Is there really a difference in culture / WLB amongst the MBB firms or is this all overblown? I consistently hear BCG is relatively friendly and academic vs Bain is collegial and fratty vs McKinsey is most intense and cutthroat but is this just marketing? BCG loves to talk about PTO. Bain loves to tout their sustainability surveys. I don’t hear anything comparable from McKinsey around ensuring employee happiness. Anyone from these firms care to comment?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I don’t think there’s much difference between us and McKinsey tbh.

Bain seems to actually be different, driven by much more undergrad hiring—>see people stay there longer and generally happier even with the big DD focus.

likesmart

Post Photo
likefunny

I think generally WLB at consulting firms is horrible. But there are some differences between the firms in terms of degree of bad WLB.

My spouse works at Mck, and I’m at Bain, and I see considerable difference in WLB atleast at the consultant level.

1. The mck teams are leaner and therefore there is lot more work for each person, leading to very late nights

2. Generally at Bain people care about your life outside of work. There are mechanisms in place to ensure you don’t have a terrible WLB, and can share suggestions that will make the case a more sustainable experience. I’ve heard case team surveys at Mck are a joke and no one takes it seriously. At bain, results are shared office wide so managers are incentivised to help resolve sustainability issues

like

Not being a hardo at all, and I’m a B4 partner now. You have no idea how different the B4 model is, even in strategy, and that’s really what C1 was asking. There’s a set point once a year, or twice at some firms, where the promotion and CTL decisions are made. The MBB model is totally different and those decisions are rolling.

And I’d also agree with those who said not making it to 2 years is in part about luck — a couple bad cases in a row can really screw you, especially if the industry is soft at the time. It’s not always this busy.

like
Recent IconRecent

Differences within the firms are far larger than differences across the firms.

likefunny

This is always the correct answer with these questions

like

Don’t know the other firms - but we do have plenty of extended PTO/Take time and part time options. Two month additional (unpaid) leave per year is not too bad!
I really don’t feel like McK is cutthroat - in contrary, one of the things I most like about the firm is how nice and caring everyone is towards each other (except for maybe 1% assholes that can probably be found anywhere)

like

For reference, Deloitte now has 1 month unpaid leave for any reason not covered by existing leave benefits.

like

What I’ve noticed in this thread is that all the Bain people are talking about how good Bain is, the McKinsey people talking about how good McKinsey is, and the BCG people are just busy trying to explain what PTO means.

funnylike

I was there for the beginning of the PTO experiment; it was dumb back then too. Well intentioned but dumb. You manage burn by building a culture that enforces good behavior.

likesmart

No. It’s mostly marketing. It varies a lot within each firm based on an individual’s priorities, but you can race to partner at each firm *or* prioritize sustainability - the choice is yours.

As someone who has recruited for all MBB and has now done recruiting on behalf of M, we are just really bad at marketing ourselves. The experience varies so much at M, that I wouldn’t generalize the experience beyond, you can make it what you want it to be.

like

I think the personality stereotypes are completely overblown. Maybe were true once, but all 3 firms are big enough that there are all sorts of people at each.

What is true is the extent to which cultural norms and structural differences drive experience at the 3 firms. I consistently see from my friends and colleagues that Bain has better wlb, a more enjoyable experience, and better retention to senior levels than M/B. There are a few reasons I think. These factors can be relevant in subsets of the firm at M/B, but I think they are more universally relevant at Bain.

- Cultural focus (from the top) on sustainability. This is driven by things others have mentioned e.g. surveys and accountability

- Team structure. Bain typically staffs bigger teams as a function of the pyramid being larger at the bottom than the middle (which is cheaper)

- Approach to projects. We are probably more 80/20 in the way we approach problems than M/B

- Home office staffing model. This reduces travel vs other firms, but mostly it means managers with poor sustainability get found out very quickly as their teams are always from their office

like

US-focused view: I also noticed you guys have way more “Americans” especially vs MB, especially in certain US cities whereas in MB is very internationalized (to the point where finding someone who cares about college 🏈 is hard), probably due to larger global presence and transfers. The general impression on-campus is that Bain is more biased against internationals vs. the other two, especially those for whom college/b-school is their first US experience.

The median sr.mgr-partner level at some of our coastal offices is probably a European or Indian male whereas with you guys I think its more along the lines of a white American male.

That likely drives differences in culture/work life balance, if you have a lot of people whose main reason for being in the us is work and who may came from other regions known for poor WLB, that’s a recipe for poorer sustainability. It also can drive ethnic cliques within offices.

MB also hire far more pHDs leading to “nerdier/more intense” culture.

Both pros and cons to each situation I suppose.

like

This topic is funny to me because my two best friends are Mck and BCG. We always joke we got mbb down three of us. We obviously don’t represent the three firms but when we get together and talk about work the differences are pretty interesting. We’ve been working for few years now at the three firms, and I consistently have better WLB than the other two. McK is always stressed out - he’s either staffed on a case working late even on Fridays or is not staffed and worries about staffing himself. He also spends few hours on Sunday night “organizing” work so he can have a better following week, but if you ask me that’s still working time and I’d never even open my laptop on a weekend. BCG friend also seems stressed out but has less work hours total than Mck friend.

like

Think the conclusion on this is that it’s also quite person dependent. Even within Bain, some people push on sustainability, take as many flex options as possible, put their foot down more frequently etc. These are the people who tend to find the job more sustainable. Whilst others choose projects with leadership they know will work them harder but they care more about getting the quickest promotion or best rating, and have a plan to leave fairly quickly to PE or something else anyway. If I look at colleagues experiences even within Bain they differ wildly

like

I think those stereotypes may have been applicable ~30 years ago when the firms were much smaller. Given their scale today, they are more similar than different.

like

I did take time at McKinsey - the unpaid time off thing consistently in my 2+ years there. Would take a week off in between every project, so would amount to ~5 weeks additional time off every year. Was awesome. Never had any impact on my ratings or performance. Is one of the biggest things I miss about Mck since leaving

like

Not cut throat here. But yes, the work is intense. It’s consulting so we all work hard. PTO is at your discretion so not sure why bcg talks about it. Nobody stops you from taking days off at any firm. Our sustainability surveys are taken seriously at least in my experience. McKinsey is larger so there are more people to raise complaints and that’s why you hear this crap :)

like

M4, I’m sure your WLB is better in B4 but quite a few of those things you mentioned we also do at Bain. In between busy projects you frequently get downtime, we have an ‘early night’ system whereby you can tell them each week a night you want to be out early (eg it’s your partners birthday or you have theatre tickets, dinner with friends etc), and staffing are generally pretty good about giving you downtime if something is going on in your personal life (assuming you feel comfortable discussing it). A lot of that depends on your direct supervisor and how much you push for it at bain. Though of course I imagine in general your hours are way better!

Outside perspective so take it with a grain of salt but they’re big firms so it likely differs by office, practice, team. When I interviewed at McKinsey one of the Partners told me she’d spent a fair bit of time working out where she wanted to fit into the firm and who she liked working with and who she didn’t.

like

There will be a baseline difference due to structural reasons (eg global vs home office staffing, pyramid vs diamond structure, style of firm off-sites), but ultimately you should find your people wherever you go.

like

If you are good, someone will work you to your breaking point. If you are really good, and an actual asset, they'll recognize they aren't allowed to burn you out.

like

Bcgs sweaty but I’m sure the others are bad too

Related Posts

Hi All,
I have applied for
EY and I got selected for the 2nd round, after completion of the 2nd round, I didn't receive any call from HR in person, nor any mail. Can anyone please tell me the EY selection process.

Thanks in advance 😊EY

like

Anyone got insights on IBM Security? Areas of expertise? QoL? Pay, etc.

How’s the presence of Deloitte ARA in the Bay Area compared to EY FAAS? Also, is it true that ARA encompasses SOX engagements in addition to technical accounting & transactional projects?

like

Hi all, I’ve been taking 15mg XR in the morning and 15mg IR as needed in the afternoon for about 2 years now and it’s helped a lot, however, when I take time off I just feel so lethargic. I’ve read about people taking Wellbutrin as well. Anyone have experiences with this? I meditate and exercise as well, but I just lack energy and almost feel like the same things don’t make me happy when I’m not on my medication.

like

Done with 2 rounds of interview with Birlasoft and HR asked for some documents.
When I can expect the offer letter?

Does anyone have idea about cisco meraki in india?

like

Hi fishes,

Bain capability network(BCN) vs Axtria ingenious insights
Which one is better and why?

Bcn - Associate - 10.7lpa fixed + 1.3 var
Axtria - associate - 12lpa fixed +50k joining bonus

Opinions on Apptio?

like

Anyone been part of a successful, school culture transformation from one that is completely accepting of mediocrity to one that collectively strives for excellence?

like
like

What are the various employee benefits that lilly offers?

Guys can someone provide me the insights on the package of Salesforce admin support resources having experience of 4+ years and cctc is 10 lpa.

Generally how much Salesforce provides on this role?

like

Hi fishes, Can anyone tell me what is the salary offered for Monitoring Analyst II ( L23) in Paypal. I have 6 yrs of experience in same domain . How much to expect and ask

Anyone willing to dm about climate/sustainability roles at BCG?

like

Guys , pls help, How much Cognizant can pay for Manager projects , 8.5 Yrs , Azure , Databricks , Pyspark

likeuplifting
likehelpful

Visa consulting and analytics. Thoughts? Worse than consulting firms or better?

like

More Posts

Any consulting firms hiring new grad students ?

like

What do you think is the better option? Both offers are around the same salary (~100k EUR in Denmark).

Solutions Specialist (security) at Microsoft or Manager in digital solutions (security) at MasterCard? Also in respective of the long term career? I have 2.5 YOE

like
like

Females, how much of your personal life do you disclose to the men in your team? I.e. Lovers, relationships, ONS etc

like

I just did my pre-licencing certification and passed my CA state exam for property and casualty. No I have no idea what to do or where to start my career as an insurance agent since I have no experience in the real world, just lots of knowledge. Please help!

like

Whether amount added on meal voucher through company can be transferred to bank account?

like

Hello Connections,

Hope you are doing well !!

I am looking for a new job opportunity as a Hadoop Administrator.

Experience : 6 years

Skills: Hadoop, HDFS, Hive, Pig, Mapreduce, Oozie, Sqoop, Hbase, Ranger, Kerberos, MySql, Unix/Linux, SSL, Hortonwork/MapR Distribution

Please let me know if any suitable openings is there for my profile.

If incase you don't have any, that is still ok.

You can simply share this post, may be someone from your connection can help me out.

Thanks
Prashant Gupta

like

I'm shameless! Who wants to hire me? Full cycle corporate and commercial real estate sales rep who wants to get into BDR/SDR roles. #ninja

like

Do you tell your boss you’re going through a breakup? I’m phoning it in and obviously going to be camera off for awhile.

like

Anybody have experience with JD-specific mortgage loans? I know BBVA offers one

like

Hi Fishes,

How is the
Samsung SSIR memory team? I'm about to get the offer this week for a firmware validation specialist role. Are they flexible to give WFH?

Hello fishes, I am not able to understand why D&A competency in TC is doing EPM implementation projects using Oracle. When there is a dedicated competency for Oracle ERP implementation. Anyone having some idea please help understand this.

like

I hit rock bottom (I mean it) and in 6 weeks I managed a vacation, landed a new job, found a great guy, and landed a bomb apartment. Everything can change at the drop of a hat - keep your chin up.

like

Dear Fishes, How’s retention policy of synechron? And Do they offer on-site once you resign?

Is it a good decision to take part in OWN SAP offered by SAP labs ?? Can someone explain pros and cons of it ?

like

Wow! What a day! What type of company starts layoffs right before the holidays? Lost my job this morning and I am stressed out. Is there any chance of finding a new job before the holidays? I'm doubting it.

likehelpful

Any business analyst looking for an exciting career with one of the top consulting firms of canada?

like

Got the offer Amazon L5 Cloud Support Engineer, what is ideal salary for this position.

like

I am not sure how ppl get married by using dating app, is this really how ppl get themselves into serious relationship nowadays?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting

Best consulting firms to work for in Hartford CT area?

like

Confession: Dreamt about Panda Express last night.

like

Effed up the schedule of a demo and won't have access to the software until the day before I have to show to the partner. Own up that it might nor be ready or wait and hope I can pull it off?

like

New project has many SSIS files that I will have to get my hands dirty with. I have always manually written ETL procedures. Any tips working with SSIS first time? Looks powerful but chunky to get into

like

So i forgot to move my 401k over from my old job a few years ago. Never done it since because I didn’t want to incur penalties. Moving job again, can I do it now?

like

What are the top consulting firms in the retail/CPG space?

like

Ugh! Got 2 hours left in a 14 hour drive with younger sis. Both of us getting on each other's nerves and I hate road trips. Help fbfam! Anything entertaining? 😔

like

Kudos to the woman who stood up against racist jabs by fight attendant today morning.... ✌🏼️More power to you girl.

like

What are some of the best books you’ve read about people and investing? Such as dealing with people (business psychology almost) and then investing (real estate more specifically)!

I am looking for books that give practical advice, not just big picture theory and motivation.

like

Did anyone read the top consulting firms to work for? 😂😂😂

like

Best stepping stone to get into MBB? MBA vs experience at Big 4 / other second-tier consulting firms?

like

Anyone ever get an Indochino suit? Thoughts on quality/value?

ACN peeps: I quit the firm last week. Will my PTO payout just come with my last paycheck?

like

Any really impactful books that have helped you career-wise? Not necessarily consulting focused. In need of guidance and a new book so figured I'd kill two birds with one stone or whatever.

like

HNY! For those of you that took the AWS Cloud Practitioner exam, how did you prepare for it? Study materials, hours, etc?

like

Is it necessary that groomsmen be in matching suits?

like

Companies hiring international candidates with MIS background? Had to quit due to personal reasons and now I have trouble finding one. Any industry will do. Couple of years of experience with Oracle

like

Which top consulting firms, if any, will pay for your MBA?

like

Looking to get into Facebook privacy legal team. Have experience as a consultant at another FAANG company. Anyone willing to provide a referral or discuss further?

like

Not sure if I am getting laid off. What are some key signs. Thanks in advance for your help?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal