Pretty happy but underpaid currently. A decent agency approached me about a senior position that would almost double my salary. Don’t really want to work there, but want to make more $$. Any advice?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Take it lol

like

This question gets asked a lot. At lower salary bands the difference even a $10k difference is enormous to quality of life. The more your salary rises, the less that small jump matters. You should never leave a place for a lateral move financially. In my experience if the raise is almost double. You HAVE to take it. If you are well liked at your current job and haven’t burned any bridges you can boomerang back at the higher salary if it’s not working out at the new place.

People who say ‘don’t chase the money’ are generally already at the level where it doesn’t matter or in the rare case of not needing it. I’ve rarely heard anyone say that doubled their salary ‘Dang I should’ve stayed at the old place’ they usually say ‘Dang this new place sucks I can’t wait for my next opportunity’ but you don’t go back down in salary.

likesmarthelpful

You have to know what you are going into.

I think about agency culture (Is it a place where you genuinely enjoy working) career opportunity (can you do portfolio-building work and is there room for growth) and salary (are you being paid fairly for your skill and experience.)

If you are at a place where you have all 3 then you should never ever leave. Don’t go to a place that only offers one.

I’ve always had 2/3 and mixed it up between which ones depending on what I needed at the time.

likesmarthelpful

Let your correct employer know that you got another offer for double your salary and ask for the same raise. Make them BELIEVE you are considering taking it.

likehelpful

Here’s my advice: Use it for leverage only if you’re seriously considering taking it. It worked for me in the past, but I know some agencies see matching another offer as a way to keep you a little longer until they can find your replacement (because it’s obvious you’re considering making a move).

Just make it clear when you ask for the raise that the agency you’re considering reached out to you, and you would prefer your current agency, but may not be able to afford to turn it down for financial reasons.

All in all, a culture fit shouldn’t be underestimated - it can be the difference between making incredible work in a place you love and waking up every day full of dread. But I’m sure there are places out there that will be both a fit culturally and economically.

Best of luck!

like

Never chase money.

likesmart

You could be playing with 🔥. Make a decision, stay or go but using other offers (is it confirmed?), will open up discussions you might not want to have. Are you ready to walk if they say good luck to you? Perhaps it would be a good time to cut you loose and find someone cheaper Will it put a target on your back if you stay? Perhaps your managers are professional however.

like

If you are happy where you are, you’re not under paid. You are in a sweet spot. This whole “underpaid” thing going around is messing with people’s heads and self confidence. Keep going and making work, getting better. Don’t compare yourself to others or listen to the chatter. You are you and are very much appreciated for your optimism. There is nothing wrong with asking for a raise, but don’t bring up the words “I think I’m underpaid”. Tell your boss how happy you are! Be the bright spot. Believe me.

like

Totally agree Ogilvy. The Venn diagram of "I tell people not to chase the money" and "my parents paid my rent until I was in my thirties" is pretty much a perfect circle.

like

I’d like to find a way to turn this into a raise at my current job ideally

like

I agree with everything here. If you actually like where you are--people, clients, everything--that is worth quite literally more than you know. You could go to this other place for the money and hate it...then youd really be stuck because of the whole golden handcuffs thing.

You do have the option of trying for a raise at your current place. But its a gamble--if you tell them its double the salary they probably cant match that. And if you tell them you really want to stay, well, now they know they dont really have to give you anything.

I dont know what Id do honestly. But if the place is actually cool, maybe you can have an honest talk with your boss and they'll volunteer to bring it up with the powers that be.

like

I would say you’re either way underpaid where you are or the other agency has to throw money at people to get them in the door. Agencies that overpay generally have issues. Either culture or creative quality. You also don’t want to end up in the cliched “golden handcuffs.” I would research salaries for your position in your market and see which agency is paying you closer to the average. It also matters if the new offer is in another market with a higher cost of living.

like

Tell us your salary and the offer and then we might actually be able to help you

smart

Again, I think the ultimate goal would be to leverage this offer to get more money at my current job, even if it isn’t a full match. Does anyone have experience with this approach?

like

I doubt your current agency is going to come anywhere close to matching another offer that's twice your salary. :/

like

If you are truly NOT considering the second offer then to me it is less about leverage. You’re playing a game.

Your current agency may say, go ahead and take it. If the new agency catches wind of what you’re doing, they might be pissed.

If you feel you should be making more at the current job and want to stay, go make your case to your CDs. Based on your merits, contributions and wanting a salary which is competitive. Using another offer to get what you want may backfire.

If you have a bona fide offer from the other agency that means you arranged to be out of work to interview, invested time in them and they invested time in you - why do all of that if you’re not serious and were only doing it for leverage? You will certainly burn a bridge at the new agency.

Someone in my group did this recently and while I thought this person was strong, i wasn’t devastated to see them go. They also did not realize that I had a wish list of recruits, and this allowed me to hire someone I really wanted. This person used the offer/higher salary to try to negotiate more money and I recommended they take the offer.

Depending on your relationships at your current place perhaps you can make his work but I would be very careful.

like

I agree with ECD1. You might end up with a result you don’t want. Are you prepared to actually walk?

like

Never bluff unless you are willing to follow through. Again, you’d be surprised how much getting twice your paycheck can help you enjoy an agency.

like

Take it and start planning the next jump

Never move for money

Related Posts

What’s the market rate for government consultants at 1.5 YOE?

like

What would be an appropriate range of compensation for a 5th year/6th year associate contemplating a move in house?

like

I am looking for a job change, Do let me know if there is any opening for accounts payable. I am holding 6 years of experience..

like

I have an interview for my first Chief of staff position with the Head of People for Disco Technology on Wednesday. Any advice on what types of questions to prep for, skills I should highlight or general insight? Yes I can look up basic questions online but I’m looking for advice from someone who has been in this type of role or hire someone into this type of role. Thanks in advance!

Hello Fishes, Anyone from JPMorgan Chase & Co.

I do need one referance for one of the opening as below:

Opening - Infrastructure Support

If someone can refer me to this position please do refer me it woould be a very kindly help.JPMorgan Chase

like

EOY : 7 ; offered band U3 ; 13 LPA
Tech Mahindra
Is that good offer?

like

I have an upcoming interview scheduled with SambaNova Systems for new grad Software Engineering role. I'd appreciate if anyone can share their experience? Thanks.

like

Hi Fishes,

Wanted to get overview of workday practice in
Deloitte India.
Hope some one can share some insight on culture and hikes.Deloitte

Hello!
Can someone please tell how much is the in-hand salary.
Thank you!

Post Photo
likeuplifting

Sales Engineer in the DC area, with 3 years in tech consulting and 2 years in sales engineering. Starting to think I’m underpaid at 105K total comp. Thoughts? Should I be changing companies or putting together an ask for more?

like

What is the EOY performance bonus % for a KPMG Senior Associate?

like

Does anyone at Atlassian (or who knows someone at Atlassian) have news on the hiring slowdown? Any updates on which business units / orgs / positions the company will continue hiring for? Or if it is actually going to be a hiring *freeze*? I did a final round interview with Atlassian that went well and I'm hoping to hear back soon...

likesmart

Deloitte India vs Deloitte USI.
Please answer if you have worked for both and have significant first hand experience about the difference in WLB, annual hikes, work culture, any other observations.
I see a lot in of this same discussion but very confusing and repetitive answers.
So would like people with personal experience to answer.
Thanks in advance 😃

like

What are the start salaries incl. bonus and retirement packages and other benefits across consulting firms?

I have 6.5 yrs of cybersecurity exp working in Deloitte usi . Can you confirm if there is any role in Bain for cybersecurity practice . As not seeing anything in Bain careers

What's the salary at Bain - consultant year 1 level

like

What the average package for Bain Analytics managee in India? Howz this different from IT consulting firms?

More Posts

How do the economics of this city work?

I make ~150K & get 8K per month net.

Assuming I have 3K rent + 1K for (car + insurance) + 1K for (grocery + utilities + misc expenses), I’m left with 3K/month saving which is 36K/yr.

If I decide to buy a 1M house/townhouse/apartment, I’ll need to put down 200K deposit which will take ~5-6 years - IS THIS NORMAL?

like

Hi can anyone please refer me for data engineer role I have 4 years of experience in DS

like

Hi Fishes,
I am looking for QA Engineer in manual testing. YOE 3 years NP 90 Days. Can someone please refer me?.

Thanks in advance.

like

Does Big 4 hires H1-B transfers for the positions that they originally don’t hire someone for who would go through H1-B lottery?

like

Moved from Canada and I have to say, big pharma in the US might very well be the devil himself. In Canada, medications that cost $30-$40, are hundreds of dollars here. Honestly thinking of leaving the field because I can't stomach the corruption.

like

Do Bank of America or frets work from home policy, if no is there any exceptions considered?? Thanks in advance

like

Hi Everyone,

Trying to take a poll. Please comment Yes if you have completed your MBA, YOE after MBA, CCTC?

I will start with mine -
YES, 2.2, 21LPA

like

Any tips on what to expect for a privacy engineer interview for google ? Interested to even learn about the roles and responsibilities of a privacy engineer. TIA

like

Has anyone gone into 5th month of pregnancy with the baby growing under the belly button? Looks more like a fatty pouch than a baby. Everyone else already has bumps starting from right under the boobs.

like

One more pic cause why not ? Hope he makes you smile after a long day at work

Post Photo
like

First time visiting Dallas and looking for a reasonably priced Airbnb. It looks like Westmoreland Heights is at the right price point, is the area safe enough? Been burned by Airbnb once before unfortunately

like

How have you coped with depression and teaching? Have you talked with supervisors? Kept it to yourself? Has it affected your ability to do your job?

like

I'm in my 2nd week with Deloitte and things just seem a bit off. I've left my resource manager 2 emails , no response from him. Not been assigned a coach or an onboarding advisor yet .Is this normal ? Who helps me get assigned to a project ? When does the process start ? I can't be just sitting and doing nothing. What am I supposed to charge hours to this week ? I've gotten no guidance on that.

like
like

Infosys offered me 33 including 20 percent variable at 11yoe. Current is 26. Suggestions please. Do they pay 100% variable ?

like

Hello, anyone who is holding 16+ years experience in Mainframe technologies and switched recently? what is your cctc range?? Might be average cctc range...

Wishing all a happy holiday and thank you for all you do

like

Hi
Is there anyone here looking to hire a Strategy consultant? I've got previous experience across public and private sector and I'm now looking for a new challenge with one of the top consulting firms in the UK.
Any help would be much appreciated.

like
like

I will be joining DI soon in SBD.

I am holding stocks and MF for couple of Indian based organisation.

Do I need to render this before joining ? Is this applicable for consulting practice as well?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Any advice on how to get laid off instead of getting fired or quitting? I’ve always been motivated but this place officially messed up no matter how hard I’ve presented my best work for few years now.

likehelpful

laid off in Oct but ended Jan with 4 in-persons and good feedback. fast forward a month - ghosted twice, one put on hold, and one no. ~1 month of unemployment left - f@&k i feel worthless.

like

What’s advertising’s version of the EGOT (Emmy, Grammy, Oscar, Tony)?

like

Show of hands. Who is receiving a PIP with an impossible short turn around to mask layoffs during COVID?
Lets discuss.

like

WFH still unclear and layoffs last week, but sure, send an email about executive level promotions. An A/S person who lost every acct they had in the 8y I’ve been there.

likeupliftingsmart

What are some other common tropes of advertising like “experts say” and “sex sells”?

like

Anyone else get screwed on healthcare this year? Went from $50 copays to 20% of visit? Ouch when it's a big bill like PT 3 times a week after a surgery. Definitely POS means something else now.

like

What’s the agency scene like in Salt Lake City? Is it worth relocating there?

like

Bean, get it??

Post Photo
likefunny