Ameriprise vs Raymond James. Is the larger upfront from Ameriprise worth it if transitioning from a wirehouse at 500k production all fee based? Or does the culture at RJ be a larger consideration?

likesmarthelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Which one do you believe in as a company? If you are going the employee route, why are you leaving your current firm and which one fills what was lacking at your current firm?

Forget the upfront, if you don’t solve why you are leaving your current firm now, you will be doing it again soon and that upfront money won’t matter.

like

I understand leaving in that situation, but how does changing firms solve that? You have that risk at any firm. If reputation of your firm means enough for you to change, there is tons of options. UBS, RBC, ML, JPM, just to name a few. All have good reputations.

Tech and back office support will be roughly the same anywhere at that level and that channel, so that shouldn’t be that big a factor.

If the check is the big issue, than shop the big check. Those two aren’t close to the best deal. Ask PRU to give you a quote, they have been digging deep to get ex wire house reps in the last few years.

like
Recent IconRecent

Screw the upfront. Go RayJay all day long.
No comparison

like

I understand what you’re saying but this is no ordinary scandal that’s here today gone tomorrow. This is a steady drip of negativity that is withering away at everything in the firm. No financial firm that I can think of has been so savagely beaten up for so long with a scandal that any Tom Dick and Harry can understand. And with no end on sight! So I can’t agree that “the same thing can happen somewhere else”. Is it possible? Yes. Probable? No

likehelpful

So stupid question. Why does everyone love RJ? It seems pretty unanimous everywhere I look.

like

That’s actually a VERY good question

like

RJ must have Supreme confidence in their rep to offer such low up fronts compared to AMP. Perhaps it’s the “Advisors are just as much clients as the clients” mentality

like

AMP office also seems to skew younger with a better grasp of technology but the product mix seemed messy. RJ had more of a family feel. Both seemed to have great people. Just surprised at the big divergence in upfronts

like

I work for AMP and if your looking at the employee channel I would go AMP all the way. Really good technology, product selection and stable company. Stay away from the insurance broker dealers. You will get better marketing support and be able to grow your practice better at AMP then any other broker dealer today. If your thinking of going independent RJ is a better option as far as net payout goes

like

Payout at AMP is not 40%, it completely depends on your GDC, like most firms it’s laddered, the higher you produce the higher the payout rate is. My payout was 50% when I was an employee. There is also no requirement for insurance or financial plans, don’t know where these other advisors get their info. I have been at AMP in all capacities for 20 years

like

Payouts vary depending on production variables. I believe the employee route it's 50 or 55% and a5 your level you would most likely get assistant and other perks. If you put some of that comp in stock options it can become higher. In the independent side it can go to the low 90s. The strengths are brand name, products, compliance. The weakness is what amp takes on the back end. But frankly every one has good and bad. I like that our compliance protects so well. I know if I flow the rules and a regulator walks into my office I don't need to sweat.

like

My dad came down to the same two companies same situation with up front check. He chose RJA. No regrets and feels he absolutely made the right decision. AMP I believe is headquartered in Minneapolis were he is from and they are savagely aggressive with recruiting. Also RJ has no proprietary products. You know AMP does. They have a huge insurance division (riversource). Do you really want to real from that bank feel environment of cross selling? If it were me I would go Indy RJFS.

like

Owner, FA1, I'm paranoid about posting my contact info but would love to chat. Do you know how we can connect outside of this app?

like

What if AMP’s product platform on the advisory side? Is there the same breadth of choices compared to a RJ?

like

Way to many variables. Let’s try and narrow this down before it goes off the rails.

Are you going “indy”, meaning you will have your company name on your cards with “securities offered through...” on the disclosure? Or will you be working in a branch for one of them with a “group” name under their marketing.

I am considering the employee channel for both firms

With a “group” name. That is correct

Very easy to answer the question of why I am leaving current firm. Think stagecoach going off a cliff. Either form would be a massive improvement from a reputation standpoint. Having said that yes the upfront DOES matter. That and technology and back office support. The upfront with AMP is tempting but my gut tells me RJ is the better move. I need help!

What does the check look like nowadays?

Check for RJ about 70%...for amp it’s 125%

Related Posts

Any one works at Luxoft? How is the work life balance? And work culture?

Hi fishes can you help with perks and benefits of joining maersk at Pune office.
Are there any reimbursement or work from home option available.

What are all the rounds of interviews in Deloitte USI? I had going through Technical and HR. Was expecting there would be some salary discussion during HR round, but wasn't any. Although they took my current CTC structure. I was told Talent team deals with salary and not the manager who contacted the HR round. Can someone please let me know what can I expect further? Deloitte Deloitte USI Deloitte India Deloitte Consulting. Deloitte Digital

like

Was scrolling through linkedin posts and saw EYGDS opened one more ofc in Kolkata and the interior and location is too good.
Why Deloitte acquired a 2 decade old Technopolis building in Kolkata!?!? 😐😏

likefunny

Does anyone have any insight on Financial Advisory consulting at Protiviti?

Hello to people who are from the HR domain

Can you comment your YOE,CCTC & the domain/sector you are working in HR?

It will help everyone to know the industry standards & negotiate the job offer.
Thanks!!

like

What salary can I expect for this role in Kyndyl? I just need a base for negotiation. I have three years of experience in IBM/Kyndryl and the role is System administrator.

like

Anyone at GM Financial as a Strategic Account Manager? I’m curious about WLB, relocation, and structure for this role/program.

like

Hi fishes, can you please help me with the years of experience required for a consultant role in KGS?

like

Hi sharks,
I have cleared
HCL Technologies technical interview and currently negotiating ECTC.....how much should I ask that HCL can offer?
I already have an offer of 22 LPA.
YOE - 6.6
CCTC - 13.3 LPA
Tech stack - Java ,spring ,microservices

HCL Technologies #hcl #hcltechnology

like

I have 6.5 yrs of cybersecurity exp working in Deloitte usi . Can you confirm if there is any role in Bain for cybersecurity practice . As not seeing anything in Bain careers

Hi Bainees,
Can someone help me understand the role hierarchy at BAIN. I am currently a consultant at Deloitte so if I join Bain, what would be my equivalent role?

Thanks in advance.

like

Anyone working in Searce Cosourcing. How in the work culture and overall company as whole?
@searce

like

I recently interviewed for L7 EM at Google and had 4 great interviews and one not so great system design. I submitted external referrals all of which gave great feedback. The recruiter said the next step is team match/interviews and then the HC. Anyone in a similar situation? What was the result? Google

Hey,

Is it a good idea to join 
Paypal for Software Engineer III from Walmart Software Engineer III, for the base salary of 35LPA and 9L RSUs per year for Chennai location ? I am currently withdrawing 24LPA as base and 4.2 as Variable and 3.5L RSUs vested for 4 years.
I have been told that I'll be part of Risk team under Paypal Transactions domain. Any Idea how is the work culture and tech stack here in this team?

like

Facebook (Meta) business product strategy interview coming up next week. Really want the job. Any tips or suggestions? Facebook (Meta)

like

Can I negotiate with infosys if I receive higher compensation package from another organization after infosys
Also I m getting lead consultant- infrastructure management role.

What is infrastructure management here.

like

Hi fishes,

TCS Hr said to expect offer letter by Feb 7 if business approval goes through.
Or she would have to come back and negotiate.
I didn't get offer till now.
How can I check my status?
It shows evaluation in progress in ibegin portal.

like

More Posts

Oh boy, they just paged “Mary and Joseph” in LGA C....

likefunny

Hi all,

I recently heard about Stoa School for the working people, who wants to do MBA. Would anyone provide any insight if stoa school is worth to consider for MBA for working professional?

like

Infosys offer 40lpa incl VP. Current company is retaining with 36lpa fixed. Will Infosys revise offer if I show revised compensation from current company. 12yoe/AEM Infosys Tata Consultancy Capgemini Wipro Cognizant IBM Accenture

like

Can someone recommend a bar with a dj in queens? Somewhere with a frat boy crowd lol

funnylike

Average London Producer Salary?

like

Hi All, Anyone moved from GBS to CIO BU ?
If yes, what is the advantages and disadvantages for this.

like

Hi folks,
Can anyone help me with the average pay scale of a business consultant (non IT ) 8 yeo in Societe Generale.

like

What it is incredible, is how we are still seeing new types of presentation of persons infected with Coronavirus

like

Heading to Vegas this weekend...winning strategies or things to do?

like

What can be the expected salary range in general for 10YOE with frontend tech stack React JS in product based companies? CCTC 52LPA, (including 10% variable+stocks)

like

Trying to help my retired dad - When I google for what to do after retirement, only retirement planning related things shows up. My dad has been a workaholic and hasn’t developed many hobbies he could pursue. I was wondering how I could help him stay slightly occupied if not busy. Anyone here experienced this with your parents or yourself? How did you navigate this?

like

S&P Global Is it wise to join S&P Global during recession time? Can we consider this company as recession proof. Any history on layoffs in the past ..

S&P Global

Is there a bowl that would be for best exit opportunities for those who are in consulting? My experience is in tech risk. Kind of feel like I’m stuck leaving the big 4 to only go into a compliance role in industry

like

Is Woodford reserve double oaked worth the hype?

like

Hello everyone! This is my first time posting since joining this platform. I’m interested in connecting with someone who is open to HR mentoring. I’ve been in HR now for about six years and have never had a mentor. I’ve been relying mostly on SHRM and other people in the company for feedback. Even if it’s for feedback, I would really appreciate it. Thank you!

like

Moving back to ATX from NYC early February of next year to be closer to family, and looking for a new job. Have 2.5 YOE in consulting (primarily financial services) and also did a data science boot camp this past summer. Does anybody know of any roles at the intersection of strategy and analytics? Alternatively, has anybody had a positive experience with an external recruiting agency?

like

Hi Fishes,

Is S&P planning to open offices?

like

S&P Global Dear Fishes,
Can someone please help me out by referring my profile for the below mentioned job ID?
I would highly appreciate your support.
Job ID: R21515
Role: Operations Analyst

Thanks in advance!
S&P Global

I have got an offer from S&P Global I want to know about following things

How much of Variable Pay is Paid ?? I got 15% of Base salary but how much will be paid like the usual norm i want to know

And what are the deductions from Base salary apart from PF ?
There are lot of allowances like internet reimbursement etc etc
Are they mandatorily credited or you need to claim ?

can anyone tell me what is the work policy in S & P Gurgaon ? is it hybrid model or wfh?

Additional Posts in Financial Advisors

Anyone know a good resource or lawyer for legal advice regarding securities license issues?

like

What's driving you to work so hard?

like

Anyone finding it harder getting managed money biz? If so, what changes or adjustments have you made in prospecting or sales approach? Thanks.

like

Heading to Vegas this weekend...winning strategies or things to do?

like

Question for my 401k focused advisors out there--what programs are you using that is instrumental to your 401k practice that you simply can't do without? I'm being pitched on Envestnet & im not sold.

like

Real tips for overcoming shyness? I hear improv classes help.

like

Anyone in the Houston area?

like

Do you dress up to go into the office?

like

I've already had three work-related heart attacks today

like

How many hours in one day puts you over the edge of not being able to be productive anymore?

like

What’s a topic you know a surprising amount about?

like

Has anyone partnered with SOFA, society of financial awareness a non profit. Gets advisors in the door at companies for purely education.?

like

Colleagues, I'm an experienced Relationship Banker looking to start a career as a FA. PLEASE, reply if you are part or you know any local RIAs hiring entry-level individuals in NY. Thanks!!!

like
like

Best music/audio to listen to while working?

like

How do you feel right now 1-10? Why?

I'm looking into the option of putting together a seminar. Does anyone know if wholesalers help cover mailings? Wheres the best place to get a mailing list for target audience?

like

Everyone has a different perspective on this but would love to hear yours. Someone has debt ranging say 4-5% interest rates. Do you attack debt more then investing to move towards a debt free life or do you go after investments since they return historically above that then paying down closer towards retirement. I know the latter looks better on paper but what about the psychological factors of being debt free and the guaranteed return on interest savings.

like

Book characters with whom you’d like to have a drink

like

CFP & ChFC looking to change firms. Currently in a bank program, but not a large portable book to bring over to the next firm. Over a decade experience and about to finish up my MBA. Currently nowhere near the income level I want to be. Any suggestions for a good program to go to for my next move?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal