{ "media_type": "text", "post_content": "Seeking advice: Once you are in a big 4 for MC consulting, is it hard to move up to MBB? If you went to MBA school and then tried recruiting into MBB with Big 4 experience? Thanks in advance.", "post_id": "578d4f35bb21f30e00afcb05", "reply_count": 15, "vote_count": 5, "bowl_id": "552d1d24dc1c586b09d2d051", "bowl_name": "Consulting", "feed_type": "crowd" }
null

Seeking advice: Once you are in a big 4 for MC consulting, is it hard to move up to MBB? If you went to MBA school and then tried recruiting into MBB with Big 4 experience? Thanks in advance.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

MC = Management Consulting, yeah I get it I said consulting twice in "Management Consulting consulting" but my question is still valid? Still at work here, I don't think fish bowl is a heaven for perfect grammar.

like

Not really. Everyone coming out of MBA is interviewing for Consultant role and has to do well on personal fit and cases. Having done consulting, cases should be easier for you.

like

^ very rare - happens occasionally, but you'd be looking at a pre-MBA role for the hire. I'd estimate that somewhere around 1% of our associates would have that big 4 experience profile

like

I was big 4 tech implementation into a top ~15 MBA and then interned MBB. It was a god awful experience for me, though they would clearly say the same. Ended up Big 4 Management Consulting and am much happier. The work is mostly as interesting, the culture (at least of my PwC group) is infinitely better, but the pay isn't quite the same and not sure the exit ops will be either.

like

@OP. My team was awful. My "boss" didn't sit with me and didn't even tell me if I was to go to the client or our local office each day. When I swallowed my pride to ask for help I got no response, and the local office "mentors" I thought I had identified took my inability to connect with my team as a reason to write me off after less than half the internship. At PwC folks are way more supportive and generally enjoyable to be around as you slog through long consulting days. My days at my internship were much longer, but that was mostly a function of having 0 direction and 0 opportunities to collaborate on problems and roadblocks. Ultimately I still tell folks to go MBB if they can. Odds are you'll leave consulting anyways so might as well build the resume as much as you can. Just don't be thinking the work is guaranteed to be that much sexier. All MBA do PMOs, implementations/transformations, etc. They just package and sell it better.

like

Wtf is MC consulting?

You need to get invited and then pass the interview process. That's as hard as it is.

BCG 1 - I'm assuming the interviewing process gets harder the more experience you have in consulting? As in they expect more from you when applying with 2 yrs experience rather than straight from undergrad?

^thanks BCG 1, have you seen people come from Big 4 into MBB without an MBA after 2-3 years experience? Or not very likely?

^thank you BCG2!

^PwC1, why was your experience so awful if you don't mind sharing? Why are you much happier with big 4 MC, in regards to work life balance or culture in general? Currently interning at KPMG MC and debating recruiting full time MBB when I go back to school (undergrad). Personally not sure if I want that intense of work load at this age at MBB though. Thanks a lot in advance.

@PwC1, damn that's unfortunate you had that experience but great advice on your end, I appreciate it. About the hours part, how many hours do you work now versus when you were at MBB? Or how many hours did the typical associate work at MBB versus what one works at the group your with now? I think that's the one thing holding me back the most from pouring hours of practicing casing to go MBB then just staying within big 4 MC for full time and going MBB when I'm older after an MBA. I feel like at this age 20-23, you are living years of your life you don't get back, and may want to have less work now and more later, but I also do realize I've chosen a career that is a little the opposite. Just not too sure how extreme the differences in hours are between big 4 and MBB (in regards to strategy type consulting full time). I appreciate the help once again! ✌🏼️

I get your concern on hours but it varies too much to say. Some people at Big 4 have it as bad as any MBB and some MBB folks have incredible work life balance because of the way they've managed their project choices and personal/professional goals

You are always living life that you don't get back. Long hours are much easier when you are younger and your body recovers more quickly and if you don't have a spouse/family waiting for you at home. Same as investing - start early and benefit from compounding. Go for MBB now, makes it easier to go for MBA, etc.

Thanks PcW1 and Consultant 1!

Related Posts

Hey all -

Quick question.

Asian male (international) vs. Asian male (US citizen / Greencard holder).

How does this impact the MBA admission?

like

Additional Posts

Can anyone please guide me for React Js interview . What topics should I prepare? I wanna prepare well for the Accenture interview . Yoe- 4
And also in recession times, is joining Accenture is a good idea?

like

Greetings everyone, I'm an on-site
dedicated IT support at a company and I
want to grow. My role isn't a traditional
support role like in my previous positions
and I discovered that I have been involved
in more managerial and administrative
tasks, amongst many other things. I'm
quite anxious because I don't want to
plateau my career in Support roles or only
getting "You seem like a good fit for..
drumroll ... IT Support Analyst" emails.
Any advice?

like

Anyone else get annoyed when an uber driver doesn't help with bags? This time I was clearly struggling and he wouldn't get out.

like

Hello folks,

I am working as a pseudo program manager (hybrid account manager perhaps) , I have an overall work experience of 9+ yrs in the e-commerce domain with a varied expertise in vendor management, operations/people management..am seeking relevant opportunities, please help

Thank you

like

Desi women: do female higher ups in India champion your ideas and propel you forward in the workplace or are many competitive towards you? I wondered if I’d get further around people who can see themselves in me just like white men see themselves in other white guys and launch them upwards. Unfortunately in my only experience with someone from abroad here she was more pandering to the desi guys than anyone else on the project. I don’t think she saw herself in me at all😂

like

please help me with some likes so i can receive dm's <3

like

few things are more frustrating than having a conversation about finance with friends/family who doesn't work in finance

like

Anyone at Dallas love field airport recently and know anything about the shooting???

like

What are some telltale signs that someone is not genuine?

like

Best all-around spa for men in NYC? Looking for one place where I can do facials, manicure, pedicure, and massage all in one sitting

For IRA (leaving company and going to homecountry) how to pick between Charles Schwab, Fidelity and Vanguard? Not expecting to manage actively, I just want to leave the fund growing over time (target date). Thanks!

like

So does anybody have any tips for negotiating salary for an entry level position? I need a job but I don't want to be screwed over.

I would really love for a consulting sit-com. Call it something like “Billable” and make it a combination of Silicon Valley, The Office, and Parks & Rec.

Instead of HOL failed attempt at making it look “cool” just focus on the absurdity

likefunny

About to move to Chicago and looking at neighborhoods. What do you all think of the South Loop?

like

American Airlines flight delayed due to some panel not being secured. Arrived to client site 2 hours late. Can I get points/who do I contact? Newbie flyer sry!

likefunny

Now that bonuses are starting to come through do you still think a lot of people will end up quitting?

like

Does anyone ever spend so much time in excel that they dream spreadsheets? If so how do you stop it; it's really disturbing my sleep...

like

Can I file for worker's comp if my shoulder's injured from being required to carry four laptops when I travel?

Two client laptops, firm laptop, and my laptop because of client restrictions on firm 1

like

How soon after work do you go to the gym? And how often and what’s your goal

like

Any noteworthy differences between folks who reach partner level and those who don’t? (i.e., what sets them apart)

helpful

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal