

like

Hi, all the tax professionals here. I have a question. My client started a business to develop a new formula in year 2013. The business failed and my client decided to abandon the business in year 2019. During year 2013 and 2018, no loss or expenses were claimed on the return. Can he claim all the loss/ expenses on year 2019 return. If yes, what the tax code or regulation can apply to this case? I appreciate your insights.

like

How many days is it acceptable to have 0-3 billable hours when you know a storm is coming?

like

EY-Parthenon (GDS) TSE-IT Team. What does it do? What would be work like? Does it have wfh policy just like EY GDS? Need help please

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal