As an interviewer, if someone writes a thank you email, but you know they didnt get the position, do you still respond? I am sure its a nice thing to do, but not sure how to even respond.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I pretend I don't know and wish them the best with the process... As generic and kind as possible

likehelpful

Thank them for their thank you email. Then be sure to downgrade them if they don’t thank you for your thank you to their thank you.

likefunny

I’d never respond to a thank you email.

like

“You’re welcome. Pleasure meeting you as well."

like

‘The pleasure was all mine! The very best of luck with your exams/process.’ And respond to any questions they might be asking about timeline, feedback, company or refer them to the right person e.g., recruiter to answer the question.

like

Never respond to the thank you email. Interviewer 101.

likeuplifting

I have never expected one in the past but now am the person doing the interviewing and will send a brief note back wishing them luck in the process. I don’t think it matters much either way but I know the dreaded feeling when interviewing...so I do try and give back what I wish I had during my own process years ago.

like

I always reply to thank you emails. I consider it discourteous not to do so. You need not lead the person along in order to be professional.

like

Typically, in consulting, the custom is that as an interviewer you will offer the candidate direct feedback.

If you haven't already provided that, use the thank you to wish them the best through their recruitment process, reiterating that they are interviewing you as much as you are interviewing them.

like

To those that said it, why wouldn't you respond to a thank you note?

like

Ive never gotten a reply back- ever - for my thank you emails.

like

KPMG2 Wrong

like

Director 1 it’s common business etiquette

like

I don’t reply

like

So if they did do well, then you would respond? If the recruiter hasnt said anything, I wouldnt want to disclose anything.

@k1 But what happens if you know they didnt make it? I wouldnt want to lie and say good luck with the interview process, if they arent moving on.

BCG1 nailed it

Once had someone write a really good thank you email and almost second guessed myself about dinging them but ultimately didn’t change my mind.

Lesson: Thank you emails are a waste of time and rarely help but could always hurt.

I never respond. That’s the job of recruiting

I only reply when we’ve passed them on and I anticipate they’ll have multiple offers. Never too early to start getting their yes.

Related Posts

like

Hello, I am a recent college graduate with a Bachelor’s in Business. I am currently looking for an entry-level analyst position, but haven’t been able to land anything in the past few months. I have a Professional Scrum Master I certification, SQL, Tableau, and excel knowledge. Would anyone be able to help me with a referral? I am open to remote, I am based in Miami, FL. Thank you

like

Hi all,
We have opening in
PwC India Government advisory in Pune.
Anyone having govt advisory experience from 2-8 years can please reach me out to discuss further.
PwC

like

Hi Fishes,

I recently got an offer from PWC for Associate Director position.

I understand PWC shows the fixed component only as part of compensation benefit.

Can you please let me know how much bonus I can expect?

Can you please also let me know what is the annual hike provided by PWC?

Anyone open to a referral for a boomerang

Hey guys
Can anyone help in letting know what is written in Experience certificate in TCS
Will my current role details (not designation)be written???

like

Is scrum master experience a common role for transition into product management?

like

Hi guys, I am working as an Investment Analyst for a boutique asset management firm in Toronto, Canada (4bn AUM) making 70k annually. I am 5 months into this role. Credentials: 6 months of prior experience in this industry at a small startup + 2 years of work exp in retail banking, CFA L2 candidate, part time masters of finance student, bachelors from outside of Canada. I want to find out if I’m being paid fairly or I should aim higher. I don’t know my bonus yet (discussion in Dec)

like

Hi everyone Today is my tcs doj and I got a mail from my onboarding manager that your doj is postponed please connect with your recruiter.
What might be the reasons.

Hey Sharks
Anyone from the
Amazon Data Science Team/ Current Data Scientist (domain - Predictive Maintenance,Retail,TMT) that can help me prepare for the Amazon Data Scientist interview. A high level road map may help!!
TIA

like
like

A Facebook recruiter reached out for Strategist position. Any thoughts on company life and benefits from existing/previous employees.

like

Would it be out of line during interviews to ask about agency revenue/growth or account health/trends?

like

Good morning. I am currently a senior associate in BugLaw, and I have applied to several trial attorney jobs in Chicago offices of federal agencies since the start of the pandemic. According to usajobs.gov, my applications to the DOJ and CFTC were “referred,” and my application to the SEC was received and my GS scale verified. But I haven’t received any updates on these applications in over a month. Does anyone here have any insights on these or on federal hiring generally? Thanks!

Hi, I'm working at a product based company, I joined as a fresher and it has been 3 years, I have not been able to get an Offer in last 6 months of Interviewing with companies like Amazon, Cisco, Akamai, Paypal and ServiceNow, but I have got an Offer from startup for almost an 80% hike. I have put down my papers, but suddenly I'm feeling I'm making a mistake by moving into a startup, because I see people with the same experience are joining MAANG, I should've waited and tried hard?

like

After 2 rounds of interview (1 hour each) , Deloitte usi hr is telling me that due to organisational restructuring the offers are on hold. Got a salary discussion call last Thrusday (no pre hire survey) . Last working day in a week. Any suggestions? Cloud Data engineer CBO unit Deloitte Deloitte USI

like

What’s the best way to turn down a 2nd interview? During the 1st interview, I learned that the compensation for the role is not within the range that I am looking for and requires 400 more billable hours a year than what I bill now. I’d basically be laterally for my current salary just to bill 400 more hours. I also wasn’t aware that the local office was strictly ID. Firm website advertises lots of practice areas. Any advice? TIA!

like

Any edutech test for the folks on bench in LTI? Any idea on what is that all about?
#new joiner#experienced#bench#ltimindree

like

Feel like everytime I have a potential job the moment I interview face to face it all falls apart. Are there certain key mistakes you guys notice that detract from someone even if they have good work?

like

More Posts

Looking to book two Iberia tickets using avios NYC to MAD business class in March but can't seem to find availability - can anyone help?

like

After 3.6 years is 16lpa a good salary?

like

Why recently thoughtsworks are hiring women mostly for graduate developer role ??

like

Any thoughts on plaintiff side bankruptcy law practice? Growth potential, pros/cons? Interviewing with a firm doing ch. 7,11,12,13.

like

I’m so glad this bowl finally exists.

like

Partners, is it okay to send a deliverable without your review?

funnylike

See the George Floyd trial verdict will be announced in the next hour.

How are you counseling clients around this? Or, are you not counseling clients on this?

Curious to hear from the bowl.

likesmart

I heard a lot of people are in bench or logging time sheet in unbilled codes in nagarro. Is it true? What is the bench policy there and do they fire us if we are on bench for some “x” months

like

Life insurance agents!! I’m in the process of getting licensed now, what are some tips you have for me just starting out ? How long did it take for you to start selling? I’ll be doing telesales only , let me know your way of selling and why it works best for you. Thank you !

like

Tax: how hard is for a big4 guy to get another big4 job in Europe? Which countries are the easiest?

like

Best credit cards for points redemption? Currently have delta platinum Amex and flying delta weekly.

like

Recruiters, is it frowned upon for candidates to reach out to you on DM on Linkedin? Or does it show that they’re more interested than just submitting an application?

likehelpfulfunny

PC gamer protip for notifications about giveaways on your phone. With IFTTT (free app that links APIs), use Reddit's applet for getting alerts for company name mentions configured to "subreddit:gamedeals free". Bunch of people post links to sales on that sub, including free stuff, and this way I don't have to proactively visit it. Picked up a few titles this way so far thanks to the "free" company getting mentioned 😉

like

I was able to squat 140lbs last month but now I can only do 100 😭 anyone experience something like this? I don’t know what’s specifically wrong other than I feel weak.

like

Public finance exit opps?

like

is there any similar company with Permanent Work from Anywhere and Good job security like EPAM Anywhere?? what are those companies?

like

Hi all,
I have an offer from a great company and i want to leave my current compan Capgemini as soon as possible.
How do I get an early release from Capgemini without serving the full 90 days notice period?
What is the notice period buyout policy in capgemini.
If we’re willing to pay the money for the shortfall days, can we get early release for sure?

like

I cannot stand sitting in a closet of an audit room with my mostly heads-down, anti-social team. Help... Advice on survival? Also feel less productive than being in office.

like
like

Additional Posts in Consulting

I'm interested in writing a book on excellence, and the cultures and relationships that drive organizations to achieve sustained excellence over long periods of time. Examples don’t necessarily have to be from the business world. Who would you study?

likesmart

Monday Morning Motivation:

Post Photo
like

Is there any advice for networking into projects when you don’t know many people at the firm yet? I always to help on BD work when I’m on the bench, but it never turns into any billable work. Every time I have talked to a partner/senior manager I was told I don’t have the skill set they’re looking for, but I don’t know how to build up from there. Feeing very lost but I want to improve my approach.

likehelpful

The North Remembers

like

So i have been fortunate that i have managed to go through my career without the need for a degree. I was lucky enough to have been hired by one of the worlds top consulting firms, worked with a whole lot of big clients and travelled a lot. It's gotten to the point where I am not even asked about the lack of a degree on my resume. Personally though, it bothers me. I have a whole bunch of certifications in my industry…but just no formal degree. (cont'd)

like

A friend of mine from a top tier consulting firm was counseled out. Do you consider it ethical that his career counselor is intentially spreading the information to his colleagues and to other consultants from other companies in the project? What can he do about it? Specially that he considers the potential layoff is purely based on the current situation (chargeability was low) and not on his performance (they said that his contribution to BD during his bench time was low)?

like

Newly promoted manager - new base $150k with 6 years of experience. Am I doing okay FB fam?

like

Bain & Company Anyone at Bain & Company Middle East kindly willing to consider referring me? I’ll provide docs for initial review ofc. Thank you in advance!

like
likehelpful

Has anyone bought an X-Chair office chair?

like

Those who have jumped from big4 to MBB, is it true that MBB is harder/works longer than big 4??

likefunny

M7 mba candidate, and looking at post mba options. Main plan is finance, but open to staying in consulting if the money is right. What is the post mba salary like in consulting at any of the shops?

like

Those who elected to take the GRE instead of the GMAT, would you mind posting your score and where you went to BSchool?

like

Seattle 🐟 I'm moving out of my current apartment in December and looking for someone to rent the place. Rent is 2300$. If I don't find anyone to rent the place before Dec then I'll have to pay 2(ctd)

like

Insights into the best consulting firms for public service/ nonprofit work?

like

Hey all, can you pls recommend resources to get up to speed on Fraud and Risk management for Payments in fintech? Books /sites? I’m not in consulting anymore so no access to internal decks. Thanks!

like

A reminder to all: we are going through very difficult times. Please help someone who has gotten laid off if you can!

like

Anyone else who was just hired at Deloitte waiting FOREVER for their approvals? I received a verbal offer two weeks ago and still stuck in approvals for their offer Deloitte (operations transformation)

like

The awkward moment when your driver introduces himself and you go to shake his hand and he wants to pound it... 🤔

Selling pressure still quite high on BTC, I suggest placing a limit order against ETH or LTC. If it drops below 13.5k, the next support is at 10k

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal