Those who switched from Plaintiffs work to Defense, what was it like? What did you like about it, what didn’t you like? Considering a switch...

Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

A buddy of mine who has done plaintiff's work just jumped ship to my large defense firm. Several months in and he doesn't seem to have any complaints.

At our experience level (6years out) he says that he may make more doing plaintiff's work, but prefers the predictability of our salaries and bonuses. He took a salary and bonus cut during covid and ended up making about $25k less than anticipated.

His biggest "problem" if you'd call it that, is adjusting to the clients' mandatory reporting guidelines. This includes the form and content of the reports, the intervals at which they are due, and the partners' various expectation about the content of those reports. Reporting to a client is a huge part of defense work so get ready to have your legal acumen challenged, tested, and exposed.


Thank you for this. Sounds like exactly the boat I’m in now.

No problem. You sound dissatisfied. If that is true, Don't forget to ask yourself whether it is the firm or the plaintiff's side-- or even the practice area-- that is causing the dissatisfaction.

And don't forget this: you are most likely new enough at this (if less than 5-7 years out and reasonable mind can disagree on whether it's 5, 6, or 7) where you have plenty of time to jump around and try new things without anxiety about what it might look like on your resume.


I switched from P to D after 3 years, and it’s 100% about personality fit with the practice area and the differences in risk tolerance. In plaintiff’s work you have ownership of the case and your fortunes are tied to the outcomes of cases. In defense work, you get paid a steady salary and get arguably more interesting work but your money is capped and there’s less of a rush.

I switched from Plaintiff to in-house for Defense Insurance litigation. The difference is between theory experience and practical experience. In plaintiff’s work my experience was more develop the case and then when it was ready to go hand it off to a trial attorney. On the defense side it’s been more mechanical (appearances, depositions, arbitrations, trials etc).

It goes from dealing with clients (plaintiff work) to dealing with claims (who are like professional clients), and billing (if you get a job with that).

Related Posts

Any reference for QA manual and automation for 8+ for pune location. Please reffer me.
In need of urgent job switch.


Moving here in 2 years. What are some things to prepare for? I know a little Spanish.

Guys after long journey with TCS, I am leaving the Organization.... Wish me luck...


Pareshan kyunki parents kalle India wich
Corona to baad v je parents nu ithe laike awaan tan maximum time ohh 6 months hi reh sakde
Samajh ni aa reha ke ki kita jaawe

Wapis jaun da man karda eh sab soch ke but you know how it is

Ki karan?


Hi Fishes,
I am looking for job reference for Software Engineer role in Singapore.
I am currently have 1.4 year of work experience


How do you get out of a credit card debt trap?


Hey Fishes,
I am looking for a new role / job change into Broker Vote

Having experience in Broker Vote (capturing regional ranks and preparing score cards for analysts), Deep Dive Analysis, Account Review Meetings, Consumption Reporting, Interactions.


Did anyone recently join PwC on H1? How long did it take to transfer the visa (end to end process)?- My start date is 4 weeks from now and status on PwC immigration portal is still showing petition is getting drafted.


How much should I charge a client for web design? I'm kinda new to the field :)


We have huge requirement for Business Analyst with domain knowledge of capital market (preferred) or Finance. Please let me know if anyone is interested


2021 Salary Reflections...

Did you: jump a bracket? get a raise? learn it's time to negotiate?

Drop a reflection below! 👇


How are you feeling about being laid off at Phenomenon after they lost Intuit?


Anyone else sing or talk to their plants? 🎶🎶🎶


This little girl counter surfed and got her entire bag of cookies down. She also opened the new thing of toilet paper and TP’d the house.

Post Photo

Hi all,

I have in total 6+ years of experience in Customer support and operations.
Currently, with Accenture for over 3 years joined as lvl 12.2 and now on 11.2. Working as so called lead but leads are lvl 10. Annual CTC after revision 6.5LPA. Please advise should I wait for lvl 10 or should I make switch. If switch then which company to try for.

Is it possible to wfh after joining ? Can we bunch the 8 days of working together into one single week or so ?


If you were a junior creative with some experiences in big network agencies, what would you choose between these two :

A - Big network agency, working only on one account but doing potentially award winning work. Very ambitious and talented team.

B - New unknown agency with a small network backup but several accounts, competing for new clients and the will to win awards too. Two creative teams for now but lots of ambition and possibly more growth and potential to evolve as a junior creative.


Happy Monday All!

St. louis or Kansas City attorneys looking for help resolving your clients property claim.

Shoot me a message!

Let’s talk!

Mission Consulting & Estimating LLC

Post Photo

Additional Posts in Personal Injury Lawyers

Best resources for a new PI attorney fresh out of law school? Something that can help me understand the process of a claim from inception to settlement or trial?


Anyone have insight regarding pre-suit attorney base salaries at Morgan & Morgan?


Anyone know what the pay is like at Wingate, Russotti, Shapiro?


Does anyone practice first party property defense?


What is the typical pay scale for a personal injury associate in NJ?


I currently work at a small PI firm in Atlanta were EVERYTHING is settled presuit. If we’re unable to settle, then it’s referred to another firm for litigation. This whole process seems very atypical to me and the attorneys rarely touch a file until the first liability offer is received. The paralegals handle everything from intake to drafting the demands. The attorney briefly skims (does NOT read) the demand packages and signs. Is this ethical?? Anyone else work at a firm that is run this way??


How difficult is it to start your own PI firm? I'm sure there are countless lawyers that start their own firm, fail, and go back to working for someone else. But most PI lawyers I know were able to make it on their own.


What is a market level compensation package for a plaintiff's side PI attorney in NYC with 6 years of (defense) experience?


Spent a long time working for a reputable insurance defense firm before switching to plaintiff PI. Recently let go from plaintiff PI firm due to pandemic financial cutbacks. Consider myself to be a good lawyer with a small network of good connections. Not interested in going back to insurance defense. Thoughts on going solo? Live in greater LA area.


How do Plaintiff's PI firms structure bonuses and raises? Should I have known this info before I started here? I am at a mid-sized (4 attys, 4-7mil cases closed annually) firm on Long Island, salaried at 62k, will be admitted 1 year in November and have been carrying my own case load since being admitted. I have also signed up a a couple of smaller MVA cases. How do Plaintiffs firms structure year-end bonuses? Also, at what point would it be appropriate to ask for a raise?


Who has done pip lit for insurance companies.

Have an interview with one in the coming weeks and hopefully making the move from PI assuming the pay and fit is right.

Question from a non-PI lawyer, if there is a car accident that causes a major injury or even death to a passenger at the fault of the driver, how far will the civil liability go for the driver? If the driver is an adult, could the plaintiff/their estate go after future earnings? Could they go after the driver’s family for recovery? Or would it just be limited to the insurance policy? Thanks


What metrics do you think are most important to measure for success of a Plaintiff’s firm? Obviously revenue, but what else is at the top of the list for you?


As a new PI attorney I am having trouble pushing the ball forward on my cases. Not sure what the next step to take would be sometimes. Partners are not much help. Any resources out there that would help?


Starting my own firm and was wondering what bank is the best for iolta? Also any affordable software, resources, etc that you recommend or don’t recommend for the beginning? Thank you!


New to PI. I filed suit and know policy limits ($500k). I want $1M but I have to live in reality. Insurance company wants to know if I have a demand. Is there any reason why I’d demand more than the policy limits?


When y’all have bench trials, what are typical awards?

Here in my jx, in little league/entry level court, it’s pretty typical judges award 2x the medical bills.


NYC area Personal Injury Lawyers:

What are some of the most well respected plaintiff’s personal injury firms in NYC, and why?


I am looking into starting my own firm with one other attorney. I have never been a partner or solo so I am trying to figure out best practices right now. I would appreciate any advice on starting up, things to avoid, preferred software, which gods to pray to, etc. The goal is to be virtual and to primarily do PI with a small amount of business services (my current book is mostly business litigation/contacts/outside counsel work).

Thank you all in advance! This is pretty daunting.


Hi all, sorry to go off topic. Is anyone practicing PI law in New Hampshire? I'm currently practicing in SE PA and also NJ, but thinking about moving up to NH. Wondering how the industry is there.


New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here


Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site


Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone


Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or