Weighing a decision to join either West Monroe Partners (HLS practice) or HealthScape Advisors. Both offers are to come in as a Manager. What would you do assuming total comp is about equal?

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Hey there! I actually work with a lot of HLS projects at WMP. Feel free to DM, happy to share my experience and chat further.

Obviously, I’m partial, but I do really enjoy a lot of things about WMP. :)

likehelpful

HLS is my favorite partner team!

likeuplifting

I'm in HLS at WMP as a manager. What's your background? Health plans, health providers, or life sciences?

like

I really like HS. Great people there. I’m bias though as they’re splinter from my old firm, which I loved too

helpful

Curious are you coming in as consulting manager or marketing manager? Both companies are great choices.

Related Posts

Hi,

I’m approaching YE compensation discussions and was curious to see what folks/the industry are paying for institutional middle-market sales/distribution/business-development roles. I have 3yrs of experience with the same firm and am currently working as a sales analyst for the institutional sales team in NA. I have experience with traditional long only solutions, real estate (primarily value add funds), and a sector specific hedge fund. Any and all feedback is welcome!

like

Hey fishes, how is the project allotment done in coforge..
It's been a month since I have joined still no tasks allocated not even induction is it a common in coforge?

This is provisional offer letter , yet to receive original offer letter. Let me understand the ctc, variable pay, and in hand salary. 12lpa is the ctc right.

Post Photo
like

Hi fishes,
I left Deloitte month but i have not received any full and final settlement and release documents. How much time does it take for Deloitte to process. My concern is with release documents more after resignation I have not received any email from Deloitte on my personal ID in next organisation i need releasing letter. Please provide your valuable insights.

Thanks

like

Anybody have insight into ballpark salary range for Director level pay at Microsoft in a non-engineering role? I understand there’s probably varying degrees based upon org/function, as well as location. Just assuming Remote work, what would salary/bonus/stocks look like? Or just TC in general?

likehelpful

What’s BCG digital ventures comp model like?

likehelpful

Hi friends I have offers from HSBC as well as Visa Inc. what would you recommend to join from better career perspective and brand ?
Software engineer with 3+ YOE

uplifting

I recently moved to US from Georgia, I have team of developers and project manager in Georgia who are able to work remotely. Big advantage of this type of team is salary per hour because its quite low in Georgia rather than US. Because Im new here I dont have connections with businesses in this field, where can I find cofounders like this who will be interested in software development and finding clients for this team?

like

I have to join a company on March 21..can anyone suggest which is good wrt job security
Ericsson/CTS/Global Logic/LTI
CTS,LTI- 28 LPA
Global Logic -26.5 LPA
10 YOE in TCS with 11 LPA(Current)--Scrum Master

Post Photo
like

How much time it takes to complete BGC by TCS for laterals

like

What are the perks and benefits offered at Autodesk India, Bangalore office. Do we get free food, outings, hotel stays, coupons, etc.😃

like

How long is the cooldown period for BCG?

like

Has anyone worked at Remitly? Curious about culture, remote work, future outlook, etc

like

Hi, what's the status of WFH policy in TCS, Bangalore? Joining it soon. Any info will help 🙂

like
like

Have people gotten their bonus’ prorated in a year they were on parental leave? Any hunches to tell if it was more less than a straight prorate?

like

Does IBM have good onsite opportunities?

like

What are some negotiation scripts you people have used to negotiate a higher salary after the initial offer?

like

If I earn 35LPA in india with 7 yrs of experience as a senior react developer, how much would I be earning i n Malaysia keeping Malaysian cost of living in mind?

like

More Posts

Common salary ranges for NYC area managers/senior managers? And please include typical sign on bonus estimates as well

likefunny

Best part about being single: Not having to hold in my gas ! What is the best part of it for you??

likefunny

What's the most natural next step for a marketing coordinator?

like

My observation is that it is hard for consulting partners to land the quality public or private board roles everyone naturally targets. Despite there being a significant amount of exceptional talent that could be deployed, there is a big bias against consultants. Everyone wants “operators,” but I feel every board could also benefit from one current or former consulting partner. But sadly, that’s not the way the external world looks at things...

like

Hey all, 4 YoE strategy consultant looking for some exit options. Looking to jump ship from consulting into something in the life sciences field, but not particularly interested in working for big pharma. Does anyone have any suggestions?

like

Hey
Could some please refer me to below organizations :
Lnt infotech
Wipro
Cognizant
UBS
Tech Mahindra
HCL Technologies
IBM
TIAA

Profile : java backend
Tech stack : java microservices aws
Yoe : 6.8
Location : Mumbai

TIA

likeuplifting

What does a VP1 make all-in in IBD?

like

Dear All Fisbowls,

I have a query. Request all of yours suggestion and if you have done something similar to this please share.

You have resigned and have offer in hand suppose 15 fixed.
Meanwhile you get another offer but they will give around 17 fixed.
I am thinking to quote my in hand offer as 17 fixed with changes in it and share it with them.
So that they can give me around 20 fixed.
Request to share honest detail here.

like

I am creating a personal blockchain network hosted on in house IOT network, anyone interested in building it along with me?

I have 13+ yoe in java, springboot, microservucrs, which cloud I should learn aws, azure or gcp

like

Other data engineers:

I'm in a new role, and working with data on a scale I haven't seen before (petabytes). When you are designing complex logic at this scale, what is your approach for load testing? I've been working with a tiny subset of data, but now I have a couple ideas I want to test and compare on a larger scale, but the scale of this data is honestly overwhelming to me.

like

What's the dress code like in the SF Bay Area consulting offices?

like

Does anyone here work at Ameriprise financial? If so, would you recommend it? What is the work life balance like? I have an interview for a Advisory trading specialist role. Thanks!

likehelpful

What’s the most unprofessional thing you’ve done in your career, publicly? I’ll go first, I openly talked shit about my CD during an edit and it got back to the CD and the CCO.

like

How do you deal with imposter syndrome? I'm a new therapist and I work with a bunch of women who have been doing this for ages. They're all really sweet, but I can't help feeling like I'm way out of my league. I mostly see younger clients which I guess works in my favor, but I just feel like I'm totally incompetent compared to the women I work with.

like

I just moved to the city. Any dating do’s and don’ts? I’m not American and not sure if there are cultural things I should avoid

like

I'm on the verge of a panic attack. help

Should people who do not have children be able take a "paternity" leave? Paternity leaves are generally supportive, but sabaticals or whatever you want to call it are frowned upon, from my experience. Thoughts fellow 🐡?

likesmartfunnyuplifting

Can you advise a young producer on working with exec creatives? How do you assert yourself & hold teams accountable to deadlines without making creatives feel as though you are challenging authority?

like

Additional Posts in Healthcare Consultants

What's the dress code like in the SF Bay Area consulting offices?

like

Anyone have experience with Cain Brothers (IB)? What’s the best way to get a job at the firm?

Planning to leave my current firm soon. Anyone want to provide a referral?

like
like

Anyone in Anthem’s Strategy Consulting (ASC) group that can give insight on the company, role, culture etc.

like

Have a direct report that is talented in data analytics, but lacks fundamental knowledge of the industry which is hindering performances. Any advice on coaching?

likehelpful

Can someone help me understand the structure of health strategy / health consulting at Accenture? Are these two separate teams? I know Federal Health is entirely separate (right?)

likehelpful

Anyone familiar with Deloitte operating model transformation healthcare roles? Any thoughts?

like

Anyone ever go to your kids career day and try to explain what you do to kindergarteners? Thoughts on making it cool/interesting?

Just getting started with Healthcare Consulting projects after working mostly on FS clients. Does anyone have reccomendations to ramp up on Healthcare/payer/provider knowledge quickly?

like

Have an initial phone interview next week with Huron’s Healthcare Strategy group. Anyone have any helpful insight into the practice? Thanks in advance!

like

If you’ve left before your clawback period ended, how much time did your company give you to pay your signing/retention bonus back?

likehelpful

Has anyone pivoted from the provider side to Strategy&? I’m applied to roles there on the payer/provider team. I have an MPH from a top program and 1.5 YoE - any guidance on what level I would come in as? I applied to both the Associate and Senior Associate roles.

like

Does KPMG’s federal healthcare advisory practice get Veterans Day off?

Hello seeking referrals for consultant roles. Have ~1 YOE in healthcare consulting and previous RA experience as well. TIA

like

Looking to get into health policy analysis or healthcare consulting in the UK or EU. I have 3 YOE in clinical practice as a dental surgeon and programme analyst, as well as a master's in healthcare management. I have applied for so many entry-level positions but have gotten so many rejections, I've lost count. Please, does anyone have any helpful leads? It gets really exhausting

like

Can someone tell me how much a senior analyst/consultant - network relations makes at CVS.

like

Looking for some career advice please. Medical Doctor (Bachelor of Medicine) and current MBA student, unsure what to career wise. Consulting is an option. How does healthcare consulting differ from...

like

How enforceable is a non-compete moving from industry health IT company to big 4?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal