How do you as the attorney balance your advice with your client’s wishes? Meaning when what the client wants is not, in your opinion, in their best interest, when they want to settle for less “to be done,” or pay more “to get him out of the house,” when do you stop pushing back and give in? I’ve lost at least one client before for pushing too hard to get what they were entitled to when they wanted to give in and I’m fear I’m facing something similar now.

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

I think our job is to provide advice, explain the law and what might happen in court and then step back. I've had plenty of clients settle for less to be done and I think that's fine. They have to live with these decisions forever and I'm not going to push them to litigate when a settlement is possible because no one wins in domestic litigation.

like

Give your advice but it’s ultimately up to the client - be sure to have them sign an acknowledgment confirming you gave the advice and their instructions are contrary to your strong recommendations etc.

like

Absolutely agree with this response. In situations where I believe they are taking a stance they may at some point regret, I always do the CYA letter for them to sign and acknowledge what they are doing. Sometimes they change their mind when they are reading back the scenarios.

like

Had this issue happen on Friday. I had was more than half way through a complicated post divorce settlement when my client backed out of all negotiations, and insisted that we move forward with a hearing we have for next week. I emailed her (so there’s a written record), explained why I believe negotiations are in her best interest. Then, I had a phone conference with her to further explain. (Did a phone conference instead of an in person meeting bc of covid). Then, I sent a separate confirming email summarizing the advice I gave her in the phone conference. When client replied confirming that she understood, I had that email saved to the file, and I put a note in my related billing entities that we were moving forward with litigation, per the clients instructions, and against the advice of counsel.

Bottom line is, give your advice, and document it (and your clients refusal to follow it) in writing. Then, you follow through with the clients objectives. Win or lose, they knew risk going in.

like

Client’s wishes are paramount. You can’t fully know why they’re leaving things on the table—even as their attorney, you’re not privy to everything leading to that decision.

Document it back to them in writing for your file. You don’t want your client later claiming that this was your fault.

like

Divorce really isn’t about winning. It’s about transitioning to a new hopefully happier life. These cases are generally not to be won.

like

I have practiced for several years and at the end of the day, the client has the right to make whatever decision he or she wishes. Your job is to advise and educate them about the ramifications of their decision. If they do not heed your advice, then you advocate for them based on what they want and write a CYA letter.
People have their own motivations in a divorce. Sometimes when a client has agreed to something we perceive as just trying to be done is that they really have thought about it and decided that money can be earned, things are just things, but there is no price they can put on the ability to move themselves from a bad situation and move on to a better life.

like

I give the advice but always remind them that it is ultimately up to them. If I'm really against their particular choice or it's truly against their interests, I make sure to put my advice in writing and list out the pros and cons of their desired action.

How hard I push depends on the relationship with that particular client. Some are more open than others. But ultimately, I lay off if I feel like it's truly what they want to do.

like

Thanks everyone, all the advice is in line with what I was thinking it’s nice to hear that others face this issue as well

like

For years my business card always stated “Attorney and Counselor at Law”. In other words we wear two hats. One as the attorney to advise our clients on the law and the other as a counselor to suggest or to recommend a course of action we feel is the best under the circumstances. But in the end the client makes the decision whether to settle and on what terms. That’s their prerogative. Even if your client is, in your view, making a bad decision or one which you would not make. Advise them as best you can, document in writing if they are not following your advice and move on. They must live with their decision, good or bad. You’ve done your best to advise and counsel them. More than that cannot be expected of you. Remember, your a lawyer, not a magician.

like

Thank you - such a simple point about both “attorney” and “counselor at law” but it really is helpful to keep that point of view in mind

I agree with what others have said. I'd add that if it's a big decision that could prejudice the client's case, I typically tell the client to sleep on it.

like

A senior partner once told me ( as a newbie more than 30 years ago) to remember that when clients make their situations more difficult, we have to fix that too. I don’t go to war with clients. I don’t create an adversarial position with them. State your best advice and take your ego out of the mix when they don’t follow it. Too many younger lawyers seem to view their roles as persuasion of the client. Actually our role is to advocate for the client and persuade the court. Just saying.

Related Posts

Anyone from Siemens client project?? How is it ?

like

On your resume do you just list your firm or do you break it down by client/project you were on?

like

How does everyone bill for family law matters? Do you always bill hourly or is there some flat fee, monthly or quarterly fee structure that could work, even in contested matters? I have cases that the clients end up spending $20-$40,000 on a contested divorce and this is really out of their budget. I feel that if my firm could charge a flat fee of $10-$15,000, it would still be beneficial from a client predictability and volume standpoint and would generate more referrals.

like

Transition manager with overall 12 years experience, looking for Transiton manager, project management or program management opportunities..

like

Hi all. I am a SCM Microsoft Dynamics 365 F&O Functional Consultant.
(Role in
IBM : Package Consultant: Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance & Operations; Band: 7A)

My relevant experience is 3.5 years(Total: 4.5 years).

I am on bench and am looking for a project.

Kindly let me know if anyone of you are aware of any such suitable opportunity.

Please feel free to ping me. Thanks in Advance! 🙂

Hello,

How is Kotak Mahindra Bank project of Wipro.......is work life balance maintained?

Please let me know...

Wipro

Kotak Mahindra Bank

like

I recently joined TW some months back and I dont know why I think have made a wrong choice for myself. I am feeling like I am lost. I am not able to fit in in this high expectations environment. I am used to working in a place where we always worked by taking help from others and here it is sort of assumed that we would be knowing everything right from day 1. Also there is no pairing in my project. Any suggestions on what should be done would be welcome.

like

I know notice period at thoughtworks is 2 months .
Given there are a lot of people on the bench , is there any chance that the notice period can be reduced down ? I'm not on the bench . Recently I joined a new project .
Developer+ senior consultant

like

Hello fishes,
Can a capgemini employee join his client organization.

helpful

If the ultimate goal is to move in pharma/biotech (bd / strategy type role), does prestige of consulting firm matter? Or would it be better to work for less known firm that may have more client facing opportunities?

like

Just got an offer to ZS as a SIP Associate consultant. I am coming out of undergrad with 3 years of full time experience in life sciences research project management and institutional strategy and development. What is a good compensation package? Total comp and base comp?

like

What are some brands with an in-house agency? Looking to make a move to client side.

White & Case About to lateral into the project finance team of White & Case. Thoughts on the culture / dos and don’ts?

like

Any investors have experience in pharma? I have a client looking for Angel investors and their minimum is $250k+, as an investor what are you looking for? TIA

like

Can we get some experiences from people for Microsoft Federal consulting? Specifically the account delivery roles? Things like work life balance, time remote vs on client sites, compensation, etc? Would you say it is more like "Microsoft" or has that part of the company just replicated Deloitte, Booz Allen, etc?

likesmart

If you’re at a small creative agency that mostly does project work, does that mean you’re perpetually pitching?

like

How do you get good at thinking on your feet? I find I always need time to think and analyse before being able to answer client queries (even those that are considered simple by others). I don't want to rush and get it wrong. I avoid phone calls for this reason which isn't great when you're in the service industry so it's starting to impact my career.

like

Hey freelance designers! What’s your going rate for a logo design/branding project for a mid-size company these days?

Getting ready to take on a project with a local real estate company branding a new subdivision but I haven’t done one of these in a few years and don’t want to undercut myself on compensation.

like

I currently working as project coordinator (on-site) for 3 months 10hrs everyday with package $75k, I want to move to remote or hybrid work but I only have 8 months of experience from my previous employer and I have completed my master's in construction management in 2021. Should I stay in my role a bit longer to gain experience or I am not able to find remote or hybrid matching my profile. Your advice and comments are much appreciated.

like

I went to excellent schools, passed all my cpa exams the first time around in 3 months, got a job at a Big4, work on the biggest client in my office. Yet I constantly feel like I don’t belong cont...

like

More Posts

Does anybody have a resource available for pricing and billing? I am 2 years out of law school, working as a corporate attorney, and wanting to go solo. Ideally, I will take my corporate client with me, but am working to build work on the side during the transition. Also, do you have any recommendations for document preparation? I would like to draft wills, trusts, and other estate planning documents, but would like a resource that has boilerplate provisions to utilize as a reference.

like

Any utilization review nurses working at an insurance company able to share if your company requires work on weekend/holidays? If so, what work do you do on weekend/holidays snd do you work s full day on those days?

like

Director salary at FTI Consulting? Specifically in the corp finance, tax group?

like

Hi People,
What is the nominal pay scale for an Amazon L4, Success Team manager?

like

Is american express odc in phase 3 pune?

What's a good show to watch on Netflix? Need rec's before Peaky Blinders comes back on. Thx

Just finished Ozark, so any shows of that type would be great.

like

Any tips on how to get started on prepping for VC interviews

like

I joined pwc india recently with IFS, but wanted to join PwC IAC IFS.

Can. Someone plz refer me. I don't want to waste my time initial phase of career. Please help me out.

Thanks in advance.

like

Hi Guys,
Help needed!!!
I got offer from HCL for the position of Lead consultant with(23.49 fixed + 3.51 variable). I have 8 yrs of experience. I want to know if this position is same as Team/Tech Lead ? As in my current organization I am working as Team Lead. And also how is job security and work life balance in HCL?

like

Hi fishes,

As per my Offer letter there is component is Engagement PB.
Will this i get monthly ?

Hey guys,
I got selected to
HCL Technologies , had submitted my documents and all the required information also updated my joining form in discover HCl website. It also shows that my bgv is completed but I have'nt recieved myoffer letter it has been more than a week. I also have a service agreement to fill it requires my date of joining which I think will be in my offer letter. Can any one help me and say how will this move from now.

like

I cleared all my rounds for 2.2 level and shared all my documents on the link HR shared. It's been two weeks and the offer letter is not generated. The HR keeps telling me to wait until Friday and then postpones to next week. Can anyone help me understand this?

like

I have a interview coming up for a Program Manager Role and curious if anyone here is a program manager and wouldn’t mind sharing their Salary and top 3 responsibilities. I want to make sure I am being compensated fairly.

like

Hi Everyone,
I am looking for a job change , I have 8+ years of experience . I have 6 years of experience in HR generalist and 2 years in Knowledge management.
My current package is 8.2 lakhs and expected is 12 - 15 lakhs
Request you all to fine me a good opportunity I will be grateful to you all


Hoping for positive response.

like

What's your experience working with United Way?

like
like

My org will be pausing the Employer match to 401k for a few months. What's the best strategy to optimize my investment at this time?
Ride along/increase or decrease my percentage?

like

Any accounting firms looking to move away from payroll services?

Interested in working in PE, but experiences align more with the Ops side (3 YOE in strategic value creation). Is there a significant difference in total comp potential between ops and investments roles? Not sure how to make a case to break into investments with minimal DD experience, so thinking about Ops recruitment (Associate). Would also be grateful to learn about potential strategies non-DD focused consultants have used to ultimately break into investment teams.

like

Additional Posts in Family Law

What days does your firm close for the holidays? Are you all working on January 2nd?

(I don't want to be a task master, but as an associate, I was expected to work a half day on the 24th, and a half day on the 31st. I'm closing the office 23rd and 26th this year, but currently listed as open on Jan. 2nd).

like

Is attaching communications between opposing counsel and the filing attorney when filing a response to a motion poor form?

like

Looking for some advice on how to find a really good attorney to deal with custody. I live in the Orlando, Florida area and truthfully don’t know where to begin. Most Google searches turn up thousands of attorneys. Is there a vetted website to find honest reviews?

like

What is your hours worked to hours billed ratio?

like

How do your firms do payroll? This is like the 5th time in 26 months that paychecks weren’t timely deposited. Allegedly, the boss did everything right and this is something in the payroll company. But his stuff is getting crazy and everyone is out on PTO, I’m kinda like: meet minimum ethical obligations and no more. Once or twice, I understand. But this is becoming regular.

like

Lawyers who draft prenups - are you interested in referrals? If so DM me your email and name and I will reach out. I’m not trying to sell you anything don’t worry - just need attorneys to refer to.

like

Hello Fam Law attys!

I am in my second year as a attorney, I was a FL paralegal before law school and would eventually like to end up there again. I am in a very small rural area, pretty much only solos, and no FL solos appear to be hiring/expanding at this time.

Do you think experience as a DA or PD would be valuable, with my eye toward a future in FL? Both for the skills gained, and/or as a resume piece?

TY!

like

Can we talk about Rates?
What is your:
1) hourly rate
2) years of practice
3) size firm
4) state

My answers:
1) $350/hr
2) 5 years
3) solo practitioner
4) New York

like

What are your client follow-up/communication policies or practices? I’m hearing more and more that clients don’t like the long periods of time with little to no contact. From my perspective, since I bill for my time, unless I have an update or need something, I don’t initiate a call. Also, clients hold on to important info and don’t initiate a call cause they’re waiting for me to communicate with them.

like

What’s a good starting salary for a newer attorney? I’ve never worked anywhere but in the public sector (even before becoming an attorney). I currently clerk for a judge and now am up to $44k as of July 1. I’m in KY. I’ve recently had a couple attorneys reach out to me about joining their practice. I’m not ready to leave my current role but I have no idea what to consider as a reasonable salary. I’ve been licensed a year and this is my first law-related job so I’m a complete newbie.

like

If your client hired a life coach/consultant to help them through a family law matter, what would you want them to focus on and what’s hands off?

like

2 days ago i told the resp on the phone i had a divorce petition to mail him and needed his address. He said he would call me back with the address because he was driving, just moved to a new place, and didn't have it memorized. He never gave it to me but i found it anyway and mailed it certified. Today i found out that he cleared out their bank account. Can i do an emergency hearing to get that money back? He does not physically have the petition yet but i definitely told him it was coming.

like

In OAH the NCP has submitted no actual earnings only hand written sched c (Uber). NCP lied under oath about how pmt for the car was made. Said a friend paid for it and he is paying a friend back. I have bank evidence that shows every car pmt came from NCP Bank and only deposits were from Uber. Problem is the car was paid off in 2018 and the CSO was from 2018. CP asked 4 mod and it was brought up to ? his credibility. How do I get it in since its not about $ now? Judge granted 1wk 4 adtl exhibits

like

Solos - how did you know when you were ready to hire a FT attorney?

like

I hate being an attorney. How do I get out.

like

Have you seen an upswing in same sex dissolution matters in your area? If so are you in metropolitan or suburban location?

like

If my clients are the firm’s clients, it’s up to the firm to let them know I am leaving right? I’m leaving for a government position so I can’t take them with me anyway.

like

Small firm (my boss, me, & a paralegal). After a hearing I did not handle, boss intended to seek review of the ruling in its entirety. What was communicated to me by paralegal was to seek review of a portion.

Seeking review is now time-barred. Boss is not upset, but this is 1 case & 1 problem. There are other cases & other stories.

How do I talk to my boss about being more present (boss is never in office, has “too many” emails, never answers his phone) without being seen as insubordinate?

like
like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal