Fellow Partners I want your unbiased perspectives on a talent management matter. I’m at MBB and a superstar Principal/AP has had an offer from another MBB with higher pay and quicker progression to Partnership. It’s someone we don’t want to lose and I’m going to see what I can do for them but of course this environment is tricky. What would you do? Would you pull out all the stops or let them go? Seeking your advice as I want thoughts from outside the echo chamber.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

First, I’d bet it wasn’t unsolicited. In some way, shape or form, the juniors indicated they were open to approach. With that said, I’d go to bat. In the end, the question is the person already gone in their heart and head. That’s best covered between mentor and mentee.

likeuplifting

Extremely helpful thanks. I also agree that we are all taking calls and it is a smaller industry than we think. I know this person is well connected and admired so it would’ve been easy to take a few calls and get an offer

“Quicker progression to partnership” means absolutely nothing. Would question the naivety of someone who is weak enough to be lured into this kind of a proposition and then openly state it to talent management or partners in leadership. On top of this, stating that the offer was unsolicited is questionable.

Lateraling across firms at the principal/AP level is a rookie move and 99% of the time a trajectory ender.

like

I call bs on your comment. I know of so many cases where folks have lateraled at that level and come out better. I did same and ended up a partner at least 4 years sooner than if I had stayed at my old firm.

likehelpful

I can't speak for MBB, but yes, I would pull the stops out if it's someone I don't want to lose, cusp of partner or not.

like

Thank you this is incredibly helpful

No offense to OP, but this is what the thread reads like

Post Photo
funny

What does this mean?

Why does it matter if the offer is unsolicited?

I agree

So OP is a partner but fb title is director? Ya, he just trying to figure out what gonna happen to him now that he got an offer

I made the mistake of staying at McKinsey when I could have moved to Bain I highly recommend moving your percentage odds of making partner are 1/10 in any chance unless you have a clear spot as a partner move I did and b still didn’t make it and ended up leaving both
Of your original firm truly b cares they will get you a way n to stay and get to partner

Related Posts

Any suggestions for a face serum or face oil for dry, sensitive, acne prone skin?

like

Bacon cheeseburger soup (with ground turkey)

Post Photo
like

Hey folks. I'm looking @ dir-level People Operations / PM or Chief of Staff roles. Industry agnostic but interested in one that's social impact focused or innovative.

Curious what that pays in CAD? I make equivalent to $145K CAD as an an Account Director / PM and Client Operations Lead at a mid-sized US-based PR/Digital comms company, with 6 yrs of exp managing multiworkstream teams and multimillion dolllar projs.

Grateful for any leads too. My network is US-based so this all new for me!

like

Feels like the world is ending and every door is closed. Couldn't even breathe. Want to find a room and lock myself in and cry

like

I left my job without having anything else lined up otherwise I would have had a mental breakdown. I’m not even in that great of a financial place, but it was my job or my sanity. I know at least three other people who, in the past few months, have left with nothing lined up. I feel like it’s something we need to be talking more about. This isn’t normal for people to be doing this right?

like

Everyone says Geico car insurance is cheap . However for me it is most expensive. I went for Allstate/State farm which were cheaper than Geico. Am I missing something?

Are there some in this group that are here to chat as well? I’m a married M, but wouldn’t mind a friend that’s here to chat

likefunnyuplifting

Pwc fishes. Do we bring up the green card chat with the RL or the partner?

Hi Fishes,
So i received this interview invite link 4 times. They just keep on asking everytime, and I fill it.
Is this how a typical interview process at Infy. 😅

Post Photo
like

Hi All ,
Can anyone please suggest which one to choose from cognizant, Coforge, Magic edtech for noida location on Java stack for better WLB and long term stability.

Thanks!

COO’s & previous SR. account executives…

I made it to regional manager for a franchise by age 22. Ran a successful financial practice & sold by the age of 33. Took 2 years off and built a health & wellness coaching platform for my wife (medical provider). Then, the last 2.5 yrs, have been a top producer in Saas sales as a senior account executive. I’ve been told I would make a great COO someday and I’m ready to take the next step into leadership. Who/what should I be targeting next?

like

Any recommendations for lawyers specializing in EB1c? Thanks 🙏

like

My Dad has over 28 years of experience in Managing accounts and Finance of various companies. He’s really struggled a lot to get where he is right now. His current company is facing financial difficulties- anyone who can refer him for any Finance and Accounting senior opportunities in Dubai - please help. Literally crying for help.

like

6 questions:
1-When to buy put contract?
2-When to sell put contract?
3-When to exercise put contract?
4-When to buy call contract?
5-When to sell call contract?
6-When to exercise call contract?

likehelpful

Which is better to join Capgemini or IBM with same fixed components considering work life balance.

like

Anyone listening to the podcast “Dr. Death”? Both fascinating and horrifying...

like

Who has the best M&A Tax Practice ?

like

How do they decide onsite salary for Germany for an experienced Java Tech Lead in TCS(10 years) ? And what would be the onsite salary?

like

Hi. Our CPG startup is looking for a content studio to help with performance marketing assets. Need from concept through production. May include photography / live action. My gut is the sweet spot for this is a young team that gets growth and what performs best on the platforms. Please dm your link - we will do calls with a few and have three provide bids. Thank you!

like

Additional Posts in Partner One

Do partners know each other’s compensation? I see partners selling engagements for vastly different numbers b/w shorter ‘interesting’ strategy work and longer ‘boring’ transformations. Thoughts?

like

/x-post from the Consulting Bowl/

Hello, Partners. Can anyone recommend fantastic courses, videos or training for a new manager like myself? I’ve come from a tech background and looking to be C-Suite

Partners: where do your clients come from? Do you spend more time acquiring new clients or using your network from past projects/peers?

like

If an employee files a complaint about workplace behavior, do you treat them differently? I'm faced with reporting an SM for bullying and finding it near imposible to believe that it won't (cont'd)

With the CDC releasing new mandates, What are partners seeing from clients? Are they asking for full return to the office? I definitely want to keep staying wfh and not commuting :/

like

Hiya! I was wondering if anyone here has any good recommendations in terms of books or learning material that I can pick up to learn about sales and marketing relevant to the consulting industry?

like

Partners, what's been the impact to ongoing sales conversations? Do you think we're all screwed for the year?

like

Joined EY 6months back as a tech consultant. My feedback so far has been great. What should I do to get the company sponsor my mba? I haven’t initiated the talk yet

Hey Partners! I accepted a position at another firm and was bumped from manager to Senior consultant level. Could you give me some advice on 3 key things I can focus on to help me re-advance quickly?

like

Curious what % of partners/MDs have spouses who also work. And regardless of non/working spouse, what do you do to feel a work/family balance?

like

How much do MDs make? What is their comp structure like?

like

So, Partners... What's your spending breakdown like? Curious to see what expenses y'all have. # of yrs as Partner may also help.

Thanks for sharing! Again, just for fun and curiosity.

likehelpfulfunny

What are the benefit differences between an equity partner and a non-equity partner (e.g. managing director)?

PwC Anyone went through a direct admit Partner process? I am being approached and have some questions (process, timeline, interviews experience, compensation etc.) Thank you!

like

Question for some of the senior partners on this bowl: do you mind sharing what does the the top end of partner comp look like? Is it like 2-3M annually? And how many years it took you to get there after becoming partner?

like

Partners with kids and a working spouse, how do you manage? Is it realistic for both people in the relationship to work full time long term? How do you keep marriage going and career progressing?

likesmart

Just heard FY23 partners at PwC are getting only 40 shares vs.60 last year. Looks like new partners are being shown the middle finger by Tim Ryan in favor of increasing stock price and getting more catalyst hires. Sucks!!

likefunnyhelpful

Does the concept of local and high value role exist is Deloitte, Accenture or PWC?... been consulting for 13 yrs

Partners, what are the financial benefits of retiring as a Partner at PwC or other Big 4s?

likehelpfulfunny

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal