I’m thinking about moving up to a high school English position from 8th grade English. Mainly I’m looking for a change. Any thoughts on the differences I’d be facing?

I have high school children of my own, but disciplining high schoolers has always intimidated me for some reason. I have excellent classroom management, but I feel like high schoolers are a little smarter ab getting around rules and less worried about consequences.

I’m told by an hs tchr that the grading load is ab the same.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Discipline in a HS setting is actually much easier/less of a problem if you understand the difference in classroom atmosphere.

The one thing that most HS students really want (especially from grade 10 on) is to be respected and treated as young adults -- not kids. Now we all know, they don't act like adults 100% of the time. But they're trying, and they want to be treated mostly that way.

As such, if you set up an atmosphere that allows for more open discussion, more agency in their own education, more input into classroom rules (at least where they don't affect results), etc. you'll find that this goes a long way to curbing most discipline issues.

Outside of that, I generally lean less towards 'discipline' and more towards 'accountability.' Which is to say (with things like assignments or whatnot), I don't punish anyone for lack of work -- the grade and parent notifications take care of that on their own. But I will have discussions with them about the important skills involved: deadlines, being able to motivate yourself to do undesirable tasks, and so on. If they want to be treated by adults, they need to learn to be responsible like adults.

The other thing that I find is a large difference between MS and HS, is that the students are more vested in what they're doing. They want to know that their time is not being wasted. As such, you should *always* be ready to answer questions like, "When will I use this?" "Why do we need to know this?" or "How does this apply to the real world?" Most of the time, I try to answer that kind of question as I introduce the unit or assignment; I head that train off at the pass. But as long as you're on top of that, it really is a good thing. Because once they know that there's real-life value to the assignment or unit, they're more likely to engage with it.

like

I student taught high school and did several years of high school special education before switching to middle school.

Discipline wasn’t much different. In fact, I found it easier at the high school level. I could always better use logic with them and usually outwit them. 😏

like

I have taught all grade levels K-12. I would agree that there are fewer immature behaviors to address in high school…usually. It may take a year or two to return to “normal”. Right now, my freshmen are similar to 7th graders in many ways. I also enjoy interacting with my high school students. They get my jokes and are more ready to focus on skills for their future.

like

Having had to do the exact opposite of what you are looking at I will say that discipline at the high school level was a little easier. If your management is good you should be solid on that part so long as you keep doing what you are doing.

like

You can often reason with high school kids. Middle school, you've got little kids that THINK they're grown. In high school, they're closer to actually being adults and not so touchy about trying to prove it by arguing with actual adults.

likesmart

Having taught both HS and MS, I find HS mu h more enjoyable. The kids have a better idea about life and are at least beginning to form career plans (even if they change their minds several times before graduation). They are more mature and classroom management is actually easier.

like

You're mostly right about that but the thing with high school kids are they are at an age that they can are assuming additional responsibilities which also come with following rules. That's why you logic and reason can work on them

like

I taught 8th grade for about 13 years and then I was MADE to move to high school because I was coaching there. It was the BEST move I've ever made. The students are sooo much more chill. I enjoy every day. If you have structure and their respect, they will accept correction and redirection. No need to fear. It sounds like you have ALL the pieces.

like

I have contemplated this moving to HS English or History BUT … my son who teaches HS told me “Mom you do not want to do that. You’d end up in jail for killing a student.” (We have Corporal Punishment in our District. I really wouldn’t kill a student!! I do think I’d enjoy teaching older students too.)

like

Yes and very effective!

Just my opinion, but I find high school kids really hard to deal with. In Junior High, the kids still have some innocence. I guess I just relate to them better.

I’d recommend 9th grade. We really need teachers who understand the young ones and can help the transition between middle school and high school.

Related Posts

Thoughts on a Consultant role at AWS vs GCP vs Azure?

like

Hi Sharks.

I am working in Devops role with 6.9 yoe.

Holding below offer.. Please suggest which company is best for devops role by considering all the factors.. Learning.. Career growth.. Technology.. Wlb... Job Security..

Standard chartered : 24 Fixed 2.5 variable pay
Cgi : 26 fixed.
Fractal : 25.5 fixed 2.5 committed pay + 1 lak joining bonus
Bosch : asked 28 still not released the offer

Thanks in advance.!!!

like

would anyone be able to give me a referral for any openings in entry level corporate positions for RBC, HSBC, BMO?

like

Looking for a position in Las vegas !?

like

Exl offices not opening anytime soon right ?

like

Does getting snapshot at partially next level in 4 perimeter and next level in 1 perimeter will be enough to get promotion? I have received similar kind of 5 snapshot. ( some cases next grade in 2 perimeter)
Current position is associate 2 in Assurance

like

Interviewing for an Equity Research Associate position at Wells Fargo, with a case study analysis being the next part of the process. Anyone have any insight or experience into the type of study this will be? Any insight is appreciated, thanks.

like

Can someone share Uber program manager base and rsu? Would that role be l5

likehelpful

Hello All, I have a case study interview coming up for a Director role within CTS UK/Europe; is anyone willing to DM me some tips or available for a quick chat?

like
like

Does anyone know if this is normal? I joined a vault 100 firm in September last year. The firm put me on tier 7. In January I had the associate review and everything was normal. After a couple of weeks, I got the call from the hiring partner telling my bonus and new salary (because of the firm-wide salary increase). I realized I still get paid as a 7 year associate. The partner said because I joined the firm later in the year, it’s normal not to advance in the next year. Is it? Thanks!

like

I am a Sr. Designer in DC looking for a position as an Art Director with experience in brand strategy, alignment, print, motion & digital design. Interested in all openings. Thanks!

Hi All
Does anyone have my information on the role Assistant Manager PPM.

Is it good to accept business analyst position in 9 lpa in Genpact badshahpur?

like

Planning to accept an offer at Kyndryl with the desired hike and a role shift from Sr. Associate at PwC to Band 8 at Kyndryl. Wanted to know if there are any cons/risks of Kyndryl from an outsider’s perspective?

like

Any data points on expected comp for a Salesforce Senior Manager - Project Manager position?

like

Hi fishes. I am a Data scientist having TC as 19 LPA (all fixed), YoE is 1.8 years. I have a bachelor's and master's in non CS/IT.
I want to make a switch for a higher salary, what compensation should I be expecting?

I'll be glad if anyone of you can provide referral.🙏

like

More Posts

Hi friends,
How is wlb in CBA? In case anyone declines their offer, do they blacklist the candidate?

like

High school teachers, to get to know your students and get them to open up, do you have any specific activities?

like

Hours check anyone? I’m at 1400 to date with pro bono. 2000 target. On track but September is looking slowwwww

like

Anyone know the comp for staff attorneys at a premiere lit boutique like Susman? Interested in making the move as an alternative to going in-house, but also aware that it would reduce comp and might be a step down and result in being seen as a second-class citizen. But I don’t really care about any of that.

like

Anyone is a tech role in healthcare ? If so what is your title so you enjoy it?

like

How much do Outreach care specialists with Anthem / Elevance health earn?

like

Can anyone share microservices questions

hearing people do ASMR voices pisses me off.

like

Curious - would you consider a lateral move to a lower ranked firm if the practice group is higher ranked than at your current firm? In other words what’s more important - firm or practice group ranking?

like

I'm a software engineer, and I've been working remotely for my entire career. I love the flexibility and autonomy that remote work gives me, but there have definitely been times when it's been hard to feel like I'm on an even playing field with my colleagues in the office.

like

Has anyone ever been "let go of"? Either laid off or fired. How did you get through it?

like

Phantom of the opera on Broadway - is side orchestra worth about 30-40 more than rear mezzanine? What is better experience for this show?

like

My husband is going through the interview process at Vanguard for an entry level software engineering role. He just graduated bootcamp but had been self studying for years as well. He's definitely junior level. What kinds of questions should he expect in his technical interview?

like

BDO recruiter reached out for an audit senior position in the DC area. Recommended or not? And why? Insights appreciated!!

likefunny

Does anyone actually enjoy working on decks? Yes? What's your secret?

like

Kpi reply krta b h is group me
Techm need NPS account from kotak only
How to open a new one.

any examples of great CPG work? trying to get inspired past the excessive product beauty shots

like

Hi!

I recently did a job interview and I made it clear to the HR my expectation salary is 60k a year, non negotiable.
Today I got the job offer and they are offering me 54k. My current company is making me 50k with tons of benefits which is why I am asking for 60k.

Should I accept the offer or renegotiate?

like

After accepting the Oracle offer's what are steps until joining. I am not able to see joining date any where on the portal. I am immediate joiner.

like

I received an offer for a mid-large size consulting firm at $80k with a $10k signing bonus to be an associate consultant. Is this industry norm- high? Low? I have no clue as it is my first offer and unsure whether to accept it or negotiate

like

Additional Posts in English & Language Arts Teachers

Anyone have any good advice for getting students to think/respond on their own? So many times when I ask them to write their own thoughts about something and to explain why they hold that opinion, many students get stuck and/or turn to the Internet. And then I find myself repeating, I’m asking for YOUR thoughts about this, not someone else’s. I teach grades 9 & 11.

like

I'm looking for the best go-to resources to supplement middle school ELA and make it more relevant and accessible to all learners.

like

When beginning a piece of literature, I first help the kids access the relevant culture. I have used web quests, but I have found that the kids researching their choice of topics and creating Slides containing information and pics results in more students participating. Recently they researched heraldry for the Medieval Era and reproduced either a family crest that they found or created their own personal crest. Anyone have other activities they use?

like

What are some projects you’ve had students do to show the influence of classical works in a genre?

My district is thinking about purchasing HMH into Literature for our reading and writing curriculum. We currently use Lucy Calkins Reading and Writing Workshop and are not happy with it. Does anyone have experience with HMH? Pros? Cons? Any info is appreciated! Thank you!

like

I recently moved to a different district and am starting to plan ahead for next year. What novels and plays do you think are worthwhile and essential for 10th, 11th and Pre-AP? I have many in mind that I have used before but am really looking for some fresh ideas!

like

I’m a 7th grade ELA teacher in Texas!

like

I teach middle school reading intervention, but I am noticing a high amount of students at our school do not have any phonemic awareness. What are you best ways to combat this?

I can not teach a phonics class and I already pull small groups. Any resources? Wanting to plan over the summer for next year.

like

I'm a first time Junior English teacher. What are some tips for differentiating an honors class from a regular class?

like

I teach British Lit. For anyone else who teaches this, what are some of your favorites to teach? I have been doing Beowulf, The Canterbury Tales, Macbeth, Etc., but want to add something new this year

like

Anyone teaching an 11th Lit course with an EOC Test? How are you preparing students by reviewing for the writing section (Informational, Argumentative, Narrative)?

like

What have been some of your favorite books to teach in the classroom? Especially from POC authors!

like

I’m a 6th grade ELA teacher. I am struggling with teaching writing. Any advice to give?

like

Anyone familiar with the Read180 program? Curious what people think who’ve tried it.

like

Does anyone have any experience using StudySync? I’m a first-year teacher and am feeling overwhelmed looking at the curriculum!

Creative projects to do as a summative for Of Mice and Men?

like

What are pet peeves you have as a teacher you have let go of? For me it is subject verb agreement.

like

Alternatives to The Hate U Give that still has a #blacklivesmatter theme?

like

Ever sit down to grade essays you know will be terrible so you put off grading and then you have to force yourself to read them?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal