Fishies, I need your help. I received an offer for $160k from guidehouse. I’m currently paid $133k at EY. I don’t particularly love my practice as it is testing and the new practice with guidehouse would be IT strategy. EY has gotten me comfortable with the reimbursement for fitness, phone and internet and the promises from Kelly Grier of “really good bonuses and raises” this year. What would you do?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I'm not sure why this is a consideration here. The raises and bonuses aren't going to make up for 27K difference in base salary. I imagine Guidehouse will also have benefits too, even though they may not be quite up to the same standard as EY. Of course, that also depends on what benefits are you actually using, because otherwise it doesn't matter. Example: amazing maternity leave benefit doesn't help you if you're not having kids anytime soon.

like

I can’t tell you what is best for you but I can tell you that my SO left Guidehouse as he has never been so unhappy with a company before. The benefits were very below average and he was saying many people hired at significantly higher than market value, but also expected to perform well above their abilities. The current staff is being paid at market and find resentment with the new hires coming in. The workforce there is full of very talented people and kind people but I think that their business model has a lot to be desired. Either way good luck

likehelpful

This is helpful. Thanks for sharing. How long did your SO stay at guidehouse before leaving? Where did he exit to?

Recent IconRecent

Still hard to wrap my head around paying someone 160k as they address folks as fishies.

likefunny

Y’all need to loosen up and have some fun! 🤪🤣

Leave.

like

Jump.

like

"I don't particularly love my practice ".

You straight up say you aren't enjoying yourself.

You got a better financial offer elsewhere.

Why would you stay?

smartlike

Leave

like

Leave! I didn’t enjoy Testing, and would jump at the chance of IT Strategy

like

Jesus - is 30K less than your phone and gym expenses?

likefunny

If you leave every year, that might be an issue, but otherwise, I think it's fairly normal for the industry. Plus the need is so high in general now, they'll overlook it

I would hop, it's a no-brainer

like

One of the reasons the pay is so high is because we desperately need people. Depending on what level you come in at, you likely won’t see much increase year to year starting out so high. Also, while our strategy teams try to do strategy, there is also a decent amount of A-123 and technologu testing, etc. and no way to know if they might move you to one of those roles.

likesmart

My experience on raises at Guidehouse is much more than inflation and reflected my strong performance ratings. It was never 1% like some are saying. Bonuses for MCs is strong.

like

What group are you in at EY?

What group are you joining at Guidehiude?

When is your next promo at EY and expected salary increase?

How is WLB now and are you moving from MCOl to HCOL etc.. ?

like

Do fish love land. Are lions vegetarian. Do birds swim. No so why would OP like testing dummy!!

Benefits are getting cut left and right at guidehouse. Get the details and see how much difference that will make up. I can't really complain too much about it here but the benefits

like

Phone stipend is 65/mo, if I remember correctly

helpful

Benefits are on the slim side because we are PE-owned and they want cash liquidity. On the plus side, the comp is good.

We are intentionally poaching other Big 4 people to stand up our core competencies. We’re a little rough around the edges but the opportunity to get in early is good, I feel. And IT Strategy and tech consulting in general is a big play.

I agree that you prob won’t see as much pay rise once you’re in - until you’re promoted. AD is 160-190 I think, D is 210 upwards in T1 city.

like

@guidehouse2 - are you part of it strategy? How are you liking the work?

DM me if you want a detailed conversation. I think I have an idea of the position you are being recruited for. And from what I've heard and seen, your experience at GH varies by practice and leadership. So I'd take these blanket statements with a grain of salt.

like

Leave

Would also leave.

Damn 160k from GH? How many YOE? Technical or non-technical?

Jump baby!

Is whatever you’re getting in perks more or less than the new salary?

If it’s substantially less, leave

Related Posts

Can I bring my parents and sibling also in relocation reimbursement and also for the hotel accommodation?

like

I gave an interview in Accenture and the manager wants me to move to Hyderabad,but I'm comfortable with the Kolkata location. I've cleared two rounds and now the Hyd manager is telling me that if I move to Hyd otherwise they will not proceed with my application any further. Can anyone suggest to me what can be done here?

like

Why are salaries so damn low in London 😭 i should make >60k TC (touch wood) with ~1YOE but I still don’t feel I could rent a decent place in zone 2 on my own :(

like

Will IBM pune match the counter offer for 9 YOE??

like

Can anyone suggest whether leaving Deloitte USI for IBM a good discuss overall?

Wondering if anyone can give insight as to what salary range is for an insurance compliance role as an IC3 or similar?

like

Is notice Period negotiable in Optum?

like

I had Technical and Managerial discussion with TCS on 2 sept. I was told I will get HR call.Then on 11th sept i got onboarding email to submit documents and the next day all the documents got verified but since then I didn't get any update and it has been more than two weeks.Ibegin portal shows evaluation in progress. Any idea if they will be sending an offer?

Bain & Company Hi, what is the typical hiring process for Bain & Co India practice, for the Consultant level? What are the tips and things I should keep in mind to easily crack the interview? Bain & Company

like

People who got 10% hike being in that CTC that was alloted to them 2 years ago when they joined!!

Post Photo
like

I have offer of Accenture and S&P. With same compensation which should I choose. Qa Automation engineer with 4+ years of experience

like
like

What's Deal Tech team in EY Parthenon? What do they do?

like

Hi guys, I have got an offer from Verizon. Role: MTS-3. Package: 21Lakhs (Fixed) + 12% Variable pay + 45 days of monthly salary as relocation expense + 50,000 joining bonus. YOE: 5.6 Years. Does the package look fine or shall I negotiate further?

HELP ME PLEASE… I AM IN THE WORST SITUATION…☹️

I‘ve joined Globant 3 months back. They have offered me very good CTC & the position is Senior Developer. I’m on bench till date & there are few more too. Being on the high CTC side & Higher position, I’m bit tensed about my career over here. Can someone please help me if it is a normal situation in Globant? Or I should worry & should be active again? Also, is there any layoff happened in Globant in the past couple of years.

like

Bbdo or McCann?

like

Can someone help me understand my in-hand salary? TDS will be deducted on which amount?Wipro

Post Photo
like

How is EY client in LTI? Role: .net core + Angular for my cousin . Iam surprised that Ey itself provides services and it is client for LTI. How is the work and learning in ey client project in LTI. Please reply.

like

I have an interview for a production manager position in Apparel next week. I am not sure what salary and additional benefits I should ask. The salary range around the metro area is 85k-120k for this position. Can someone give me some advice?

like

More Posts

Tmrw is my joining date with optum when will I receive joining formalities and onboarding procedure

like

NFT’s... no interest in buying them but very interested in buying into whatever it is that makes tick. I think there’s a lot of money to be made off of such a ridiculous investment. Any ideas on what to buy to take part in the business of NFT’s, without having to pay $69 million for a drawing of a cat?

like

Hi Sharks, I don't have any friends in Tech Mahindra. Need to confirm one thing. I am holding offer from TechM and HR told whatever total variable pay we mention in offer letter, we pay the same on Monthly basis in salary.
Is it true?
Kindly confirm.
Also please let me know how's TechM for SAP functional consultant profile?

like

Want to send a thank you gift card to those who wrote me a letter of recommendation. Is $50 from Amazon good enough? From what I can tell, each recommender spent about 4 hours on this. Thoughts?

like

Best way to casually come out to coworkers?

like

Anyone from Code Vyasa?

like

Anyone want a referral to pwc. We’re hiring!!

funny

Layoff going on in Synechron ?

like

What is ideal package for tech consulting with yoe 8.5.
Or say whats the bracket for salary in ey for this yoe slab

uplifting

Was on a call hungover and high today negotiating a $1.5M contract 😬

likeupliftingfunny

If you could give me one piece of advice to make my work days better, what would it be?

like

Which PE firms in Boston have the best reputations?

like

💲For those who DON'T think a six figure salary is possible:

👉Just ask for it. Really, you would be surprised. Might be easier to switch to a new company and ask. I did that 3 years into my career.

And 🛑 wasting your time at a company that under-values you severely. Sometimes switching companies every 2 years or so will allow you to keep raising the bar for yourself.

like

Does this debate remind anyone of an agency meeting, where people just talk over each other?

likefunny

Hi everyone. My high school is going to be adapting a hybrid model at the start of the school year. I plan to take a digital approach to everything. I have plenty of activities from the past that involve interaction and conversation in the target language, but I was wondering if anyone has some great digital or distance learning activities or ideas to share?

What is average hike received Persistent Systems Limited assuming one to be an average performer Persistent Systems Limited

like

 I heard a commercial on the radio for Verizon that said something to the effect that parents are now learning how to lesson plan. Are any of you off the hook for lesson planning? Just wondering because I’m over here busting my butt!

funnylikehelpful

Some questions to discuss: What firms are making the biggest moves in cannabis? Who will be seen as a market leader in the industry by the end of 2020. As the legalization movement sweeps the U.S. ...

like

I've read through every one of these threads and used the observations / advice I've seen here paired with my own research to get "into the game." It seems like Ripple, Monero, Gnosis, and Golem are the ones worth being in outside of the "big 3" (not MBB). I also bought $1000 worth of ethereum at $210 yesterday because I thought that was a good price, but it's only continued to fall... is that a long term hold or should I convert it to Gnosis or something else?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Friend: "Where do you want to go on vacation?" Me: "Honestly, just to my patio. With a book and a drink." #RoadWarriorDreams

like

Is it viewed more favorably to go through a recruiter or personal referral for MBB?

like

For those that have been laid off, how’s the job search going? Have you gotten offers fairly quickly (I.e. 2-4 weeks after getting the notice)?

like

Who are the top consulting firms for competitive strategy?

like

Anyone wake up feeling like they having a quarter life crisis every two years? Woke up yesterday feeling young and wanting to go out; woke up today wanting to have a kid 🙄 wtf is going on? Normal?

like

Best consulting firms for PE work (CDD,Value Creation)? Looking for the best firm for exit ops to PE ops eventually. Thanks!

like

How many snapshots you have? I only have five client snapshots so far

like

Can we all agree to buy one Cadbury Cream Egg each this year so that they can afford to make a new commercial? #BawkMeow

like

Smart to look for a new job with a “recession” looming? Wanted to leave by end of the year, but nervous I’d be the first laid off at a new spot

likesmartfunny

Barack is in the Waldorf Astoria!

like

Thoughts on Wealth Management as an industry? Offered a role to work under a senior FA and eventually take over the book (~$800M AUM and growing). It sounds great, but I am worried about the disruption this industry is facing with Robo advisors and other low cost, DIY options. I’d want to make sure the clients stay through the transition, and I don’t want to join a dying industry. Thoughts and advice?

like

Beside toastmasters, what are other ways to improve communication and public speaking skills? Books, podcasts...?

like

BCG folks, I hear rumors of layoffs happening given the slow pipeline. Is it true?

like

Top consulting firms in the aviation / urban air mobility space?

like

I got laid off from deloitte. Now i work in cre asset management. I don't love my job. I am on visa (opt stem) . I need to work on finding happiness with my work to be more productive and be happy. I am very depressed and therapy isn't helping. If anyone is in a similar situation or can offer support or advice I would greatly appreciate it. TIA.

like

Is anyone from Nashville or know downtown Nashville well? If u had to stay at the sheraton grand or ac hotel which would u stay at and why? For location and for the property?

like

Deloitte ladies - do you know if facials are covered under health subsidy? I know massages are but not sure abt facials.

like

I feel stuck as a Strategy Manager and want to make a career pivot at 35. But have no idea what i should do? Any suggestions, resources or books that I should read to help with my existential mid thirties crisis? I have experience in technology consulting, corporate strategy, freelance consulting and law. Do I go back to being an Attorney, or do I retrain and become a financial advisor or something else?

like

Top consulting firms right there!!

Post Photo
funnylike

Any good business/consulting books on amazon kindle that y’all have read that has helped you in your job?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal