I am looking to get into the human resources field, but also I want to gain some management experience. I have an offer for a management role at JP Morgan Chase, but also have an HR assistant role in a municipal sector offer. The salaries as you can imagine are a huge difference, but I’m looking towards the long-term, which will ultimately be an HR manager or director. Should I do the management role or should I take my chance with breaking into the HR field with the other role?

likesmart
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

My first question is why do you want to be in HR and do you have any education or experience in the field?
Second question is regarding the salary. Is the HR Assistant salary in line with what you currently need?
While it's important to think long term and gain experience in a field you want to be in, you also have to consider the ability to pay current bills.
The current economy is not favorable to HR roles. Keep that in mind.
No one can make the decision for you...just think both roles through.
While one may be a passion and get you where you want to be long term, it may not pay what you are looking for (for years).
And the other may pay well but your heart may not be in it.
Not an easy choice. But I'm happy for you to have the option of actual offers...those are hard to come by in the current market.

like

I would personally take the management role. Especially in this economy. With inflation and tariffs being what they are, sticking with the job that pays you more while working on your HR skills would probably be the better option. But I tend to be pretty risk-averse, so take that with a grain of salt.

like

Chase is such a huge company. You can find mentors in HR to help you with your journey into that space. The key is to network and you’ll be meeting your goals sooner than you think.

Related Posts

How do you navigate when you've already accepted an offer, but you get a better one? I'm supposed to start a new role tomorrow but got an offer for the job I really wanted, and it pays 50k more. Is it horrible if I quit while having just started?

like

Dick's Sporting Goods Would love for a referral to PNC UPMC Dick's Sporting Goods for product/project manager position in Pittsburgh! Thank you!

like

Asking for my brother, does anyone know of a legal services opening for entry level lawyers in NCR region? Noida is his current base.

Previous experience in contract management.

Certified in drafting and negotiating commercial contracts.

Please DM / comment! It'll be really helpful. TIA 😁

like

I am selected for Data analyst Role at Optum Grade 26, current ctc 6 lpa, YOE 3 YEARS...What should i ask HR for fixed component, already HAVING AN OFFER OF 13 FIXED...

Hey guys,

Anybody willing to refer me for LEK?

Last year, I had passed the CV screening and got the invitation to take the test. However, I did not get the invitation for the interview.

Would like to apply again this time with a referral.

like

I am going to start a career as a Patient Access Rep soon. I have previous admin experience and I am wondering if I should ask for a pay increase to salary? The starting pay for this position is 16.25 but I am wanting to ask for 19up…How much are patient reps making now days in this medical field?

like

I am an HR Executive with established business and startup experience. I have experience building HR depts. If anyone can help me find a lead, connection, or hiring manager, for an open role I would appreciate it. Thank you.

like

Hi everyone,
I’m hiring for x3 Sr / Jr Application Security Engineers in my team.
UK based, team is 100% remote, although the office in London is there if you prefer.
Pre IPO unicorn valued FinTech startup.
Get in touch for more info 🙂

like

Hi HSBC sharks, my CCTC is 17.4LPA (Fixed). I have been offered a position at HSBC for Senior Analyst position. They are not offering a single rupee more than 30% i.e., 22.6LPA. What can I do to ask for more? Or it is their maximum at this position? Please help HSBC HSBC India

like

Hi Fishes, I need your genuine suggestions in finalising which company to join.
I have 2 offers :
ZS Associates - 15l fixed
Thoughtworks - 18l fixed
Role - Senior Consultant in Test
Experience: 5 yoe
Please consider job security and learning opportunities as parameters while suggesting. Thanks in advance!!

like

Dear Folks,

Can someone refer me into Microsoft, for Azure DevOps role. I have 5.5 YOE

like

Make 235k tc in tech consulting. Is there a role on the sales side where i can transition to and make more? 9 yoe.

like

What are some good ways to get into management?
I am an individual contributor with ~8 years of experience and a strong track record. I enjoy my work, but am getting a little burnt out being directly customer facing. I also want a bigger seat at the table. I am not the most natural people manager, but want to push myself and take on a new challenge.
What can I do to position myself for this?

like

Anyone from Astrazeneca are there any referral programs ongoing, I need referral for a Data Engineer position. Having 5 years of experience.

like

Hi Fishes,
Actively looking for a job switch.
I have been alligned with TCS from past 5.6 years.During my tenure, I worked on SAP R/3 Financial Accounting - GL (General Ledger), Fixed Assets Module, Accounts payable, Accounts Receivable,Roll out projects, and involved with different kind of testing like Regression, Upgrade, End to End testings.
Have an experience in Oracle to SAP data implementation project, Also have knowledge on S4 hana,
Handled multiple role SAP Finance Functional support t

like
likehelpful

Hi Fishes,

Is Daimler truck innovation center India(DTICI) good to join ? Regarding job security and WLB.

Please assist .

Tech Stack - Java
YOE - 8+
Role Offered - Principal Consultant

like

Does SAP Labs has any option like External Title for employees.

I have recently been offered a position where in System Title is not upto my desired expectation, but, the HR mentioned that I can have the desired designation as External Title.

like

More Posts

Hi EY folks,
I am joining EY GDS as senior.
Do EY GDS do background verification for all my previous employers ?
They have asked me to submit document only for last employment for BGV which first advantage is doing. And offer letter mentions to submit only exp/relieving letter for last 2 employers as applicable while joining.
Little confused as I am have bad experience with one of my employer.

Kindly help me out.

like

Any recommendations for front door security camera’s (eg ring)? Want one for my parents who live in a not-dense suburb

like

 I heard a commercial on the radio for Verizon that said something to the effect that parents are now learning how to lesson plan. Are any of you off the hook for lesson planning? Just wondering because I’m over here busting my butt!

funnylikehelpful

Senior Program Manager / Director looking for EU based remote work. Planning to relocate back to the EU on a permanent basis in the next 4-6 months. Open to work & would appreciate any kind of referral!

like

What is SUNDRY allowance in Accenture?

like

What’s your worst proposal writing experience?

27 years M from suburbs Chicago looking to date

Could anyone from Bain’s London office provide any insight into how much travel was typically involved (Pre-COVID)?
Also, how do you see the split of WFH/office/client site be going forward?
Thank you!

like

Apple Watch or Fitbit? Does anyone have both? If you have both, do you use the Apple Watch as a regular watch and the Fitbit for working out? Just curious to see what people think. Thanks!

like

Any suggestions for how to keep my mind and body busy? My job is painfully slow and not challenging and I’ve started to re read old texts and have OD’d on Matthew Hussey videos. What are practical things I can start to help turn this next chapter? Besides job hunting! I feel like I need to throw myself into something worthwhile that I feel good about! I just don’t have inspiration or motivation right now. I feel flat.

like

Hello! Planning to move to Chicago in Feb(Not the best time, for sure) would love to hear your suggestions about neighbourhoods that you are in and beyond. Currently looking at the loop, Logan square, Lincoln park and Lakeview (would prefer closer to the Red line and groceries)! It’s my first time moving alone and a little nervous lol, would love some help! Budget is around 800$ (2B/2B) for sharing and 1000$ for a studio! Any leads/suggestions/options would be great! TIA!!!

like

Hi fishes, Offers from JPMC (X LPA fixed) and Mastercard (X+7) Never worked in BFSI. Which one to consider? JPMorgan Chase Mastercard

Hi Fishes ,12L INR fixed in Accenture how much would be in-hand per month.

Any NYC agency doing consumer healthcare / OTC? I’m so done with cancer, diabetes, conventions, charts and launches 😪

like

I have $20k student loans and have been paying $1k per month throughout pandemic to lower the balance. Would you continue to do this? I could pay them off, stop payments in hope of debt relief or keep up with current strategy. TIA

like

Hi Folks. Switching from product base to service base at level 9 in accenture in SAP Domain .
Can some1 explain how the journey starts from day 1.
Heard Noise abt client interviews , bench process,layoffs etc etc.
Need Serious Comforting advise.

like

What's the bench policy at IBM ? For how long one can stay in bench.? How much time it will take generally to get the project/assignment. IBM Tata Consultancy

like

Dating. How do you navigate dating attorneys and being a judicial law clerk? Conflicts? Awkwardness?

likefunny

I need a career mentor for the tech industry!!!

like

How much time do you spend actually playing with your dogs every day?

like

Additional Posts in Career Pivot

Has anyone started a new job while expecting a child? I'm thinking about it but could use some input from people with experience.

like

It’s a new week!! Target to win 🏆.. Win! And keep winning!

likeuplifting

Anyone that’s had a contract position with Facebook (Meta), what is the likelihood it will turn into a full time position? I have an interview with them tomorrow.

like

Tips for applying for a PM role, being a software engineer my whole life! Much appreciated!!!!

like
like

What are the top companies to work for straight out of college?

like

How hard is a career pivot from digital advertising to a product manager or even developer? I’m learning python 🐍 and at the point where I’m working on a pretty advanced project. I think having technical skills in combination with digital marketing can increase my net worth in the long run .

like

Hello, we've recently started a community focused on FAANG interview preps. Wondering what kind of content people might be interested to see in such communities.

like

What do you all think is the upper limit range for someone in an account manager role at a tech firm? What’s the career path? Was there anything you’ve done in terms of upskilling that resulted in increased pay? Or should I just pick something else if I want to be making more than what I make atm ~150k TC with 6 years exp.

like

Are there any careers you would say an individual can pivot to from acquiring a decade of customer service? No BA or masters. Have a diploma in Audio Production and Engineering which is pretty niche. Any advice?

like

Need help how is @fujitsu as a company for sap Consultants ? Implementation project environment ?
I got an offer of 22 lpa
But I m happy in my current company also .. wanted to do implementation that y I m in dillema

like

If you're interested in joining EY. Please mail your CV to ammar.azizi1@gmail.com along with the Job ID from the EY careers website (ey.com">https://careers.ey.com) for a referral. Please only send your CV if you have not applied directly to the same role or already asked someone else to refer already. DM me here because sometimes the CV goes into my spam folder. Cheers!

like

What is your opinion on online assessments as part of the hiring process?

like

Sure I just started a new job as a project coordinator in January .
It my first job in clinical trials technology position prior to this I was in dentistry for 32 years and it’s taking me a lot to learn all the ins and outs of data analysis and some of the tech talk.
I’m very grateful to have the position because it took me 2 years to find a job! I just wish I could perform better and know my job a little more intimately.

like

I am actively looking to transition into a tech company. I’ve worked in campus recruitment for 2 years at a construction company. I am open to any advice.

I’d prefer a remote position. I am willing to take on training or classes to become a better recruiter.

like

For those looking to get into tax technology at Deloitte, let me know. I’ll take a look at your resume and see if it’s a good fit!

like

Considering moving from BD/Partnerships in tech to Corporate Development. Has anyone here done it? Did you like the switch and do you have any pointers on getting in

like

I am possibly going into a cyber security role where I would be leading internal and external content. Thing is, my career has mainly been in fashion which I am trying to move away from, to get into the tech space. This is a great opportunity that will definitely teach me a lot and help get me further into tech. Problem: I’m scared. I’m scared I won’t enjoy it, scared I’ll be bored!!!, scared I’ll fail, scared I’d be making a mistake. Any advice? Has anyone pivoted like this? I want to be open.

like

So I recently accepted a 12 month contract-hire position at a much larger company. Pay is more than 50% of my salary, and benefits/401k is covered by the recruiting agency. I was confident in my now manager, who told me directly this will become a permanent role. However, i’m nervous about where the economy is going to be within the next year, and after getting a few linked in messages to interview for full time positions, I’m starting to second guess myself. Thoughts? Advice?

like

Crossroads Toyota Motor Sales, USA, Inc. I have been with the organization almost 6 years and have accomplished achievement of my MSL (Masters Strategic Leadership) and LOVE the organization…BUT…I am not having any success in moving into a new position…my interviews are great experiences but it seems to be a pattern of not being selected yet encouraged to continue applying…received information from a mentor/manager to ask for candid feedback…when is enough…ENOUGH??

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal