Just had someone in NYC I want to work for ask me my salary. It's illegal now but I didn't know how to tell them. I told them my range. What would you have said?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Say, "If you have to ask, you can't afford me."

like

Tell them what you want, not what you make. Don't give them a range, give them a number you'll be happy with (a range means the lowest number).

Them: What's your current salary?

You: I'm looking for $ XXX in salary for the position under consideration. That number is negotiable based on the total compensation package.

Them: But what is your salary now?

You: That number is immaterial. $ XXX is my starting salary negotiation point for this position.

Them: If we don't have your current salary, we can't move forward with negotiations.

You: Thank you very much for your time and consideration. I will be happy to entertain an initial offer based on the information already provided.

If they really want you, they'll work with you.

I once worked for a guy who used to negotiate union contracts for an East coast newspaper. He always gave in on hourly rate and screwed the unions on benefits-they were fixated on rate. That shit all adds up, and you should scrutinize the benefits with a fine-toothed comb BEFORE accepting an offer. Some of it is negotiable, and ALL of it should be factored in.

Pull out a calculator and spend a couple hours monetizing your benefits (current and proposed). Vacation days? 401k contribution matching? Stock options? Cost of med/dent/life insurance? Maternity/Paternity leave? Parking? Bonus structure? Flex accounts? Tuition reimbursement/assistance? Relocation assistance? It can all be translated into dollars, and figured into the equation.

If you're going to take a hit on benefits, negotiate a higher salary. Don't get fucked at the drive-thru.

like

"That's not exactly relevant but I'm looking for $$-$$"

like

^I'd take out the "it's immaterial line cause it's a little harsh and pushy and replace with this similar line: "I'm willing to negotiate but I won't be able to do until I receive an offer." Still firm but not as confrontational and gives them the answer they want (you can maybe be cheaper) without actually committing to anything. Of course, when you give a salary you always ask for more when you want/would settle for, so you can negotiate without losing if it happens.

like

"None of your god damn business." (Don't worry it will not come off as harsh, New Yorkers appreciate forthrightness.)

like

It's not illegal yet, it takes effect later in the summer, I think July, can't remember. Every time someone asks you about your current salary, say that actually you're looking to discuss the going salary for this new position instead and the unique experience/skills you bring to it. If they insist (unlikely), say you prefer not to share as it's private and you're not comfortable sharing

like

I read this recently I thought it was a good take on how to handle. Net, net it's all about ranges. Give it a read:

Recruiters Don't Need Your Salary History -- But Here's Why They Want It

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/recruiters-dont-need-your-salary-history-heres-why-want-liz-ryan

like

Ok, found another great article. Read this one too. Titled, how do i tell the recruiter shes not getting my W2???

https://www.forbes.com/sites/lizryan/2017/04/22/how-do-i-tell-the-recruiter-shes-not-getting-my-w-2/#2510eece4f31

like

They were definitely trying to low ball me. It was the first interview and they didn't ask me to present my work or talked much about what I'll be doing.

Sounded like they were scouting for cheap talent. Hate that.

Thanks. Next time I'm going to think out loud and ask about benefits and retirement too, because I have to factor that in. Asking for a range is a good idea.

Related Posts

Hi Fishes,

I am a software specialist having 8+ yoe, currently working at Mastek with a CTC of 17lpa. Can anyone help me with the current market CTC considering the below:
Current Role: Tech Lead
Tech Stack: Full Stack in Java, Springboot, Angular, Mobility, AWS beginner.
Your responses will be much appreciated.

like

MasterCard offering - Level 6 at YOE 11.
1. What % of the variable one gets in a year? Is it 100% as they mention in the offer letter or less? Does it depend on performance ratings?
2. Is Level 6 okay/good/appropriate for 11 YOE?
3. Which month is the appraised salary effective from?

How are IFS bonus and raises this year?

likehelpful

What is the pay bracket for DI AM level (A&A)?

like

It's sad to see people with 2-3 years of experience getting paid more than you when u have double the experience. 😄 Best part is they are still complaining of getting less. Well I guess you should never settle. New gen is giving a hard time to the experienced folks. I think this is the high time to upgrade your skills. Come out of your comfort zone and start looking for new opportunities. I think this is the best time to switch if u haven't already in quite some time.
Thoughts 💭 ???

like

How much Nielsen IQ pay to sr support engineer role with 7.10yrs of experience?

like

Any info on Fractal Software salaries?? They are hiring for a Research Investment role, and I can’t seem to find anything on compensation.

like

California 🐟 does your vacation payout when you leave your job get taxed at regular wage, or bonus, levels? Does your employer have discretion to choose?

like

What bonuses are expected to get paid out for FY22? There was a raise in July but no bonus, correct? Is it only equity awards in Nov? Or will there be an element of cash bonus?

like

Tomorrow is a big day for me!
Made a written offer on an apartment on Sunday. Owner‘s starting price was 500k. My offer is 450k. He thanked me and we are meeting this weekend to „negotiate“. Tips?

I heard from some people who have joined ibm recently that IBM revise offer letter with 1 to 2 L increament just few weeks before joining? Is it true?

Hello.
I have the opportunity to work in Germany EY i am currently in KSA.
How is the salaries , living , etc....?
would you recommend that i move to Germany?

like

Are the salaries paid to those with no advanced degree comparable to the salaries paid to those with advanced degrees (e.g., JDs) by manager level in ITS?

like

What is ideal package for a project manager with 7+ years of experience in IT firm

like
like

What’s the benefit of being a manager apart from the bumped up pay?

like

Ey Gds or PWC Sdc/AC which one is good for 9+years of experience interms of WLB, hikes and other benifits?
TIA

like

More Posts

I have a question for my fellow PI paralegals in Texas. TPCIGA requires that we submit all medical bills through the clients insurance before proceeding further. The client in question has Aetna. I sent the bills with a cover letter to Aetna via certified mail. I am having so much trouble getting a status on said claim. Does anyone here have experience with that and can assist me? Any help or guidance is appreciated.

like

Hi All, looking for referral for Plsql with 6 years experience. Please let me know if anyone can help

Deloitte Manager or IBM Manager?? Please suggest.
Almost same fixed package.. skill SAP Functional Close to 10 Yrs experience.

How to get into IBM ISL from GBS

like

Is it possible to ask for joining bonus in ibm since I didn't request during the time of offer.. i am yet to join ibm.. Could you also suggest a good reason to ask for joining bonus?

like

If I resign from IBM , within 11months 15days what will happen?

like

Midlevel and seniors, how do you review juniors’ work without redoing them? Any tips on giving instructions or spotting mistakes?

like

Hi all,

I'm currently working as a Salesforce Developer with 1 yoe. Looking for a change. If anyone can refer, pls DM so I can share my details.

like

Bedtime stories for accountants

Post Photo
likefunny

What is the notice period in Cognizant. I joined on JAN 2021 they didn't mentioned on the order letter as well Cognizant

like

PROPOSAL: Can we start naming names with respects to layoffs, furloughs, and pay cuts? Knowledge is power, and the only ones who benefit from vague exchanges of info. are the employers. Thank you!

likehelpful

Tier 2 to MBB fish... How has recruiting for other jobs compare at the two firms?

like

When did you tell work about your pregnancy?

Ladies, did you put on make up before your delivery for photo purposes?

like

Looking to move back to La in the Marina Del Ret area, any good apartment recommendations?

like

Anyone aware of the IBM new centre being opened at mysore ?

Persistent conducts interviews just for timepass. After clearing all rounds they don't offer. Aspiring candidate dont attend interviews.

like

What “self help” books are you guys reading? I just read Untamed by Glennon Doyle and wow, I want to start from the beginning again, but feel like I should read something else. Would love any suggestions.

like
like
like

Additional Posts in Advertising

how’s Code & Theory these days? does it seem stable and process driven? WLB?

like

Food/bar recos in CHS?

like

Modern problems require modern solutions.

Post Photo
likefunny

Can someone explain how billable hours work? At a new agency and although I had to fill timesheets at my previous agencies, they were mainly used to ensure we weren’t over servicing a client/for setting the appropriate retainer for contract renewals. I asked ppl at my agency but haven’t gotten a proper explanation. I get the impression that billing to the agency admin code isn’t recommended, and my manager said he bills everything to client codes, but that doesn’t make sense to me .

like

Long shot here, but does anyone have a google sheet / excel document with a list of all potential Advertising Award Show submissions that you would be able to share? Including deadlines for 2021/2022?

like

Thoughts about Digitas Health?

like

Looking to take a break from the advertising agency world (honestly pretty burnt out on ad land) Thoughts on working at an agency who may be more focused on branding or content creation. Anyone made the jump?

like

Facebook shutting down Oculus Story Studio... VR dead?

like

Why does everyone make such a big deal about the Oreo moment whenever a SB comes around? What’s so good about dunking in the dark 🤨

likefunny

Client removes all copy in ads re: product description or product benefits due to pending legal review. Removes visuals of product doing its job. Blames agency that ads aren’t driving traffic/sales

likefunnysmart

I got the job. That is all.

likeuplifting

Are CPGs pushing more faux-health benefits than before?
Or is society catching up to the bs?

Post Photo
like

Is it really that hard for managers to book their own conference rooms and send out invites? The time it takes to ask one to do it could it not have just been done by themselves?

likefunny

What agency did the Absolut campaign?

like

Saturday night live is getting good again.

like

I was recently laid off and my client offered to be a reference and wanted to see if there was anything else she could do to support me during this time. Any tips on taking advantage of this generous offer?

like

Yo W+K, this was a flop. Why is a large scale fast food company crowd sourcing funding from its consumers to then sell back an idea to them? This is bad and cringeworthy.

Post Photo
likefunny

This may sound odd, but can you run an agency without an ECD/CCO?? (Asking for a friend)

like

I think I’m finally burnt out on agency life. What’s a logical next step? Freelance? In-house? A new career all together?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal