I’ve been promoted to vp in IBD at a MM. how should one think about eating a one year demotion to Asso3 in order to move to an EB?Stakes are much higher than a 2nd year analyst doing the same

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

It's completely up or out... BBs would keep you around if you're a work horse, but EBs usually would want to see a transition from a with horse (early associate years) to a race horse, i.e. Someone capable of bringing in revenue and moving up to MD on track.

You need to do a bit of self analysis on how you got to where you are right now - all / most of the up and up or did you also somewhat got floated through on a track by not completely sucking

Taking a demotion is probably ok, but moving from MM to EB as an exp VP would be really difficult (too much process focus vs actually thinking strategically and diff client base).

Plus you can always move to another EB if this one doesn't promote you in a year (written or not, it's completely discretionary in an at-will employment)

Good luck!

like

I'm same year, have gone through the thought process. Depends on where you are in life and how much it would hurt you personally to lose a year. For me I'd rather be somewhere less prestigious but get the responsibility and development now.

For up or out you should have a frank discussion with your target. They shouldn't be hiring for an Associate 3 if there's no VP seat open. Can you extract a guaranteed promotion?

like

EB better than BB unless you want to bank for life. Do you want to bank for life?

Do you want a life?

I’m really focused solely on the pros/cons of a demotion. Question is trickier than “bb or eb.” what happens if you get demoted but don’t get promoted back? Isn’t it up or out?

I’m a vp. Chill. Exactly it is up or out but why would you make the move without a guarantee? If you did any google you would know that you wouldn’t make the move without a guarantee as3 to vp1. Especially at EB where the assessment to become a VP is much harder

I would assume you’ll get promoted back up unless you are questioning your own performance. Comp-wise, probably a good decision because EBs pay more than MM banks as you move up. So the year back will be made up for within a couple years. The big question is can you stomach an extra year as associate? I made the same switch a few years ago (didn’t have to go back a year) and I certainly was not willing to do an extra year of associate at the time.

I have no doubt about my capacity to do the work and now seems like my last real chance to upgrade in terms of platform/comp.

But I’ve also seen things go wrong for very capable people because of personality fit or poor group placement. I’d have to prove myself all over again in a span of months. However unlikely, the costs of fucking it up are quite high.

Also, tbh, having to take orders from VPs again would be awful for my ego

like

I’ve learned that a story/explanation goes a long way. If it’s a logical process to you, then taking the demotion isn’t an issue. I had a friend in asset management who was a partner at his firm after nearly 5 years (small joint, couple billion in institutional) move to banking after an MBA and is currently a VP working his way back up. He just got an offer to leave his BB firm to enter as VP at a company in his coverage universe. He’s stroking it. Generally people don’t care as much as you think they do.

Yeah, he realized he wasn’t passionate about following markets everyday and wanted to start over as an operator at a company. He went into banking post MBA in order to make that jump.

VP is the hardest role to find. You have leverage so IDK why you'd take a demotion.

Wait a year and take the hit then. Hard to do VP to Associate. I have rarely seen it in my 13 years. Where it has happened it did not work out. I took hit from VP2 to 1 6 years back which still hurts...

Related Posts

Hi, fishes.
A quick query here.

I'm going to move from non IT profile to IT profile. Basically I'll be applying as front end engineer in new company. Previously I was working in a BPO profile.
Just wanted to ask if I'll be provided training in my initial months as a front end engineer or am I expected to work from the very first day.
Your comments will be really helpful.

Thank you.

I’m potentially moving from a senior social role to an account management position. I feel I’ve capped my growth in social and want to explore other sides of the business. Any tips to set myself up for success?

like

Hypothetically what’s the shortest amount of time you should stay in a job without switching. I kinda wanna try my hand at a different industry but don’t wanna kill the experience I have now by leaving too early

like

Hey all! Interviewing and need some insights about accepting a non-tech product marketing job. I currently work in SaaS but was offered a higher paying job in educational publishing. It’s a non-tech product marketing role. I want to take the job but I don’t know if moving out of tech would be a bad move for a product marketer? Would it be harder to pivot back to tech?

like

Need Some Advice ->>>
Current Role - Senior Associate, Salary 120K
Offered Role - Manager, Salary 150K
Yoe - 5, Tier 1 city (SF/NY)
Worth jumping Ship from KPMG to Tier 2 Consulting (Grant Thornton).

likehelpful

I'm currently in a BDR role but have been studying for my PSM and getting ready to take that test soon. Does anyone have any advice for how to pivot from sales to being a Scrum Master? It seems everyone wants a SM to have 3 to 5 plus experience to even look at your resume.

like

Accepted offer to leave consulting (3 YoE, no previous lab experience) to join corp strategy team at biotech, any advice on what to do during the first couple of weeks?

like
like

I was hired within the last year as a site supervisor. I did well my first few projects with the company. They asked if I’d be interested in transitioning into a construction manager role. I agreed. Now I still am the site supervisor on projects but I’m also doing all the construction manger duties on the project as well. Essentially 2 jobs for one salary. We have yearly reviews in December but no talks of raise have been discussed. Any help on approaching this to my boss?

like

Human interest stories might not be where the money is, but making the switch has saved my sanity after the tragedy I’ve covered the past few years.

like
like

Is anyone part of Toigo? How helpful is/was it in your career search?

like

Hi fishes
I have experience of 2 years in oracle plsql and i am looking for a switch

but i want to work in Java development and I have learned spring mvc, spring boot and I have good knowledge on core java, collections

Will be it be good decision to directly get a job as a experienced candidate by telling I have experience on Java(2years)
or
I shouldn't lie about my prior experience on oracle .

Thanks in advance for your valuable suggestions

like

Advice needed:

Strategy Analyst at a corporate -> IT DD/ODD at EYP -> Strategy Consulting at the same firm

Detour or shortcut, my goal is to be in strategy consulting. Is it better to just wait for a couple more years and then go directly into strategy consulting? Are IT DD and ODD experience viewed favourably by strategy consultants?

Would switching from S& to LEK boost, hurt, or not change exit ops to PE/ PE ops/Corp dev & strat roles? Also looking at benefits of not having independence and utilization requirements. Thanks!

like

Hi all,

Currently, I am working in TCS and I have offer from CTS. Now, TCS trying to retain me with similar hike offered by CTS.

Is it better to stay back in TCS or move forward with CTS.

I have completed 7.5 years in TCS & my total year of experience is 9.

Please suggest. Thank you!

like

is it worth it to shift to IB or MBB after 7 years in the big four(audit and fdd)? I do think IB and MBB are interesting fields that you can acquire unique skill sets and a good network. But I don’t think I couldn’t keep up already for a daily grind. The reason why I did not pursue it earlier in my career is that I am not from a target school and I do not have an MBA. lol thoughts?

like

What are the best roles in big tech for someone with tech backround/software development experience ~1.5yoe with an MBA and consulting ~2.5yoe?

Thanks!!

like

I’m a bit rough around the edges and I think this is severely hindering my abililty to connect with people in my department and civilians. What are some good ways to break out of this and develop my people skills?

like

How's the job security for a 10 years experienced DevOps engineer. I am planning to join.

Is it a company where people can stay longer . ?

like

More Posts

Any tips or advice for Google Strategy & Operations interviews? I have my role related knowledge interview next week. Thanks a lot!

like

How is everyone getting Fall/ Spring/ summer internships? Are you all applying on the company website/ LinkedIn page. Networking to recruiters? Through college career center. I've been applying and not getting anything? Any tips or advice?

like

How does this resume look, as I have been applying and not hearing back, is it because I graduate in 2023?, Also I am at an internship right now but I know the return offer won't be good only 60k even though I will have my degree and CCNA

Post Photo
like

Roland Berger boston or chicago office?

like

Any CPAs out there that decided to buy and run a business? Curious if my theory that after advising businesses how to run efficiently and effectively, that I could fairly easily deploy this experience in an existing business. Obviously I'm not ignorant that there will be obstacles to overcome but ultimately think it would be successful. For added context, I have an MBA, have focused of business development so understand sales and dealing with customers.

Thoughts welcome!

like

Has anyone started/considered starting an individual/small business income tax preparation side gig? What were the challenges juggling w/ a Full Time job and getting clients?

like

Best books about product management for a good exit to industry? I already have an MBA and PMP but looking for a refreshed perspective since it’s been years since my formal education.

Currently reading “Product Managements Sacred Seven” but it’s geared toward the startup world. I am in healthcare and not looking for a startup role. TIA!!!

like

Accenture folks!
Can I submit the Time report in the next fortnight if I missed current fortnight (1st -15th sep).
Will there be any consequences?
I have recently joined Accenture (DOJ- 1st Sept) and I am yet to receive the WBSe details for time report submission.

Please help as I continuously receiving automated mails to submit the time report.

Thanks in advance!!

like

Once i withdraw resignation, are there consequences?

likefunny
like

Hi All,

Is it okay to join Mastercard Project from third party payroll?

like

How would ne product Mangager salary slab?
YOE: 6years

like

What type of technical and behavioral questions will KPMG ask for my last round of interviews? Anyone have ideas?

like

Monday Morning Motivation:

Post Photo
like

Really confused as to whether to incorporate my NY- based makeup startup as an LLC or an S-corp? Not based in NYC if that matters and no revenue yet. Should I be looking into Delaware at all (specifically a Delaware C-Corp) if I do plan on raising capital at some point down the line? Also - for any FDA lawyers out there, what is the problem with developing makeup (specifically foundations) with SPF? I've heard it's "heavily regulated." What do I need to be aware of? Thanks in advance !!

like

Heard that due to high Attrition TCS is recruiting Ex TCSers. Is it true. In that case what should be the minimum gap to be rehired.

like

Does anyone have the AWS Cloud Practitioner certificate and does it hold any value? I’m non-tech looking to get some certificates under my belt to be more marketable in my job search

like

Anyone knows the Post MBA salary at BCG Dubai, starting base + bonus?

like

What’s the standard RTO (return to office) plan for MBB as of now?

like

Additional Posts in Finance

Is it just me or has there been a noticeable brain drain in banking in the past few years? Analysts are not what they used to be.

like

Good day to be buying bonds... any of my fellow yield grubbers out in effect today?

like

Fixed income vs Equity trading desk at BB? Why are trading desk at BB down year over year? Fixed income desks In particular! Future of trading leading to full automation?

like

Simple life hacks that make a huge difference:

like

Anyone else feel cautious about the JP wellness screening? Is this something they can use for drug testing? Even still it is weird giving my blood to my employer

like

Any CAIA holders out there? How have you generally been viewed?

like

How long do Citi background checks take? Do they send you an application once you sign the offer?

like

What is considered business casual in SF? Is it suit with no tie or Polo and chinos?

like

Why are there VPs commenting in this app? For god's sake don't you have like significant others, spouses, more going on with your life??

like

Is it just me, or is Soros getting uglier every year? It's like the dark side is twisting him up.

like
like

What can I do during downtime throughout my day to prepare me for investment banking? I have a while until I am eligible to move internally but I want to be prepared when the time comes

like

Can someone explain how to maximize the 401k employer contribution -- by when during the year should I have invested the full $18k to get the 1.5% match?

like

From associate to VP - what specially to learn

like

NASA What is the salary range for JPL- Financial Analyst III?? @nasa@JPL

like

What is an appropriate bonus to give your admin (she books all my travel and processes expenses/receipts)? Travel once or twice a month, don’t have her schedule meetings for me at this point.

like

PE has taken some heat recently as an industry. My initial plan was to get my foot in the door within the next couple of years, but I'm not sure if this is the smartest idea. Thoughts?

like

Looking into preowned watches under <$10k resale value...patek, vacheron, or rollie?

like

Any insight on CAIA? Difficulty and whether it impacts salary?

like

Received an offer from JPM for a branch manager position, but afraid of getting the offer rescinded due to going through bankruptcy almost 3 years ago . I’m freaking out hoping this won’t be an automatic disqualification, has anyone been through this same experience and gotten hired in?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal