I started a new role 30 days ago. HR did a check in with me today and the HR lady gave me some new feedback that was my first time hearing about. Meaning my manager never brought this up in our 1x1s or when I have asked about feedback. Is this protocol or should I be concern that they are raising concerns to HR without talking to me after my first month?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I would imagine your manager is prob some 24 year old media planner with poor management skills.

Yes, I would kindly talk to your manager and let them know that you're here and ready to learn, and that as long as you give feedback to you respsctfully, you'll be receptive to it.

Going to HR without speaking to you first was a cowardly move on their part.

like

Seems like a red flag, best case if just with regards to their communication ability, worst case they might have made up their mind about you. If it were me, I would message your manager and say that [HR lady] mentioned something about [new feedback] and you would like to discuss when they have a moment. Give them a chance to tell you themselves, otherwise I would be weary..

like

Ahah whoops! Thanks.

I'm sure you're already thinking the worst, so I don't want to bum you out. But get back into job search mode and try to hop before you get a 10 minute check-in on your calendar in 2 months. They're starting a paper trail, and there's a good chance there's something going on that you wouldn't and won't be made aware of.

like

I just want to say thank you to everyone who has inputted! I have talked to other mentors and they also feel I’m being set up rn. Talking to my manager to see what’s really going on and will determined my next step from there.

like

yes.

funnylike

I would be concerned. That’s terrible management and setting you up to take a fall if anything ever goes wrong.

like

Agree with the comments above. Would add that if HR is talking to you after one month, that is quite early enough on that they are mentioning something to you. And you should be on alert. Sure, this would be better coming from your manager, but the feedback is coming, and coming quite early enough on (the way you write it makes it seem like you’ve been having 1x1’s for a year, and this is your first hearing of it. But 1 month is nothing. You’re still within the probationary period). If HR is checking in with you this early on, it means you’re not hitting the marks as expected. And this is the first step in them saying it’s not working out.

You could still turn it around, depending on what the feedback was exactly.

like

So I just switched from media to strategy and HR lady told me she heard that my thinking isn’t where they thought it would be

It does sound like they are starting a “paper trail”. But bigger picture it’s messed up that when you switch disciplines they don’t give you time and support to get up to speed. What is their plan for bringing you along?

like

They gave me my proficiency planner to show the skills I should be developing within the next year . I need to be intermediate in each section. I hvnt even set my goals yet. I’m suppose to be doing that next week. They told me in the interview to let me learn and develop as a junior brand planner.

Not a good sign, you need to be extremely open and honest with your manager about concerns, expectations and timelines. They need to lay out for you exactly their expectations and goals for your learning and growth. In writing.

As for the thinking part, strategy is about understanding the brand, it’s differentiation, how it fits and stands out, the competition, the market, overall economy factors and overall consumer trends and behaviors. Media is just the vehicle to deliver the strategy and idea. Think strategy first.

It also might just be they think you are not a good fit culture and personality wise.

like

I feel like it’s a not living up to their expectations if they are saying my thinking isn’t where they thought it would be

Yes. Very.

Related Posts

Can someone share any openings for JPMC Bangalore related to freshers.
Tech stack is SQL and Tableau. I am a fresher with 10 months of experience in internships and 1 month of full time experience.

Thank you for your help!

like

I am looking for a job change from system administrator to data analyst role.
Is there any opportunity available?

Can anyone please refer me to KPMG.
I have 6.5 yoe in manual testing, US P&C insurance, GuideWire all centers knowledge. Also know basics of API testing and looking for lead level role.

like

Hello fishes.

I was reached out by a
Microsoft recruiter yesterday. And I told not interested in the position. Now I feel little bad may be i should have given the interview. Can I reach out to the recruiter again ?
PS: it's been only 6months since I joined in the current company

Microsoft

like

First year analyst here... my manager often asks me to buy coffee for her and never pays me back. What should I do?

like

Non-eng... Got past the hiring committee! 🥳 does anyone know the process from now? And how long it typically takes? Thanks !

like

How is the manager role of Deloitte India for analytics and cognitive practice? Anybody from this practice who can help me on this decision please. How is wlb, I know mine is going to be client facing and that I would be expected to do more that just project work but does that mean I would have to work on getting projects for practice or how it will be?

likeuplifting

My partner is unstable, refuses to take their meds. Regularly snaps and lashes out at me. Im leaving and I feel compelled to tell HR for my replacement’s sake. Am I out of line?

Can Anyone in Cerner Corporation refer me for this role Asset manager. I'm an ex employee.

Im a RN and took on a new role working in Home Health. I chose this position because My husband & I recently moved to PA with our 2 kids (1&3), with no family available for his residency program with a hospital. If you know that life, I’m pretty much the main parent for our kids. I don’t want to work in the hospital/floor work anymore; nor do I believe the hrs are flexible enough. I need a job that’s flexible for the kids but pays >$44/hr. Maybe remote or hybrid? Please help w/ suggestions.

like

Any good tech/faang type business jobs in Chicago hiring? At B4 now

like

Hi there!
Searching for suitable job opportunity. Please let me know if you're or your fiends , company has an opening

I have experience in working as executive assistant to managment and strategist.
Searching for roles similar to these roles and responsibilities.
My total work experience is 5 years 3 months. I have worked in various High growth business domains

Please DM me if you know of any suitable opportunities, thank you

like

Hi folks, I have an offer from Persistent for Java developer and they're offering me 7.5 LPA for Senior Software Engineer role.. Is this the right scale in Persistent ?
My experience is 3 years

like

Any way to get in one of these IPOs prior to them opening up to the wider market?

like

Do Canadian firms have any interest in hiring American JDs given the market and that Canadian associates are moving to the US?

like
like

To stay or go? Is it time to move on?
I've got 4 years at a staffing agency after getting Masters in HRM and making a complete career change in 2018. Doing full cycle recruiting and account management. I feel I'm doing very well (in the role and with comp $57 base + commission = ~$91k last year) BUT I feel stuck!! I'm feeling undervalued and unchallenged. I think I'd love corporate recruiting/TA Specialist, etc. How do I make the jump? Should I just keep truckin??

like

More Posts

Does your firm give you credit for hours that were written off? Sometimes I feel if you don’t lose anything for hours cut from the bill, you have incentives not to be 100% honest w/ your timesheet.

like

Does anyone know how litigation finance works on the plaintiff side? If someone wanted to bring a lawsuit against their former employer would a general contingency arrangement with a plaintiff’s firm make sense? Or would one need to find funding and then contact a plaintiff’s firm to actually handle the case? I’m a transactional lawyer, so this is out of my wheelhouse.

like

Hello! I see a ton of questions in here about interviewing and getting hired as a PM. I also know that it’s really hard as a manager to hire a great team. I’m the head of product at a growing startup, and just hired two PMs in 3 months. One a career switcher who’d never been a PM before, and one a seasoned principal PM. Whether you are someone who’s interviewing or someone who’s hiring right now, ask me anything!

likehelpful

Looking for a 6 month lease in manhatten, anyone got a room? Anyone at all? Someone has to have a room. Starting Jan 1. Let's do this people

like

Are people at Deloitte actually germinating "MBBD" or is it just a FB quip?

like

Have any of you ever worked for a haunted hospital or facility? The senior nurses keep telling me stories and I'm nervous to start nights!

like

LinkedIn is going full boomer-Facebook complete with pictures of a computer screen rather than a screenshot or “share” 😐 comments were fun too.

Post Photo
funnylikeupliftingsmart

does anyone have any model practice / prep materials that they'd be willing to share? happy to contribute $ ... struggling to figure out how to practice in a structured way

like

So if I short a position in my rollover Ira- and buy different stocks. I won’t pay taxes on it?

like

Hi Fishes ,

I am 8 years of experience in data analytics and data visualisation . I am currently working in deloitte usi as sr consultant .
I want to move abroad for jobs .Please suggest me effective portals to apply for countries like UK and Ireland.

like

Hello fishes,
Can a capgemini employee join his client organization.

helpful

I think there should be more males caretakers in this world. Some of my clients just feel more comfortable with a guy and it's kind of sad how often they say I'm the only male they could find.

like
like
like

Happy Wednesday. It is Wednesday right?

Post Photo
likefunny

Hi

Has anyone from the cognizant registered BH for a car in Pune or Maharashtra? And are they allowing it? As per rules its allowed but I heard RTO is declining the request

Any thoughts on living in the area around Madison and Morgan? Looking at an apartment there. That area seems pretty cool and not far from the heart of Fulton. Wanted to get other peoples opinions before moving forward with this place

like

Moved from Canada and I have to say, big pharma in the US might very well be the devil himself. In Canada, medications that cost $30-$40, are hundreds of dollars here. Honestly thinking of leaving the field because I can't stomach the corruption.

like

What's a fair amount of resignation notice to give when you are a C-level/executive committee member?

like

Have any of you pursued a graduate certificate in cyber security? If so, did you find any value in it? I currently have Bachelors and Sec+. I’m looking to obtain my AWS CCP in the few coming weeks and was looking for what to get next. I entertain the idea of continuing to pursue my education but I don’t want to incur too much debt with a masters.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Which portable standing desk converters do people have and recommend. I live in a tiny NYC apartment so use my dining table as the office during the day but need to put it away at night.

like

What are some of the top B2B marketing agencies in the west coast? Any perspective what makes them great?

like

Serious question - which one lasts longer: real Donald Trump or Marcel?

like

which agencies in the city are creative driven rather than account driven

like

Anyone in NYC area have an actual office instead of open floor plan? #CantTakeItAnymore

like

Daniel Brian Advertising makes employers donate a $1 every time they wear shorts to the office...but apparently it’s only enforced on female employees.

DBC - what do you have to say for yourselves???

like

Laid off in August. Just wrapped a 4 round intrvw w a big name agency... but another candidate got the offer. ISO of agencies hiring. I’m happy to share a portfolio and conversation with all in NYC.

like

Dear KBS, today we received 17 all agency emails. Yesterday it was 20. Surely upper management has a better way to use their time. Make it stop. Love, KBS

likefunny

I laugh during awkward situations. The other day someone called me out on laughing. It was awkward.

likefunny

What do y'all know about Konrad NY?

like

Any AD creatives out there using iPad Pro to supplement your Art Direction? Hoping to move my hand-drawing skills to a more seamless digital space. What programs should I get?

smart

Just had someone in NYC I want to work for ask me my salary. It's illegal now but I didn't know how to tell them. I told them my range. What would you have said?

like

What is the Netflix employees email format?

like

IHOB? Droga just ripped off a 10 year old Pizza Hut ad. Pasta Hut—coming soon!

likefunny

Have you ever seen a client fired in mid-production?

likefunny

How do you not go absolutely batshit with anxiety while job hunting?

like

Food/bar recos in CHS?

like

Thoughts on CP+B Boulder? What is the vibe like there? Who are the clients?

like

Do you guys touch type? How long did it take you to learn? lol

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal