Interviewed at Huge for a Project Manager role and had to do a live presentation. Gave me a brief, 15 minutes, and expected me to sketch out a full Project Plan and Strategy Reco on a whiteboard 🖕😭

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Sometimes those roles overlap, but usually at smaller shops. It’s definitely a little outside our wheelhouse, but related I guess. It’s probably to see how you handle an assignment you’re not comfortable with. See how you contribute to the overall vision of the project. That’s my guess anyway

like

@R/GA 1 But, that’s all we are and we get paid damn good for it 😂. Kidding. It’s a lot more to the job, but strategy is typically not what we do. You have to be solutions oriented, should he able to think from all perspectives of everyone’s job and know what they do and know how to plan and execute all types of projects.

like
Recent IconRecent

Ironically, I thought I did a good job but they didn't make an offer. The whole process was ridiculous though. Half the people who I was suppose to interview with didn't show up, the recruiter wasn't even there, the people they did send in were confused on why they were interviewing me, and I was told I was gonna have 45 minutes to put together a presentation. The brief was so arbitrary and vague and dependent on a lot of factors not explained but I took a solid shot at it. Except in reality, I had about 15 minutes tops and some markers that barely worked all while I worked on a giant whiteboard in an all glass conference room while everyone stared at me and giggling like I was an animal in the zoo. The whole experience really left a bad taste in my mouth for an agency I always respected greatly.

like

I get outlining a top line project timeline (to see how you think, work under pressure, etc), but why on earth would a PM be responsible for Strategy??

like

PMs should be able to think strategically... or you just become a meeting scheduler/budget tracker 😕

like

And I've know a bunch of past Huge PMs and not a single person had to go through this process. I'm starting to think I was a guinea pig for a really poorly thought out program.

like

It was more so program-level strategy focused. Like here's the client brief, tell us what we should produce to satisfy the objectives, and how can we do this in the given timing and budget.

like

Yeah, totally. Shit happens and I'm not losing sleep over it but thought I'd vent here quickly. The first woman they sent in to interview me straight up said 'I have no idea why I'm here and I have no input in the hiring of your role but I guess they needed someone to interview you so here I am' 😭😭😭

like

Damn that’s intense. How’d it go?

like

I don't do presentations. I'm serious. If anyone "requires" this assignment or gives me homework, I decline.

like

Ah makes more sense when you put it that way. Still pretty intense to be doing a white boarding session in your first interview. Ugh. Hope you nailed it!

like

P1 - have you ever conducted or been involved in these types of interview case studies? I have and what they are really after is a bit of thought into the types of deliverables you *may* create as part of the project & timeline accordingly. Otherwise, what will you put in your timeline?!

like

I would welcome this interview style. Sounds better than a bullshit conversation about why I want to work there and what my strengths are and where I see myself in 5 years.

like

Maybe they just pretend to interview people to get them to do schedules

like

OP it's better that it didn't work out. Huge is tanking as a company right now so you dodged a bullet

like

Sounds like it was a challenging & not very fair experience DP OP. It's always so hard when you put in the effort but the people you are interviewing with don't show the same level of respect & effort

like

I got super weird vibes when I interviewed at Huge a few years back.

like

Sounds like utter bullshit, OP.

like

@OP mine wasn't anything specific, just a general bad feeling. And I've learned to trust my gut.

@Account Director Ya, I've started turning down most places that want me to do a writing assignment.
1) that's what my portfolio is for
2) they never give a proper briefing and writing is never done in a vacuum like that

like

Exactly, OP. We're not in high school and they don't get to give me an exam. If they can't ascertain my qualifications from live interviews, references and how I carry myself and speak, they're idiots I don't want to work for. And I haven't been asked where I see myself in 3-5 years in a long time because I'm usually the one asking first what are the long-term career prospects of this position? What are your plans for supporting my growth?

like

Related Posts

like

Deloitte experienced hires, who all received written offers and in process of visa/ onboarding, have you heard back anything about hiring freeze? Or recruiter asked you to delay joining date?

My visa got submitted couple of days back and waiting for decision. When I reached out to recruiter to give her an update and mentioned once there’s decision will discuss on the start date before putting my 2 weeks, she mentioned “Yes, we should talk before you put notice” - Am I overthinking? Deloitte

like

Hey Everyone, I’m interviewing with Accenture strategy (UK) for a manager role. Can someone please provide the salary range for a manager

like

Hello Everyone,
Would someone be willing to refer me for a position in Salesforce at Hyderabad ? I am looking at Program Manager roles currently with 9 years of experience.

Many many thanks in advance

like

Hi All ,

Is anyone working in Fujitsu as associate technical service engineer ? I was interviewed for Azure & windows admin profile but the designation mentioned as Infrastructure Associate technical service engineer . I'm wondering if this is okay ?

Thanks,
Nagarjun

Hi Fishes,
How long does it take to release offer letter from HSBC. I already have given HR round and submitted documents for background verification.

like

Last month someone from Natwest posted an opening on a linkedin professional network, I sent him my CV. After couple of days 2 rounds of interview happened and I was told that I am selected, salary was discussd and he told me that offer letter will be released soon. No commumication was done over email. Was he a fraud?

How do I leave my role as someone on the talent team. I am on a small recruitment team of only a few people, who connect daily. I am also responsible for sending out updates tracking new hires and upcoming leavers (aka I would be on this list if i decide to leave). If I am looking to leave my company, considering all of these things, how do I do it in the least awkward, most professional way possible? I want to put in at least a two week notice, but will continuing my work after that be weird?

like

Anyone have any suggestions on how to break into this field as a mid-level commercial litigator? I was thinking of taking the CIPP-US test but would that be enough to get some interview traction?

like

hi all, currently have two offers:

1: EY - FDD, home city, very good $$ for FDD

2: PwC - post-merger integration, DDV team (essentially M&A Consulting) - bigger city, always been keen to move

Coming as a Senior in Audit, with recent FDD exposure (2 deals, obviously not much). I was looking for something more than just number crunching, wanting a mix of quant / quali / strategic work. M&A Advisory or a Corp Strategy role is where I'm looking to end up long term.

Thanks in advance!

like

I’m Looking for a flexible 100% globally Remote opportunity in either of these:

Project Management
Scrum Master
Delivery Manager
Digital Manager

Any help would be greatly appreciated🙏
Please like to push the app to share.

likesmarthelpful

What are some key changes or additions you made to your LinkedIn which resulted in more recruiters reaching out?

like
like

Has anyone moved to ireland or visited for a long period of time. A role is opening up there and I have the potential to move. What are some things that I should consider. Currently live in SF, CA

like

Let’s say you have a project that you charge hourly for. The briefing itself/getting acquainted w the project was a solid hour. Do you charge for that hour?

smarthelpful

This query is w.r.t to TCS, After the interview call, how many days does it take to get a call from HR. Will there be any change in status over TCS ibegin portal to understand the status of candidature ?

like

can anyone please share @CitiusTech MR round general questions? today i hvae MR round.

like

Can anyone refer me to any openings for Oracle Fusion/EBS Finance Functional role ?

like
like

More Posts

Do anyone know what are the wfh kits will be provided by Hexaware for experienced employees who is joining newly to organization?
Any ideas?

Hi Fishes,
+Repost
I have 6 years of experience and have offers from the below companies, Help me on selecting the same?
I am getting a headache as my last date is approaching. Please Help me before Jan 18.

Company, project, CTCdetails are below.

Value Labs - Banking(Fullstack) - 19Fixed + 2LPA
NTT Data - Well Fargos (React) - 20 + 3LPA
Hexaware - Amaze Banking Project (reactjs,AZURE) - 20+2 LPA
GSPANN - Sports E-commerce (AWS, MERN) - 20+2 LPA

Any tips for having to attend a team lunch and a separate happy hour while fasting? Outside of Ramadan happy hours aren’t awkward bc I’ll just drink soda or something. However, now do I just sit there and stare at them when they are drinking/munching on their lunch ? 😂

like

EY Hey fish, has anyone recently got their H1B visa stamped in Dubai / Abu Dhabi, but is not a resident of UAE? Would love to hear about your experience. Thank you!

Hello have a question How much make a lead mobile engineer technician in CBRE in Virginia

likehelpful

Hpe Hr releases an offer letter with joining after 2months. Should I wait or back out? What if they withdraw?

Are interview case studies difficult? Is it done live or is it take-home? What should I expect in terms of content/questions, duration, difficulty?

like

Looking for some recommendations for a day trip in/around Chicago. It's going to be sunny tomorrow! 🌞
Any leads?

like

a question for my fellow asian women - moving there in a few months and wondering how safe you all feel? i know it’s been a scary time with increased hate crimes. open to hearing any insights, tips, experiences. stay safe ❤️

like

Hi

Has anyone from the cognizant registered BH for a car in Pune or Maharashtra? And are they allowing it? As per rules its allowed but I heard RTO is declining the request

How is a Partner’s sales bonus at your firm calculated? Also, what if multiple Partners have connections at the same client when a sale is made? How is the bonus fairly distributed?

like

What clients does Nagarro have? Indian? US? European? Spreaded accross the world?

like

I have many options to consider but two options below are what I’m thinking of right now.

I want to see your thoughts on which one I should pick.

Job A: Project Engineer. 135K/yr base. 10% signing bonus.

Job B: Senior Project Manager. Contract. $60/hr standard. $90/hr overtime.

Additional Information added / pinned in the comments.

Hi Fishes,

What is criteria for IJP after joining BNP...
I have joined in may 2022, but not liking the work i am doing, its basically different than my expertise, by when i will be able to apply for IJP?

like

I've read through every one of these threads and used the observations / advice I've seen here paired with my own research to get "into the game." It seems like Ripple, Monero, Gnosis, and Golem are the ones worth being in outside of the "big 3" (not MBB). I also bought $1000 worth of ethereum at $210 yesterday because I thought that was a good price, but it's only continued to fall... is that a long term hold or should I convert it to Gnosis or something else?

like

Bain & Company Heard MBB offices in Amsterdam have some of the best wlb in europe, anyone working there can confirm?

McKinsey & Company Boston Consulting Group Bain & Company

like

Hi Folks, my counselor informed me I am being moved from Senior 1 to Senior 2 but rating is progressing. Is that good or bad ?

like

Additional Posts in Advertising

@MAL LA creatives, how's your experience been working for apple?

like

Just when I think Facebook has no more room to grow... it adds another 100mm daily active users. At what point does Facebook become simply too big to fail?🤔

like

Fishbowl gentlemen, what are you wearing to your holiday party? 👔👗👙👘🎩

like

What is the one firm or agency you'd like to work at?

like

Will Ferrell and Wix. Nicely done.

like

Anyone know good headhunters for finding In-House gigs at Tech/Startups?

like

Layoffs at grey?

like

What other companies are an option for a digital producer besides advertising?

like

Have you ever used topresume or wonsulting services? Does it make sense to pay them?

like

What's the quickest you've gotten a job, from first interview to offer letter?

like

Waiting for the Avon shit storm LOL

Post Photo
likefunny

Can you be hospitalized for exhaustion?

like

With so many layoffs and the strange uncertainty of this industry right now—is anyone scared to death?

likehelpful

Just started Succession. Does the world of advertising have a family similar to the Roys?

likesmartfunny

After going through a round or two of interviewing with an agency, how can you let them know you're not interested without burning bridges?

like

Say "Ice Bucket Challenge" again. SAY IT AGAIN.

like

Anyone know anything about the people, work, or culture of R/GA Tokyo?

like

How common is being told to lie to clients about the number of current staff or about the abilities of current staff? For example, promising services that no one at the agency is able to do?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal