Agencies still do creative tests? Saw this one on LinkedIn [agency redacted]...has anyone ever taken one/gotten hired after? Are they more helpful for hiring juniors? Are they just scraping for free ideas?

Post Photo
like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I think it’s fine. A portfolio isn’t always the most accurate measure of someone’s creativity—they could be propped up by someone else’s work or conversely they could be tremendously talented but not have had the right opportunity.

like

Almost every agency I have applied to, including where I work right now, has asked for a test. While applying, it would make me sit back and think if I actually want to be there or not.
If it's a solid yes, I would do the test.

I stopped applying blindly once I realised it is almost a norm when even the worst places (I was desperate) would ask for them.

Maybe this is just in India but I wouldn't be surprised if other places do this as well; I currently work under a DDB-owned agency.

Also, I am a Jr. right now. So maybe the test thing ends in a couple of years (hopefully).

like
Recent IconRecent

I was under the impression *I* was the big cheese.

like

Look, I’m a rat, so of course your cheese is important. But I’m also an idiot. So let’s talk muffins.

like

Nothing screams creativity like copy pasting a New Yorker Caption Contest cartoon and asking ppl to replicate a formulaic McSweeneys article.

Maybe come up with your own “tests”?

likefunny

“What If we use examples of quality that we didn’t make nor will ever make”

“Approved”

like

The agency is Walrus and yes, the same test has been in use for a while now.

Why would the agency’s name need to be redacted when they test is available to view publicly on their website?

like

Just didn’t want them or anyone to think that I was shitting on them or anything. 

like

that agency has done that same test for a while. more of a novelty than anything

like

also that agency has been one that i’ve wanted to work at for a while now. if you get hired dm me and please hire me lmao

likefunny

Lol this test is enough reason to not want to work there. What a joke.

like

This is not an agency looking for free ideas. It's the old crew from Mad Dogs looking to see the weird and wonderful ways a creative person thinks rather than just blindly picking graduates from VCU. Given the diversity issues in this industry I think it's a good way to find creative potential in perspective juniors as opposed to unpaid internships and expensive portfolio school degrees.

like

I like this take CD5
I wonder whether it has in fact unearthed a dirtbag diamond

Hard pass. It’s like asking for free samples at the restaurant.

like

It’s not likely they’d be getting anything useful they can profit from.

But making us desperate (out-of-work or just trying to get out-of-our-current-work) creatives jump through hoops for a general resume submission to be kept on file is a bit too much.

Also: though I like New Yorker cartoons, McSweeney’s lists and The Economist’s classic campaign, I don’t consider having the exact same taste and sense of humor to be a prerequisite for creative collaboration.

like

Solution: If they’re seriously considering someone but on the fence, pay them a one day day rate to do this test.

like

😂 what fresh hell is this?????

like

I would never.. I only do it if it’s paid. And they have to pay my regular day rate. No hourly. No price reductions.

like

All of this. If you need a test to prove yourself then...

like

#2

Post Photo

#3

Post Photo

“Go ahead I dare you to move it!”

That cheese is mice

this test would never translate into real, usable work. it’s not like you’re being asked to come up with creative concepts for a live brief... from that perspective, i believe this is more than okay.

Applied thoughtfully, these are great. In my experience, a good way to open the door to Junior talent with less/non traditional backgrounds.

Tippy never really went away.

Post Photo

Related Posts

Anyone from Google who is willing to give a referral?

like

Hello Guys,

I joined
Cognizant recently, the project interview calls which I am getting is not from my base location.
I have the location constraint, should I wait for the right opportunity or raise this concern to ADP team so they can look in to it?

As per ADP policy, one should not have any constraints and take the project as FCFS basis.
Cognizant

like

HCL Technologies
I team I joined HCl two days back, can I leave now I just got another offer from a product based organization. What will be the process or consequences if I just inform hiring hr that I am not going to continue

like

Is a “coffee chat” the same as a first round interview for on-cycle recruiting right now?

like

It has been 2+ weeks since I completed the Interview & Psychometric Assessment rounds with Macquarie Group , but yet to hear anything from them. I also followed up with HR but with no response. For the record, the interview went well. Any idea if they usually take this amount of time to get back? If I got rejected, why not communicate directly?

like

Hey everyone, I gave Tata Consultancy interview 3 days back and same day got mail as shortlisted and to upload the docs. My status in ibegin is evaluation in progress. How long does it take to get HR call for salary discussion? PS I have 20 days left in notice. IBM Accenture Cognizant

like

Hi everyone, Amdocs hr called me slry discussion today(pune). I quoted 12 LPA.She said that's too high, will ask my team and get back to you. What can I expect from them. Should I follow up with them or will they get back to me with their final figure?

current CTC :5LPA
Position offered: DevOps Engineer
Exp: 3 yrs

Amdocs

I am in a tech IC position. One of friends switched to FAANG by converting the profile to consultant profile. The friend who might have less tech knowledge than me is now in FAANG and earning more. If the end goal would be that the friend might one day be a product manager and me an engineering manager taking instructions from the same friend, isn't consultant profile an easier path to growth. I had been practising DSA for years and the competition is only ever growing.

Hello
Anyone working as a Team leader in Operations team of
Standard Chartered Bank? I have taken the assement for the said role, need some suggestions and informations. Thanks in Advance. Standard bank Standard Chartered Bank

like

Is anyone in Experience Strategy/Transformation in the Netherlands willing to chat about a referral?

I am planning a move there from Canada throughout the summer (and eligible to work there)

Happy to provide more information

likehelpful

Hi! Does anyone work for DeciBio? I’ve been trying to break into consulting and believe their Life Science Analyst position would be perfect for me. So far I love everything i’ve read about the firm, but i’d love to talk more with someone and possibly get a referral. I plan to apply this week. Thanks!

like

Hi Fishes,

I'm looking for a Job change for a Business Analyst role and having experience of over 9 years in multiple domain projects. Certificates: Scrum Fundamental, Agile Scrum foundation and AWS services fundamental.

like

I am looking for a referral for a job in Pfizer. I am a Pharmacist with many years of Pharmacy and Business experience. I am also in the process of starting my MBA. I would appreciate the help greatly as I have applied to other Pharma positions without referrals and not had much success this way. Any help will be greatly appreciated.

like
like

How would you answer the question "Why do you want to switch to data science?" during an interview?

like

Hey all, I need referral for RMG role in L&T, Mumbai. Can anyone help?

Guys, my Amazon BI Engineer Phone Interview is on Tuesday. Anyone has given BI Engineer Interview at Amazon or Any FAANG Companies? Would like to discuss. Please help. Amazon India Amazon

like

Got an offer from pwc in the data privacy role.
With 13.5 Lpa currently i’m at 12 and made switch on march.
Though my current company is an mnc but not that big and no work pressure is there, amazing work life balance. However, there is little to no learning and its very slow, the project is just starting and the client itself is not clear what they want. Do you think I should switch just because its a big 4. Please help me decide. Yoe -3.5

like

If anyone needs a referral on below skills.
Happy to help 😊

Post Photo
like

More Posts

Thoughts on benching kittle? Have jaylen Samuels who I can plug in at TE and could play CMC, Chubb, Gus Edwards as other RBs

I am currently getting interviewed in Oracle. I have been told that there will be 4 rounds and 1 SG round. what does the SG mean?

like

AMC to the moon baby

like

How do you guys do DD on NFTs?

like

Accenture is hiring Microsoft stack.

Post Photo
like

Thank you for starting this bowl! I just turned 50. I had my one and only child at 41 and went straight into menopause. My symptoms were perhaps confused with postbpatrum and nursing hormone symptoms but bow my hair is dry and frizzy yet somehow also oily and my skin lacks luster and I gain weight so easily. Working from home for eight months has definitely hanged my body shape and not for the better!

likehelpful

Looking for inputs...
Is it worth to join snowflake as a solution consultant with hardly 15% of salary hike?
Have a decade of technology consulting experience.
Will like to hear insiders view.

like

Anyone at Google willing to refer? I want to apply to a role I’m interested in. Thanks in advance! 🙏🏽 Google

like

Is PwC AC doing lay offs?
Especially from Tech Consulting (Insurance/Guidewire) practice??

like

Tips to build my brand and network as a junior practitioner navigates their career to the next level at the firm?

like

Most of the folks in PDM received no adjustments is it same on other projects too

like

Do citi bank risk team send their colleagues to US for projects? What is the criteria for going to US ??

like
like

Currently commuting from Newport Beach to Beverly Hills 4x a week for work. I thought I could last till lease expiration (May) but it's really getting to me. Any recs on neighborhoods with sub 1.2k rent? This will be the max I can afford while still paying for my Newport apartment

like

Hello fishes,

I am on notice period and m joining TCS by nex tmonth
end.now I received the CTC revision of 9.8 which was 8.9 by before ....in TCS offer is 15lpa..is it can I ask the HR more like one lakh plus as they revised me in Cognizant? Or shal I just move on ?pls guide me will TCS revise ?

like

Hi Fishes, Y.O.E 7.5+ years. Tata Consultancy TCS is offering 25LPA including variable pay and everything. So just 15% increment on my current salary since they mentioned I am leaving my current organization within 1 year.

They mentioned 8-12% is VP plus 80k from that salary is paid at the end of each year. Is it a good enough salary for 7.5+ yoe candidate. Also any heads up for the things I should look out for will be really helpful.

like
like

hey folks, does anyone have advice on how to leave a company that you just joined? I’ve been at my agency for barely two months before getting an amazing offer elsewhere. How do I leave? Should I leave before or after the holidays? My team/boss are SO nice, and I’d hate to burn a bridge.

like

Hi, I am being offered 27L + 2L Variable for Manager (M1) at KPMG India. Will I also be eligible for year end performance bonus? Or is variable pay the only amount that I’d be eligible for?
Am I being lowballed by the HR in terms of offer ? Approx 8yoe currently at 21LPA (recently promoted) KPMG KPMG India

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

do you cover your tattoos for client meetings? i already had tattoos but were easy to hide on camera, i now have a pretty full sleeve (all visible on camera) and not sure if i should cover them (wearing long sleeve top or cardigan) or just live my best life?

like

I just got into reading books, any suggestions to start with? Which could help to increase media/marketing knowledge.

like

Has anyone been able to negotiate anything extra or terms when being laid off?

like

Hi friends of fishbowl! A year ago I told myself no more agencies. Then I got a job at another agency and I’m basically hating my life more than ever right now. This place is not good for me mentally and I’ve only been here for 90 days. I should’ve listened to my gut but here we are. So my question is what job titles should I be targeting as a senior project manager if I want to go to to client side?

like

Dogs in offices are cool, but who's offering some comfy siesta benefits? 😴💤

likesmart

Anyone else feel like avoiding all these spots before the super bowl is an extreme sport? Maybe it’s just me, but I want to see them at game time... reading ahead takes all the fun out of it for me.

like

Working on a long term brand platform, which had the potential to be a really stellar, powerful body of work.

Sadly, it's being driven into the ground so hard by stakeholders that I have no love left for it. It's slowly becoming an embarrassment.

How do you go about this? Do you just swallow your pride and just take the paycheck? Try to fight for it tooth and nail while you still can?

like

Want to get your opinions on the best small agencies in LA in terms of work produced (media and creative)

like

It’s hard to be motivated when rounds of layoffs happen and you see all your friends leave. But one thing that’s gotten me through all of this is working out. And when I say workout I mean the most pathetic, sad, barely completed beginner-level cardio dance routines. I’ve somehow forced myself to move while on lockdown and it’s somehow forced me to feel better. Whatever you’re doing, wherever you are: get up and move even if you don’t finish or end up going on a walk. Pls take care of yourself❤️

like

Curious how other people’s brains work.
When you get an activation brief, what’s your process for coming up with a solid idea?

Look for cultural moments that you can adapt? Look through award show books? Scroll YouTube videos until 3am?

I know that every brief and every idea is different, but I’m more interested in the process and what you’re creative routine is to get the wheels turning.

Thanks.

like

What agencies do you think are the most supportive of women and families? i.e parental leave, work hours, etc

like

How many agencies that have spent the last year talking about Black Lives Matter/equality/diversity and then don’t do a very simple thing like closing in recognition of MLK Day?

likesmart

Tired of this constant grind and constant layoff situation in NYC. Thinking of making the move to LA. Any thoughts? Yay or nay?

like

What big moves/life changes are you guys making in 2020?

likeuplifting

I think I’m potentially about to be fired this week in retaliation from my boss...what should I do?

like

How long did you stay at your first job?
And what made you change places?

likesmart

Do I need to be a top performer to get hired client side/tech/etc. as a creative (copywriter)?

My book really isn’t anything special but also wouldn’t mind looking outside the agency world.

like

Do you think it’s a better look on your resume to get a promotion at the company you are currently at, or move to a new company with a higher title? Does it matter?

likesmart

Any senior art directors at NY agencies looking for a new partner? Pref someone at BBDO, DDB, TBWA, Droga, Wk, Mother, T+S.

funny

I totally understand the hustle of emailing people you don’t know to create opportunities. I just don’t understand why obscure vendors email creatives rather than production 🤦🏻‍♂️

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal