Would you take a pay cut and demotion to move from T2 (Kearney, LEK, OW) to MBB?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Do NOT take a level cut coming from a firm like OW, Kearney, S& at the PL/EM level or above. And NEVER take a pay cut.

1. Your risk adjusted chance of making it to equity partner is much much lower than if you stayed at your current firm. Don’t add an additional hurdle (of a re-earning a promotion you already had at your old firm). If they want you as much and see as much of a future for you as they say they’ll find a way to make it work.

2. You are already coming in with the deck stacked against you. You’re an unknown competing against people who already have a good reputation and have been promoted at least once at MBB. It’s harder to staff a good team because you don’t have the relationships and a lot of people will try to avoid working with new laterals. It’s harder to work with the best partners because they already have a strong following and don’t need to staff an unknown. You don’t know what you don’t know so you’ll get dinged or judged for doing things a way that may be objectively fine but isn’t how it’s done at M or B or B.

3. The most likely scenario is either you get out counseled before or at the next promotion point or you see that’s likely and find your own exit. The lower title counteracts some of the brand benefit from MBB. Also you have to explain why you took a step back in title in interviews which may raise questions

4. People who tell you otherwise either haven’t been laterals themselves or are the few laterals who have been successful. So not an accurate or unbiased sample.

likesmarthelpful

Appreciate this perspective. Would like your thoughts on going from Big 4 SA (1 year at level) to Associate at McK.

If I want to stay in consulting forever and I’m confident that I can rebuild my strong network from scratch then maybe I’d do it for the better comp at the highest levels. But otherwise I don’t see what sort of career experiences MBB could offer me that I don’t get at K already.

like

Define homegrown - coming in as BA or equivalent after undergrad? Or Associste level still considered homegrown?

Do NOT come in with tenure credit.
1. It increases the risk of being out counseled by speeding up the “up or out” window for very little gain

2. Unless you’re incredibly lucky it’s going to take your first 2 cases in the new role before you figure out enough of the unwritten expectations and ways of working to start to be successful. Typically you do one case in a lower role just to get to know how the firm works you could easily be 9 months in before you have integrated. Lots of risk going up for a promotion a few months after that competing against folks who have a stronger network and more and better evaluations

like

Very situational and depends on career step etc.

like

always tenure cut, not always demotion. If you are in your current level for more than 1 year, you can perhaps come in at the same level; if you are first year ish in your level, then you will likely get demotion

likesmart

I would never take a title cut, too many things can go wrong … only would take a tenure cut

like

pre MBA, probably. post MBA role, maybe (but no). manager or above, heck no.

likehelpful

I'm doing this but was a hard decision. And in many ways, depending on how you slice it, not a rational decision.

like

One year out is super early, don't sweat it. Congratulations!

like

Made the lateral transition at EM. Working out fine as I was specific in what I wanted to do here (no generalist mindset) and came in with ~1 year at the level. If either of those were untrue I would absolutely take the title cut. Some of my peer lateral hires are not doing well due to learning curve or just because teams will balk at staffing a new hire EM (such a critical role at firm)

like

Considering going from SA at Big 4 to Asc at McKinsey. Thoughts?

No

like

BCG2, Generally agree, but as someone have been doing DD work at Tier 2 and coming to PIPE with tenure credit, i found transition relatively smooth. So if OP is in a similar boat I don’t see why he/she shouldn’t jump (besides demotion)

like

How is BCG PIPE?

Worth joining BCG as SA when I’m ~9 months into my post MBA role at my T2?

Going through this exact thing rn. Semi-recent M promo and they want me to come in at consultant/associate level which is a pay cut for me. Honestly not sure what I will decide.

BCG1 - it works out for some people, especially at the A/C level. But a lot of it is luck in terms of how well you click with the team you land with. For PL and above I recommend against taking tenure credit or demotion because you don’t know it you’ll be lucky or not before you join or even early on after joining.

At a entry/junior level the valid points above are not that material for you.

Related Posts

Hi all,
Please refer me for AI/ML engineer and Data analyst-Engineer post.

I'm looking forward to make a switch towards AI/ML and Data science field. I've an experience of 2.5 years in the field of industrial automation but I really think this field is outdated with no more exciting job opportunities. I really feel that I'm stuck here and I hope you can understand my situation.

I'm willing to work as a fresher if required, but I want to move on.

like

Hi Folks,

What is the minimum hike percentage in yearly appraisal in barclays? And what is the minimum bonus percentage they give yearly?

Will Barclays HR reject yearly hike or bonus by saying below dialogue?
"you are already having good package(CTC) as per your experience or as per market value, so we are not giving you any yearly hike or bonus for this year."

like

Hi fishes,

Suggestions please!!

Today i received an interviewer call from deloitte and he asked my expected ctc, i have no idea what's the average package could be and said 3.5l p.a. for a post in cash applications.

Im having 2years 10 months experience and previous ctc was 2.4l p.a.

Tomorrow im having another round of interview. Can i negotiate again with hr after my selection process completed?

I'm thinking i could've said upto 4l p.a.

I'm confused totally

Any suggestions please!!

like

Anyone willing to share Amazon Canada - L6 PMT TC offers from 2022?

like

If we join as P4, how much experience is required to get to P5 ?
Larsen & Toubro Infotech

like

Starting pay for Randstad for Google sourcing/recruiting?

like

What is the criteria for ITA promotion in TCS. Totally I have 4.1 year of experience (2.7 year in TCS and 1.6 from previous company). Am I eligible? What will be the hike ?

like

How much salary for Consultant at Manchester, UK. What are other benefits. If anyone can help.

1st Post: How do MBB Risk & Regulation Teams compare to Big 4? It’s the only area where I’ve seen a Big4 Manager move to an MBB without a demotion (at least in Europe). Any insights are appreciated!:)

Which Canadian Banks or IT companies pay high(100k plus) for a mid level software developer with 4 years of experience in spring boot and angular?

Promotion to SC with 1. What raise and bonus can I expect ?

like

Hi fishes,
Yoe 10, cctc 9.7lpa in tcs. accepted an offer in a product based, for 19lpa ,, is the ctc ok as per market standards .

like

Duane Morris salary for 3rd year in TX?

like

I'm about to be a 4th year associate and looking to lateral. Would I get a 3rd year salary still or 4th year?

like

Hi Guys,

Which one is better in terms of WLB and exposure 
Cognizant or @Persistent systems ?

YOE :- 3 year

Tech :- Salesforce

Location :- Delhi/NCR

Pay :- 15.5 LPA

like

Hi Everyone,

I just wanted to ask: What's the salary for a systems engineer in
Lockheed Martin? Also if someone who got hired as systems engineer (or any other engineer field) what are the recommendations and how much salary should be asked? Thank youLockheed Martin

like

Tips on how to successfully explain to your bosses that titles are indeed important in your career development?

like

If you could start your career over today, what industry would you explore?

like

Senior FDD at middle market in MCOL BDO RSM what are you making? Asked for at least 90 so far on my offer, wondering if this is reasonable. They’re probably going to offer me 87.5k on offer letter. Tips on negotiating?

like

Any Telus EA’s want to provide salary bands?

like

More Posts

110k base and 74k ote. TC of $184K and got this role after exactly 12mos as an AE at another company.

like

My favorite part of eating broccoli is all of the fiber bloat with none of the satisfaction 🙃

funnylike

As temperatures go below 50, what's a good peacoat / dress coat / outerwear I could use with a suit? Working in NYC so snow is a possibility. Trying to stay under $500.

What’s a good time to tell your firm you’re not interested in ever becoming a partner?

like

Hey everyone. Unfortunately, I was laid off this week. I was in corporate operations for a healthcare company. My job entailed negotiating contracts and other things with stakeholders and lots of data analysis for tracking client ITP. If anyone could help me out that would be really appreciated. Thank you.

like
funnylike

Hi everyone, Is this good time to join TCS for long term with 8YOE and 30LPA CTC . Are they giving wfh for Gurgaon location? Tata Consultancy

What's the difference between changeability and utilisation? How does it impact promotion, performance appraisal if you're on a non chargeable project that gives utilisation to the resource?

What is the typical salary for a Manager and Senior Manager at CBA?

like

Hey Fishes, can anyone refer me for Deal Advisory- FDD Role for Senior Associate level in PWC SDC? Would be even great, if someone from same profile can connect so that we can discuss further for the same.

Edit : I have already checked on PWC career section that openings are there for the same.

Looking to connect soon & thank you all in advance.

like
like

Hello,
Does anyone have leads on any associate brand strategist openings in Los Angeles?

like

For audit - How’s your firm’s data and cognitive technologies? Which tools/capabilities are you actually using in practice? And what capabilities are just hype right now?

like

New joiners Helpful post: 3 months probation

Existing Folks, Pls explain the criteria that a person will not be considered to clear the probation period. Anyone faced this in Jpmc & what they will do usually if your performance not satisfactory.

1. Do they really see performance in first 3 months?
2. Do they confirm if an employee meets basic fundamentals like WFO, ethics and learning

like

How do you avoid burnout?

likehelpful

Likely too small for this group but anyone come across solid channels for micro PE deals? Is this pretty much calling up a mom and pop shop you’re interested in and wining and dining them?

like

Traveling to DFW for a wedding and my friend at Goldman gave me his Corp code for the Ritz. Has anyone done this and do they actually check if you have a Goldman email address etc?

like

I’ve been thinking about starting a blog for community managers. What topics would you like to see covered?

like

Getting a tour of an agency tomorrow.
I've done my due diligence and researched their clients, awards, culture, etc to ask question.

Any other tips or questions to ask?

Additional Posts in All Things MBB

Starting at McKinsey as associate in a couple of months. Currently still working at a T2 firm, was thinking whether to leave current job now and spend a few weeks preparing for the grind at Mck. Goal is to get to EM in 1-2 years, 1 year being the more aspirational target.

Advice on best use of time and tips on how to fast track to EM as exp hire?

like

What are the in-office vs. WFH expectations for Bain & Company for cases where you're not on site (e.g., PEG)? Is there a minimum # of days in the local Bain office?

like
likefunny

I found the EM round cases difficult. Should I expect the final round to be even more difficult? McK

like

If you get denied at the application round for BCG, but have a good resume, whats the cool down period / recommended advice?

like

Thoughts on joining MBB pre vs post MBA? I have the opportunity to lateral to MBB now but will have to reset tenure to fresh hire. Or I can apply and go do MBA after next year to try again at post MBA level at MBB. Is there a difference in exit opps for both paths?

like

Is INSEAD MBA a good program for breaking into MBB specifically in London? Wondering whether I should consider LBS / M7 US schools instead especially if they allow a London application anyway

likehelpful

Would you respond to a rejection mail? Got a rejection from BCG after R1 interviews

like