When do partners decide when an associate is good enough to make partner? I’m a senior and it is extremely clear to me when an associate has it or doesn’t, and moreover it doesn’t take eight years to figure it out; it takes just one or two matters for me to know if they’re adding value or are ultimately just a commodity. It’s hard for me to avoid the conclusion that associates are largely being strung along by partners who are going to can them at some point, long after that decision is made.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Strung along is a funny word to use. Aren't senior associates being paid like 300-500K plus bonus and benefits? Obviously paternship might be better but if you are that hungry for it then you should demand it and if they say no move elsewhere.

likesmart

I don’t understand why this is a surprise to anyone, though. On track means you haven’t done anything bad and you’re a good attorney. It does not mean you’re a huge business generator who’s going to make partner, and any good midlevel/senior associate knows there’s more to making partner than being a good attorney. I guess firms can be more clear about yelling this in your face, but just look above you - are your seniors all making partner or just some of them?

Also, lateraling to make partner at a smaller firm sounds good in theory, but you generally need to be a business generator there too and often partners at smaller firms make less than senior associates at Cravath scale.

like

Yeah you can also argue associates are stringing the firm along doing mediocre work and collecting high salaries and bonuses until they get their in house exit or exit to a better firm, if you have that mindset (I don’t).

You can be enough of a value add as a junior/midlevel mediocre associate, so they keep you around until you’re so expensive that it doesn’t make sense to keep you unless you’re great. It’s at will employment, on both sides.

And becoming partner is not necessary or required to be successful. I’m perfectly happy to keep making half a million dollars a year and never make partner and that works at my firm (I realize not everyone is so lucky).

Not everyone is cut out for partner. It’s ok. It doesn’t mean you’re a bad attorney, it means you’re not billing crazy hours and bringing in crazy business generation.

like

I would happily make 500k as counsel for the rest of my career!

like

That’s a big fear of mine (though never was really 100% for partnership anyway) - and what exactly is “it”? Feels like it takes so much just to stay on top of things already and to stress about “it” just seems like extra suffering.

like

OP, I think if you’re one of the associates who has “it”, you know. I think partners can tell whose cut out for partner by the 2nd or 3rd year. That said, I think as folks get more senior they can lose that “it” factor (i.e., they might have the qualities of a really good associate but as they get more senior they have trouble with the aspects that make a good partner). So generally I don’t think you’re safe until the 5th year mark at the earliest. And even if you don’t have that “it” factor, partnership will definitely string you along and try to milk you for all they can get — there’s an economic incentive for them to do so.

like

I think generally all associates receive the same official treatment (i.e., positive but general reviews, gratitude and platitudes when deserved/needed). The superstars are only differentiated or treated differently when it comes to unofficial feedback (i.e., offhand comments that the associate has what it’s takes to be partner) and other special treatment (e.g., partners stepping in to remove them from bad deals or giving them more difficult tasks or authority to review their peers work, etc.)

like

@Counsel 1, I’m curious, is there a reason you don’t want to try and shoot for an Equity Partnership?

500K is a lot of money. But if you’re very skilled at the work, from my point of view, as long as you wouldn’t mind doing some BD and more admin work I don’t see the the reason to hold back on not trying to double your salary (or make even more, possibly).

You seem very reasonable so, if you don’t mind sharing, I’d like to hear your thought process on remaining at the counsel level.

like

I was never a high biller and my impression of other counsel at my firm is they’re not super high billers either (or they’d just go for and make partner). But I definitely work late nights/weekends etc when needed, so partners/clients get (and feel) taken care of. It’s not a 9-5 gig by any measure. Conceivably I could manage a more regular schedule if I was willing to do more work on other peoples deals but my preference is to be in charge of my own deals.

helpful

I’d say somewhere between 6-8th year. That’s when you get a good sense of whether someone is just a good baby lawyer or can actually be an owner and generator on their own. That’s assuming the partnership decision is made on those factors. It’s oftentimes not.

like

At C1: Does that include bonus?

Yes, it’s all-in. Just standard Cravath scale for senior associates.

like

@Counsel 1

That makes a lot of sense. It you can maintain a schedule that works for your life then I think you’ve found success. I don’t know as many counsels (probably because I’m in a generalist practice) but I’ve observed many senior associates end up billing a ton of hours whether they want to be partner or not. So in my head I had some trouble understanding if you’re going to do the hours anyhow, why not get the benefits? But in your case it sounds to me like you’ve made a very reasonable decision and still have the flexibility to pivot to a different role if you’d like in the future.

FWIW, and this might just be a unique thing about my firm, once noticed that associates who bill 2400-2600 and who spend time on marketing themselves and trying to increase the profile of their group and the firm externally generally do better than people who just put down their nose and grind for 2800+ a year. I think past a certain point more hours aren’t helpful for your case because there will always be younger attorneys in the future who need work but there’s a limited amount of attorneys which the capability to develop new business and ensure critical relationships endure.

Related Posts

I would like your opinion: assume someone at its late 30’s that has been doing Trade Finance (structure trade finance and product development) for the past 10 years. Also assume this individual is looking to do something different but still in banking to leverage the experience acquired through the years... now here is the question: what potential career paths do you see for this person?

like

How old were you when promoted to CD role?

like

What are some of the best consulting firms for a software engineer? Is MBB still considered elite in this area too?

like

Hi,
Can anyone suggest the better option between Finastra and HSBC Technologies? Both are for BA payments. From the perspective of a BA which will be the better option to grow and learn?

like

I’m new to in-house and I begin in January. I wanted to basically better understand M&A and all the inner workings of expanding the scope of a business into new avenues. Does anyone recommend a book or two that may be relevant/helpful? On amazon, I see “The Art of M&A” and “Working With Contracts”. Thank you for any insight.

like

Anyone know if AWS level 7 is a match for Accenture CL4? Is AWS level 7 really a senior manager?

like

Unsure about what to do.. worked as an analyst out of school for $60K 2017-2019. Left after 1yr due to a toxic work environment & to care for my grandpa who had cancer in 2019. Was out of work for 2 years & now have an offer in accounting for the government at $40K. Should I take it because any job is better than nothing or should I keep interviewing & wait for something more aligned with my goals & salary expectations. Don’t want to make the wrong choice again.

like

How much does AVP at citi bank gets paid in FRM - ICG in NYC? Currently a senior BA getting close to get promoted and unsure if it will be a good jump or if Im demoting myself

like

Hi Everyone! I have been working in Salesforce for about a year now. But I am not enjoying my work as it's mainly on backend. I have been wanting to move to Web Dev. But someone suggested that like if I like frontend I should try LWC instead as I'm already into Salesforce. So I'm quite confused which way should I go. Can anyone help me with the same Tata ConsultancyAccentureDeloitteZS AssociatesInfosysSalesforceSalesforceAmazonMicrosoft

like

My team(over $2mm in revenue and $250mm in AUM) is exploring the RIA space. Any insights from similar former wirehouse teams who have already made the move, or teams considering going RIA? Many thanks

like

I love what I do and I have an offer to stay in International Development and be a manager with 86k, focusing on my technical area + lots of travel. But I also have offers from Deloitte and EY to be a GPS consultant at ~100k. Is it worth it to move to D or EY? Have personal financial goals that i need to reach for my family and thats why i started considering EY and D.

like

McKinsey & Company Any tested strategy to move from FDD/PMO profile to a strategy/consulting profile?
How would you bring that change to align yourself towards a strategy profile at a Manager level?
Are there any projects/internships that one can do to gain practical exposure ?

EY EY-Parthenon Kearney Strategy& Accenture McKinsey & Company

like

Hello I am looking to pivot careers. I’ve worked in warehousing, shipping and logistics my entire life. I don’t have much experience else where. How do I find the right move to make?

like

Pivoting from copywriting to _____? Interested to hear from copywriters who are either considering or have already transitioned into a totally different or somewhat similar creative role.

like

Giving a CLE on practical tips for young lawyers, which focuses on practical tips such as looking for leadership opportunities and client development. We want to give a hand out of resources we’d recommend, like books, podcast, etc. Any recommendations for resources we should include?

like

Hey fishies! Been a GVP consultant for 3.5 years now, hard work, tough “in trouble” clients, and just haven’t had the chance to work with a team long term! Been in the industry a while, current Head of DSPV and looking to jump back into FT work. Non-MD so it’s hard to find companies that will hire me even though I teach in grad school and headed for my PhD. Any thoughts? Openings?

like

I’m currently Working in Healthcare IT as a Project Manager. Thinking of transitioning into healthcare consulting. What are your tips on this with regards to companies, options and challenges

like

Hello Fishes,

How is the role -Project Support Specialist ( Learning Studio) in terms of work-life balance and CTC. What is the pay range being offered ? Also, is there scope for growth in this role?

Thanks in advance 🙂

I’m four months into my job and I got put onto a PIP. I worked so hard to break into IB, put up all the hours and even working 2am nights for weeks, learned a ton, and improved a lot along the way as the sole analyst yet this happens. I’m extra worried because it doesn’t seem there’s IB analyst positions out there. Im really hoping come January more positions come up but I’m just praying they don’t fire me until then. Anyone have general tips for this situation?

like

I’ve 3 years of sales experience in retail ( reached 90k over target) and 2 years of digital marketing experience, I love selling and building connections with people, I want to join a Saas company and work as a SDR but keeping getting rejected due to the fact that I’ve no saas selling experience. I love to learn! Is there any recommended courses or anything I can do to get my foot in the door?

I’m a native English and mandarin speaker based in Dublin, Ireland.

like

More Posts

In case I’m not the only one who cares. The strike at Facebook is about union busting. I will be back with more because I am a dedicated gossip gatherer.

likefunny

Any tips on how to maximize fun and convenience at COTA ? Going to a Grand Prix after 11 years and first time in the US. Ill be flying into Austin and appreciate any inputs from folks here on stay , travel , seats and other general inputs. Thanks a lot 😊

like

It is almost the end of the traditional school year 😅. What are your summer plans?

like

Does anyone getting similar mail daily :Know Your IBM January'22 - Register Now ?

Standard scoring

Need 4 out of 5:
James White @ Mia
Mark Ingram @ TB
Jaylen Samuels @ Oak
George Kittle vs Den
Nick Chubb vs Car

Russell Wilson vs Min or Kirk Cousins @ Sea?

Folks in Bay Area... do you own a home here and if so what neighborhood is the best in terms of school district? I live in mtv and the home prices are scary to say the least. (2bed min)

So what percentage of your income do you spend on housing?

Post Photo
like

I just realized I’m the dead participant.

Post Photo
likefunny
like
like

Will TCS change the work location before joining. What is the process

like

In Mexico, travelling solo, for about a week over NYE. Recommendations for things to do to meet people? Anyone else in the area?

like

Hi fishes,

I have 10 YOE and working as .NET Core microservice developer. Also hands on experience in event driven microservice architecture ( confluent kafka). Please suggest me how much should I ask while negotiating.

Thanks🙏

like

Dear All,
I am seeking suggestion, Recently started fishing business.
Presently nothing is on paper and it done same as farming… catching and selling locally in market, We have also employed 26 people to work on trawler for fishing.
Is there any way to register firm to take some investments from market/banks

How is WLB at a MM fund different from a MF? I’ve heard MF are worse on average, but what makes it worse? Is it just the hours, or is the work also significantly different?

like

There are openings in Dhanvarsha Finvest Ltd for Area and Branch credit manager in Andheri Mumbai Location. Product: Business loan. YOE 2 yrs and above in underwriting. Qualification should be Graduate and Post graduate.
Interested candidates can connect me on LinkedIn

like

Burnetters are always last to know about Burnett news. 😑

like

Hi all, I have been practicing for 5 years (admitted in NY & NJ) and recently went in house. I just started a side business of writing blog posts for firms or solo practitioners. DM for more info!

like

Candid thoughts on the Ogilvy LA office?

Additional Posts in New York Big Law

Is it normal to not get a perfect review? Just curious . Does everyone pretty much get some sort of constructive feedback?

like

What are firms’ current office attendance policies? (Would be helpful if you name the firm).

helpful

Corporate attorneys in NY, how many hours do you work? Please also list your year. Thanks!

like

Is anyone able to recommend a recruiter in the NYC area? Second year associate looking for Labor & Employment opportunities at mid-to-large sized firms. Thanks!!

like

Going to a new firm and bringing a client or two with deadlines before I leave — can I do the work now but bill the time later at my new firm as long as I don’t double bill at my current firm?

like

Any recommendations for recruiters? NY RR second year. I prefer to stay in NY.

like

Partners - Do you ever take vacations?

I have been at my current firm for about 1.5 years, and in that entire time the partner in my group hasn't been out of the office a single time. Is that normal? I can't tell if it's standard for big law partners to not take time off, if the dynamics for my group may be different (only 1 partner in the entire group), or it the partner I work with is just a masochist.

like

I’m a first year associate (almost second year). I work at a national firm and I’m not a litigator. When I started with the firm, I was told I could work out of any office. Long story short, I regret choosing the office that I chose. I’d like to transfer to another office - is that a difficult ask? I’m licensed in the state I’d like to transfer to. I don’t know how to make this request.

like

Anyone looking for an apartment in LIC?

like

Any insight in Sidley’s global finance practice? Type of deals/clients and internal dynamics. Thanks!

like

Got an opportunity at a boutique firm. I’m a 2nd year in big law and never moved before. What are the pros and cons of leaving Big Law to go boutique? What should I be aware of before saying yes?

like

Does anyone know if this is normal? I joined a vault 100 firm in September last year. The firm put me on tier 7. In January I had the associate review and everything was normal. After a couple of weeks, I got the call from the hiring partner telling my bonus and new salary (because of the firm-wide salary increase). I realized I still get paid as a 7 year associate. The partner said because I joined the firm later in the year, it’s normal not to advance in the next year. Is it? Thanks!

like

As a (class of 2020) second year whose several classmates from different groups are already thinking about leaving/going to other firms, should I explore other options too? Don’t know if they’re being dramatic about how bad it is or if I’m just drinking the koolaid in my group?

like

If I didn’t go to a top tier school, should I just forget about applying for AUSA positions at SDNY and EDNY?

like

Reposting: anxious q- should incoming juniors start thinking of backup plans? Were offers revoked in 08/09? Or start dates pushed? Would be starting at a V10 in lit if that helps. Thanks all.

like

Have opportunity to work in my firm’s London satellite office for about a year and a half, and then come back to NY headquarters. In good standing with firm and have M&A and capital markets experience. Did not start traveling abroad until my bar trip (did not grow up with the money for trips like that) and think it would be a good personal and professional experience. Any thoughts / advice?

like

A junior associate at big law here. When you get emails from recruiters asking for a call to discuss new opportunities, do you respond declining or do you just not respond? What’s the norm? Do you respond to cold emails?

like

Any POC M&A midlevels here actually feel you are treated fairly? What firm? Have been at 2 firms and have lost hope any M&A groups exist that grant us the same grace and opportunities as others :/

likefunny

White & Case About to lateral into the project finance team of White & Case. Thoughts on the culture / dos and don’ts?

like

What length of vacation do you usually take? I’m a big fan of taking many 4 day weekends (instead of 1 or 2 longer vacays) but apparently those aren’t encouraged in the Big Law world?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal