BCG Boston or Morgan Stanley investment banking NYC. Lost and confused fishy here and am trying to weigh compensation against quality of life. Not to concerned with exit opps and really coming down to location (Boston preferred), compensation, and quality of life. The finance offer is temping and tough to walk away from despite base salary being the same. Différence really lies in bonus potential. Banking 80-100 percent of base. What are bonuses at BCG like?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Anyone saying that wlb is the same is out of their minds - unless you’re traveling every week to a mine in the middle of nowhere. IB is consistently 1-3am finishes, weekend work, and vacation is a luxury. Out of my entire network, I have never had a friend say their wlb in IB (BB amd EB) is close…70 hours would be a dream for them and it’s terrible for consulting.

like

S& completely wrong. Not sure how it is there, but from working at bcg can tell you it is far far better WLB on average than banking

like

I’ve been at both BCG and MS. Our WLB is significantly better. Anyone who says otherwise is incorrect. BCG is not easy but it’s no where near regular 90+ hour work weeks.

Comp is lower - but probably by less than you imagine since 175k base + 20-30% bonus + 5% PSRF and a much more generous expense policy gets you pretty far and promotions are faster on balance in consulting.

Finally and importantly I’ve found the culture here much better.

like

Both. People are way nicer, your exit opportunities are more diverse, and I think the work is a lot more interesting personally

Recent IconRecent

I will say the banking hours are terrifying a bit. Not so much that you have to work late but that it’s consistently one all nighter after another…

like

Sorry if I missed this but are you pre or post-MBA? I’d advise someone to go BCG regardless because I don’t believe IB hours are in any way worth it, but I think BCG is even more of a slam dunk choice if you’re post-MBA. Reason being is the exits that some people prefer IB for (PE, VC, HF) are going to be far less if not shut off for a post-MBA Associate in IB.

like

To me if there’s any doubt in your mind that finance is what you want to do for your career, then take BCG 100%.

I am an ex-banker.

If you are in your early 20s and can sacrifice 2-3 years, the financial return is far far greater in the IB route. Don’t think about your next 3 year’s income. The real difference will be over 5+ years. You will make what a BCG junior partner makes after one promotion at a PE or HF.

like

This is assuming you want to do PE or HF. Which if that’s the case then MS is definitely the better choice. Disagree on the financial return for anything other than that though.

Do you want to do finance? Then do MS.

I agree with the others that WLB isn’t much different - but I do think the cultures are very different, especially for women.

Post MBA, here. I agree that some if the exits to MFs will be shut off but I think middle market is viable.

Yep!

If I were to go banking, could I lateral to consulting at project leader level, or would they make me redo some time

I don’t believe it would be possible. MBB usually even down titles managers that come in from T2 and other firms because it’s very hard to start right as a PL with no C experience.

Related Posts

I’ve never considered freelancing before, but this year I got hit with a series of unfortunate events… including leaving my role for an amazing offer that later got retracted. Any tips on where to start?

like

I’ve worked at the same well known tech company since I graduated school 8 years ago. I’ve been promoted 3 times so I’ve held a few different jobs within my org.

BUT .. I’ve applied to a few companies and getting no responses. Is it a deterrent for hiring managers/recruiters that my experience is based primarily at one company?

like

Hi Fishes,

How much should be the salary of BI/DW senior manager havin 12+ yoe as per market. Please let me know.

like

Best programs to specialize in?
Blue prism, UI path, or AA

like

How high can google go on signing bonus ( currently $25k) and equity (currently $65k) for L4 position.. total exp 4 years .. should I negotiate?

like

Janhit mein jaari. Folks, while retaining, don't fall for onsite trap which they'll try to lure you with. One of our mates has learnt this the hard way. Go ahead with with your job switch, don't fall for this.

Post Photo
likehelpful

I’ve worked 2 years at a non profit 501c 3 tech startup. When I started there were 6 employees we now have 22. I am considered a part of leadership and am a people manager in addition to my sales role. I am a high performer and last year got a 10% raise (which I asked for). This year I was offered 5%. I am going to counter but curious what anyone thinks I should ask for. I was thinking 8%.

like

Deloitte 🐟: what’s the expected compensation for a SM in Seattle area? 10 YOE, Tech Consulting. Currently making $190K+ bonus.

like

Anyone know the salary bands for a Deloitte Consulting FS senior Manager in Phoenix?

like

Thoughts on pros/cons of moving from a large national firm to a smaller regional one? I’m considering it, but wondering if there’s anything I should be concerned about in making the jump.

like

I have got an offer for Manager level at a Big 4 in Consulting. People who are 3-4 years juniors at my MBA college are at Manager level and might get promoted sooner than me. Also, a couple of immediate juniors are at Senior Manager level.

Have you been in a similar situation? Is it awkard? How to handle it after joining?

PS: If you are wondering, I do not have a Big 4 or consulting experience while they have it.

like

What does it mean when a company is hiring lots of marketers?

like

Hello! I am a recent graduate of a medical billing and coding program and I’ m finding it really difficult to get a job because most employers are looking for someone with at least 3 years experience. How do I get my foot in the door with no real time experience?

like

Anyone hiring for a Marketing Analyst position?

like

I currently work as a senior accountant in Nashville. Is it possible to go to public accounting?

likefunny

Cts vs LTI vs Tech Mahindra, which one to choose interms of job security for 8 yrs exp

like

Anyone familiar with what comp is like for Supply Chain Consultant at Slalom?

like

Is it mandatory to pass Barclays GSC test after completing people screening and joining after 2 weeks? I got the email now.

like

Does wells fargo has analytics centre in Gurugram or any future plans to open it there ?

like

Notice period in jpmc is 1 month or 2 months?

like

More Posts

Anyone willing to refer for the LEK Associate position?

UG Degree in Business from a T25 school (Summa Cum Laude)
1 YOE at Deloitte Consulting
Previous internship at large Life Science company

likefunny

Intel Corporation Samsung how to compare Senior staff engineer position in Samsung with Grade7 in Intel? is both are same or senior staff engineer is higher? Any comments?

likesmart

Your favorite resources for learning just enough UX?

My baseline is a data scientist background: stats, data visualization, storytelling with decks

like
like

Larsen & Toubro How much is the maximum package for SAP Basis consultants ? I don't see people who are more than 25 lpa . If anyone has more salary package please share your experience and salary and extra specialization ? Accenture Tata Consultancy Tech Mahindra Wipro Larsen & Toubro Deloitte Cognizant Capgemini SAP

like

Anyone have TAS comp info for Senior 1 top 40 PA firms (Eide Bailly , Sikich , Weaver , etc). I have interviews but don’t want to scare them away with high salary expectations. MCOL. Having trouble finding info online. TIA

like

What is BDO transaction advisory like? Hours, people, and learning at the senior associate level?

like

How are appraisals at Wissen Technology ? Wissen Technology Wissen InfoBeans

Hi Guys,
I've provided all the details related to my employment, Qualifications and CCTC to HR very correct but I've miscalculated fixed and variable pay, will there be any issues on BGC?

Please help!

like

Does Bank of America provide cab facility to NOIDA?

like

Joining D soon in S&O. Apparently my group has exposure to Monitor projects on occasion. Anyone in Monitor free to connect so I can confirm a couple of things?
Thanks

like

I’m concerned about the surge in omicron. I packed everything, just in case. Q2 is ending, a new quarter is starting. We get new kids each quarter as a Specials teacher.
It’s stressful at quarter changeovers.
In going back after break, it’s too much of a contrast. I cannot sleep, I wake up in the middle of the night, “for the day”, about 6 nights a week. To stay structured, I go to “Surrender yoga” daily. I’m good to go do 1 more thing after yoga. I feel accomplished. Couching causes anxiety.

like

Hello fishes,

Urgent ask!
How is the "COGOPORT" company?
Work culture and Learning in general?

like

Hi all,
How much time will they take for background verification in Barclays.
Can anyone tell.

like

The world is your oyster 🦪

like

RESUME HELP! I’ve been out of a job for 7 months now. Can anyone provide me feedback regarding my background and experience on my resume? Also suggest any roles? It’s really tough finding a job. 🙁

like

Any guidance on PwC DVV entering MBA level senior associate? Looking at Greater Texas region

like

Any consultants out there in the Digital Strategy realm?

like

OK, so, right now I make a helluva lot, but I think I wanna make a bloody helluva lot because that seems to be what I should do - and what many of you do, as well. So, I wanna know from you super lotters what threshold I need to reach to fill the dark and empty void and be consumed and enveloped in the warm embrace of self-satisfaction and peace of mind. Please depict this value in terms of a recognizable sum, like avg yrly Swiss household expenditure per capita or Lambos.

like

Does anyone know if the salary for a Managing Director at Slalom is comparable to MD salary at Accenture/Deloitte?

like

Additional Posts in Consulting Exit Opportunities

Appian is looking for experienced hires to join our Professional Services team! Openings in DC, Denver, Boston, Raleigh, Toronto and Ottawa. Great product & lots of work with clients. DM for details!

like

Anyone who got an offer from Accenture consulting able to have them change the home office. Interviewed for DC but now want to stay in NY.

Anyone here who made the exit from Big 4/MBB consulting to a VC? If so, I’d love to hear about how the experience is so far. (Not to mention the WLB and comp!) I’m considering a career change but have no one in my network I can go to for insights. Thx! 🙏🏾

like

Thoughts on IBM Software? Is it going to make a comeback or just a dead cat bounce?

like

Anyone willing to refer for the LEK Associate position?

UG Degree in Business from a T25 school (Summa Cum Laude)
1 YOE at Deloitte Consulting
Previous internship at large Life Science company

likefunny

Doesn’t feel great when the job you are interviewing for (that wasn’t advertised at all) is posted on Linkedin a few days after you interviewed 😞 Gotta keep looking...

like

Went through 11 different companies’ interview processes before landing a job out of consulting. I thought it was going to be easier, but what I realized is a lot of companies place more emphasis on..

likeupliftinghelpfulsmart

How common are credit checks for roles in accounting or finance positions? Will high utilization on credit card balances and low credit score be a deal breaker? I’ve been irresponsible and made mistakes, but wondering if I can switch jobs now or if I’m best off waiting 1-2 years and cleaning up my credit first.

like

Any recent numbers for Salesforce TPM - Senior Manager position?

like

I had a recruiter phone screen two days ago. I just realized I completely forgot to send a thank you note afterwards. Is it still worth sending at this point ?

like

Applied to a ton of industries but final offer only from deloitte. While the offer is fantastic for me, I am so torn between wanting to take a job for 60k n staying in one place. Am.i crazy

like

Hey team - currently negotiating compensation at a series C US based startup. Director level with 50% travel to APAC. Reporting to COO. What comp should I ask for?

like

What’s a reasonable amount of time for it to take to hear back after a first round interview? It’s been 6 days for me

like

I exited to FAANG from big4 and part of me is seriously thinking about getting an mba to go to mbb. Does that make any sense?

like

I come from a pure healthcare background and have minimal finance skills/experience. Want to eventually get in healthcare investing in a MM PE fund.

Is there anyway that I can start to make moves on this, while at my Big 4? Who are the best types of folks to reach out to at my Big 4?

Anything I should get smart on? Websites, podcasts, books to read?

like

Hi all I need advise please help! Long post sorry in advance. I contacted a director in a group that I previously interviewed for months ago and they ended up hiring internally. Said person was so pleased to hear from me and told me there were open roles so they were going to refer me personally to the recruiting person (Cotd)

like

So JUUL is hiring again? Had a recruiter reaching out..

likefunny

Netflix shouldn’t be considering in FAANG
Should be Uber or Microsoft instead
Change my mind 😉

like

Keep getting feedback that I don’t come off as excited for the role. Not sure how to fix this as I prepare a lot of these interviews and truly am interested in them... any advice?

Recruiter reached out to me for a PE opportunity in SoCal. Any ideas of WLB of PE (as compared to consulting)?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal