how do you deal with people who aren't creative telling you how to do your job? for example dissecting design work or copy despite having zero experience in creative. said people are above my position so can't exactly tell them to get on their bikes.

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Ask them what their intention / purpose is for the change? Then ask if you can provide a creative solution to said purpose. Every root can yield different branches. It’s a delicate game of politics.

likesmarthelpful

Yep! This is the go-to strategy for me anytime someone is suggesting things on a topic/area they don’t know anything about. Happens a TON for me with our social media strategy (“this needs to go viral!” 🙄) Sometimes their bad ideas have good nuggets you can pull from. Then they feel like they’ve been heard and you don’t have to use their totally dumb idea or risk getting reprimanded from a higher up.

like

For me, it’s always a good moment to understand the why better. Which usually ends up building a better relationship which means building respect, trust and curiosity for other POVs.

Also a good moment to check my own ego about the work.

like

^ This

75mg of CBD oil. Then peeping my bank accounts to calculate the day I can be financially free.

likeuplifting

You'd be financially free sooner without the CBD oil.

“Let me think about that.”

like

Realize their butts are the ones on the line, if they insist on a change, they are ultimately responsible for the results. Then put the good version you designed in your portfolio.

likehelpful

This literally bleeds animosity. You’re trying to build a relationship as well as relate work you’re proud of.

like

Urgh welcome to in-house.

like

Yup. Telling an SME their video idea sucks is a very tedious issue.

likefunny

Echo other's advice asking the why or trying to understand the root cause. Typically request like these come in because the person reqursting thinks it will solve an issue from their POV.

Of course I once received a very bald, honest request:

"The client has childhood issues with the color purple."

like

The movie?

I have always found it an interesting part of marketing that we are kind of the one function that others feel they can offer advice on. I don’t go to accounting and say “you should think about doing your books this way.”

I think asking what it is about their direction/suggestion that they like or how it will make it better. Have they seen competitors or other industries do it?

It is also a good opportunity to think strategically about your own choices. Can you answer soundly why you’re making the choices you do?

It can also be helpful to watch for any particular pet peeves they have. I had a director early in my career who hated “floating” products in ads or products - he liked to see a bottom shadow or something to ground it. It never bothered me but i quickly realized it was an easy thing for him to be happy about and made the rest of the approval process easy.

like

Was the director me? Lol. Can’t stand floating products unless the product is literally floating.

like

This is currently the biggest stressor in my life, although people both above and below me.

like

I just change it to their satisfaction. Getting approval is more difficult. Good taste is relative. You live to fight another day.

likesmart

Now quadruple that experience. That's in-house in higher education.

My strategy is to ask a lot of questions. Why do they feel that way? What goal do they have? How would they do it? Sometimes if you start digging, there's gold. Other times, you can use their responses as fodder for illustrating why they are off base in their feedback.

like

Ask them to tell you the problem not the solution

like

I’d most likely tell you the problem and my solution.

I agree with VPM 1. You didn’t mention if there was a brief? If there is, try to understand how they think the work isn’t meeting the objectives in the brief. Good briefs always have this. It’s the marketer’s job to articulate the business / communication objective, not to be the art director and solve “how” to do it.

like

Once I worked with an executive who took full responsibility and admitted his brilliant idea derailed a project. Once.

I had the same issue, it's just part of in-house work, it's like when in agency they tell you you need to have ticker skin

haha! my comment wasn't finished and got published!
I was saying that I had the same issue, it's just part of in-house work, it's like when in agency they tell you you need to have thicker skin.

I tried asking the problem, and offer other solutions but some of them just can't see your skills as an actual skill, they think what we do is just dictated by opinions so they think they can have theirs.
But some will respect your experience so I would try.

My other issue was that sometimes you don't feel like you can push back on comments if you are not senior enough. There, you just have to be lucky to have a boss that values you. And the way to get there is to point most of these issues out to your boss and what you were suggesting as a solution, so you will get their trust and they will let you act on your own.

Anyway, I did definitely sit in meetings with people a lot more senior than me and telling them why their new solution wasn't going to work, but you need to be very careful of how you tell them.
Just make sure they feel like their concerns are heard and you are taking their solutions into account but even looking for a better one.

To be honest, all these reasons plus the lack of creativity in the work itself made me want to consider going back to the agency. Where I am sure I will find a new set of issues :)

Related Posts

Hi Sharks

Looking for Program Manager role within
Google . Kindly please help me get a referral for it.

Regards
Nemo

Hey anyone willing to swing a referral for roles in change management consulting or healthcare consulting

like

MBB AP about to exit to non-FAANG tech. Would you expect a signing bonus and/or pre-determined severance pay if things don't work out with the new company? Anything else that people have negotiated during their exit? I'd be leaving a large amount of bonus on the table to leave before the end of the year.

like

I'm not hung up on PE/buy side exits, not closed off but nbd. Would be just as happy to stay and make MD (or exit into corp dev if I want an easier life when I'm older)

My dilemma:

I'm at a LMM investment bank. Can get crazy sometimes, but otherwise chill. Typically done around 7-9 pm, had maybe three 1 am nights. Haven't worked a weekend in over a month. Fridays almost always done at 5 pm.

Have an offer at a reputable MM bank but probably pretty sweaty. Worth the move?

like

I don't know if this is a recent change but I’m seeing postings for junior copywriter/community manager roles. Have these roles always been attached or posted at a junior level? Is this merged role worth considering as someone young in the industry with more traditional intern and freelance copy experience.

like

On a project (A) with a role that's a bad fit. Have been approached by a partner on another project (B) who wants me staffed on his engagement by April. How do I transition over from A to B knowing ..

like
like

Hi All
Does anyone have my information on the role Assistant Manager PPM.

Anyone living in Hannover Apartments in Tyson’s wants to split the referral bonus?

likesmart

Any mid-level copywriters looking for work? We had another writer leave and are looking to fill the position. It's a small shop with incredible creative leadership and fun food accounts. Trust me, you’ll get a lot of opportunities and have a blast. PM a link to your book and I'll tell you more.

like

Morning! Anyone who’d be kind enough to provide a referral for Apple. There’s a position I’m interested in and would like to give it a shot. Thanks a lot!Apple

like
like

What can I except a product manager role interview questions to be?

like

Anyone with leads / opportunities at your respective companies in Digital Marketing? 8+ years experience here across various aspects of digital (content, seo, ppc, automation: salesforce pardot, marketo, etc) Currently a manager at an Agency in BC, Canada. Looking for a consulting / agency kind of role!! Appreciate any help! Much thanks!!

like

I need a mentor to guide me for a job role in MBB. I have 5 YOE (4.5 years in Manufacturing & Automation 6 months in SaaS) any volunteers?

likefunny

Interview lined up with Flipkart for business finance manager role what's the salary band in this role. Am a qualified CA currently working with swiggy YOE:3.5 Flipkart Swiggy

Trying to figure out if I should start as an inbound SDR, or try jumping straight into an AE role in SaaS.

I left mortgages at the beginning of the year to start a franchise business, it's now semi-self-sufficient so wanted to start a career again and I live in the Silicon Slopes area. Everyone I know is in SaaS or software engineering.

Just wondering if I should push my resume as far as possible and try to snag an AE role or take my time in a new industry and start from the bottom.

likehelpfuluplifting

What is the salary range that Salesforce offers for SFMC consulant role?

like

What do you love and hate about your position?

like

More Posts

Does anyone remember in grade school when one of the assignments was during the time scientists announced Pluto was not a planet and some teachers had us write essays and whether Pluto should or shouldn’t be a planet using so scientific based arguments? I panicked daily about the state of our education system in America.

like

What’s a good CISA program?

like

Do partners know each other’s compensation? I see partners selling engagements for vastly different numbers b/w shorter ‘interesting’ strategy work and longer ‘boring’ transformations. Thoughts?

like

I've been struck with the feeling my company, a small Fintech, prioritize the +8y/o experienced professionals rather than the hard working ones. Nothing new here, the ambient seems ok on the surface but everyone tries to steal your job and important tasks.

I'm currently at my 29s and studying for CFA lvl1 but since its a startup I've been doing too much operational work rather than analysis itself. Any advice on how to control anxiety and approach this career pivot? Anyone have dealt with this?

like

Guys — any suggestions on durable loafers in the $500 price range ?

like

Going to Jamaica for a bachelor party Memorial Day Weekend...da hell do I wear?

Recommendations on slim fit denim shirts. Not for the office of course but I feel like it’s a staple I need in my wardrobe.

What are your favorite sock shops? 🧦

like

What is a considerate way to say “no thank you” to a recruiter? I was contacted on LinkedIn and want to be respectful of the recruiter’s time but also want to thank them for thinking of me.

like

Let’s hear some good news! Share your biggest wins so far this week!

like

Has anyone here been able to recover from career setbacks caused by Dot Com, 9-11, or Great Recession economy? Just turned 40 with 15 years of relevant industry experience, and my Big 4 employer brought me in at a level designed for 25 year-olds. Career progression is apparently based on time in role rather than performance, so I’ll have to spend 8 years climbing back to the level I was at pre-recession. Is there another way, or is my career stuck in neutral?

like

Should you take a role that you don’t want at a company you do want in the hopes to move around?

like

Can a company with offer letter sent on email if joining is delayed due to notice period

like

I have 7 years of experience in Finance.(more friendlyin AR). Looking for a job change can any one please refer me. Due to low pay I am looking for a change

like

Counselor never talked to me about my year end review and it was never released to me, I still haven't had my comp discussion. Didn't get the comp email or any PPB in my paycheck, am I getting fired??

like

Salary for senior copywriter in Chicago. 6 years experience at big agencies? Good book but no lions yet.

like

Fun question: if you have green card, which industry / role would you like to switch to? (and what is your current industry / role btw)

like

Are any members of this group producers at an independent agency?

like

What kinds of things do you do in commercial healthcare? If that’s a thing?

like

Additional Posts in Brand Side

If you were to launch a new product campaign for a beverage in Feb/March, would you focus on spring/summer imagery or more oils that feel too premature? What cultural/timing things would you take into consideration?

like

Hello guys
Please help me get 11 likes.

likeupliftinghelpfulsmartfunny

Looking to move to the client/ brand side of things from the agency world. Decades of successful experience running integrated marketing strategy and execution for major fortune 100 companies as well as start ups in B2B and B2C. Fintech, finserv, SaaS, tech, RE experience. Any leads would be appreciated.

like

What’s it like at Verizon?

likefunny

Looking for some guidance/ input regarding salaries...
What's a good general range for a promotion to Marketing Manager who would be overseeing all national (USA) marketing for a Global company?

In-house, 4 brands, based out of our LA office.

Thanks!

like
like

Does anyone have experience with a CMS migration? I inherited a migration plan with very little context. Any recommendations or best practices on how to move forward? Who should be included as stakeholders?

like

Likes to Open DM please ❤️

Post Photo
likefunny

I’m interviewing for an in-house brand position at a tech company... after 10 years in the agency world. Any big things to watch out for or ask? Thanks 🙏🏽

like

Hi, new to this bowl.

Looking for a new role leading a PM and/or ops team. I'm an agency (media & creative) vet - depth in digital, crm, creative, tech, data, & process dev/deploy.

Have also worked ~4 years transforming / running ops at Kimbery-Clark's Digital COE and ~a year on web & digital projects at NYU Langone Medical Center.

Do IH agencies have substantial PM teams / need for leadsrship? I know many need operations & process enhancement.

Any specific roles on anyone's radar?

Thx!

like

I’ve noticed on Glassdoor, salaries for my level (Director) are higher than my base but have similar bonus opportunity. At what level of pay gap would you push or make a stink? In hindsight I should have pushed more during the hiring process. At 160k base now, seeing ranges in the 170s to low 180s. These are specific to my current company.

like
likehelpful

Posted this in a different channel but does anyone here work at Peloton (or know someone who does) and care to share their experience or thoughts on the company?

likesmart

Marketing folks - may I ask how much you are earning based on yoe? I’m trying to make the transition and want to understand better about the salary range.

like

Comparable salaries?

Applying for promotion to Digital Design Lead. 15 YoE, currently making about 82k + profit share. 3rd in seniority and department is currently restructuring. Based on some other internal salary ranges, planning to to ask for 106k, about a 30% jump. How does this look?

like

Procter & Gamble I just applied for a Multicultural Hair Brand Manager role at Procter & Gamble. Anyone work there currently or previously? Know of any recruiters I could connect with?

like

Do any brand teams have a good agency briefing template and process you follow?
-Any tips on getting the best creative solution from your agency?
-Do you have any specific criteria you look for when selecting an agency?
-Do you prefer ‘one stop shop’ or specialists in their fields? If the latter do you do separate breifings?

like

Those of you that were on Agency and switched over are you producing projects at the same level? Is there operational support? Can you push back on the bad ideas? Are there leaders who ‘get it’?

like

What is the best way to reach out to your in house agency ? I want to share our call for artists . Do I have go through HR? Or is there a place I can simply post an announcement ?

like

Working at a hospital with a million programs and services. When is developing an independent brand for a group justified, and when should it remain part of the parent brand?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal