How do you respond when someone sends you a really bad portfolio? (Not student work) If I get sent a good one, I’m always happy to pass it along or offer advice and review if asked. But sometimes I get one so bad there’s honestly not even one constructive thing I could say, and I feel bad ignoring them.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You say so much when you say nothing at all. Ignore them or risk being labeled an a-hole for being honest. Unfortunately that’s the world we live in.

likehelpful

Thank you, this is good advice and perspective.

like

Just say you’ll “be happy to forward it along” but they “should know it’s a really bad time in the industry and with recent layoffs and salary freezes, I haven’t heard of any new hiring.”

like

Tell them. If not they will spend a long time being rejected for roles. Ask Chapt how to make it sound professional.

like

Yes, Marketing Project Manager III, some people do need mentoring.

like

I say: “Thanks for sharing, I’ll pass it along if I see anything pop up that seems like a good fit. Good luck!”

That way, I’m not lying. I have actually one time passed along a “bad book” to a smaller print shop that was looking for a junior production assistant. Not sure if they got the job, but it was technically a good fit for them.

likehelpful

I would be honest. Maybe youll hurt their feelings, maybe you’ll be seen as an a*hole. But youre doing them a kindness in the long run. Which takes real integrity!
If their work isnt there, they should know.
Theyll appreciate it in the future.

like

I find silence the most polite way to reject someone and my prefered method to receive bad news.

like

Can you be direct but kind: Your book doesn’t have the kind of work that the team tends to respond to…

When they ask what they do like, you can be as aggressive or not as you prefer.

like

Probably. But if you’re in and they’re not, it’s justifiable that you might know more about what they’re looking for.

But that’s just one way to do it. Essentially, you don’t want to say what’s wrong with their book, just what it’s not.

like

Could I send you mine for review?

funny

Related Posts

In SAP what we can expect in welcome kit

like

Is anyone in Experience Strategy/Transformation in the Netherlands willing to chat about a referral?

I am planning a move there from Canada throughout the summer (and eligible to work there)

Happy to provide more information

likehelpful

Is it standard to not pay non-exempt employees holiday pay until they pass probation?

like

5th year with the company, C3, level 9 going level 8 soon (CD&O), NYC, base 117k - where am i in the pay band? Switching companies, trying to figure out how much to expect/ask

like

Working on some law firm applications tonight and it sucks that I know that I am so capable and have a strong work ethic but firms can’t see beyond grades or the fact that I didn’t go to a t14 law school or prestigious undergrad. I’ve worked twice as hard and feel like I’ve barely even gotten half as much. It’s discouraging sometimes especially because I worked so hard with pretty much no guidance (first gen, poc, low-income) to get into college and do well and then get into a t30 law school

like

Hi Folks,

Which company (TCS & HCL) is good in ITIL Domain, i am asking only in ITIL stream not over all as a company.

Please provide your inputs or comments.

Has anyone moved to KPMG from another firm and felt like it was the right move? Just want to make sure I'm not buying into "grass is greener" mentality

like

In your ICUs how many make it after intubation and proning? Just curious to compare.

like

Let me know if you are interested in any openings in Plante Moran! We are hiring!! I can give you a referral!

like

The past 24 hours

Post Photo
like

Any one attended @Tiger Analytics MLE interview?

Need insights on online test round. kindly unicast!

Hi! can anyone please refer me in ZS? I’ve the job Id.

like

Looking for a bilingual (Spanish/English) para or esl teacher for a charter school in Minneapolis

What’s the most effective way for producers to network for new job opportunities?

like

Don’t you just love when an AE one year out of undergrad tells you your estimate sounds high?

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Do you know of any full time/freelance creatives who also direct commercials? Like, ones who cherry pick jobs they want to work on?

Likes needed for DM

like

Iam currently working in dell technologies, planning to move barclays global service center chennai , what about job security in barclays?? Kindly suggest

likeuplifting

What are your favorite online strength training program sites/apps?
For reference, I want to work out 3-4 times a week and want a program that balances all body parts. I'm tired of searching videos on youtube and apps.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Can someone explain Wayfair? How do they have so much stuff? Where does it come from? How do you make decisions? It’s overwhelming and then I close the app.

like

How big does an agency have to be to justify a CCO title?

like

I know agencies across the board did some layoffs right before the holidays, but when do we think hiring will pick up again? Getting to a point where I feel like I need to start thinking about a change.

like

If brands are leaving Facebook in droves because the platform refuses to take down false/misleading information... Why are they still advertising on Fox News?

Post Photo
likefunny

How many times a week do you ask yourself why you’re so terrible at advertising and why is it 1 billion?

like

Are there any NYC ad agencies that have flexible remote WFH policies or is everyone required to be in the office a few days a week?

like
likeupliftingsmart

Is there anyone who would like to take a look at my portfolio and give honest feedback?
I’m a mid-level art director so someone in cd level or beyond! I would love to grab 3rd party’s opinion:)

like

Is there an online marketplace for SquareSpace portfolio templates, i.e., a place where you can buy a template, download it, then build it yourself? Alternatively, is there a place where I can hire someone to recommend a SquareSpace template, gussy up said template with type and/or color tweaks to make it less template-y (no functionality changes needed), and then design a simple logo? Looked at Squarespace Experts but seems a bit intense for what I need. Google isn't giving me much.

like

Is it had to become an Art Director for a fashion brand? Because I was told if you aren’t familiar with Textiles, patterns and fashion merchandising it’s hard to get into.

like

Besides salary, how to pick between job offers?

like

What programs, sites, etc does your agency use to track time? I work at a small agency and looking to implement tracking on my team across client/project level.

like

How many agencies give cost of living/yearly raises vs just a “yearly bonus” ?

Can ya guess which one Barkley is?

like

which agencies in the city are creative driven rather than account driven

like

I’m looking to make the move to London — what are good smaller shops there? Any recommendations for how to take the plunge into shifting from the states to there? How to get an in into networking etc

like

How do you create the visual direction of a print campaign for example? Is it generally just about creating a mood board that sets the look and feel? Should it be specific (as in drawing or illustrating) with the pose and the framing?

Cause my thinking is more of the former where you give the photographer their own take of the idea. Curious to know how you do it.

like

Dogs in offices are cool, but who's offering some comfy siesta benefits? 😴💤

likesmart

Do I need to be a top performer to get hired client side/tech/etc. as a creative (copywriter)?

My book really isn’t anything special but also wouldn’t mind looking outside the agency world.

like

Getting pushed to do account work as a PM is making me want to scream. And the bullshit let's align on PM expectations meetings when I'm doing my job is driving me up the wall. I'm doing my job....YOU aren't.

like

Any senior art directors at NY agencies looking for a new partner? Pref someone at BBDO, DDB, TBWA, Droga, Wk, Mother, T+S.

funny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal