Why almost all the PE/VC applicants get into HSW, but only 10-20% of the MBB applicants get into HSW?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

1) it’s a lot higher than 10-20%…that’s roughly the range of acceptance rates for the general applicant pool at these schools, so that’s obviously wrong

2) PE / VC (at a good shop, not random family office of 7 employees) is harder to get into than MBB and much more interesting (fewer investors applying than generic consultants). MF PE is basically a ticket to HSW.

like

Only 10-20 % get into one of three HSW? I thought it’d be 50%. And LMM/MM PE/VC candidates definitely don’t all get into HSW, most probably don’t.

like

I’m not actually sure if this is true, I feel MBB applicants almost have a better shot , or at least equal shots. So many very qualified PE assocs want b school , but the equally qualified MBB ones don’t necessarily

like

Not sure where you’re getting these numbers from but in our Bain office we were shown numbers which suggested nearly 50-70% of people applying to HSW get into at least one of them. I imagine the % getting interviews then is even higher. As McK1 points out correctly, % LMM/MM PE/VC getting into HSW is not nearly as high as “almost all getting in”.

Which bain office are you in?

I would assume the size of the applicant pool plays into this. There are likely a lot more MBB applicants than PE/VC applicants

most mega funds and top mm funds have strong ties to H/S and associates there will almost always get in if their grades and scores are about average (unless there are just too many associates applying that year). the fund will have a partner or an MD who’s an alum and big donor and will go to bat for them

Plus self selection,
A lot of the PE/VC don't even bother going unless it's HSW.

Related Posts

Does MBB provide breaks around the Christmas/NY time frame similar to B4?

likehelpful

How did Big4, and MBB, or any Management Consulting Firm market themselves to get clients?
I do not mean how you are marketing now, but what are the marketing activities and assets that companies worked on in the first period?

like

My career goal isn’t to make it to MBB or a unicorn or FAANG. It’s to feel fulfilled and challenged as I progress. I can’t be the only one that isn’t title or company chasing.

like

Bain & Company Heard MBB offices in Amsterdam have some of the best wlb in europe, anyone working there can confirm?

McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company

like

£50k TC, 2.6YoE working within the change arm of a bank ——- what do experienced fishes think is a good next move for someone like myself? Might want to move into consulting one day with ultimate aim of MBB but also enjoy technical coding work, particularly in credit risk / counterparty credit risk in banking — could use some fresh perspective ; quite confused atm as interested in many things! Don’t mind staying in change management either TIA - appreciate any advise

like

Any tips for those that went from novice case interviewing ability to securing MBB offers? Anyone have a good training/prep plan? ACN’s cases were a lot easier. Looking for info. on how to start!

like

Heard that partners at MBB that focus on public /social sectors (higher education institutions, government, non-profit orgs) get lower salaries than peers. Is that true and by how much?

likehelpful

Hi to everyone, I am looking for a referral in MBB for wealth management or PE teams, is there anyone that can help me? I am currently enrolled in CFA lvl. I and have 4 yrs of IT strategy consulting experience.

like
like

Bain & Company Hi fishes, I'm looking for jobs at MBB. Seeking referrals. Thanks!!.McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company

Anyone considering a move to MBB

like

(1/2) For those w/ technical backgrounds: how did you develop executive communication skills? I’m a year into MBB (post MBA) and have had really great reviews on client, problem, and team

Bain & Company Atlanta people! I’m in the process of applying for MBA programs and wanted to ask what recruiting is like for MBB from Emorys program? Is there a reasonable shot at getting into the Atlanta office from Emory, or are those openings primarily filled by other schools (Duke, UVA, etc.)

Boston Consulting Group
McKinsey & Company
Bain & Company

like

What are some of the best consulting firms for a software engineer? Is MBB still considered elite in this area too?

like

How much weight does brand name consulting firms have on top MBA programs? For example, is it significantly better to work for MBB firms vs. big 4 vs. well known specialized boutique firms?

like

How MBB experience help with Warthon application. I work in analytics and want to get an MBA to get into more strategic positions ins Tech companies.

What are some strength points I should focus on? And common weaknesses. Any tips are appreciated!

Thanks in advance.

Anyone got the skinny on Alix consulting?

Got pinged by a recruiter for an MD role in digital transformation

He claims they compete with MBB and Alvarez.

Thoughts?

like

Hi Folks having YOE of 3.7 yrs in IT, any chance to move to any one of MBB

Got my MBB offer as an Exp Hire! A few insights from my case prep. I practiced ~10 cases solo using Case Coach videos. I'd watch the interviewer speak, pause the video, practice (speak out loud, ask questions, explain my approach, even time myself), then play to see what the candidate did, and evaluate myself for gaps.

I also learned the evaluation criteria and internalized the generic case frameworks.

I do work in consulting and had done live case interviews 5 years ago

likeuplifting

Hi there, I will be completing 1 yoe in May 2022 and looking to join MBB's. My key skills are Aletryx, SQL, Excel with VBA, R, Python, Tableau, and Power BI. I am looking for some guidance from people working in Analyst roles at MBBs.

like

More Posts

Hey y’all!
What are some brands that you’d consider when shopping quality men wardrobe.I’m looking for quality items, not necessarily “designer” brands ( Gucci, Prada and so forth).

like

SOPRA STERIA openings who can join before end of Jan 22

Post Photo
like

As a self-pay lady, it’s really annoying to end a stim cycle with boxes on boxes of leftover medication. They could have estimated more closely and included refills or something.

like

Ibegin is not accessible …seems the site is in maintenance, any one facing issue right now ?

like

Vodafone offered me 7 lpa for 3 yoe java , can I go for it or I will get better offer ?
How is work life balance Vodafone

like

Hi peeps,
On the day of joining (at Vois), when do we usually get the joining confirmation form to submit?
Today is my joining and I don't see any invite or communication from vois.
What happens on the first day? Please help.

like

Is anyone going Mindspace, Hyderabad office? Need help in collecting the ID badge.

like

My utilization went to 50 in IBM, I think I have taken paternal leave since it went down. My manager put my as PIP improvement goal in checkpoint.
Need to know how to bring this up and is that my job is under risk? Band 7b

like

Is Infosys has some policy of 70% in 12th and graduation for experiance candidate also?

like

I have just immigrated to worth, Illinois from the Middle East. I have 6+ years of experience (proofed by a certificate) from Four Seasons Hotel Amman. Can anyone recommend a 5 stars hotel with front desk supervisor vacancy?

If there is a case that we have to quarantine again. Do you all think it is possible for store associates to work remotely? If so, what are some ways this could work? I fear another pandemic or outbreak and so many people being out of work again. I can't even fathom those that had jobs in retail that had little to no choice to not be remote.

like

For the Wharton app, what do you mention for professional awards? Can I mention “above average annual performance reviews and salary bonus”?? Thoughts??

like

Hi Sharks,

I need an urgent reply.

I have Joining with CTS today at 10:30 AM and some documents required for Virtual Onboarding.

They need EA form and they said it is part of offer letter.

So I need to print entire offer letter and sign and send back to them please reply?

like

Hi 🐠,

I have recently joined Infosys and they have put me in a project where I will be the only guy working in the team and the team lead is at the onsite location. Are such projects good? Because I haven’t worked like this anywhere before.

TIA :)

like

Austin residents - recommendations on sushi restaurants and outside bars to check out downtown? I’m going to be celebrating thanksgiving solo with my pup, so am going to treat myself to a staycation.

like

Has anyone tried to enforce a European non-compete/non-solicit (both foreign choice of law and venue) in the US? The employee moved with the company to the US 7 years ago and was never provided with an updated agreement. Assume for the sake of argument that the agreement is enforceable in the country of origin.

like

What do you do when your client doesn't understand OR appreciate your work?

like

Hi guys,
Is it raining in Bangalore? Planning to travel this Friday .
Location - KSR - Vasanth Nagar (Near MG road)

like

ZS 🐠, how often are you at the office vs client site? I’m curious because I’ve heard they don’t travel much

like

S&P Global Hi Fishes, how much salary can be expected for 12 Y exp guy in proposal management S&P Global Market Intelligence

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

How useful is sponsorship as a negotiating lever for full-time roles? I realistically do not see myself going back to consulting after B school. I have to stay for 3-4 more months to keep my sponsorship but starting to seriously consider quitting ASAP

like

Why does Stanford GSB ask if any ‘close relatives’ are also applying for the same MBA class? Would a cousin count and should I disclose this information, or will it factor against me?

like

Accenture tech consultant vs KPMG Management consulting for top MBA exit in a few years? Which one will look better?

like

Anyone open to chatting about their career journey and why they'd like to get an MBA? I'm only 24 and am trying to figure out how this can fit in my life and would love to hear how others have done it and why! Just feel pretty overwhelmed at the moment

like

Pros and cons for LBS/INSEAD Vs US B-schools?

like

Are gsb invites done?

like

Boston people - I have a set of GMAT veritas prep books for sale for $50. DM me if interested.

like

Anyone used an admissions consultant for Mba application? If so any good experiences ?

like

Has anyone gone to INSEAD while intending to end up in the US afterwards? I’m enrolled to start this fall and getting cold feet 🙈

likefunny

Chase Reserve just upped their fee to $550. I’m starting my MBA this fall - is it worth keeping the card?

How much does work experience impact your chances for MBA? Currently in a PMO function and the point of getting an MBA is to exit out lol

funny

MBB nyc: kellogg, booth, tuck

like

Any Consortium R1 applicant to CBS or Stern heard about interviews yet?

like

How would you rank the T10 MBAs right now? Do not know which ranking to trust...

like

I have a mediocre GPA from a undergrad school outside the top 10 (but inside the top 20). Is it impossible to get H/S with this profile as an ORM even if do everything else right?

like

What does the salary progression at MBB look like after getting your MBA from a target school?

like

My SO and I are contemplating pursuing MBAs simultaneously; is it advisable? Any personal experiences to share?

like

Princeton Review for GMAT/GRE prep, good or bad?

like

Does an MBA (US) make sense for me? Male, Indian, Age 32, Married working in tech consulting with 10 YOE. Base is $165 with steady increases and bonus is typically 15%. I eventually do want to cross the $300K threshold but I know stopping work for 2 years and getting and MBA probably won’t get me a $300K job right away. Becoming a manger in my current company/path will probably get me there in terms of TC. Also considering EMBA from a good school (Wharton Global, Duke, Kellogg, Booth).

like

What should I be keeping in mind when deciding to apply R1 R2 R3 etc.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal