Looking for advice on applying R2 this fall or delaying application until next year. M7/T15

I have 4 YOE in healthcare in a rotational management program with the goal to pivot to healthcare consulting post-MBA (ideally MBB). However, I’m about to start a new job as a SC at a Big 4 in healthcare consulting. I still want to get an MBA for a variety of reasons.

Is it worth delaying until Fall ’24 to have the consulting experience on my application as well as the chance my post-MBA goals change?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Stats:
- WM
- 3.4 undergrad GPA in economics large state school (honors college)
- took the GMAT a few weeks ago (650) & targeting a 720 in retake

like

What did you do to increase that many points in 3 weeks?

TWO BIG QUESTIONS YOU NEED TO ANSWER FIRST: Why do you want an MBA?
How will you make your application stronger in R2 this year versus next year?

Goals wise:
- It sounds like you’ve essentially achieved your “post-mba 🥅 minus the extra prestige of MBB”
- Writing about doing healthcare consulting post-mba at mBb could sound v generic to adcoms and would require a lot more oomph with long term aspirations.

Stats wise (which I think actually matters less than I thought before applying but is v easy to quickly judge)
- Assuming WM = white male who studied econ, you’re an overrepresented demographic.
- You have a sub T15 GPA average (also weirdly low for a honors student in Econ), which isn’t helped by being from a large state schools that typically have decent grade inflation.
- You have a sub M7 GMAT average even if you score a 720 on the retake.
- if you apply this year, you’ll enter with 5 YOE. if you wait, you’ll have 6 YOE which is still certainly in range, but you’ll be competing with people who have fewer YOE and can be at the SC level.

Things that you haven’t shared that could change the discussion
- you’re from a low-income first generation college student background OR had to learn English as ESL in college OR you had some very extenuating 🏥 condition/event OR you have a strong upward GPA trajectory like 2.0, 2.5, 3.0, 3.5, 3.5, 3.75, 4.00, 4.00 to justify the low GPA.
- you’ll do better on the retake than 720
- the work that you’re doing is super cutting edge and newsworthy
- you have other redeeming qualities/hobbies/activities that make you more of an interesting well-rounded person.
- your ability to obtain strong letters of recs now vs next year
- your ability to commit the time while onboarding to a new job to actually do apps
- the impact you’ve had in your work (idk how impactful you can make a rotational management program sound) vs what you’ll have in your new job to show on apps.

I don’t think I could answer your question with the infor you have provided alone.

like

Thanks for the insightful response! I have answers for a lot of these, but hadn’t thought about some yet.

In an effort to try not to identify myself even more, I’ll just mention why an MBA.

Why an MBA?
- network, potential career pivot, learn new skills, try a new industry during summer internship, break from work, improve candidacy for senior leadership positions in the future
- long term career goal (as of now) is not consulting, but will use consulting to get more non-payer experience and learn which areas are better fits (provider, federal, biopharma spaces, etc.)

I’ve decided to delay my application a year to focus on improving my GMAT, networking with students, essays, getting more work experience, etc. with the added bonus of applying during Round 1

You could delay until next year. The experience may help with recruiting for the internship. First round is also slightly better than R2 and you will have more time to prepare essays and have more stories available.

like

Related Posts

I’m 32. I have $80k saved. $40k currently invested. Then ~$50-60k in 401k. My plan was to save for a house, but prices have skyrocketed. As life returns to normal...I need to now move out from my parents’ again. Do I bite the bullet and rent in NYC, or stay and save another 12-18 months and hope to buy something? Full transparency: taxes make it very difficult to buy. It’s not the down payment, it’s the taxes.

like

Submitted cbs with ea score. Jheez. Yet to take the gmat for the other schools 😭

smart

Do Optum offers some relocation benefits. Like inital days staying at some guest house/hotels.?
If yes then to whom we have to reach out?

like

Are Google , IBM , Meta learning certificates, worth it? Do they really impress employers? If had an IBM data science certificate without any experience for example what type of role can expect or should I expect any?

like

Hello folks,

How's Tata Elxsi for MBA(B.tech) graduates? I recently got an offer from Tata Elxsi as Project Associate through campus placement. How is the work env, and growth opportunities.! Should I consider the offer, or start looking for other companies.. Please give suggestions..!

Post Photo
like

This is the great resignation, right? Thoughts on jumping for the fourth time in seven years? I’m chasing the pay to get to where I want to be and have an offer but am getting reservations on making a move within a year. Appreciate any similar personal experience.

like

Best consulting firms to target for Supply Chain & Operations Strategy apart from MBB after graduating from MIT SCM

like

Should I get a CPA for Transaction Due Diligence?
I’m a new grad working in FDD and I’m trying to decide if becoming a CPA is worth it. I do not plan on staying in accounting in the future. I’m more interested in strategy work. I certainly do not want to do Audit. Would you recommend getting the CPA considering my career aspirations? Do you think it’s worth it? If not, what is the best way to use my time efficiently?

like

Has anyone ever pivoted to Product Manager at big tech? Thinking about making a switch and would love to hear some of y’all’s experience. Thanks in advance!

like

Has an ALM in Management at Harvard Extension School led you to a career at any high power corporations such as Goldman Sachs?

like

what is the pay range for role - manager 1 assurance at pwc sdc kolkata?i have 6.5 yoe and joined at 21lpa + 10% vp, four months back. managers from other big 4 start around 28lpa. does sdc kolkata pay m1 this much only or have they underpaid me? i am considering dropping paper and looking out again.

like

People over 40, what advice (career, financial, relationship) would you give to people in their early 30s? I see people in their 20s asking this for those over 30 so I'm curious 😊

likehelpfulsmart

What are the exciting exit opps in the GTA area like, specifically in the Tech space? Startups / FAANGS?

like

I just started doing insurance defense 3 months ago. A few of my billing entries have been cut. I feel very bad. Does anybody have any tips for writing better time entries?

like

Did anyone transition out of law and pivoted into marketing? Would love to hear your thoughts! I have a public relations degree but very limited work experiences.

like

Recently accepted an offer for a manager in Bizops in Ad sales for a tech firm. Curious about the growth opportunities in this area. What do folks do after 2-3 years in such roles ?

like

Travel and TTC combo haven’t worked. After 6 months, the only offer I got included 4 weeks paid and FLMA only after 1 year. So 1) go and risk laughable benefits or 2) stay but risk TTC. So shitty 😭

like

I am thinking to switch my career from being an auditor to software. How hard it is to switch? Has anyone done this? What are your experiences? Thank you.

like

I have 2 offers one from my Current company and one from Cisco my current company is giving 10 percent more than cisco Where should I go should I join cisco or stay in my current company( a small stablished startup )Considering my final goal as FAANG (similar) and I come from a Small College Cisco Amazon Uber Walmart

like

More Posts

like

Is Canarsie in Brooklyn a safe area to live in?

like

Hi Anyone from US Tax . I recently got an associate 2 offer and they have mentioned phone allowance , mon le connection allowance and bus subsidy, what are these. ?

Also what's the salary you people get

like

Just wondering about how is the WLB in HSBC account of Synechron, Pune? I am reading so much of pros and cons on Glassdoor and here. Some are saying the cons like Hire and fire are a FAKE news.

I have the highest offer in hand from Synechron with HSBC client. Please help me make up my mind whether I should join them or not..?

I have another offer with LTI as well but just a marginal difference in pay, and the Location is Mumbai. Should I choose LTI instead?

Please Help!!

#LTI #Synechron

like

Hello Fishes, looking for an opportunity for below mentioned role.
If anyone could share some leads.

Role: Scrum Master (PSM I Certified)
Total experience: 5.2 years ( 2 yrs as SM and 3.2 yrs as QA)
Location: Pune or remote

like

Best consulting firms to target for Supply Chain & Operations Strategy apart from MBB after graduating from MIT SCM

like

One of the company asked if i could join as early as in 1.5/2 months where I have 3 months NP and haven't put papers yet .. i asked one of my senior in my team about this who's already resigning...and she has told about this to the entire team 😶. I realise it's my mistake asking her :p
Now that I'm not hearing back from the company which I gave interview and my environment at current project is a mess atm...Should I just put papers or bear with it till I fine another one..??

like

Sunlight Financial please refer me
I'm having 3.5 experience in angular + .net core

Hello Team, Could you please let me know, how much salary will be sufficient to live in malaysia with family.

How much salary can we expect for 10yrs of experience.

Looking for a mid to senior level PM for pharma work. Must be high functioning and work independently and also well with others. Going through these interviews and the well seems pretty dry, thought I

like

Hi there! What's the protocol for posting resumes?

like

Hi what topics to prepare for iOS interviews especially for product based company

like

Hi ,
I have got sodexo card activated today. I found there is Meal Pass card, Meal benefit pass card and Cafeteria card

Which one we get money loaded ? Will that only usable in Bofa cafeteria!

like

What clients does Nagarro have? Indian? US? European? Spreaded accross the world?

like

There’s no excuse that by the age of 25 you have never tried therapy. I’m speaking directly to the demographic in this group who I’m sure over 95% of people in here are earning 6 figures. Key word: TRY. I understand it’s not for everyone but to have never even attempted seeking therapy is a injustice to yourself and the people around you.

likesmartfunny

Should I get a CPA for Transaction Due Diligence?
I’m a new grad working in FDD and I’m trying to decide if becoming a CPA is worth it. I do not plan on staying in accounting in the future. I’m more interested in strategy work. I certainly do not want to do Audit. Would you recommend getting the CPA considering my career aspirations? Do you think it’s worth it? If not, what is the best way to use my time efficiently?

like

USI Onsite 🐠

This is my first year being onsite, wanted to check how the onsite comp revision works, would I get increments in line with the US practitioners??

Who decides our onsite comp. Is it done by USI leadership or US leadership??

like

Has anyone ever pivoted to Product Manager at big tech? Thinking about making a switch and would love to hear some of y’all’s experience. Thanks in advance!

like

Additional Posts in MBA Applicants

Is it possible to do part-time internships in consulting while doing a full time mba? Considering a few schools in the northeast but not sure if it would be completely feasible or if the firms even offer something like that

like
likefunny

I read on another thread that someone got rejected by HBS without interview and was then accepted to GSB in the same round. Does anyone else have some success stories like this to share with us HBS rejects?

like

Submitted cbs with ea score. Jheez. Yet to take the gmat for the other schools 😭

smart

Hello folks,

How's Tata Elxsi for MBA(B.tech) graduates? I recently got an offer from Tata Elxsi as Project Associate through campus placement. How is the work env, and growth opportunities.! Should I consider the offer, or start looking for other companies.. Please give suggestions..!

Post Photo
like

About to write about how two years as a Resident Assistant in college shaped some of my values and key traits. Planning to highlight initiative, people skills, innovation (in dorm programming), and commitment to first-year students’ wellbeing. Any other tips on traits to feature/examples to use?

like

Wharton calls started for Asia! This has been a really useful and supportive group through the process. Good luck and thanks all!

likeuplifting

Help me settle a debate. Which has a lower acceptance rate, McKinseyites applying to HBS or HBSers applying to McKinsey?

like

When applying for Financial Aid, does it harm you if you show the college that you have too little in savings? I am planning to take a loan for my MBA.

like

I work in deals and am frankly frustrated that those with 9-5s can get better GMAT scores with their schedules while I have to work around an unpredictable schedule at 80 hrs/week.

likefunnysmart
like

Is 47 considered a low quant score for top 15 business schools?

funny

Who applies to HBS in R2? I was surprised to hear the pool is just as large as R1. Any speculation on the strength of the R2 pool this year?

like

Salary expectation for pre-MBA internships?

like

Is the ETS GRE-GMAT converter accurate? My GMAT is above medians everywhere but I don’t know how much it matters.

like

What’s the quant cutoff for M7? Scoring Q49 / Q50 but want to know if Q49 as a consultant is OK or good enough.

like

Does your undergrad school matter to MBA admissions? Does it make a difference if you have a great GPA from a state school or an average GPA from a highly selective school?

funny

Any tips, tricks for GMAT and using Magoosh effectively? I’m a month-ish out of test day, and using Magoosh... my practice test says 660 (although I did much higher on GMAT math than Magoosh math).

like

Anyone got fellowship or need based scholarship at M7 schools?

like

Best GMAT study materials?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal