How different is a strategist role in a media agency vs strat planning in a creative agency?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Different enough for the media experience to be seen as not being relevant at all.

like

I wish you all the best in your goal. If you really want it, you will get there. Transferring inside your existing company could be the best bet, especially if they value you in your current role - just be prepared to be patient and try and build it into your end of year review/goals. Maybe your current company will help you make the shift over time.

like

Creative planning can seem like a bit of a black box to people outside / trying to get into the discipline. There are people like Mark Pollard ( google him ) doing wonders trying to help aspiring planners get into the industry.

Working in media won't harm your chances, however it might just be worth going straight for the job you want to do. Education in the field should help you get an entry level job, or shadowing a planner at your current job and letting your managers know your aspirations to move from a/c to planning can also be a route.

like

I don't think it's fundamentally that different and I've worked in both. You can always learn the technical stuff and the language. Being a strategist... understanding how to investigate deeply and with empathy, employing an iterative process, thinking strategically, articulating clear, actionable ideas... is what makes a good strategist and good strategist. And in my opinion a good strategist should be able to almost seamlessly work across disciplines and variables. It's one of my biggest pet peeves that employers sometimes put you in a box - if you've done retail/experience/comma/brand etc. that's all you can do. Twice I had a boss that saw strategy as the above and working for and with them were some of my most rewarding professional experiences.

like

Creative agency panning is focussed on the the right message. Media agency planning is focussed on the right moment/location to deliver the message. In a perfect world both strategists would work side by side, influencing each other.

like

I've thought of all this too but wonder, would a media strategist gig be more likely to lead to a comms planning role? Cause comms planning, albeit super specific, seems a lot like a higher level media planning in my mind

like

If you rely on recruiters to contact you on LinkedIn as your career strategy then yes, working in media probably won't be your route to a creative planning role. However, if you have a curious mind and are motivated, no prior job should exclude you from planning. By it's very nature, the job requires you to have a broad understanding of the world around you. Education is also never a negative IMHO and I have employed two graduates of Miami ad school who are exceptional.

like

Creative agency = plan for what the creative needs to say... Media agency = plans for where/how the consumer will see it

Thank you! So basically, if I'm interested in strategy at a creative agency in the long run, I shouldn't start in media.

Not to dismiss what the Group Director has said but working in media will probably hinder your chances because once your linkedin says media those are the only jobs people will reach out to you for. Also education in the field will not help you get an entry level job but a lot of networking will.

@Group Director please employ me :)

But thank you for all this thought. Since I'm already planning to transition out of Account, I want to make sure my next jump is smart

Working in media should not hinder your chances whatsoever; I'm living proof! I began my career in media (thanks to graduating in a recession) and took it with the mindset of learning what I could while full well knowing my goal was to transition to media planning. It can be done. When I was transitioning, my media background was a huge asset, particularly as planner's roles continue to include comms planning. My advice: use this and any position to learn about the industry, get smart and network. Networking is so damn important; my former media director boss gave me my first job in account planning. As you move along, keep your eyes on your goal. Oh and last thing: the best planners are those who have an interesting life outside of advertising. Be an interesting person and spin your media experience to the job you want. You'll be just fine.

Related Posts

Hi all,

I have final interview with ZS for BT solution consultant role, the interviewer is associate principal. What kind of interview will it be, what kind of questions can I expect? And luckily if I clear the interview, how much CTC should I ask? My current CTC is 20.2 LPA with 10% variable and YoE is 8.8 years

like

I see that Kforce is hiring. Are they a legitimate company and what do they pay there operation supervisors ?Kforce

like

Hello everyone! I work as financial advisor and I’m looking for a referral. I’m based in London

Thoughts on Director of Software Engineering at a small firm $165k base + 10% annual bonus. No stock options, no RRSP match. YOE 12, experience in current role 3 yrs.
Current compensation $140k, no stock options or RRSP match, but love the organization.

like
like

Hi everyone! Anyone from Oracle willing to provide referral for a role in the MENA region. Any help is full heartedly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

like

Anyone else feeling like picking money over creative and craft? Might be a career killer but how bad is it to chase the money and go in house? Some in-house is pretty sweet (Spotify, Square space, FB) while others are blah. Is it okay to ditch agency life as a mid-level when you decide the portfolio isn’t worth it?

like

Looking for advice. Currently work for top 5 insurance broker on the P&C agency side as a commercial account manager. I’ve been doing this for about 15 years. Next year, I will graduate with my MBA. My question is how do I transition to the company side and what roles should I target? Bonus points if you can tell me the minimum salary for the role you suggest!

like

Telus or Nagarro? Which one is better? Both are offering permanent wfh. Role - Automation Testing

like

Does Spotify tend to keep its contracted employees? Trying to judge the risk of accepting a 6 month to possible hire position

like

Would you rather work for big corporate or small company? Sales role

like

I have cleared my first round of interview for c10 role at Citi. For second round, they are scheduling with US team. What can be expected from this round? I am told that it is technical. Citi

like

I need a referral in Adobe noida for frontend position?

like

Guys
I just made a mistake in resume work experience section
I mentioned 4months extra experience for my current role instead of actual experience.. company is same
It's just that I moved to other team within same company but mentioned 4 months earlier than actual joining time.
Will it be a problem for BGC

like

I work in food production. I work closely w/ accounts who order products 4 foodservice & grocery stores. I feel that customer service is not an appropriate job title for what we do. we communicate w/ our customers/accounts but we are more like account managers. We also deal with transportation issues. They won’t change our pay because we are CSR’s & we are compensated as such accord to industry standards. What is an another job title we could request that would compensate us 4 what we do??

like

Hi Fishes ,

Im looking for a new job.

Tech Stack MERN/PERN.

exp : 2 years

Looking for a referral

like

Biggest advice anyone give for MBB is to get a referral. Usually this would be someone from your network that you know. But what if you don’t anyone. Going cold Turkey on LinkedIn doesn’t work even if you have shared connections; doesn’t translate to meetings etc. I know something about my approach to networking is not correct. I understand that networking is more about relationship building and fostering a mutual long term relation. And was wondering if anyone had any advice. (Rising senior)

like

Looking to change firms or exit into the Denver area. Want to cut travel to be able to spend time with my spouse. Basically a BA and PM skill set but hungry to learn. Any leads?

Hey everyone - truly sorry for all who have been affected by the recent layoffs 😥

My company is actively hiring for a Senior Product Designer, if you or someone you know is looking! It's a backfill fulltime role at a very recession-resistant midsized B2B SaaS company. 100% remote.

Please include a portfolio link if you're interested! No degree requirements, 5-7 YOE, tech design experience a must.

likesmarthelpful

More Posts

This channel should be called the “Dog Bowl” - Hi from my hound, Rosie!

Post Photo
like

Helo fishes !!

Anyone have worked in Indirect procurment and logistics invoice verification in SAP MM.

If so kindly suggest me some online videos for learning.

like

Lateraling to the Litigation group of a V10 firm in SF. I’m a junior and so far have had general litigation experience. I know in house opportunities for litigators are limited. What should I focus on in terms of practice areas within Lit to make it to FAANG as a 5-6th year associate (and what’s the comp I could expect)? Thanks so much!

like

Hi all,

I would like to know about the job security and wlb in LTI(petroleum projects).. any info would be helpful.

Thank you

like

Hi all,
Looking for Business Analyst/Associate business analyst position.
YOE:3+
Background : Tech + Operations
On-site experience++

like

How much I'll get in hand?
IBM offer

Post Photo
like

Hi guys,

Has anyone worked and heard about Optiv.

It's a cybersecurity firm based out in us.

Just wanted to know about background and work culture in optiv. How good it is in cybersecurity space nd what it offers .

like

What does Well-being mean to you?

like

I’m looking to change careers from CMA to Project coordinating/program managing. Any recommendations on how to increase my interview intake and/or how much I should be asking for?
Anything helps!! I appreciate it.

like

I’m obsessed with tiktok and am ashamed 😞

likefunnyhelpful

Really jazzed about this project… love the art and that cause.

Post Photo
like

Hey guys. Can I get some likes for my little Chi Chi? 🥰🐾

Post Photo
likesmart

Just pulled the trigger on a 49” ultrawide monitor! Gosh I hope that wasn’t stupid.

likesmart

Citiustech is hiring for below mentioned roles.

Kindly DM for referrals :)

Post Photo
like

Somedays I’m disturbed i might live past cocktail hour.

like

So Doug & Partners actually shut down? I thought Doug just retired. Why didn’t the other partners buy him out?

like

How much do public sector MDs make at Big 4 and other firms?

Additional Posts in Strategy & Planning

Do strategist have online portfolios? I’m working on mine but never have any to reference...

When writing a brief what is your process for getting true alignment with account and creative esp when it’s hard to get on higher ups radar - just “drive bys” more organized meetings to share out?

If you were unemployed and straight out of undergrad, which would you choose?

Denver Ad School’s 5 Quarter (50 weeks total) Strat program, or Miami Ad’s 12-Week Strat Bootcamp?

like

Do any of you find that your brand teams are trigger happy when it comes to doing workshops? I find that whenever someone isn’t sure about something, there’s any instant desire for a 1-2 day workshop that Strategy leads. I love workshops, but doing them constantly is horribly exhausting.

like

Community manager for 1.5 years, feel like recently have been performing high above my level (doing senior strat projects bc he was incompetent). When should I expect/advocate for a promo?

What skills do you need to become a Digital Strategist?
What are the daily activities?
What are the tools you need to know?

Thanks

like

Any good brand strategy case study resources/tips? 🙏🏽

like

What is the brand strategy team like at BGB group in NYC? Pros and cons?

like

Top agencies to complete an internship in Detroit area?

Dream job.... plan b or in the industry. Describe it please!

Moving away from a national radio show during morning commute. Enjoying NPR, but (besides music) what are you listening to to get your morning wheels started?

Who are the most brilliant strategists in NY and the rest of the world to work for/learn from?

like

Freelance Assoc Strat Dir role at Publicis NY on a top beauty brand. Now through April. Write me on LinkedIn if interested!

Similar to most recent question - anyone switch from agency to client side? I’m trying to expand my job options. Thoughts & experiences around the day to day?

How is WK London doing ? Lots of strata leaving and they lost Three ! How is the strat vibe

like

It feels like the whole brand strategy/upstream focus vs experience/activation/digital strategist (downstream) issues are at an all time high lately. Anyone work at an agency that has figured it out? How does your agency handle it?

like

Why are you all treating this bowl's main page as a single thread?

like

Looking for recommendations to generally upskill my Strategy work (or learn from scratch) — be it courses, classes, books, podcasts, people to follow.

For context, I’m a freelance Social Media Manager/Strategist and I came into Ad world via Startups. Throwing myself into learning on the job with more Strategy gigs - but I still don’t feel like I quite know the lingo or best practices or theories.

like

What certifications should I obtain to differentiate myself from other strategists?

like

I work at a big well known agency on well known clients. I am thinking of jumping to a lesser known agency to work on B2B. It would be title and pay increase. Think it will be hard to pivot back to b2c and better known agencies after 2 or so years? Or go for it?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal