Wanted to take a poll here. What do you think should matter more when hiring: longevity at agencies worked or skillset/portfolio work?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Skillset/portfolio work.

like

Portfolio.

I'd rather have a great creative for a year or two, than a mediocre one for 5.

like

I think skills and portfolio can be two different things. While a portfolio can and should be an indication of one’s skills, it’s not always the case.

Creatives put stuff in their book when all they did was banner ads or they were one of 10 creatives on a project. Then there are some who haven’t worked at big agencies or made revered work.

To hire someone based off their skill set reminds me of CP+B in their glory days when they’d hire t-shirt designers, sign painters, construction workers, etc. I think that contributed to their cool work, because those hires weren’t hardwired by the typical agency culture and those who made hiring decisions were able to see potential through one’s skill set.

Hiring someone off a book is seeing I have the Oreo Doomsday Vault in my book, and saying “So many awards! Much wow! Must hire.”

It takes a special kind of recruiter, Creative Director, or ECD to be like the former.

likesmart

Portfolio. Only boomers care about longevity.

like

Unless they’re spending years at a top tier agency, I’d wonder why they’ve decided to stick around for ages at a shop that isn’t giving them anything for their folio. Not that there’s anything inherently wrong with that, but you have to be right with it.

likehelpful

Portfolio

like

Both, but I definitely consider the work first before I ever look at career history.

When I’m hiring for more senior roles, I look to see if someone has stayed longer than 2 years anywhere. If they havent, I usually ask a lot of follow up questions to see if theyve just left for good reasons or if theyre the type of creative that just resigns the second things get difficult.

likesmart

Longevity like, time served per job, or experience in years total? Skillset and portfolio work I’m sure are going to win your poll (and I agree), but I also, personally, would be wary of hiring someone who had a bunch of 6 month non-freelance stints in a row. Hiring is a pain, and I wouldn’t want to have to fill the role again if they’re going to bail at the first sign of discomfort.

like

I don’t disagree with you. But my primary point is there are people who leave for legitimate reasons and there are people who find problems with every place they go and refuse to stick it out. I’m just wary of hiring the people for whom it seems to be a pattern. Like with relationships, when people always say it’s their exes fault, it’s often them that’s the problem.

likesmart

Portfolio

Skill set and portfolio, for sure. Longevity is only an issue if you have been with one company for life, and interviewers might want to make sense of why you're angling to leave, or if you move every 12-18 months into lateral roles, and they might want to understand what's behind the jumps.

Related Posts

Hello everyone! I am looking for advice. I am a C&B Team lead ( about 15 years of experience) but all my experience was in Russia. Now I got married and moved to UK , plus we have got a baby in 2019 so now I am looking for a job in UK having 3 years of career break. Although, I am getting CIPD lvl 7 diploma this year. I am not ready for team leader's role now . So my question is about HR area, where could I find a job with my only Russian experience? HR generalist, C&B analyst, HR BP, recruiter?

like

Hi everyone,
I’m hiring for x3 Sr / Jr Application Security Engineers in my team.
UK based, team is 100% remote, although the office in London is there if you prefer.
Pre IPO unicorn valued FinTech startup.
Get in touch for more info 🙂

like
like

Can some body give knowledge about L2 round for wipro, java domain 7 years of experience.

like

How is the work life balance for Data science role in CFR at Amex?

like

Hi all,
How is module lead position at Mindtree, I've joined TR couple of months back and currently negotiating with mindtree at offered CTC of 15(13.5fixed+1.5var@100% pay)
1. How is work culture, projects, wlb, yearly hikes at mindtree.
2. What is the salary bracket for this position at mindtree how much can I negotiate further.

3yoe as Java backend dev
TIA

like

ValueLabs is Hiring Node JS Architect
Dm for referral

Post Photo
like

Any advice on landing a strat & ops role in a tech firm? The JD is my dream role, but these opportunities are few and far between, and yet I keep getting rejections even at the CV stage. Currently in a DD shop, so could be a fit issue (but I can’t pivot…)

like

Exit opps at a manager level - Big4 vs industry jobs? Security Architect at FAANG vs the normal career path at PwC. If compensation being slightly better at FAANG, which one would you pick and why

like

Hi everyone.
Just reached final on-site round for a Senior Manager position in the logistics department. Role is for Amazon UK. Recruiter is asking me now for my expected compensation (base salary + total comp) via email. Any idea what to aim for?

I don’t know the level but was aiming £80k base, +15% bonus. If I don’t fall under their budget, would I automatically be removed from candidates?
Any tips are appreciated!

like

I was told I was selected for VOIS and salary discussion is also done... But haven't even got the letter of intent yet the HR informed that the role need to be approved

How much time will it take to get an offer letter from VOIS

like
like

Any edutech test for the folks on bench in LTI? Any idea on what is that all about?
#new joiner#experienced#bench#ltimindree

like

If promoted to senior associate through internal job move in Cognizant , then increment is done according to new role or old one?

like

I have worked in marketing for about 6-7 years. First few years were in social media management. My goal is to work at a big tech company.

I’ve heard mixed results about the ROI of earning an MBA. My near future goal is to move into a Marketing Director (or senior manager) role.

1) How much does Google, Amazon, Microsoft, etc. value MBAs in the hiring process?

2) Anyone currently working at the companies above with only a BBA?

Current situation: Marketing Manager, 90k, NYC.

like

Hello! Looking for some guidance. I will soon be leaving Verizon after 15 years with them (6 years HR experience, 3 years Operations, 6 years leadership). The last HR position I held will be eliminated and I was offered a severance. I am now in the market for a new place of employment I can call home. I was thinking of trying for a start up. But the likes of Google, Adobe, etc. also seem appealing. Would you recommend a start up as my next endeavor? I enjoy helping build processes and policies.

like

Does HR reference check multiple candidates after final interviews or should I expect an offer once my references check out?

like

Has anyone been given an offer or received further movement on their application after a month or more from your last interview? Not sure if it’s odd that the company reached out after my final round interview to have a call and “discuss next steps” but then they haven’t responded to me since I’ve followed up (I’ve poked 3 times every 11 days or so but I plan to leave it be now until they respond).

like

Hi All, I have overall 9 years of exp in Project Management. Is anyone hiring for PM or PMO roles?

like

More Posts

How is the life and work culture in the exl?

like
like

Hi everyone

Please help me to know where C1 falls in EXL hierarchy and what should be the range of pay cycle for C1 band

Thanks

like

Hi all,
How is module lead position at Mindtree, I've joined TR couple of months back and currently negotiating with mindtree at offered CTC of 15(13.5fixed+1.5var@100% pay)
1. How is work culture, projects, wlb, yearly hikes at mindtree.
2. What is the salary bracket for this position at mindtree how much can I negotiate further.

3yoe as Java backend dev
TIA

like

ValueLabs is Hiring Node JS Architect
Dm for referral

Post Photo
like

We need the ability to filter politics... getting real tired of the same old conversations bubbling to the top...

like

Hi
Has anyone used/given coderbyte sql assessement.
Just trying to get a little more understanding on it.

How long NielsenIQ takes to release final offer letter after sharing salary breakup ?

likeuplifting

Is NielsenIQ (chennai) has dress code? Do we need to wear formal dress to wear every day? Nielsen

Can anyone please tell me what additional perks (if any) Nielseniq provides? Also, with 2.9 YOE, they are offering 16LPA for 6-2 band. Is that standard or are they trying to lowball me?

like

Any advice on landing a strat & ops role in a tech firm? The JD is my dream role, but these opportunities are few and far between, and yet I keep getting rejections even at the CV stage. Currently in a DD shop, so could be a fit issue (but I can’t pivot…)

like

Are poppers bad? Are they frying our brains? Post your thots below

Hi all! I’ve been dating my bf for about 4 months now and there are some things he says/is into that make me believe he is either Bisexual or has gender dysphoria. I could really use someone’s advice who has a similar experience like this. Is anyone willing to chat? I just want to be supportive and helpful.

like

Where are you buying your kitchen cabinets? Used Ikea in the past but that's clear not going to work right now.

like

did your family create space for emotions growing up? (positive and negative)

like

Anyone else’s weekend went by quicker than usual?

likefunny

A reminder to all: we are going through very difficult times. Please help someone who has gotten laid off if you can!

like

Exit opps at a manager level - Big4 vs industry jobs? Security Architect at FAANG vs the normal career path at PwC. If compensation being slightly better at FAANG, which one would you pick and why

like

Anyone at Protiviti in their Cybersecurity consulting practice willing to chat? Looking to inquire about pay, culture, etc. Thanks!

like

How to negotiate at McK? Any advice for what to ask for? Current offer is much lower than what I’m being paid in big tech.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

#IWD topic: In this new era, how is it okay for Ed Sheehan to be popular for a song "I'm in love with the shape of you"? 👨🏼 asking. Basically straight up Objectification. Thoughts?

like

Where would I find a list of all the advertisers who are doing Super Bowl TV spots next year ? Thanks

like

Need to update my LinkedIn page. Anyone have tips on the best things to call out? Clients, projects etc?

like

What are some questions to ask/things to look for before the first time you’re jumping ship that helped you decide whether it was worth it (other than remoteness, salary, and benefits)?

like

This in their 30's, how much money do you have saved? Did you start your own family? What's your age, and do you own or rent your place? Btw I'm in my mid 20s.

like

Which portable standing desk converters do people have and recommend. I live in a tiny NYC apartment so use my dining table as the office during the day but need to put it away at night.

like

My new agency’s healthcare plan only has ONE physician in NYC listed as in-network... is a plan this limited the norm?!

likeuplifting

Funny to see how men are trying to post shit about DMA...

like

Any other writers hate writing spots for public radio? It's like navigating through a minefield until you put out the most bland, uninspiring few lines you've ever written in your life 😑

like

Getting really frustrated with a boss that is completely bipolar in our interactions. Management does not seem willing to tell them to stop being psycho. Beginning to think the only way out is out

like

Rename each agency as a trendy artisanal brand with the “Blank & Blank” format.

like

72andSunny creatives: how did you get your job there and what was the process like?

like

Anytime a client says “thanks for the creative thinking” just know they’re going to kill everything.

likefunnysmartuplifting

How I’m feeling today..

Post Photo
like

I like everything about my agency except my partner. Do I leave if they don’t have the budget to get me a new one?

like

Alas, I don't qualify.

Post Photo
likefunny

I promise you, whatever you have to tell me as I sit down with my lunch is not as important as eating my lunch.

likesmart

Drinking Soylent for multiple meals a day so I don't have to waste time getting/making/eating food. Let's see how this goes...

like

This shouldn’t be news to people but it is.

Post Photo
likeupliftingsmart

So, again my client went with the banner and website design ideas from from their print-based (and cheaper) agency. Now I get to make their garbage. Sometimes I wonder why we bother. #designrant

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal