During my screening call, I said my expected salary range is 85K-95K. Got the offer today for 90K and I want to counter 100K. Is that a bad look? Should I counter 95K or go for 100K?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

This could be interesting, $90 is in the middle of you range, so you should be happy. If you want to counter, go $95.

likesmart

Do they offer a bonus? Good 401k match? Equity? Other perks? If they don’t offer a bonus or other good perks, I guess you could say that you envisioned other aspects would be included in the offer, which is why you gave the range of 85-95, but since they’re not included (and I’m making up a story here), you want to revisit the salary request

like

I like the idea of blaming the lack of stock options as the reason you need $100

like
Recent IconRecent

Go for 100k

like

The job?

likesmart

could someone share their experience with negotiations? I have a verbal offer and nothing in writing yet so I expect to hear an official salary soon. I would be kinda nervous asking for more money

like

Yeah I was recently interviewing for a couple positions. For one I said that I’m expecting $75k based on next promo, so would hope to make at least that to consider leaving. I’m don’t think entitled to bonuses, and not sure about matches. But I set my baseline and they would’ve countered it down most likely. This is cozy industry accounting with great work life balance, so definitely a bit more structure and less room to negotiate there..but have them give their number first.

I came across that tip, and had been working with a different recruiter at the time who I had also told $75k base. I told her I felt that was shortsighted of me, and I should’ve asked what they typically pay for these roles. I ended up pushing for $80k as a minimum for and investment management accounting opportunity. That job came with 15% bonus and 4.4% contribution on-top of of base and bonus, so my total comp would’ve jumped from low $60’s to $96k which was insane.

If you ask for their number first - you can’t leave any money on the table.

like

update: I countered 97K and requested to work remotely from a different country for 1 month (still working in US time). They said they couldn’t do that salary and accommodate working abroad so they rescinded the offer. lol

likefunnyhelpful

It was probably the remote work from another country that sunk you, not the money.

That doesn't necessarily make them a bad place to work for. There's a whole host of issues with having employee work abroad. Some local or even regional player can't operate with that kind of risk.

When you said 95 wasn’t your expectation that they would counter with something less?

like

Go for a more targeted number like $97,500. Makes it seem as though you've done thorough analysis of your market worth and not just targeting the 6 figure mark.

likesmarthelpful

Always ask for more before you start. Negotiate, negotiate, negotiate

like

When they ask why More money?

someone interacted with this post and gave me a notification so here’s another update nobody asked for: got an offer at $114k base, plus RSU and annual bonus target 12%. and the 401k match is 1:1 up to $15k 😂 in the end i had to stay in the same city instead of moving 6 hours away but this job is much better

likeuplifting

Was the offer verbal or written? If it's written, I assume that there are no other comp. If that's the case, go with 100k. Industry usually offers 5 to 10% bonus and other comps like stock options. It won't hurt to ask.

Is it a private company? No annual bonus and no stock options, no 401k matches... Did you know how much you have to contribute for insurance plan? Put everything in a spreadsheet and calculate all factors. If you ended up paying a lot for insurance, it is not worth of pursuing IMHO.

like

I’ve read to always counter 10% higher than you initial offer, which your $100k is in line with. I just went through this process my initial number was the top of the range I gave in my phone screening. I came back and countered at 10% more after taking about a week to think about it and they accepted within an hour. Only caveat they had was that I won’t eligible for a bonus or comp cycle adjustment this summer.

Related Posts

Hi All,

Kindly help me in resolving the dilemma

MBA with Total YOE - 7+, relevant YOE- 5.3 , Skills - CYBERSECURITY,GRC, Audit.

I have got two offers
1. Genpact - 27 CTC (24 fixed + 10% variable plus gratuity) Manager level
2. Airbus - 23 CTC + 5 L JB
I really wanted to work with Airbus but they are not budging from the offer of 23 even after I told them I have a better offer from Genpact with better position. HR said they will come back..

You think Airbus will come back with better offer?

like

I started in my first SDR position in a small SaaS start up few months ago. I am the only SDR and their first ever.
The base salary is ok but I haven’t received any commission structure up to this day.
I book an average of 3-5 demos per week. People always show up, but the thing that worries me is that I do not have a way to track how many meetings I book in our CRM,and to be honest I feel like I didn’t get the best training overall. Should I start looking somewhere else? Thoughts?

Thanks

likehelpful

Any Scimitar 🐠 or folks familiar with Scimitar? A colleague at EY just accepted a role there and claims the total comp is 40% more than his total comp at EY and he was at the very top of the senior consultant pay band as an MBA hire. The folks on LinkedIn look like a bunch of former PwCers.

like

I have about 4 years of experience and an MBA degree. I have currently joined one of the Big 4s as Consultant but recently got an offer from McKinsey digital as a Knowledge Analyst. Do you think it will be a right decision to take this offer? I am being offered about 20 lpa (including all components)

Hello Brother & Sister fishes,

Please share what would be the my in hand salary as per your experience if you are getting approximately near to 12 - 14 LPA.

Tech Stack : eLearning Consultant
YOE : 5 yrs

Note: No offence, Kindly don’t bully in reply section, I know I am under paid as per my YOE looking to the current market standard.

Post Photo
like

Salary slab for EY GDS manager rank 32 and year range

At what point in my career as a receptionist should I consider asking for a raise? After one year? After five?

like

Whats the ideal package to ask for in consulting industry for a professional with manufacturing background in india ?

like

I have recently joined Wipro, in my offer letter my location is mentioned as Gurgaon and in PSP page under Project Allocation location is mentioned as Banglore, so what is my base location ?

like

What's the payscale range for Learning managers in India?

like

What should be the ideal salary of cloud/devops engineer with 12 years of exp and having exp of working for multiple e-commerce companies.

like

How much does KPMG KGS offer for
Role: Consultant
Location: Pune
YOE: 9
Profile: BA, Financial Services Solutions

I had cleared all the rounds in S&P and had salary discussion 1.5 month back. The HR is always saying the management is on leave and will soon get the approval and release offer. Today she shas asked for one more week to release the offer. Should I wait for it or move on. Are they waiting for some other candidate to join before rejecting me at last moment. Only 10 days of my LWD are left.

Want to negotiate salary at an AMLAW200 firm in atlanta. Not a lot of public information about what peer firms (ie, not NY lockstep firms matching cravath scale) pay. What are mid-senior level associates making in Atlanta?

like

What would you consider a good appraisal for a Back Office Operations role? Is pushing for 20% too much? I am quite sure I am underpayed.

Hey fishes, last week into my notice period. Help me choose between Nagarro (Staff Consultant), Aristocrat Technologies and Coforge (Lead BA). Nagarro Aristocrat Technologies Coforge Tata Consultancy EY Criteria: Quality of work, Growth prospects Thanks a lot !

like

Hi Fishes,
What will be my in-hand salary?
Can anyone help me with that?
Tech Mahindra

Post Photo
like
like

Hi ,
I have an experience of 1.8yrs as a business analyst in wipro with 4lpa ,how much can I expect with an another company.

like

So I’m charging jobs due to unforeseen situations to another company as a assistant manager and I wanted to know is it unprofessional to turn down a job after you already accepted the offer to take another companies offer if the pay is better by $5000-?

likesmarthelpful

More Posts

Hill holiday and Arnold: heard massive layoffs at both places. Is everyone ok?

like

How many agencies give cost of living/yearly raises vs just a “yearly bonus” ?

Can ya guess which one Barkley is?

like

Best tacos in SD? I'm all ears

like

Hi Everyone,
Does
EY provide joining bonus?
EY

How’s everyone doing?

like

Do all big 4 firms “even out” experienced hire salaries over time?

like
like

Hello Fishes,

Anyone here as VP or AVP in barclays...I've came across with one very suitable opening with barclays... Can anyone reffer me please?

like

Roth vs Traditional 401k, thoughts?

like

Anyone else get awful anxiety while hungover? My chest is always super tight the next day after drinking

like

I have accepted a job at Buckingham Strategic Wealth. My current employer wants me to stay. Is this a good company to work for? Seems like a great place! I know every place of employment has some issues.

likehelpful

I have an offer for $130k for a senior attorney position in a boutique L&E firm. Also have a recruiter who thinks she can get me into another for $150-170k. Both are more than I’ve ever made (Denver, 17 yrs of experience but completely different practice areas). Any tips for countering the $130k offer for more using the other potential offer while not risking a complete withdrawal of the current offer? I’ve never been in a position to bargain my starting salary so this is all very new to me.

like

Big match tomorrow. Post today!

Hi fishes! I recently graduated. I got campus placed as associate analyst consulting in Deloitte in my 5th semester. It's been an year there was no communication from the Deloitte apart from the letter of intent. Now recently I received a mail saying we'll be onboarding in phases and onboarding will be completed for 2022 batch by February 2023 . Legit they are making us wait for another 6 months....like wtf is thissss!??!????!!!! Your opinion/advice/suggestions are most welcomed!!!

like

If you could, how would you change things to prevent yourself from becoming unemployed?

likehelpful

Expecting an offer today from Deloitte consulting (commercial). Would love to hear tips and advice on how to react to the call and negotiate/what to negotiate more for. I was laid off back in the fall and will 100 percent take the offer - super excited!! But don’t want to show my emotions. TIA

like

Hcl offer me 12 lakh on 8.6 years and CTS is giving me 16 lakh... Will hcl revised my offer letter on basis of counter offer and match the same ... I want to join HCL but they offer me less amount

like

Should i join s&p now, I heard some bad news of its merger..

like

Additional Posts in Accounting Exit Opportunities

Looking to switch from tax associate to big4 tax senior. Any referral/recommendations? TIA.

likefunny

Is it too early to start applying for industry jobs to start after the April tax deadline?

like

Doing a panel interview with 2 managers tomorrow for a senior accountant role- Any tips? I never did an interview with 2 people at the same time

like

For those who went from audit to FDD, what is the biggest difference in the work you do? From the look of it, it's basically audit minus control work. I love audit in general but hate controls. Seems like a good move?

like

2nd year staff from Big 4 looking for a Staff Acct position?Co pays 70/75k max.CPA not mandatory but pref working on it.High growth env. PERSONALITY important.Hardworking&can put in the hours.Bay Area

funnylike

Can anyone working for DT’s ARA or PwC’s CMAAS tell me what does their job specifically include, hours and exit opportunities?

like

Has anyone heard of Lurie LLP I’m seriously interested in their private client service/wealth advisors

like

Has anyone moved from B4 to a startup biotech? Position seems really interesting but overall seems risky. They’ve only had a Series A financing

like

Who has the best M&A Tax Practice ?

like

What are some of the more common exit jobs that audit managers take?

like

Is it possible to switch path from tax associate to data analysis?

like

Currently controller at a smaller company reporting to the cfo. What are some next career moves back to larger companies or how easy would it be to jump to the consulting side?

like

Could anyone tell me the pay range for Citi bank internal audit for AVP level in UK? @citibank Citi

like

Has anyone actually gone through with accepting an offer from the Siegfried Group? I hear from a recruiter representing them probably once a week. How is it?

like

How useful is a CPA license in finding a non-accounting job? Eventually I want to go into more of a financial analyst role but tbh I’m curious about what most people leave auditing to go into. I’m open to anything.

like

Has anyone used indeeds resume writing service and is it good? If not what do you recommend below $100

like

Do you think getting SQL/Python experience is worth the extra time for financial analyst roles coming from Big 4 tax consulting? I would love to hear any advice for shifting towards the financial modeling path from accounting. Thanks!

like

How would one make the switch from internal audit to change management? Trying to get out of IA and work in change management but need some pointers to start.

like

HCOL audit SM looking to leave big 4. What should be my comp expectation?

like

I have been in Risk Advisory for about 5 years but I have been feeling extremely bored with the work and I am currently contemplating my next career move. What are realistic career opportunities for me excluding technical accounting, internal audit and compliance? Would obtaining an MBA help my career prospects?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal