Our annual reviews are approaching & one of my direct reports has been with us for almost six years w/ little growth. My reco was to let him go & find a stronger, hungrier & more motivated designer at the same level. However, my boss instead wants us to promote him in hopes that will spark some motivation. I am not behind this decision & have voiced my multitude of concerns in promoting an employee who doesn't deserve it. HR is behind the decision! Thoughts on promoting an undeserving report?

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Do you think your bosses perspective is maybe your direct report has been doing the same thing for 6 years and the change of a new position will boost their morale. Also when did you notice the like of motivation. If it’s been for 6 years. Why are you not questioning your leadership or the growth of this employee.

like

Yikes. Sounds like the decision is already made.

1. Make sure specific metrics and performance goals are outlined and communicated to the underserving report as they step into their new role...so that way if/when they underperform your boss will see that promotion does not equal motivation.

2. Start/continue sourcing for stronger candidates - keep your pipeline active on your own, because you know this direct report may not last in the new role.

like

Yeah… for what you say here maybe his personality is not that ambitious? Why let him go, though? Any possibility to keep things as they are and bring your get talent to challenge instead?

Have you discussed his goals with him at prior reviews? It’s possible he’s not motivated but also possible he feels there is no opportunity for him or he’s received little to no recognition and doesn’t want to put in extra effort if there’s nothing to gain.

Related Posts

Hi Amdocs fishes,

Can someone refer me, i have the job id?Amdocs

Thanks

like
likeuplifting

What is the process to resign from EXL?
There seems to be no option to create a exit request

Has anyone in big 4 asked for a transfer to a different country? (I.e Canada). Currently debating whether I should transfer with the firm or apply for express entry myself.

like

What are some of the best consulting firms for digital strategy roles? Looking for a change and was wondering which of the T1/T2 firms have digital practices in Canada. I have applied to ATK and McK. BCG is working to establish their presence in Canada but their team is focused on establishing top down. Bain doesn’t have digital focus. Can anyone shed some light on other T2 firms?

like

Is April (easter time) a good time to visit Norway? If yes, what are some of the places you would recommend? I’m looking for hikes/ national parks experience and don’t want to spend much time in city.

Ladies, did you change your last name after getting married? I’m worried about the impact it will have on my publications.

like

Does anyone have suggestions for a refresher course/presentation on critical care? I'm an OB/GYN wanting to keep myself educated.

like

Has anyone considered making the move to the corporate world? I work in admin for my nonprofit right now so I make a decent amount (53k) my benefits are unbeatable. PTO & sick time PLUS self care days. Flexibility. Etc. the one thing we’re lacking is structure and honestly im burnt out and overwhelmed with my work load and I know I could be getting paid around 10-15k more for similar work. Anyone gone to corporate and regretted it? Loved it?

like

Have you ever tried to bring about a change/stood up for something at home/office etc. Did it succeed/fail? How was the experience?

like

Selling a Tresanti standing desk (see photo). Listing at $275 but negotiable. Like new condition, owned for less than 2 years. Features: Adjustable height desk (height range 29.4 in - 47 in), complete with 2 USB ports, wireless charging, storage drawer, and other features! DM if interested!

Post Photo
like

New hire commandeered my office chair

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Just looked up a firm a recruiter told me about. I would be the only Latino on the roster and among the few that didn’t go to an Ivy League or top 20 law school. I don’t even know if I should bother applying...

like

When do you update your LinkedIn when lateraling? I have a week off in between firms and am unsure as to when the appropriate time is to update my profile. My first day at the new firm? Or after finishing at the old firm?

like

If an individual resides in CT and works in NY can we serve them in NY?

like

Curious to know what other firm's bonus structures are, particularly those with billable requirements of 1900 and below. Trying to understand what the norm is and figure out if associates at my firm are getting screwed. thanks

like

Do PEs offer singing bonus or relocation fee?

like

Now that Facebook is Meta, I thought I’d just pitch MANGA as the new FAANG…

like

Would you report a neighbor that hit another neighbor's car or mind your business? New to Seattle and not sure what the code of conduct is around here - mind your business or be a good neighbor 😅

like

What are your thoughts on the future of RPA in the next 10 years considering all the tools/vendors in the market today?

Additional Posts in Leadership

Any advice for a first time manager ?
Context: after ~10y in technical then marketing role, taking over a team of analysts, first management position.
Tips, readings, stories, … are welcome 😁

like

So my team currently uses onenote to house all of our SOPs and reference guides, but it’s becoming a monstrosity and it’s really hard to search and navigate. What programs do you use to provide your team with resources? Or is there some trick to onenote organization that we are missing maybe?

like

If you wold like some assistance with classroom management or even managing your owe children, check this out this resource.

likehelpful

My remit quadrupled+ in a recent re-org with no increase in pay/promotion, my new director is new to the company and was zero help, and I was passed over for recent promotion during the comp cycle. The new director essentially began shutting me down any time I ask for clarity in my career progression. Now they have taken credit for the project I’ve been building over the past year+ without giving me props whatsoever to higher ups. What is the best plan of action here?

like

Is an MBA really worth it?

What does an online MBA look like in terms of class time, work load, realistic time to complete etc?

like

My Creative Directors, who are strong copywriters, are really struggling to collaborate with Art Directors. Are there programs or classes that teach creative collaboration and the creative process?

like

Ideas for gifts that can be bought in bulk for a team of 35? Don’t want to get them junk, but also don’t want to break the bank.

like

Have you been invited to join The Human Gathering?
Did you do it? Was it worth it?

I am currently looking for a mentor and not sure the best way to approach finding one. Any advice?

like

Hi everyone!

After years of hard work, I just got my first position in a leadership role! Yay! I’ll be leading a team of 12.
I wanted to know if you had any tips for me, things you wish you knew before, or things previous leaders did for/to you that you found admirable or stayed with you. I want to make sure I’m there for them and want to be a leader they will remember positively.

Thank you so much!!

like

If you wold like some assistance with classroom management or even managing your ow children, check this out.

like

What is your job title? As it right now I’m managing a team of product owners and I’m unofficially being called “Chief Product Owner.” I’m in the process of working with a coach to get my resume updated so I can begin applying for external roles. But I don’t even know what job titles to target.

like

"Everybody can be a leader" some say... "Leaders are nurtured not born" say others... True.

But... this is also true: "not everybody wants to be a leader" (whether they can or can't be). It is a fairly common practice in organizations with traditional career management structures for people to "be promoted" into leadership roles as the "end steps of the corporate ladder" that was climbed doing technical work. And, unfortunately, this doesn't work all the time

Post Photo
like

Is there a corporate way to bring up to senior leaders that an IC is causing issues across multiple teams because they are demanding and also doesn’t collaborate well? The IC gives vague “direction” then says they are too busy to clarify. They also refuse to use our project management/ collaboration tools.

like

I have been in management for the past 8 years and part of large corporations. I just recently joined a small organization that I have wanted to be a part of for the past 2 years, accepted the role of general manager. This organization knew that I don’t have general manager experience, no payroll experience, no experience setting prices, no purchasing experience and today, 6 days after starting, I have been asked to step down due to not being confident that I will be ready in 3 weeks…

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal