There are advisors who present themselves as a financial planner first and investment manager second. Which one are you?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I used to focus more on planning and held myself out as such. The last four years I've really just been the investment guy, planning was much more fulfilling in my opinion. I plan to start the CFP next month. I have lost clients over their returns. Conservative clients only being up 7% last year (when they came from cash) apparently wasn't good enough for them. Leading with returns, imo, is too hard because despite what anyone claims you have no control over that aspect. Planning seems to be a better leg to lean on, but at the end of the day is more often than not just a sales tool and much less about planning and more just about gathering aum.

like

I am more of a financial planer. I basically explain there are two ways that value is added in a portfolio:1. Making sure the asset allocation(Financial Planning): tax effect and liquidity is inline with your goals - ONLY a planner can do that. And I cite vanguard that on average that adds 3% of risk free alpha a year. I'm consistent, predictable and you know that the value I bring is appropriate for your plan, and you get that same value in every environment.2. Security/Sub-Class Selection(Investment Management): - The very best in that arena will not talk to you. The very best are highly institutionalized and only talk to guys like me who will put $10 MM+ with that one manager. At most you're a potential $500,000 account (or whatever) ... whoever is talking to you sucks.(whoever is talking to you.. as a security picker.. the financial planners talking to you are fantastic ;) )

like

I believe I have at least not won accounts because I'm not more of a planner. As many of you know, Jones has always had an investment first, planning second mentality. I believe they are trying to switch that. I can say without a doubt that we have a couple of people in our region who have proven to the rest of us that the formalized planning approach wins more clients than just the investments. As one of them likes to say "Investments are a dime a dozen and you can get them anywhere." Both of them have a very strict process they utilize with their referrals and their existing clients. Both of them bring in tons of assets every year. I think our top guy has already brought in something like $13 million YTD. He brought in over $30 mil net new assets last year. I'm attempting to switch my practice to a planning one. It's not an easy switch to make with existing clients.

like

I pitch that I know what I am doing. If someone is meeting with me, there is a reason. I then let them tell me what they are looking for, and then I show them what I do, and let them choose how they want to work with me (wealth, planning, investments). If I had to say one or the other, I'd go the planner route because I charge more for it and it has greater mass appeal. If you want only investment advice, great. I still get paid and don't have to do as much work.

like

I present myself as a life management advisor and tell my clients anytime they have something to do with money they should call me

like

Waddle and Reed! Wow I love that positioning. I’m stealing it! Thank you

Related Posts

I have $100K liquid cash over and above maxing out 401K, HSA, College fund, investments in Index funds and emergency fund. I plan to leave $25K for contingency. Of the $75K is it wise if I purchase I bonds worth $30K (myself, spouse, kid)? Current combined rate is 9.62 Does anyone foresee the interest rate drastically reducing? I don’t intend to cash them out before 5 years.

How much rent amount should I pay to get maximum tax deduction?

Should I sell Tesla while it’s up 6% today?

like

What is the difference in subscription to notified and subscription to approved mutual funds?

like

Hi folks,
What do you show as investment proof if investment is to be done at a future date? I have a life insurance whose premium is due in March. What can I submit now as proof for this declaration?

How likely is this stock market rally to persist? Are any of you buying currently, or just waiting and holding on to cash?

like

Noob question: I exited an ETF position on TDA however the funds aren’t available for me to plough back in. Any suggestions on how long it takes for a trade to settle?

like

Can someone calculate income tax on below, new and old regime with no investment no rent

Post Photo
like

Do Big 4 partners need to maintain any level of independence in retirement?

like

Need some budget help. Just starting out. About 70k gross, 2.1k/ month in fixed expenses ( not counting food etc), 12k of debt. 26 yo w/ no real savings

like
like

People recruiting at FAANG/big tech right now- do you have a sense of how they’re handling equity/stocks in making offers? Stock prices are WAY through the roof and likely poised for correction... are they taking this into account when making offers on number of RSUs? Risk of joining and losing money

like

Any thoughts on the below mix of index funds for a portfolio? Too little? Too much?

VOO
VUG
QQQ
VGT
MGK
VIG

like

I have Moderna calls that expire on October 15 with a strike price of $300. Should I sell before S&P 500 inclusion and buy back in?

like

Is 3.0% for a 30 year fixed loan an 0 points good? I messed up on my initial loan and I really need to refinance and while I think it’s good, I also thought my last loan at 4.5% was good as well. I’m clearly an idiot and need advice. Sorry if this question seems stupid.

like

My dad stole my identity a couple
years back and tanked my credit score
- brought it down to like 400. I've
been working towards fixing it so that
my boyfriend and I can buy a house in
the next year or so. This morning, I
checked my score after not looking at
it for a while and I'm in the mid 600s!
Y'all don't know how happy I am
about this lol

uplifting

Looking to buy Rolex OP. Thoughts on new vs used? Is the additional ~2k worth it for new?

Does your bank use Presbuilder or any other automated PPT add-in?

I just moved to another place that doesn’t use these and I wonder why not.

like

Asked this in another group and realized this group might have more insight. Which one should I get: Chase Sapphire Preferred or Chase Sapphire Reserve?
I have a 1.5% cash back card from CapitalOne

like

More Posts

For you experts... I’m a first-timer (pun!) buying lux watches. I’m looking at an updated model of a JSC (geographic), to be released sometime Q4 this year. MSRP is 12k few questions:
1) what is realistic price ballpark from an AD (I’m not in a hurry)
2) any advice for reaching out to ADs, especially given this isn’t yet released? I.e., any common mistakes to avoid?
3) MSRP includes leather strap, and looking at current model prices, metal strap adds ~2k to price. Sound right?

Thank you all!

like

When an MD asks you for any feedback you may have for them, what would be a good response without ticking them off?

likesmart

I work with someone who always makes subtle digs at my code. Like they’ll say good job… and then they’ll say there’s space to refactor/improve code quality and we can handle that later. I get that you can always improve code but it’s so irritating. Any advice?

like

Started talking to this guy through group a group telegram and one day he offered to pay for my lunch as I had helped him out with something. Since then he has been offering to pay for my dinners, salon visits, shopping etc and I have accepted 3-4 times. I am in a steady relationship and my boyfriend doesn’t know about this. The other guy just says he likes paying for my stuff and there’s no agenda. Is this a little weird?

funny

Hi fishes !

My elder brother whose yoe is 9 years got a new job in Siemens with a fixed CTC of 40 LPA.
His skills are AngularJS, AWS

Do you think this is a good package as per his skills . He has tons of big professional level AWS certifications and his communication/soft skills are as good as his technical/hard skills .

like

Anyone willing to provide a referral to Perkins EC/VC preferably remote but willing to relocate to NYC. Thanks!

likesmart

Did anyone complete NNN?

like

How is Big 4 client experience + actual technical skillsets/ experience viewed when interviewing with ServiceNow?

helpful

Anyone got PCR tested at a Walgreens prior to India travel? How long did the results take to come back?

like

What's the maximum package a devops engineer can get? Plus devops engineer can be consider same as software engineer in terms of package?

like

Are there any other survey companies you’ve gotten quick cash from like NewtonX?

like

Any openings for Data Engineering profile?
Skills - Snowflake, AWS, Matillion, Airflow
YOE - 4.6

like

Why hike letter is not released yet?

like

I am a RN in New York State for 14 + years. I am looking for remote jobs, all the jobs I come across you need a compact nursing license. The problem is NY is not a compact state. Does anyone have any suggestions? Thanks so much!

likehelpful

Need like for completing profile. Thanks.

like

How much should I expect as a L4 CSA at Microsoft, living in Texas? Want to know if I’m being made a fair offer.

like

Please help me with 11 likes

like
like

Anyone recently hired at Big 4 - are there still signing bonuses and referral bonuses? If so, what firm and how much?

like

MM PE vs MF PE - which would you (do you) prefer and why?

like

Additional Posts in Financial Advisors

Class A or B office space? As a relatively new RIA and financial advisor, should I go with class A office space or class B? I know appearances are important, but did office space make a difference?

like

Do you think you will be able to economically achieve more than your parents?

like

I'm looking to improve my communication skills to navigate a very political environment better (i.e. I need to be more diplomatic). Any books recommendarions are appreciated 💁🏼‍♀️

like

If money wasn't an issue, but you had to pick a career or job, what would you be doing right now?

like

Have a client who can be a pain in the butt. Very demanding when he wants something. Only wants something a few times a year, but exhausting when he does. Almost 1m all managed. Keep or let go?

like

If you buy individual stocks at what point do you get out? Both if it’s lost or gained..curious to hear others thoughts. I have a loser I bought at $77 currently at $31. Don’t plan on selling 🤷‍♂️

like

Anyone looking for a succession plan or looking to sell their book? CFP with a decade experience in Wealth Management.

like

Rookies who made it past the first year and are still in business. What firm did you start with? Are you still there (if not new firm). What would you change if you started again today?

like

Want to hear responses from other RIA owner/operators or IARs. Assume basic E/O is $1m limit per event and you have several big accounts ($5m+) would you raise your E/O limit? If so to what?

like

Can some of you experienced folk recommend some good books for rookies? What are your favorites for investment strategies, marketing, selling, etc.?

like

This quarantine period is really messing with my structures for WLB

like

Anyone with US Trust as a PCA? Looking for additional details in terms of the culture, day to day type of things and how you’re doing there vs. what the recruiter stated was the average?

like

Anyone else bring home a lot of stress/anger after a long week? Negative impact on my home life, any advice?

like

In your aggressive portfolios, what % do you put in international? I've never done more than 25%, but i see people at 40 or 50%. If international averaged 8.1% from 93-17, while domestics averaged

like

For those that work from home, do you often find your self playing with your phone while you're in a call and not paying attention to what's going on in the call?

like

Question for my 401k focused advisors out there--what programs are you using that is instrumental to your 401k practice that you simply can't do without? I'm being pitched on Envestnet & im not sold.

like
like

Associate advisors working for a RIA - I’m trying to get an idea of salary ranges. What’s your salary and how many years of experience?

like

What’s the most bizarre way you’ve seen someone try to (or succeed in) landing a client?

Completely psyched myself out in an interview. How do I recover? I just got so nervous

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal