What are the trade offs among these 3 roles (comp/wlb)?

IBM (Current/Remote)- Managing Consultant (B8): 185k with 5k bonus
Boston Consulting Group (BCG) . (Hybrid)- Consultant: 190k + bonus
Booz Allen Hamilton (Hybrid) - Associate 180k

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

BCG has the highest medium/long term potential by far. But WLB is going to be worse.

like

Maybe potential by reputation gains into MBB domain but highly unstable

For BAH, 180 is great for Associate level and you will likely have great WLB (I work 40-45 hrs a week as an A). Annual raises are in the lower side though and no bonus below Senior Associate (SM equivalent) unless it’s in the commercial sector.

like

Depends on the market as well as the median for your area. The increase will be on par with other associates in your family, maybe a bit lower for the first year. Other perks on making associate include an increase in PTO

Recent IconRecent

What field are you in ? 180 seems very high for an associate

like

Do you have these offers in hand ?? IBM paying that much for managing consultants ??

like

Why?

I know nothing about IBM, but that's a solid offer for us. You'll likely have excellent WLB here.

If this is on the federal side, BCG has a WAY smaller fed practice than we do. As a result, career mobility in BCG fed is going to be substantially worse than for us.

BCG is going to have the most comp upside.

like

What’s the location?

like

That is a very high to salary for b8. What is your JRS?

Take BCG no question. WLB will be the worst but long term trajectory is worth it.

like

MBB is very tough now. If you go for comp then you’re up or out in 2 years. And that’s an individual contributor role to start. Same without noticeable benefits for Booz

Sounds like you might not like it but can cruise at IBM as BCG PL equivalent

like

BCG

How many YOE OP?

This is never heard of at IBM…185K is high and I manage a relatively high paid b7s and b8s

like

Band 8 (Managing Consultant) with only 3 YOE is surprising. Were you hired as a Band 7 out of MBA/Grad School? Because if you were hired as a Band 6 out of Undergrad it would be extremely rare to get 2 promotions in 3 years. A graduate degree would also explain the $185K comp as a new Band 8.

Yeah I’ve been fast tracked from b6 but do have a masters

All I hear is nightmares about BCG right now. For the first time in decades, I hear IBM isn’t too bad. I’d stay there. If you’re in consulting, bonuses aren’t too big of a deal anyway.

Nightmares? What happened?

IBM annual hikes are below inflation

Location?

DC

Seems high for B8

I was 0.93 PMR when I left (185k)

Related Posts

I got call from NTT data, how is the company, hikes, work culture ? How much i can expect with 7 yoe.

like

Looking for some therapy, frankly. Somehow I've tied my self worth to my salary over the years. About to take a pay cut and having trouble accepting it, though I know extra time and overall balance will be worth it. Help!

likehelpful

Currently a new S1 thinking about taking a FP&A role. Is going from Senior to Analyst not Senior analyst a bad move? Mediocre raise in salary (3k) but well known company with a flat structure

like

What’s the salary range for an operations manager at a startup in TO? Overseeing sales, rev, support, success, and a bit of other company ops stuff. Glassdoor has a big range so I decided to ask here for more insights. Thanks.

like

Hello All,

What is the policy for Variable Pay in
Nokia, if we leave the company in March will we get the Variable? Nokia

like
likefunny

Hows the Mphasis directcore division...what project are there in mumbai...hows the culture?

like

Selling 2 Acer HD Dual Screens + Docking Station if anyone is in need of some WFH upgrades. 21.5 inch HD LCD monitors and an HP Thunderbolt 120W G2 docking station. Lmk if interested!

like

How is the citi project in virtusa?

My tech stack: Java, spring boot, microservices, react

Is there any framework used ?

Please suggest

Thanks

like
like

Can anybody help me with the salary bracket for process developer band 5B

Hi guys, can anyone help me with the hierarchy structure followed at KGS? I have total of 6+ years of work experience. Will I be able to pitch in for Manager?

like

Do JDs feel like they’re being significantly underpaid when compared to others at law firms?

like

Is cognizant offering permanent WFH option for new joiners?

like

Received offer from UBS at last moment. I have just 1 week to decide. Both Offers are same. Please help to decide
Credit Suisse Vs UBS
Comparing WLB, Pay & Bonus, Onsite Opportunities, Employee Benefits, Leave Policy YOE - 10.5 Yrs (.Net)

What is the salary range for L7 in consulting?
Location: India

like

Does any one know UK onsite salary for manager role for short term

Hi All,

What will be the In hand salary for this compensation in IBM Bangalore
YOE - 6.7 years
Technology - Salesforce Developer
Current CTC - 10

Thanks

Post Photo
like

How much can sap technical consultant with data migration expertise 5 yoe at day of joining expect at IBM? Cctc 16

like

In IBM how good is the BCBS project for business analyst?

like

More Posts

Any thoughts on VOSO and CND?

Weekly Bachelor in Paradise thread: post your predictions and reactions here.

Last week, Chris crumbled and left paradise (and somehow convinced Alana to join him) after facing criticism from the peanut gallery, while everyone seemingly forgot about Brendan and Pieper.

This week, with Chris and Alana gone, will Brendan and Pieper’s chickens come home to roost? What about Joe “I totally don’t love her. Wait I dont know, maybe I still love her” Amabile?

uplifting

What makes a great investment teaser vs an average one?

like

How close do you live to the office? What are the pros and cons that you have experienced living far/close?

like

Looking for a referral to Dell, thanks in advance! Can provide more info in dm.

like

Has anyone undergone laser treatment for acne scars on the face? Are you happy with the results? How much did it cost?

like
like

Hi Fishes.
Hope all is well. This is my first time asking for refferal. Please help.

I have around 6 years and 2 months of total work experience in TCS , I am currently serving notice period and it's now 45 more days to go . My last working day is on 4th August.

I have worked with pharma, FMCG and currently with Manufacturing client as BA, more on supply chain.

I am looking for Business Analyst, Consultant role . Please refer me for all the opening in your organization.

like

Asked ChatGTP to name best consulting firms for software due diligence. It failed to name EYP, A&M :(

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi Fishes! I got this job offer recently, would like some advise on the salary breakup side of it. Please help me understand what the optimal breakup would be from a tax saving pov for this ctc

Post Photo
like

I read this super interesting article about how big companies like Toyota are investing in social-emotional training for their employees and seeing massive benefits. I actually think this could be a whole separate class for students of all ages. Learning about conflict resolution, growing your own self-regulation skills...it's really important.

likeupliftingsmart

Any teachers here who changed careers? What was the change?

like

Joining IBM in December. under 30% tax-slab.
How is my tax calculated, will IBM ask for my prev. comp Form16? (or my ctc is prorated for Dec,Jan,Feb,Mar)
at least for the 4 months of this FY I need full sal. in hand.
How to proceed. I wish my JB comes without tax deduction.

How rigid are practice & office alignment at EY? Considering an offer in FSO Digital Strategy on the west coast, but want to understand how difficult it is to switch if I later determine there’s another practice more interesting to me, or if I’d want to move office locations. TIA!

likefunny

What is L2 interview in coforge? Will it be more of a technical round or some Senior Manager regarding other aspects?

like

Guys - A seasoned BSA looking for PO / PrM opportunities in asset and wealth management firms. Is anyone willing to refer me to their team or forward me to their acquaintances? Appreciate it.

like

Alright auto fishes, I’m in the market for a entry level luxury car. Open to used or a lease. I don’t plan to use it as a daily driver, live in an HCOL. Only restriction is that I’d like to keep my monthly costs at no more than $600-$700/month (including insurance, financing / fees, etc; have a parking spot already). Doesn’t have to be a European badge. Thoughts?

like

Has anyone made the switch from EY consulting to CBS? Thanks!

like

What is the best performing NPS available on market. Let's assume that I invest 50k per year for tax saving, what could be my retirement benefits out of this(30 yrs of investing). Please help me with calculation and suggestions.

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Overnight layover with some buddies in Doha - any suggestions for St Regis or the W? Landing around 11pm and leaving at 9am we just want to go clubbing and party before the next flight.

like

Bain fish, does anyone know how utilization in North America is trending for this year?

like

Any good book recommendations for new Managers in consulting ?

like

What are Accenture Levels? What's above an SM specifically?

like

Changing addresses sucks, why doesn't the U.S. implement a personal "code" based address system?

Meaning if my address code is "A123" then all I need to provide to my bank/employer/friend is my code and if the bank/employer/friend mails something to "A123" it would always come to my most up to date mailing address even if I relocate.

like

Best consulting firms to work for that will allow 100% remote work indefinitely regardless of what clients do?

like

Hello.

I am planning on moving to NYC Manhattan in September 2021.

23M - Entering my second year in consulting. Looking for a room or for roommates!

Please message me if you have any advice or if you are in a similar situation!

like

Hey all, can you pls recommend resources to get up to speed on Fraud and Risk management for Payments in fintech? Books /sites? I’m not in consulting anymore so no access to internal decks. Thanks!

like

EY fish - when you are laid off, is it immediate the day you're told or do you get a little warning?

like

Applied for EYP TSE Operation Analytics Senior and had a initial screening call with EYP recruiter two weeks ago but she has been ignoring my follow up email and hasn't been responding since. Is it normal or I'm no longer in their consideration already?

Also wondering if anyone from that practice is willing to connect? I'm currently in DDV and very good at Alteryx and Tableau, so want to make the switch.

like

Is there a difference in culture between the different EY-Parthenon offices? Read something on here that the Chicago office is known for being toxic internally. Any thoughts on the SF office?

like

I finally have an extra room to set up a home office. I’m looking at motorized standing desk, but there are so many options out there that it is overwhelming. What’s your recommendation for an L-shaped desk?

like

Any Freemasons lurking around here!? Thinking about making a Bowl for my Traveling Brothers. Maybe to talk about how we view this unique Labor (consulting) in a Masonic context, post some inspirational messages, recommend good books, idk stuff like that...

like

I really need a job that is slow paced and has a good WLB. Anyone have a job like this that is willing to connect? I would really appreciate it.

like

What do people in PE ops do?

like

Happy Monday!! Just a quick reminder to NOT feel bad for taking time off. You deserve it! You only get 1 chance to live your life. There are no do overs. This is not a game!

🚨Motto for the rest of the year: Working to live not living to work.

Side note: you’re replaceable at almost every company but not replaceable to your family.

likeupliftingfunny

Anybody here work at BloombergNEF? Would be keen to hear your thoughts and experiences.

like

How rare is it for a consulting firm to hire someone who doesn't want to relocate to one of their offices but can still travel to clients? Interested in a firm that doesn't have an office in my city

like

Brisbane hotels - Hilton or Sofitel?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal