Hi everyone, wanted to ask the pros here - we're scaling and have 3 new hires, out of 4 new hires total, who are POC. There are only a couple other POC in the office, who have been here for a while. And the problem is, as fate would have it, none of these 3 people are going to work out, from literally just a work performance point of view. It's fully random that they are not white. However I am very concerned about what message this will send, to all. Should I address this somehow?? HOW?

likefunny
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

What factors have gone into determine they won't "work out"? What training and coaching and guidance has been made available to them? What biases have they been subjected to that non-POC team members haven't been?

like

This!

like

3 out of 4 are bad hires? Without all the details my default opinion is the problem is more related to the manager.

like

As stated above, figure out why they are not working out and what support you could offer to combat this. Surely, out of three, at least one should work well with the right support. If not, ask yourself how your team managed to make three poor hiring decisions in a row.

like

Great point! If a team has 3 of 4 doing something wrong that says more about the team than those 3 people.

like

IF we are to assume you all did the right assessment matching their skills to the role then it sounds like you all failed to explain the vision of the company and also failed to provide the proper motivation for them to work towards the team’s goals.

POC have stronger community-based ties (“it takes a village”) so individualism (“I’m a man/woman at 18”) isn’t really the backdrop like how mainstream culture portrays it. Trial by fire doesn’t serve those three well without avenues to ask for help/guidance/mentorship.

More trust and goodwill is needed to convince them that their success translates to company success (rewards, recognition, letting them solve problems creatively, etc.). Just ask and listen….

Now, If you failed to assess their skills from the jump then the blame lies squarely with hiring managers who have misguided intentions - what else are they getting wrong?

likefunny

Saying POC looks and sounds like Colored People. Racist as F**k. Stop defining people by their skin color. Period.

like

make sure you document all your attempts to improve their behavior or make them better employees and then fire them. You should not fire or go out of your way to keep bad employees just because they are POCs.

like

No need to worry about it.

Explore other options besides termination, like additional training, mentoring, or probationary periods if there's room for improvement.

Related Posts

I have a friend looking for a graphic designer that can build her a style guide. Anyone have any recommendations?

Please send websites as well.


Thanks

like

I am a middle school coach, and many of my students request that I use discord to help track progress outside of school. Has anyone used discord for coaching before? Is it worth downloading and making a server? 

likesmart

Which HCL office is better to go out of Magarpatta office and Quadra office in Pune.
Have a choice to join any of these two. Please suggest.

like

Will be in the market for a car in a month or so - narrowed down to Mazda CX 50 Turbo but the BMW X3 is only around $5k more compared to the Mazda Turbo trim I liked. Torn between these 2, would really appreciate any advice/insight in making this decision in regards to longterm ownership, rate of depreciation and maintenance.

Dark Brandon strikes again

Post Photo
likefunnyuplifting

Average salary for Director level at Visa? I have an offer in NA Operations, based in NY. Any info on comp that would be comparable would be hugely helpful!

like

What's the level 6 and level 7 pay in Accenture?
I am from product tech background, 13yrs + exp.

Accenture

I have a senior business process manager interview next week, any tips? It requires 4 hour long interviews in which one is a business case study. What would you recommend while I am prepping?

like

So i have adhd and really bad anxiety. Seeing a physchiatrist that will likely put me on anti anxiety meds.

Has anyone with adhd here gone on anti anxiety meds without treating the adhd, and if so how did the meds affect concentration and memory?

like

I have an interview for a sr assoc PM role at Cap1. What are some things I should expect and how should I prepare?

like

Value Vs Price

While selling something I believe in, I've always focused on the value to justify the price & leave a little room to negotiate.

If I personally believe in a terrific, purposeful value packed product that commands a certain price- I would make sure it gets reflected the way you position, pitch and solves a crucial pain point like no other.

Reason being simple- If you believe in something it's easy to sell

Looking for my next play as Tiktok India had to restructure. Thank you!

like

What’s is your favorite fast food chain and why? There is so many I don’t know which one to choose. Thank you.

like

See you guys on the floor when markets open

Post Photo
likefunny

Is freelancing paid media or social media lucrative in Toronto? Looking to make the jump to that

like

Do you have to have an MBA to get a job at Big4? I'm trying to get into Deloitte.

like

Hi Fishes,

Currently I am working as senior software engineer in a product base company. My tech stacks are React, Redux, Node, AWS and Graphql. I am thinking to switch the carrier in Block Chain or Data Science. Will it be a good decision to make the shift.

Total experience is 5 years.

If it's okay to shift. Could you please help me with the steps for preparation? I will really appreciate the help.

Thanks a lot.

like

I haven't received offer letter even after waiting for more than 16 days, i have given more than 10 interviews till now and have 4 offers but this one is taking a lot time giving a high rise to my expectations but am losing hope from this..can anyone suggest how much time usually it takes to roll out letter...please.

Planning to exit tech firms as a mid to senior level roles. What are some possible sources I can reach out at to make this happen?

like

What’s a fair operations manager salary

Watching CSI type shows was more fun before I knew the limitations of the technology, it seemed like magic to me

like

Additional Posts in Diversity & Inclusion

I'm in desperate need of tips to get genuine buy in from our predominantly white, male senior leadership to create a more inclusive environment. As is often the case, middle management and below is very diverse and then at Director+ it gets much more homogeneous. So far any real initiatives get shot down in favor of performative actions to post on SM. Is this just how it is, or can we try something different?

like

Feeling very frustrated right now…company talks a big game about DEI internally, while requiring new hires to move to Texas/Arizona, while the company’s PAC donates to politicians pushing extremist, regressive, anti-woman and anti-LGBT laws

They want to encourage us to “bring our whole self to work” while putting us in situations where we can’t be our whole self.

Anyone else in a similar place, feeling discouraged? Any tips?

like

I find myself in workshops and meetings, groups of 15-20 people, and I’m always the only woman. In my entire department, there are no other women. I’m getting to the point where I’m feeling defeated and burnt out. I’ve been working in male-dominated environments my entire career (over 10 years) and I’m losing motivation. Any tips or words of advice to get out of my mental rut?

like

Hey everyone! Does anyone have a list of top companies in the US that are truly diverse and inclusive. I’m disabled poc and a recent grad as of December 2021 and I’m looking to start applying to other jobs as my current company has not been accommodating at all. TIA!

like

Looking to support a new APIA founded startup? Well look no further!

Have you ever found something online and thought "... if I buy this, what about my anniversary gift, that trip to Europe, the car I always wanted..."

Well I have and founded Okane (money in Japanese 🤑)

Okane is a free Chrome Extension that focuses on goal-based budgeting. We track your wealth and help you save for your future goals while avoiding impulse purchases, right as you shop online. ( okane.crd.co)

Lmk what you think!!

like
like

How do you professionally address a noticeable lack of diversity on your team? More than 85% of my team is white or white passing, and of the remaining individuals none are Black, Indigenous, or AAPI.

like

We all have beautiful names and we should all be addressed by those names and the pronouns that we identify with. I particularly like Erik and you can refer to me as He/Him or They/Them.

At MNP, we foster an inclusive and safe environment for all to openly share their pronouns. We respect the pronouns that you choose to identify with.

like

In honor of National Voter Registration Day, The New Yorker released the transcript of a previously unpublished interview with James Baldwin, who gave a first-hand account of "Freedom Day 1963," a Black voter-registration drive in Selma, Alabama. Baldwin's descriptions from that day are so vivid and detailed that you can feel the fear and anger of the event. If you have a couple of minutes, I highly recommend you read it.

Hi - I am a career pivot from higher education into tech and have final round interviews for a DEI Coordinator role (which I'm super excited for). I am meeting with three people that I would be partnering with for the job and it was shared with me that these interviews will mainly be behavioral as well as questions on my technical skills. Does anyone have any resources to help me prepare for this? Anything is greatly appreciated!

like

Current DEI Professional, can everyone support me on the likes so that I can unlock being able to message someone. I will do the same in return. Thank you

like

I used a tool at my last company that worked tremendously well in helping me resolve conflict with a co-worker and I would love to bring it into my new company - its an Ombuds platform.

Any suggestions on how to make this happen? Has anyone done this before - brought in a tool to your new company that you've used before?

like
like

Working at a company and they can’t seem to hold on to their female, black and people of color employees. I blinked and 3 of the people who were in my onboarding class were either fired or they left. For context I’ve been in company less than a year and there are people who have been in the company 25yrs. I’m thinking of cutting loose before it gets to my turn.

like

Our team is about to recruit and we are trying to live our DEI values. Any tangible actions you can suggest to how we can widen our attractiveness to a more diverse candidates? Applies internally and externally. Thanks for any suggestions.

like

What are some examples where you feel included at your organization?

like

I am frustrated as a Gay Woman who has given her all for 30+ years grinding to be the best. I have been in closet, out of closet, in-between and am tired of it. I want to be VALUED as a human being. I have gone from Rock Star to problem when people "found out". I have trained and promoted hundreds of people and been passed over for promotions because of not being a man. I have trained men with less experience, worse results only for them to move forward. If Diversity is important...prove it!

like

Hi everyone! I’m pivoting from working in politics in search of a role in DEI. I have 1.5 YOE managing multiple campaigns and a BA in Global Studies & MA in Ethnology. I have experience working in and with non-profits and a passion for people and culture. I’d love to connect to hear about your journeys & advice for an early career transition!

like

Do you feel like your work is making a difference at your current company? Why or why not?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal