When I was completing my undergraduate degree, I presented at an English conference. My subject was Teaching Students HOW to Think, Not WHAT to Think. Some people there disagreed. I thought about this because I thought I heard someone on a newscast say that teachers should be teaching students what to think. How many of you think that this is what we as educators should be doing: teaching our students what to think.

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Agree.. we give them tools to see both sides and they then get to make decisions and think for themselves.

likesmart

We have been teaching to the test for so long that we have removed all creativity from the curriculum. Creativity is where critical thinking skills are born--the ability to problem solve and to see that there is not really a box (rather than thinking outside it). Kids can't problem solve because we have been giving them the answers for so long. What happened to asking a question and waiting for a correct answer? Nope, we jump right in and tell them if they can't figure it out on their own. We need to be teaching kids how to think, not what.

like

I frequently said to my students :"I don't care *what* you think; I care *that* you think."

Then I taught them Logic. Syllogistic reasoning, Logical Fallacies, etc.

smart

In general I think we teach them how to think. That being said, everything could be taken to extremes or misapplied.

A kid uses white supremacist or misogynistic language in my class towards classmates I am not going to say "Well, it is not my job to teach little Huey what to think." Nor am I going to entertain the possibility that they might be right about outrageous conspiracy theories. So when a student who is a flat earther wants to start a debate, I will tell them they are wrong and move on.

likesmarthelpful

This becomes political very quickly. Especially because if you teach them how to think (or even encourage them to think at all), Republicans will accuse you of teaching them WHAT to think. Critical thinking threatens them.

likeuplifting

Unfortunately, you speak truth.

I agree with you! We should help students access their own thinking around many things.
What in the world?!?!

likesmart

I’ve never heard anyone in education say that. Sounds like a not so good professor

like

Never! Where were those folks coming from? Were they political? I have never heard teachers talk about telling kids what to think; it’s always been how to think. When you step into teaching what to think, you are indoctrinating—no matter what side of the aisle you come from.

If we taught what to think, our lives would be much easier! But that’s not why I’m in the classroom.

like

Unfortunately, the persons at the conference were educators (university level). The recent mention was someone (politician parent news person?) on one of the weekend news programs. As I mentioned in my original post- I HOPE that I misheard or misunderstood what he said🤔, but I don’t think I did. Unfortunately.

I try to teach my students how to think; I find that a lot of the examples I use end up as responses to essay questions on the tests. Apparently, the students believe I am there to teach them what to think. (If they use textual evidence in support, I cannot argue too much, as using evidence to support ideas is a major skill I am trying to teach. If all they do is repeat back to me what I said, I dock them for not supporting their points.)

smart

I understand because many students fall apart when I press them for an individual thought. Some to the point of tears, and I am beginning to feel unease because I do not see this trajectory having a positive outcome for our future. I keep thinking of lemmings, just following along to the precipice.

likehelpful

So tough, there are definitely times when some thoughts are hurtful and I always try to begin w/ framing thoughts from a SEL viewpoint so students can use their critical thinking and create their own ideas around how their thoughts impact the people around them.

smart

How to think is a better choice for our students. This way, they can synthesis and assess their thinking to make valid justification for their thinking!! As the saying goes: "think outside the box"!!!

like

I 100% agree with you!

I know I'm coming to this conversation a bit late, but I completely agree with the original post. Our job as educators is not to indoctrinate. Students need us to model and assist in their ability to acquire knowledge; what they do with that knowledge after that is their business. We only teach HOW to acquire knowledge.

Related Posts

My wife and I are thinking we may do an all inclusive resort in Punta Cana this year for our big vacation, anyone have any experiences to share? Thank you!

like

Hi Fishes,

Can you please refer me in QA automation senior or lead roles, 15 days is left with my notice period.

YOE: 10+
QA automation testing - Java selenium

like

Hi everyone! I wanted to share an awesome resource. Yoga Foster offers teachers lesson plans on how to use yoga and mindful movement in your classroom. You can also apply for grants for yoga mats!

likehelpful

I joined a real estate team & I was expected to show up at 9:00am sharp every single day. Is this a common team policy?

funnylike

Hello! This is a long story, so I’ll try to keep it brief. I work for a very small supplement company - it’s myself (marketing/acct mgmt) my coworker (sales), and the owner. My coworker is struggling to complete his tasks/meet his goals, and the owner is coming to me about angry clients. I’m afraid my coworkers inability to complete his duties is somehow being reflected onto me? What’s the most tactful way to have a conversation, either with him or the owner? Can provide further detail if needed

like

I have completed 2 years in Accenture yesterday(joined as an ASE) ...can I expect an email today from company stating the promotion to SE ? (Not asking if it will be applicable)

like

Need likes to activate DM
Thanks :)

like

What has your experience been switching from on-premise solutions to SaaS software? Any regrets?

like

Product switch to Engineering?
Hi, I’ve been a PM for 3 years (2 years SaaS ad tech, 1 year DTC e-commerce) and have an PM offer from an excitingstartup. I have 8 YOE and an MBA from a Top 15 business school. My background before Product was analytics and I still write SQL/build visualization. In the Bay Area, approaching 34, and have a baby daughter. keep wondering if attending a FT coding boot camp to get into engineering is a good move. I’m looking for a true work from anywhere, flexibility,

like

The Bowl is oddly silent

like

Guys.. I’m struggling. I really want an MBA. I love learning, want to go back to school, and think it’s amazing networking. That being said, I don’t feel like it’s the *right* move for various reasons

like

Hey 🐠, what are your recommendations of books, articles, or practice tips to improve communication, both verbal and written? Want to be stronger at running meetings, pitching ideas, writing (cont’d)

like

Hi All, I am planning to move to a rival firm but have a notice period of 2-3 months in my current month. Has someone done something similar ?

like

HI - I am M at T2.

Any P/AP in McK London willing to speak/chat reg how certain practice works etc. and refferal ?

like

Anyone pursued a MSL in Taxation degree? Did it open up additional opportunities? Trying to get into tax planning/structuring but don’t have a JD (not interested in practicing law). Currently CPA/MST.

like

Guy,

How can I get into Microsoft without an MBA in a Program manager role?

I am currently an Associate Product Manager. Overall Exp 4yrs.

Is it possible to get in or MBA is a must...

helpful

Hi everyone,

I have got the ey hr mail stating i should provide him with aadhar card, information sheet and latest resume for a audit and assurance contract for 6 months as iam a semi qualified CA.

Here my question is should i take this opportunity. Cause since this is only for 6 months. After that, what i can do, where should I try to get the job?

In mid size firms, people won't pay as much as big 4 pays.

Should I take it or am I making a mistake by taking this.

like

Hearing of layoffs with some Chicago agencies. MSL...Porter...Ketchum...others? Sign of bad economy coming? Hate to sound skittish, but I lived through 2008

like

Additional Posts in English & Language Arts Teachers

What era/genre would you say we're living in right now?

like

Happy Friday!!!! How many of you have started using these one-pagers I hear all the Lit teachers talking about? Do you get thoughtful, quality work from Ss?

like

Anyone have any good advice for getting students to think/respond on their own? So many times when I ask them to write their own thoughts about something and to explain why they hold that opinion, many students get stuck and/or turn to the Internet. And then I find myself repeating, I’m asking for YOUR thoughts about this, not someone else’s. I teach grades 9 & 11.

like

When beginning a piece of literature, I first help the kids access the relevant culture. I have used web quests, but I have found that the kids researching their choice of topics and creating Slides containing information and pics results in more students participating. Recently they researched heraldry for the Medieval Era and reproduced either a family crest that they found or created their own personal crest. Anyone have other activities they use?

like

My district is thinking about purchasing HMH into Literature for our reading and writing curriculum. We currently use Lucy Calkins Reading and Writing Workshop and are not happy with it. Does anyone have experience with HMH? Pros? Cons? Any info is appreciated! Thank you!

like

How long have you been teaching? Also, what does self care look like for you?

When you teach a novel in class, do you assign pages for students to read at home? They never do it! How can we finish anything?

like

I teach British Lit. For anyone else who teaches this, what are some of your favorites to teach? I have been doing Beowulf, The Canterbury Tales, Macbeth, Etc., but want to add something new this year

like

How many of you have a set curriculum and how many of you get to choose the literature/create your own content? Which do you prefer?

like

Is there any writing prompts that stand out to you in the responses you get from students? Preferably ones that are outside the box, but I'd love to hear some tried and true traditional ones too!

like

I teach middle school reading intervention, but I am noticing a high amount of students at our school do not have any phonemic awareness. What are you best ways to combat this?

I can not teach a phonics class and I already pull small groups. Any resources? Wanting to plan over the summer for next year.

like

Ever sit down to grade essays you know will be terrible so you put off grading and then you have to force yourself to read them?

like

I’m thinking about moving up to a high school English position from 8th grade English. Mainly I’m looking for a change. Any thoughts on the differences I’d be facing?

I have high school children of my own, but disciplining high schoolers has always intimidated me for some reason. I have excellent classroom management, but I feel like high schoolers are a little smarter ab getting around rules and less worried about consequences.

I’m told by an hs tchr that the grading load is ab the same.

like

Anyone else experience of a lack of passion for the job in this Covid world? I just feel like I’m excited about what I’m teaching because so many techniques are not at my disposal. I also feel exhausted by the mask. I’m all for wearing them, but wearing it all day drains me. Any helpful ideas to reignite the passion?

like

What are pet peeves you have as a teacher you have let go of? For me it is subject verb agreement.

like

I learned so much about group work over the past few days. I now know to assign kids tasks in a group. I am planning a Socratic Seminar for R &J and Julius Caesar. Any insights or feedback?

like

Hi All! I am teaching English 4 for the first time this fall, and I’m just wondering what ideas y’all have for starting off. My class will be TINY (less than 5) so I want it to be super-engaging. All Black and Brown students. Help!

like

What is THE BEST professional development you've ever been to? (Conference? District workshop? Etc.)

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal