Creatives: how would you feel about being given a creative problem to solve as part of your interview process? Something like a past client ask that they had as a bit of a test.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I would hate it. I've had one interview in which they asked me a question like that — though it was for an in-house role, not agency. I BSed a decent response but it was pretty frustrating, because that's not usually how the creative process works... at least for me. I need to sit with the brief, do some research, spit out some dumb ideas, then eventually come up with something solid. Unless they're asking how you would handle a "real-time moment" on social or something, it just seems like an unrealistic/unfair test.

like

That would be a good sign of somewhere you don't want to work.

like

If they paid me for it.

like

If it was a question meant to be answered in a few sentences on the spot I don't think I'd mind. It would help show someone's thinking process. What I hate are the take home test assignments, those are bullshit, especially for creatives.

like

I won't take a copy test. I won't give you free work. If I'm sitting accross from you in an interview, you should've already seen my book. If you have questions, ask. If you don't know what you're looking at, you're starting to lose me. If you haven't seen my book at all, I'll thank you for the office tour, tell you I hope we cross paths again some time (We won't.), and I'll shake your hand farewell.

like

I think it's great. Depending on how open the prompt is, it can tell a lot about a person's process, thinking, and taste on what and how they present work - sometimes portfolios fail to show that.

like

I would love it, but if the candidate is nervous and feels as though they are being tested, then you might not see their true potential.

like

@OP That would make it more reasonable but I still would hate it.

like

Not a creative but I love this stuff because it lets me shine way more than talking about myself does

like

Isn't that what my portfolio is for?

like

This is the double standard - this is almost the norm in strategy roles. 10-15 minutes to answer an existing problem (not free work because I've already solved it) - I want to see your thinking to a real probleM, CUTS THE BS in your resume.

I've been doing this for a while for strategy roles - I get a better read on candidates, have very few bad hires. and to the one candidate who gave me a better solution than we delivered to the client - we sure as hell hired her.

like

(Also helpful because a lot of times you can't publicly share strategy work in a portfolio esp if it has any client data)

like

So, to rephrase the question. If it was asked in an email before you had a physical interview. How would you feel?so you had some time to think of an answer.

like

(Ideally given ahead of the interview though)

like

Fuck that shit. I'm not for free work.

like

I can't pay my rent in compliments.

like

Understandable sc1. What it'd it was part of the emails preceding an interview? Something like "first thoughts, what is a creative solution?".

Related Posts

Is anyone else having the worst time switching jobs? I’ve been applying for a year and haven’t gotten any job offers even though I get interviews. If anyone knows of a headhunter I could reach out to though I’d be so appreciative! I’m so frustrated….

like

I have a consulting/PE interview on Friday, please recommend consulting books or sites to read. Need to speak consulting language

like

Anybody here tagged in Wipro yahoo project !?

like

Are all big 4s in India the same? Moved from US to India and the work in one of the Big4s for consulting is so bad!! Unstructured, lack of traction, superficial work done.. 🙄🙄 how does any work get done? The project didn’t achieve targets last yr and they’re still making same mistakes this year..🤦‍♂️

like

I am defending an eviction for a client who has given possession of the property (as of Nov. 30). Plaintiff’s complaint has one claim – possession. They did request relief for attorney’s fees. NJT/Final Hearing commenced 10/27, was only 30 min and was therefore continued to 12/20. Plaintiff had counsel at that time but they are no longer represented.  I want to file something notifying Court that Plaintiff claim is now moot, making sure that judgment is not entered that hurts (cont'd)..

like

Is it SAFE joining Wipro as technical lead (B3) with 37LPA? Knowing that package is pretty high as compared to collogues in same band. HR is not ready to give project manager(C1) position.

Appreciate your suggestions/input.

Would there be any scope of increment going forward?

YOE 8.7

Tech SF DevOps

Wipro Infosys HCL Technologies Tata Consultancy Cognizant

like

Is Bain Singapore hiring experienced consultants? If I have 2 years of experience, what level should I apply for?

like

Is it worth using a recruiter? I am a U.S. Dist. Clerk in non major market targeting NYC. Didnt summer at a firm. T6, good grades (3.5-3.6).

like

which is better EY India or EY GDS ? Want to know in terms of hike , variable bonus, perks and benefits. Not bothered about client exposure and all.

Can someome share the pay range for:

Manager 1
Manager 2
Manager 3

I recently got a call from EY and they said based on interview either one of the three will be given. Is it possible to get min 32lpa?

LoS is SaT

like

Got an interview for an application security role with Facebook next Monday, what are the best sources to cram for python data structures and leet code questions ?

like

Interviewing for an internal role and hiring manager wants to finalize it before YE. Is the odd of slightly higher if HC round is passed?

like

McKinsey & Company Any advice to help prepare for data science analyst role at top consulting firms (McKinsey & Company EY Boston Consulting Group etc)? Any materials, open source platform recommended to take on freelance data science project? When should I start actively looking and applying? I am a new grad who is working in tech as a marketing analyst I’m looking to pivot to marketing& sales data science consulting next year. Would like someone with similar backgrounds offer some practical tips.

like

Does anyone offer any resume writing services? Or willing to let me use theirs as a template? I have 6 years of CS experience & a Masters degree but I am having no luck with landing a CSM position within the 6figure range, it’s seems like these companies are not even looking at my resume. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

like

Anyone at Spotify that can speak to their experience, saw a position this morning that aligns very well with my background and future goals.

I’ve applied a handful of times in the past and feels like my resume just goes straight into the void, I’d love any tips on how to get it to a person 😊

like

Hi! I'm currently interviewing (3/6 interviews so far) for for an appeals manager role for DME. The job entails not only to bill for dme (cms 1500) but also to follow up on any denials or appeals, amongst other administrative duties. My questions are is it typical to have 1 person doing both the billing and denials within a new vertical for all ins.? How difficult is billing for dme as I only have experience in gyn onc and lactation billing? What's a fair salary? I have 8+ yoe in rcm, no certs.

Hi Guyz,

I went through the entire recruitment process and got selected for IBM ISL. Now I am being told by the HR that they are unable to release offer as there is a hiring freeze.

Can any one please tell me if its correct or just an excuse not to give me offer. If its true, when will this freeze be removed?

like

How to tackle gap periods in IT interviews?

like

What's the bench policy at IBM ? For how long one can stay in bench.? How much time it will take generally to get the project/assignment. IBM Tata Consultancy

like

Anyone have insight on working at Verily as a project manager?

like

More Posts

Hi. Looking for info reg how log in and log out card swipe data is monitored at TCS. Who can access this data ... managers and team members? Do HR conduct an audit of the log in details of associates?

like

IFS rocks!! Missing my PwC peeps! 😢 😊 Wish you all a happy 2020!

like

what's the best lesson working in the retail industry has taught you?

like

Is it safe to join Verizon now ?

like
like

How much should be the salary for an events manager in FL? I handle global events

like

Are your offices reopening soon?

like

Hi fishes,
I need your valuable suggestions from your rich experience

I am going switch my tech into Java development. I am having around 2 yrs of experience in Database.

What are the skills you expect from 2 yoe java developer, which skills I should focus more so transition won't seem too hard.

Note: I am going to join as experienced guy only

please give me your suggestion. It will help me a lot to work and gain those skills now only before switching.

Thanks a lot.

like

Confession: Sometimes I’m afraid to ask for more resources in my role, because what if I have everything I need to succeed and still come up short?

Anyone else experience this and successfully push through that fear?

likehelpful

98 almost 99k base salary in San Diego, CA not including the bonuses or OT… is this too low or reasonable?

like

Currently my location is banglore. I raised location change request to chennai..I informed the same to my Manager..he said there will be less growth in chennai..is it true🙄

like

I am having 12.5 lpa CTC with 7.7 YoE. How much can Delta Airlines offer?

like

TRON correction anytime soon or buy at .20?

like

The unending cycle is for real. Reached my LeanFIRE number 2 months ago, yet I don’t feel satisfied. Still reaching for the stars… when will this human desire end?

like

Anyone near the DC area by chance?

I work on a consulting team at a large software company. I’m a job hopper, around 2 years each at my first and second jobs and a little over a year at this job. I recently found out they’re shutting my team down. We’re not fired, but they’re transferring us to the core implementation team, which has a horrible reputation for malignancy, overworking, and isn’t at all what I was hired to do. How hard is it going to be to for me to find a new job? Should I just stay and try things out? What next?

like

I am an incoming Associate at Strategy& Dubai office. I am a bit worried right now and wanted to know whether Strategy& will be honouring the full time offers? Is the firm doing well?

like
like

Additional Posts in Advertising

Anybody working with a client that is looking for content or has everyone just decided to rerun old work?

like

Any word on Swift in Portland?

like

How many months in is it normal to hate a new job vs you've given it a long enough chance to know it's a wrong fit?

like

Dear Creative Directors who’s only talent is showing up to meeting with a full repertoire of buzzwords, die slow. Thanks, everyone.

likefunnyuplifting

Does anyone know the stories behind KFC's "I love you Colonel Sanders" dating sim game and Wendy's D&D rpg? Were agencies involved or did they start in-house?

like

Traits of your favorite account people?

likesmart

Thank you all for existing on Fishbowl and for being such a supportive community. It’s been a difficult year, but at the end of the day, I’m glad to have people to commiserate/celebrate with ❤️🙂❤️

like

Been asked to present my current client’s plan and PCA in second interview for a role. Am I being over cautious by not feeling comfortable with this?

like

I’m currently in the US but starting to miss the family and friends in Europe... The agency I’m at have offices there. How common are transfers? Who do I talk to in the agency? Don’t want to come off as I want to leave but more so that I want to be closer to my family.

likehelpful

Any agencies that have a good reputation, but suck when you actually work there? Wonder why that happens?

like

Not to be an asshole BUT... why hire juniors if you are at a high level creative agency? (Stealing culture/ platform insights not withstanding )

like

Hey is there anyone interested in starting an agency in NYC?

like

gary v(isionary) dropping heavy truth bombs, what an absolute mad lad 🙏💯

Post Photo
funnylikesmarthelpful

Which holding company gets the best rental car discount? And which rental company?

like

Who's got the most fishbowl points?

like

Pros and cons of working on an auto brand?

likesmart

It's the end of an era: what's your favorite thing about Obama? #ObamaFarewell

like

What odd questions about your job did you get at the xmas / Hanukkah table?

likefunny

Marcel here. So instead of talking behind my back, how about saying it to my face? Here I am, ready to answer questions, concerns, or just talk sports. So what would you like to know? 🤖

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal