Made it to final round interviews at 9 agencies over the past 7 months. I get specific, and positive feedback but I just can’t land an offer. Anyone else been in this situation and resolved it?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

I know I’m biased as a Strat but I would think a strategic account person would be a good thing? Unless it is what others were saying about having to work a level down; they may think you won’t be happy in the role.

like

just a reminder that it's considered to be helpful to bookend your interview with stating how confident you are that you can make major contributions in the role rather than this is what you want because it really is all about getting them to realize what's in it for them. It also helps as you close out your discussion to reaffirm that you were highly confident about the contributions you could make before the conversations and you are even more enthusiastic now. Then, the important thing to say next is to ask if they have any additional questions they would like to ask you so they are just as confident as you are about the contributions you can make. I to their candid input. is often disarming and you sometimes really get a chance to hear what hesitations or concerns they have while you still have time to respond to their candid input.

likehelpful
Recent IconRecent

Perceived culture fit (ie my experience with current clients seems more structured than that of the agency), or it turns out they prioritize specific experience more heavily than the recruiter thought (such as heavy TV production). I’m applying for Account Director roles, a lateral move, so I am surprised with the emphasis on executional experience over business leadership

like

Literally got told this by my (new to agencies) ED... basically that he’s “changing my role” and I’m essentially a supe now

like

I’ve also received feedback that I speak like a strategist though my background is in account 😑

like

NYC, LA, PDX

Are you a straight white male?

like

Nope

like

Yeah that one is bizarre. It’s an asset as an account person to have strategic thinking.

like

I’m doing my best to fight the “Account people only forward emails” stereotype 😊

likeuplifting

That seems like waaay too much interviewing. You are probably exhausted. Be choosey. Know what you want. Be clear about it. Listen to the opportunity and ensure it aligns with your goals.

Can you read people and situations? V important as this work thing marches on

likehelpful

Also yes, I’m so exhausted. But if I haven’t gotten a Yes yet, I don’t feel I’m in the position to say no to an interview

Whats their reasoning/feedback?

like

Reading all these comments and your responses, OP, it does seems they want someone who can do the day-to-day work, and you have not been talking about that part of your experience. I would think you get to your level by doing all the things at lower-experience levels, but likely they want to hear you say that you are able to.
Good luck.

like

Thank you, I appreciate the thoughtfulness and will take this into account. I shifted my original narrative from focusing on executional work to strategy/leadership examples because I sensed that being executional at a director level was looked down upon by some interviewers. Will be more mindful to speak from both angles next time.

How many years of exp? Just curious. It gets more competitive at the director level.

like

9 years

Have you ever considered that one of your references could be telling all these people something bad about you? Not sure if they’ve asked for references, but if you’ve made it to that many final interviews it’s either that or your salary demand is too high

I trust my references of course, but only one agency has asked for references so I don’t think that’s it. Salary range was discussed with the recruiter before any interviews.

At least you did not get ghosted after the final rounds

What types of roles? What specific feedback are you receiving?

Account Director! The feedback is in my first reply up top.

Related Posts

Re-invited to interview at BCG but also want to cast a wide net and apply for Mck and Bain. However got rejected last year this time at the resume screen stage. I’ve changed firms since I last applied (to a well known boutique) - is this sufficient or am I still frozen?

like

Hi Folks,
Hope you are doing well, I need valuable suggestion on few of my queries.
I had joined
KPMG(KGS) on April 2022, during the interview i have been told that i would be working on Java Backend Development as my background belongs to same technology and my interview was also happened on Java/Spring/Microservices; but they put me on Low-Code / No code Platform and its totally tool based work. I am frustrated with the current work as i didnt find anything productive to learn.Continued in com KPMG @

like

I know I’m an excellent designer and creative leader but I am having the worst time securing just an interview. I’m tired of being ghosted. What can I do?

like

I m doing leet code problem solving practice since last two months to crack coding interview however I feel it is hard to solve medium and hard category problem most of time . Is anyone else faced similar issue and able to overcome by following tutorial or course ? Any kind of leads to overcome this Issue will be helpful . TIA

like

What is a good interview answer for leaving a job after a few months when the real reason is that you’re sleeping with one eye open in hopes of not being on the chopping block after two rounds of massive layoffs? Company culture is at an all-time low, and it will only go down from here from what I’ve seen in the short months I’ve been there.

like

Interviewing with Oracle for Senior Director role (Strategic Client group). 18+ yoe
How is the work culture and PIP at Oracle? I have a comp discussion planned this week, any insights into their salary structure will help - base, joining bonus, RSUs, etc...

like

Is freelancing allowed in walmart ? Freelancing means taking interview on behalf of a 3rd party company .

like

For those that didn't make it thru their
MBB interviews and were told to reapply in a year, what point did you start studying again? Did you take a couple months off or still practice throughout?

like

What are the chances of Amazon (or FAANG in general) allowing you to apply/interview again for a position that you did not get in the past?

like

I’m looking to transition from an academic medical center to pharma or a biotech. I have about 8 years of clinical research experience overall — 7 years combined as a CRC (CRC I, CRC II, and senior CRC) and 1 year as a PM. I’m also recently ACRP-CP certified.

I’ve worked with many different industry-sponsors and CROs throughout the years, but many jobs I am applying to require experience at a biotech/CRO/pharma company. Would really appreciate any advice or referrals. Thanks in advance!

like

What questions should you ask during a phone screening with a recruiter?

like

Beginner video editing advice wanted - I’m working on a personal side gig project. As part of that, I’m recording short interviews with people currently using a camera and/or iPhone .. (cont)

My Accenture recruiter told me that in order to revise my current offer she would need to reject my current offer first and no need to worry on that part. Is this normal? Please provide genuine feedback.

like

Disney Streaming Services I completed my interview process with DSS early last week, and was reached out by recruiter that all rounds were strong hires, and they are extending an offer. We set a time to talk on Friday about the offer. However, the announcement of targeted hiring freeze happened on Friday. I was ghosted with no call. What should I expect now? Would I still have chance to be offered?

like

I have submitted documents to Capgemini for BGV. HR round is yet to happen. How long will HR take to release offer?

Finished final round interviews and got notified I moved onto the final step - references. Is it safe to think I’m the only one at this step? Or is there typically multiple candidates still considered

like

Interviewing for a tech job for BlackRock. Do they really want people in Atlanta office 3 days? Doesn’t seem competitive for the market. Is there flexibility in this? Or are they watching badge entry?

like

Had an interview yesterday and the interviewer wanted to understand what I did - even 1 month gap between jobs - from 2009 to present 🤪 Not interested in the job anymore tbh

likefunny

Had an Excel assessment yesterday as the second to last step in an interview process. I was using a new computer and long story short, had some technical difficulties (or maybe just my own incompetence under stress) and ended up only getting through half of the test. I’m on the fence about emailing my recruiter and explaining the circumstances/asking for a retest. Don’t want to come off like I’m complaining but also don’t want this to be the reason I don’t move forward. Any advice appreciated…

like

More Posts

Hello Folks, I just created this bowl for helping business central consultants in taking right decision. Share your experience and let's help each other. Thanks!

like

Is Flex Jobs worth the money for people based in Switzerland?

like

A campaign my partner and I thought of went into testing, but died in the process. Same idea, concept, name and execution used on another client/ campaign just a month after, that we weren’t on. Few people from the old team were on this new campaign. We’re disappointed about it and wondering if this is a common thing that happens?

like

Ratings on three projects - 3,2,2. Utilization - 90%... Proposal hours - 15... Firm activities - 43 hrs... I then get a YE rating of 4 😕 ... How worried I should be regarding the layoffs???

like

Hey guys, question regarding new years resolutions. Anyone know some good books about how to lead better and step up to become a great CD?

Has anyone rented out a space at a Marriott hotel for an event? Aren’t you supposed to get Bonvoy points based on the amount you spend?

like

Hi Fishes,

Anyone from IBM. I need referral in IBM for below position.
Middleware - Service Delivery Specialist. Please ping me if anyone from IBM

like

Anyone have a contractor role in digital transformation? Thanks

like

What do y’all think about the new Copyright Small Claims courts that will be set up within the year?

Hello,

After onboarding in Deloitte USI Hyderabad do we need to report immediately from next day to office as per hybrid model or we can continue wfh until assigned to project

like

When is WFH ending ?

like

Folks, AC Kolkata employee here.
Will management approve my request to buyout half my notice period if i promise to serve the other half? Also, any idea how it will get calculated?

Need ur urgent help and advice on this.

like

Hi please give me guidance. I am studing for far. And it is sooo much material. I am a tax person so it’s a lot. I am done with chapter 3. I have off until this Thursday. I plan to take the test beginning of august. My goal was to complete the video/ chapters/ and do a first go at the questions during my time off.

like

How much are you expecting in raise/promotion or exit opps for having the CPA title and credentials?

like

Hello! I am reaching out for any insight on best employee engagement ideas to spruce up morning meetings in the office. Open to any ideas - Thank you!

like

How is Forvis? I am thinking about applying for an entry level audit associate position. Is it nice working for them? Do you get to travel on audits? Also, is the unlimited pto truly unlimited?

like

Are Google , IBM , Meta learning certificates, worth it? Do they really impress employers? If had an IBM data science certificate without any experience for example what type of role can expect or should I expect any?

like

Can’t decide between Hanoi or Ho Chi Minh city for 5 days in Vietnam. Also is it necessary to join a tour group? Thoughts?

Any one has specflow dumps for CCA exam?

I am currently working as an Application Engineer at Amazon. I want to move to the AWS team as an internal transfer. Any tips to crack the interview or any referrals.

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Has anyone successfully made the leap from digital to brand planning? Any advice?

like

A couple of ppl in my previous agency, saw a competitor acct try a very interesting idea that we thought was cool — but their execution was super localized, in europe, and was not even done to its fullest potential. So, they didnt get ANY press (just like two articles from random websites). Fast forward and Im at another agency, thinking that now more than ever, that idea could be done better. Is it fair game?

like

How many times a week do you ask yourself why you’re so terrible at advertising and why is it 1 billion?

like

Have you ever seen a client fired in mid-production?

likefunny

People whose spouses work in time consuming jobs like doctors and lawyers how the eff do you tend to your home life? My kitchen looks like an animal attacked it.

like

Seeking advice as a junior level employee in strategy land — what are your thoughts on where the agency landscape is headed now? Should I stick with it in the coming years? Should I jump ship and seek comms/brand work elsewhere?

Any and all thoughts appreciated!

like

IHOB? Droga just ripped off a 10 year old Pizza Hut ad. Pasta Hut—coming soon!

likefunny

I posted in the NYC advertising bowl & didn’t get any bites which was discerning - putting something together for international women’s day and looking for the most prominent/well known/powerful women in our industry. Agency, post production, production - can be anywhere in the US! Please give me SOMETHING!? I know there’s plenty out there. I just want to hear what the masses think. TIA

like

It’s hard to be motivated when rounds of layoffs happen and you see all your friends leave. But one thing that’s gotten me through all of this is working out. And when I say workout I mean the most pathetic, sad, barely completed beginner-level cardio dance routines. I’ve somehow forced myself to move while on lockdown and it’s somehow forced me to feel better. Whatever you’re doing, wherever you are: get up and move even if you don’t finish or end up going on a walk. Pls take care of yourself❤️

like

Any advice for your LAST day in office?

like

Does anyone work at an agency that has a different structure for teams and departments than the typical layers of account teams, strategists, creatives, etc? Curious if there’s anything inventive.

like

I have a great opportunity on the table that’s currently work remote with the end goal of returning to the office 1-2 times a week when it’s safe. However, after the past couple months, I don’t see myself returning to live in the big city. Has anyone requested to work fully/mostly remote with a new offer? How did it go? How did you request it so it seems beneficial? Thanks 🙏🏼

like

Thoughts on the MasterCard team at McCann NY? Thanks.

like

Places in NYC hiring sr creative teams?

like

Anyone in NYC area have an actual office instead of open floor plan? #CantTakeItAnymore

like

I’m clueless about 401ks. If I go to a new job does all that money I put into my 401k transfer with me? I’ve heard both yes and no so I am confused

like

Curious how other people’s brains work.
When you get an activation brief, what’s your process for coming up with a solid idea?

Look for cultural moments that you can adapt? Look through award show books? Scroll YouTube videos until 3am?

I know that every brief and every idea is different, but I’m more interested in the process and what you’re creative routine is to get the wheels turning.

Thanks.

like

TRUTH OR MYTH? Agencies don’t always post their available roles. Sometimes they fill up roles with referrals from company employees.
What do you think?

likesmart

My controversial opinion of the day is that organic social is worth fuckall for the majority of brands (including the trendy lifestyle ones) and that influencers are just propping up vanity metrics.

likesmart

Advice needed!
I have been a strategy and planning associate for a year and a half (first job out of college), I found that I'm not really cut out for this sector of advertising and would like to get more into the creative area. I've applied to countless copywriting jobs but only get rejections. Does anyone have any advice? Are there other areas I should be looking? I'm getting so discouraged at this point so any feedback would be helpful.

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal