I was laid off last month but now in the final interview stage for two very different opportunities.

First opp is a digital agency and they asked if I’d consider a part-time contract gig with the “goal to hire” in 60 days, depending on the COVID impact. So no guarantee for a full-time offer. Second opp is a client side marketing role at a publicly traded company that has been somewhat recession-proof. Culture is very corporate and a bit conservative (not creative).

What would you choose?

likeuplifting
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Client side to be safe if you end up not liking it you can always apply agency once things have had enough time to normalize and positions start opening back up. In the meantime you at least have a secure job.

like

This. 100%

like

I never trust companies who do “goal to hire”.

likesmart
Recent IconRecent

Client side, recession proof. The work is a little more boring but right now take the security, get equity and bulk up your 401k

like

Well if they asked you to consider it, say you did. Then say I have another offer that’s offering me a regular gig, no contract to hire thing. Tell them you can’t do the uncertainty right now. You just got laid off and no one knows what’s gonna happen. You both have leverage but you have a better offer too.

likesmarthelpful

I was about to write this exact thing. If they really want you, and know you have a concrete job offer with the other co, then they’ll figure out a way to bring you on as a full time employee.

like

This is such a personal decision. My two cents is to really think about what weighs more for you. Obviously job security is something all of us are longing for, but there’s nothing worse than having a secure job you don’t love. I made that decision a while and left in less than 3 months. If you really love the creativity of what we do it’s really hard to be somewhere where that’s not the case. You can get by and adapt, but it’s just not the same.

Either way I’m happy you have those two opportunities to consider!!! It’s been rough for the past few months and it’s nice to see people having new doors open for them!

Best of luck OP!

like

Client side

like

Depends a bit on what you need in life. Can you afford to lose your job in 60 days? Do you need health insurance?

like

I could probably be ok without a job for up to 4 months. I’m on my husbands health insurance.

like

Go client-side because it’s typically more money and a MUCH better work / life balance. You’d be incorrect in thinking it’s recession-proof. Especially if you’re in marketing since it’s always the first to go—even though all the evidence proves that marketing efforts should be doubled during a downturn.

like

Ditto. Best advice.

In this era, go client-side for the benefits and salary, and go for the full-time job. That will only make you more valuable to an advertising agency after a year where do you want to be

like

Been client side for two years. Don’t regret it one bit. Better pay, benefits and work life balance. Plus when you say crazy stuff people think you’re the resident rebel genius.

like

Yeah - congrats, you are in demand and that’s huge. Question is where you are in your career/what will make you happiest and most productive at this career stage/what sets the best foundation for your future? If you’re in a role that revolves around the creative product, plain and simple, it’s one thing; if it’s about creative problem solving, you can usually find those difference-making opportunities in even conservative environments. Personally, I’ve always inclined to creative risk-taking, because, for me, a good day is good work going out the door. Your actual mileage may vary.

like

I’ll second that. I recently changed jobs and the more corporate environment, less creative work has made life hell. I recognize though it’s not the same everywhere so that’s why I say take the pay and benefits and give it a shot if it dies t seem too bad.

like

Client side. Go for stability in a recession.

like

Let us know which one you pick when you do!

like

I will, I’m having lots of conversations happening this week and next week with both companies. If I get two concrete job offers I will share my learnings with this group in hopes that someone else might find it helpful.

like

Agency! Client-side is where creatives go to die.

likefunny

You've got to eventually go somewhere to die. It's tough to accept but that's this business. There are no retirement parties at ad agencies for 99% of us...

likesmart

Client side. Pay, benefits, power dynamic is worth it. There are still shitty days but the rest makes up for it

like

Client side! Don’t believe them about temp to hire.

likesmart

Really appreciate the input from this group. Being flexible with roles has really helped with my job search. Thanks for the feedback and good luck everyone!

like

Flexible roles= ECD >SR Writer or GAD >Jr Acct Manager

like

Congrats op! ✨

like

Thank you, not a done deal yet but final conversations this week.

Go for security right now. That’s been my approach at least. I shifted my workload to prioritize the big revenue less creative accounts I work on. There will be new creative opportunities when things improve.

like

Related Posts

I’ve been at my clerkship for 5 years (4 with a different judge) and one with my current judge, and I heard horrible things about him before starting, but I assumed they were exaggerated. Turns out they’re all true, and I’ve had to start therapy to deal with him and the incredibly toxic environment. I’m trying to get out ASAP b/c he also has a history of firing clerks without cause or notice, but I think I’ll only be able to give two weeks notice if i get the job I’m interviewing for. Thoughts?

like

I have an offer from IQVIA for an Engagement Management (Tech) position. Is it a junior role? Also, what should be the salary expectation? I have 9.5 YOE in IT consulting along with an MBA

I'm looking for opportunities and seeking referral so, need some virtual hearts to dm. Please help

like

Most staff/sr assoc would make 80% of salary for the next 4 months if fired & yet firms are considering pay cuts.

Like at this point just fire me idk what kool aid some of you are drinking

like

Have a onsite with the Google Finance Ops team in a couple of weeks. It looks likely they have been on a hiring spree for process and program manager roles. My background is in supply chain contd...

Has anyone butted heads with an office manager their age? We have a new one who seems to be trying to control my schedule during Covid (ie she assigns me office days without asking me, if I leave the office early or don’t come in one day due to video calls she emails me and tells me I need to inform her of my whereabouts), when that has never been part of her job duties before. Partners don’t care that I WFH.

like

Resigned from my job for blatant racism last week. Been a contingent worker for 6 months. The manager that recruited me unfortunately left after a couple weeks and went to another company. She however recommended me for the permanent opportunity to higher management. The acting manager came in, permanent role was posted, I applied, interviewed……manager told me they chose someone else external for the role. I could sense the manager had no intentions to hire me permanently

like

What are the best websites you’ve used when applying for a new job? Any that are specific to saas/tech sales or ones that have yielded good response rates?

like

I’m a non-TX immigration attorney mentoring a UT student who went to my undergrad. He’s done incredibly well in OCI and pre-OCI. Thus far, he’s landed interviews with (all in Houston): Baker Botts, Sidley Austin, Kirkland, Winston Strawn, Reed Smith, Norton Rose, and Locke Lord. Also Perkins Coie in Dallas. He’s leaning transactional, but also open to litigation. Any insights/advice on these firms in the TX market? Any to avoid?

like

Looking to apply for venture x before the offer goes away today. Anyone out there willing to share some of their referral bonus? 50 bucks?

like

I'm looking to find a job like the Forward Deployed Engineer role Palantir Technologies in the UK.

I have become hooked on finding a job that involves solving the kinds of problems they presented during their interviews. Although I got to the final round my performance anxiety got the better of me (I think I wanted the job a bit too much...). I will reapply after working in a similar company.

Is it "deep tech" / "data science" or "smart enterprise" that they're doing? Any advice welcome.

like

Hello All, I have been selected in the interview at NTT DATA and also submitted documents as requested by Recruiting HR. However , it's been a 10 days after docs submission but haven't received any call from HR for salary negotiation. On email follow up with HR, he said he is on it and will come back to me soon for further process. Any views.NTT DATA

like

Should I leave my company? Been here 1.5 years and was told I was getting a management promotion 5-6 months ago.Still no solid traction and they are opening up a req for it 😑no one on the current sales team has ever been promoted (2 years)except our boss who has been promoted 3 times. We hit quote every month/q/year by a lot. I have several offers at double my OTE. Already asked what the timeline is for a new manager and I was told soon and I'm "up for consideration." What would you do here?

like

Got hired 3 years ago- newly created staff accountant role with the plan that it’ll go into a senior and then manager role. 1.5 years in I get a title promotion to senior, told I’ll get more duties, start supervising AP, and get monetary promotion to match next year. Got way more work, but nothing else promised within that year. Told next money bump would be manager role (no raise for senior still) and I need to take on more and start supervising AP. Again, seeing nothing…time to leave?

like

Thoughts?
I’ve been working at my current company for 11 years, for the past year I have been waiting for a promised promotion. I have been fully remote for 7 years pretty much good work life. Busy. In April they said I have the job still waiting. I am a project accountant III to a finance business manager.Could be long nights &stress. Still unknown pay maybe 20k increase.. Last week I was offered a govt job at NGA (Budget analyst) 40k increase not guaranteed remote. 45 min drive +retirement

like

Hi All..Once project completed if no projects will HCL ask to relocate???

like

Hope the matzah is keeping everyone sustained at client site!

like

I left biglaw after 3 years to a mid-size firm. Took a pay cut but the hours, people, culture and work were so much better I never thought twice about the salary or “prestige.” Ultimately I started 2 very small firms. I am not rich by biglaw standards but I have a very comfortable life and put my kids through college with no debt. 35 years after leaving big law, people are still impressed when I say I started there. I feel like I still had the benefits of the connection w/o the suffering.

like

Confession: I used my hospital client ID today to get discounts on donuts. 😐

like

ACDs in tech, what are your salary ranges if you live outside of SF + what city are you in? I’m in SF (big tech co) and given covid, been thinking about leaving but curious what numbers I would be looking at in Seattle vs LA or other cities with tech companies. Thank you!

like

More Posts

Hi Fishes,

I have got offer from CTS and doing pre-onboarding formalities. As part of BGV the are asking to fill HR Manager name and contact numbers. How we can fill that because my previous company is HCL where the HR people are keep changing & @they don't even respond to their employees. Also, we couldn't add their phone number as well. How to proceed with this as this mandated for BGV. Any one please helpout.

like

Hello All, I have been selected in the interview at NTT DATA and also submitted documents as requested by Recruiting HR. However , it's been a 10 days after docs submission but haven't received any call from HR for salary negotiation. On email follow up with HR, he said he is on it and will come back to me soon for further process. Any views.NTT DATA

like

Should I leave my company? Been here 1.5 years and was told I was getting a management promotion 5-6 months ago.Still no solid traction and they are opening up a req for it 😑no one on the current sales team has ever been promoted (2 years)except our boss who has been promoted 3 times. We hit quote every month/q/year by a lot. I have several offers at double my OTE. Already asked what the timeline is for a new manager and I was told soon and I'm "up for consideration." What would you do here?

like

Got hired 3 years ago- newly created staff accountant role with the plan that it’ll go into a senior and then manager role. 1.5 years in I get a title promotion to senior, told I’ll get more duties, start supervising AP, and get monetary promotion to match next year. Got way more work, but nothing else promised within that year. Told next money bump would be manager role (no raise for senior still) and I need to take on more and start supervising AP. Again, seeing nothing…time to leave?

like

Hi fishes,

Please help me choose the right option considering yearly hikes, promotions and good projects.

Tech stack - SAP finance
Yoe - 8.5 years

Pwc offer - 19 fixed + variable + 1.5 lakh joining bonus
Accenture offer - 22 fixed + 0-27% variable + 1.5 lakh joining bonus

like

What are some tools you use to track progress (IEP goals) for high school students? How often do you track?

like

Finger Lickin' Good

Post Photo
likefunny

Visited Deloitte Towers today. Huge queue in cafeteria. Looks like every one is working on Tuesday and Thursday

like

Anyone know how working for the IRS would compare to Big 4?

That Friday feeling

Post Photo
like

Truck drivers! What is the weirdest thing you've seen while out in the road?

likefunny

Did any one join through HCL virtual onboarding process. How was your joining experience. By when we will get laptop/desktop

like

Cali freelancers... does the passing of Prop 22 affect us at all?

like

Whom you surround yourself with is a choice, just like everything else in your life.

Don't underestimate the strength you can gain from having the right people by your side who genuinely support you through good times and bad. You shouldn't make space for people who bring constant negativity.

IG: Burnoutcoachcarlo

Post Photo
like

What’s a red flag you look for when considering new clients?

like

Interested in everyone’s opinions on replica luxury. I ask because, as noted in the previous thread re: Chanel’s price increases, the quality of authentic luxury bags is going way down while the price increases consistently. Specifically Chanel and LV. I’m fascinated in the online rep community and it looks like rep quality has increased exponentially (with genuine materials and 1:1 markings, stitching, hardware, etc). What’s your argument for or against replicas?

like

I have received pwc ac documentation email on 7th but still did not got any update...please advise .. Thank you

Moving to LDN hopefully by November. Can anyone please suggest muslim concentrated residential areas? I would really like to stay well connected with the community.

like

Anyone from wipro Hitachi ABB account ?

like

New in my market and just got review feedback that said “this region (the South) is more passive aggressive, we don’t do well with people (I.e. you, from up north) who shoot straight. You’ll also do..

like

Additional Posts in Advertising Careers & Job Hunting

Looking for Senior Researcher & Strategist in Dallas Fort Worth area to come work in tech. Message me for more information.

like

Anyone in Portland down to chat? I have a small creative portfolio and a couple years of management experience. Been looking for PM roles (but am open to anything).

like

Happy fishing, fishies.

Post Photo
like

I’m looking for a writer to help us with unique content for a heavy machinery/industrial website. Any idea how I could locate such a niche freelancer?

Any chances to move from Europe to the States? How’s the visa situation? Are agencies sponsoring?

like

I’m looking to hire a full time strategy director. Big agency experience. NYC based agency, but remote for the foreseeable future. Drop me a DM with you email or website if you’re interested!!

like

Any Boston AE/SAE jobs available?

like

Saatchi LA is looking for an ACD/CW

Post Photo
like

What do you do if you just started at an agency, like a week ago, and then get an offer from your dream agency

like
likehelpful

Our client, a Manhattan pharmaceutical digital advertising agency is looking for a VP or SVP Brand Strategy.. Needs experience working on a brand with multiple indications in the oncology space (ideally) and be actively working on approx. $7 mil. of revenue.
1st. round of interviews will be internal. Candidate will be asked to present to the agency, then meet the client. On-going work will be remote. The salary range is $165 to $210++ negotiable
Contact us for job description
Stay Safe

like

Hi Fishies, I’m looking for a Creative Strategist role (+ have copywriting bg). Lemme know if you know someone who’s hiring!

like
likehelpful

Hello!

Anyone hiring for full time Recruiters? I’m in the market looking for a new role. I have over 5 years of experience in the tech industry.

like

Asking for a friend: any AD openings in Dallas?

like

Crown Social, in Seattle, is looking for a highly conceptual freelance (with full-time option) designer to dive in (this week preferably) on a new campaign for our Amazon client. Interested?

like

Anyone looking for a senior-level writer with everything from social to broadcast?

like

San Diego gigs at Grizzly.

Post Photo
likeupliftinghelpful

Have agencies started looking for spring interns yet?
Looking for art direction intern opportunities in New York

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal