My firm offers a pension plan. When I retire, I have the option to take a lump sum or an annual pension (various options available under the annual pension plan, such as me only, me+spouse after my passing, etc.).
I am considering the lump sum option, to have better control over my money (I’ll park the lump sum in an IRA to manage taxes). I don’t want to leave my future funds in someone else’s hands. Can this group help me with thoughts (pros and cons) on this?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Specifics needed - but here’s what my plan is when I retire - TODAY IS MY LAST DAY !!

my plan in retirement is to have as many unrelated income streams as possible to cushion any challenges to any one single stream

I have a 401/IRA, Roth, brokerage account, CDs, HYSA, social security (plan to take at 62) and my B4 pension

The thought here is that while a lump sum allows me the flexibility to invest, I am already covered with IRA/taxable brokerage accounts for that.

I am planning to use to pension as a guaranteed income stream - while leaving the equivalent funds in my stock market account for me to manage - hopefully at a higher yield than the pension provides

likehelpful

Grace - kinda both really

If the stock market is down - which it will be eventually - the annuity income prevents me having to sell stocks or bonds to that same value and thus avoiding SOR issues

The annuity increase by 3 or 4 % each year - the equivalent invested in an S&P index fund historically averages 10%

You should compare the pension payout rate vs a comparable fixed annuity.
If the pension rate is comparable or worse than an annuity then probably go for the lump sum.

If the pension rate is better than any annuity you could buy then you should consider it

likehelpful

This is a very practical criterion. Besides comparing annuity payment rates, how much weight do you think inflation should carry in pension versus lump sum payment decisions?

I am in a similar boat, except that we have 2 different pensions that allow for a lump sum or a payout over years, with the same kind of 100, 75, 50% survivor benefit. I'm working with an advisor and we jointly determined that the one with the low fixed rate will be taken as a lump sum, while the higher rate one that has a better long-term rate will be kept as an annuity. The rationale for us was simple - my spouse, who is younger and does not have the accounting/business background, wants the guaranteed check for the rest of her life. We will have more money than we realistically need, so the kids will eventually end up with a lot of it. If it makes her more comfortable, I'm fine with keeping a piece of it as an annuity.

The reason I bring this up is that maximizing assets is not always the best answer. If having the guaranteed check is going to make her comfortable, then it is worth doing. It also allows me to be a little more aggressive with my investments, since I have a fixed annuity that covers our family's medical, utilities, and basic expenses. Good luck!

likehelpful

Financial advisors almost always advises retirees and employees to take the lump-sum pension payout over guaranteed monthly lifetime payments. A lump sum gives you 100% control of the money, allows you to build lasting wealth, and leaves an asset that can be passed on to your heirs, whereas a traditional pension stops paying when you die.

You should also consider whether you have other savings or investments outside of this pension and your expected retirement age when weighing this decision.

like

It depends on the health of the beneficiary and the health of the annuitant… women almost always outlive their male spouses… pensions can allow for a delay of social security… if you have other retirement assets, taking the pension can be a part of a broader income planning strategy…

IRA’s when passed down to next of kin (non-spouses) can have huge tax implications… there are other options available for pension (annuity) payments, like joint + period certain… at times even with a spouse inheriting an IRA, there are non favorable tax implications, depending on the spouses age…

There are a lot of considerations… I’d recommend OP speak with a planner to discuss the ins and outs of everything…

likesmarthelpful

On paper the lump sums usually looks best, but from my experience retirees don’t invest like that in reality. A portion of your assets as a monthly income reduces stress. Employee pensions are usually are superior to retail products as they are free of fees. Balance is key.

like

You should also confirm whether the program is actually a pension, which is protected by the US government via the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, or if it is just a retirement plan that is self-funded by the firm. Each comes with different levels of risk.

likesmart

I have this. It’s a lump sum or the firm will put you in an annuity, (your various options look similar too). I went with the lump sum,put it in a rollover IRA and have it invested conservatively so that it yields a little more than it was growing while in the pension. I’ll start pulling out RMDs when required. Until then, I’ll fill in my tax brackets with Roth conversions annually using pieces of my IRA.

like

It’s hard to truly weigh your options with specifics.

like

*without

Begin by doing some financial planning and figuring out whether you want annuities to begin with based on your situation. If not, you may have answered the question in advance.

If you do want annuities, get the lump sum and annuity values and compare them to market annuities (SPIAs and DIAs) to see if the annuity offered by the pension is better.

If you want annuities and this is better than market...then maybe do it. If not...presumably not.

like

Deloitte has pension plan?

KPMG no longer has pension plan. They stopped it a few years ago and moved to an annual contribution to a 401k.

OP - take a look at my reply to Strategy&, and please let me know if you have any questions or wish to talk offline

Thanks SVP. I am processing all the comments here. Very helpful.

If you don't want to entrust your funds to others, then you should manage your assets in a reasonable and diversified manner

I would always rather be in control of my assets then let a company have control. you can guarantee your own income if you want with different investement types and its probably more income then they will guarantee even with the lump some penalty. just don't do something that has a lot of fees like an annuity, covered call etfs or bond ladders are good or high dividend paying stocks and etfs on their own.

Lump sum because you can invest it on your terms. They will usually assure a much lower 4% .. but assured. And god forbid you pass away before you and collect the monthlies in retirement .. it’s money your descendants and dependents never see. I recently made the decision to put into an Ira when I left for the above reasons.

Related Posts

Suggestions on where one may locate reasonably priced board games in Dubai? Somewhat random but I assume consultants play board games too

likefunny

Please can anyone help me in completing independence policy exam

like

Hi Fishes
One of college's son is doing his BE in CSE (computer science) he is looking for internship.
Any body can help.
Please DM to me.

like

Hi Infosys guys, I have cleared one technical interview and got email for further round which is planned for tomorrow. Email mentions that this is a telephonic interview, is this supposed to be an HR round discussing salary or another tech round.

SAP SD - 2 YOE Current CTC is 4.8LPA.

how much should I ask at infy? Position offered is associate consultant. Thanks in advance.

like
like

I have almost 5.5years of experience and working with TCS from almost 4years my current package is less than my experience.
I have interview for HCL for network engineer/administrator role. How much should I ask during salary discussion?

like

Alright everyone — I’ve put out posts about initiating a happy hour for everyone in this bowl. It’s time and I will give it a shot.

Monday 1/14 @ BARO (34W 32nd St.) in Ktown NYC.

like

The unending cycle is for real. Reached my LeanFIRE number 2 months ago, yet I don’t feel satisfied. Still reaching for the stars… when will this human desire end?

like

Anyone have any suggestions how to break into in house counsel from Big Law?

like

What do u prefer

Post Photo
helpfullike

Hello All,

I am currently working as Talend ETL Developer. Company which I am working currently doesn't have projects for this skillset. Need some suggestions. Which technology is good now in current market similar to the skills which I am having. So I will be upskilling me in that technology.

Looking to fill 2 open QA roles in my team.

1-Functional testing (A little knowlegde on automation is a plus)
2-Automation testing - C#/Java, C# is preferred.

If interested kindly DM me.

like

I realized recently how much my distaste for networking and big friend groups has impacted my ability to find new jobs. 10 years in, how can I reverse this bad habit ?

like

Anyone else think that people on LinkedIn need to remove the sticks in their butts? It's like they'll go posting about industry trends and then at night pound 8 beers and puke on the sidewalk

like

Anyone ever hear of agencies hiring a writer team? This is something that interests me, but obviously it’s a pretty unconventional thing. But hey, we live in the digital age right?!

like

Ask media agency for traffic sheets all week. Media agency finally sends @ 4:30pm on Friday. Media agency rep - “If we can get by EOD today, that would be great! Thx!”

3 sheets, 600 rows each

😐

likefunny

How do you make the jump from a tax accountant role (associate 1st yr) at a Big 4 firm to an entry level supply chain job?

like

Partners - do recruiters/headhunters ever reach out to you? What types of roles/levels do they reach out for?

When you independently search for other opportunities (if you do), what types of roles do you look for?

like

She fell in love with a consultant and...

Post Photo
funnylike

Did you ever have any issues with your family questioning what you do and saying it wasn't a "real job" ? They think being a social worker is fluffy and I should have just become an "actual doctor or psychiatrist"

helpful

Additional Posts in FIRE Financial Independence Retire Early

All these weddings are blowing my mind and budget. I've had 5 weddings so far this year with several more to go by EoY. On top of that I've been asked to be in a lot of them which adds additional time commitment and cost. The cost of a bachelor party + shitty men's warehouse suit rental + travel and airbnb for the weekend + couple hundred bucks for wedding gift means I'm blowing tons of money for these weddings but I feel bad to say no.

like

Okay guys give me a list of things to lower my taxable income. Make yearly with wife 200k.

like

Is anyone else worried about an upcoming market crash, similar to the dot com bubble?

like

The unending cycle is for real. Reached my LeanFIRE number 2 months ago, yet I don’t feel satisfied. Still reaching for the stars… when will this human desire end?

like

Has anyone successfully “ported” their mortgage? Just learned about this and doing some research since rates are so high now. Current rate is 3% and new home will be more expensive, for context.

likesmart

Anyone here from NYC? Be cool if there was a meetup.

like

Thoughts on potential business ideas or investment opportunities where I can live the life I deserve now and not in retirement? I’m always trying to think of potential business ideas and come up with nothing. As far as interests, it doesn’t matter what it is. As long as it makes money I’m interested.

like

When do you predict the dip? I've been waiting for so long, but don't want to buy now. VTI seems inflated.

likefunny

I’ve been reading a lot of FIRE books lately and want somewhere to discuss. What are the biggest takeaways from your FIRE journey/ research?

like

TC New grad Software Engineer
Base: $110k
Sign-On: $35k
RSU: $120k/3years
Relocation: $20k

Starting fresh with virtually $0 savings and $0 worth of financial literacy, whats the best course of action? any advice is greatly appreciated!

like

This is gonna sound stupid, but I’m honest - I can’t do math. Calculating a tip is as advanced as I get. Thank god for excel formulas and a math savvy husband. At the end of the day, I pay all the bills (I know- but I’m more organized) and make double his salary, what low stress effort (on my limited math capacity brain) can I do to increase wealth?

I feel like I should be doing more with extra money to help us financially, but I’m scared of having to study stocks and understand the numbers. 😖

like

Are y’all waiting to do a mega backdoor Roth to see what they do about build back better this year or just moving forward with it?

like

Sharks! I’m 33, currently working as a Java Architect (11.6 YOE, 40 LPA INR). I’m planning for retirement at my 40. Currently owning a house worth 1 Crore INR where I’ll be closing my home loan by this August. Please suggest diversified options of Investment for my retirement. I don’t have any investment till now (except the house) as I used my whole income to close off the Loan which I took in 2019.

like

What’s a good, practical tax book to read for someone who knows nothing about taxes? I feel like I should familiarize myself with them but don’t know where to start/find the topic very overwhelming and dense even as a finance attorney. Welcome to other beginning finance book suggestions too! (Already read Kiyosaki and Ramsey)

like

If you were 22 years old with $55k in cash and $14k in student loan debt what would you do?

like

Once you hit your FI number, what are your plans? 1 yr? 3-5yrs? beyond?

like

For the past 2-3 years, I have obsessively tracked my net worth/income trends/investment performance over time. I checked my trends just now, and OMG I hit the 300k net worth mark right around Christmas. I guess I haven’t looked at my dashboard for a month. This feels so cool. I want to shout it from the roof! I can’t really brag about this to my friends, so I’m sharing here! 🎉 🎉

like

I have 10k extra to invest. How should I grow it? Any growth stocks to recommend?

likehelpful

I have mostly passive investments. I was thinking the other day: what if everyone had only passive investments? Wouldn’t this create incredibly high amount of systemic risk? Are we all sheep??

Is there a definitive guide to cost of living? The obvious cost of living centers (SF, NYC, LA etc.) get covered a lot, but I’m wondering where my city falls. It’s a modest Midwest city with ~100k residents but is a relatively touristy spot. It often feels like a MCOL area but I’m not sure how to adequately judge that, and it would be helpful to know when comparing salaries and the like.

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal