Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at
Highlighted IconHIGHLIGHTED

Case interviews are, in my opinion, they best indication of talent you get in the recruiting process. How else are you going to test critical thinking? Unless you want to rely solely on a resume plus test scores - which provides a big advantage to traditional backgrounds (who tend to be less diverse).

like

I think you can learn much more by asking good behavioral questions. I once worked in a research heavy economics role and the questions were all about my senior thesis, how I collected the data, how I cleaned it and verified it, the code I used to analyze it, etc. Not everyone in management consulting has that sort of quantitative experience but I think you can modify the questions to really probe how someone has worked on real problems in the past. I think case studies still have value, but the really seem more about how someone can package a simple analysis rather than solve problems.

like
Recent IconRecent

Where are you quoting the “require case interviews…” from?
I read the article and didn’t see it there. The article is great - nuanced, asking the right questions, and suggesting alternatives. I agree that the case method is overused in consulting.
I think your commentary is a bit strange. For instance, the charge of “elitism”. Consulting firms are unabashedly elitist. It’s part of their value prop: “we’ll send a team of people that went to Harvard to your factory in [insert non coastal state]”

like

Again, consulting is a joke. Quite frankly could hire fresh high school graduates and really save costs. Nothing that a tech savvy high schooler couldn’t do. Basically white collar factory work.

likefunny

I’ve made this argument for almost a decade now - the major consulting firms should just hire kids out of college into a work-study type program. The kids get an education in stuff actually useful for a career in consulting or tech and they get paid vs being saddled with debt. Companies get cheaper labor.

like

What? That quote is not in the article and there's nothing in there about white men being favored by the case study interview process. Don't make something racial for no reason.

Consulting recruiting is elitisit in general. That's the entire point and the value prop. Nobody would hire or want to work for MBB if they were not elitist gatekeepers. If anything one can argue that the case is a meritocratic way to find people who are willing to do the prep work to do well on them, given the amount of free content there is out there on case interview prep.

That said I'm skeptical about how much value there really is in using case interviews in consulting recruiting. Anecdotally, I've sometimes done quite well on case type interviews when I didn't prepare at all, and sometimes not well after preparing a lot. I suspect that it's a quite "noisy" signal of ability.

like

That’s the point - case interviews don’t prove innate talent or intelligence, nor does doing well prove that you do your homework. Instead, they allow the interviewer to use their own gut instincts to decide who gave the best answer. Sometimes that gut instinct may be racially biased, whether the interviewer knows it or not.

However, as the article pointed out, it’s different when the question has defined good or bad answers determined ahead if time, so it’s harder for those biases to creep in.

like

Honest Q: how could the authors have performed the research that leads to this conclusion given that, by definition, they do not have information about the job performances of people who failed the case interview? How could you do this without that data?

I’m not saying case interviews are great, they’re not.

like

It said somewhere in there that they had a meeting with a European economist who did have data. Though not a lot of information on how that person acquired it.

Facts

like

I’m glad this got some traction. Just want to make folks aware that case study interviews are a high barrier of entry and you’re missing out on diverse talent who can show their problem-solving skills through other ways (behavioral questions, presentation of past work). You’ll probably get more creative thinking and work than someone who can just memorize those case solving frameworks.

like

Solving a case is the most similar interview experience I can imagine to what I do as a strategy consultant day to day. So yes, aptitude. It is similar to being asked to role play in a sales interview, code in a software interview, or build a model in a PE interview.

And the whole point is it’s a framework that helps people from a variety of backgrounds show that they can be structured and logical problem solvers.

Case interviews do one thing very well - they help identify people who are not going to be successful consultants. Regardless of how well they can bullshit a resume.

like

The article mentions nothing about race. Quit race baiting.

The quote is not from the article — it’s from a friend. It rang true to me — despite having succeeded in strategy jobs in boutique firms and in-house, I’ve never applied to management consulting because of the case interviews (I’m not a white guy). I then tried to research whether case interviews were in fact indicative of anything and found this.

A1 one of which is that people from traditional backgrounds will have resources they can call from help, while a lot of more diverse hires would not!

Related Posts

Thoughts on mobile retargeting? This has been recently added to my role and I’m curious if this will become more popular with the major increase in phone/tablet use

I am a former employee of Indian Railways PSU and want to join consulting with little experience. Is there anyone working in top consulting firms who can review my profile and refer me.


Any sort of help will work because I am in need of a job right now

like
like

I have 10+ years experience in digital production at agencies, but wasn't been able to land a job at one of the top production places.

I'm thinking of applying for Senior PM at Media Monks (also got lots of PM experience and just doing my PMP). Is that a suicide for my production career? I'm generally more interested in production than PM.

like

I have an offer for a PE Ops role and whilst comp is good it seems like they're hiring a pool of internal consultants to leverage for implementation projects within specific PortCos and therefore I won't be driving initiatives centrally - is this standard practice for Ops roles?

At this point I think I'll turn it down given I'm looking for something that operates more centrally (driving not implementing myself)

like

Can somebody refer me for SCRUM master position in Tech Mahindra.
I am PSM 1 certified as well as currently serving notice period

like

Is it possible to apply to or be referred to more that one role JPMorgan Chase India? I have 4 years of experience in Tax and have been trying to switch industries based on professional education (ACCA-Completion Jan 2023). I see 3 profiles on their portal that I qualify for and I was wondering how many I can apply to or ask a referral for. I know Goldman Sachs only allows to be referred to one. Is the same here? Thank you so much in advance!

like

Hey I have a React interview coming up for ZS Associates? What is the pattern of the interview and kind of questions they ask?
ZS Associates

like

Hi! I am at the case study stage for a role at a company that is UK-based. I am in the US and I'm not sure how salary should compare. The role is slightly junior to my current role, so I am expecting lower comp, however it is SIGNIFICANTLY lower (50% less than what I currently make).

The role and the company are exciting, I've loved my discussions with the manager...would I be crazy to consider that much of a pay cut?

Are the benchmarks so different between UK and US that this is reasonable?

like

To anyone who has successfully gotten an offer… how many stories did you prepare? Assuming 5-6 total interviews.

like

LTI hiring for on below roles
Please DM for referrals.

Post Photo
like
like

I have been in my position for 27 years and have never seen such a state of affairs as I have this year (but then, with the pandemic, who has, right?) Well, long story short, we've gone hybrid (some in person, some online). The teacher has been out with surgeries and covid. I have been teaching both groups at the same time. Sometimes a sub for help, sometimes not. I love the kids, but really?

Starting my first in-house counsel role after 5 years in biglaw on October 31. Any best practices tips or other pointers would be so appreciated.

like
like

Has anyone ever negotiated a salary for a contract role?

like

hi! I have a first round interview for an Advisory and Financing IB role at a French bank (super happy bc it’s my dream role)
How should I prepare? Any advice regarding the behavioral and technical part is highly appreciated! ❤️ Thanks

like

Anyone here who can refer my friend for HR Executive role?. She is an MBA Graduate In HR and having 2 years Recruitment experience. Any opportunities for her?

like
like

More Posts

Has anyone taken an online animation / video editing course before? My company will likely sponsor one but I’m not sure where to start. Would love to learn basics in premier and after effects pretty much. Thanks!

like
like

I think WW and MTCH are strong calls going into earnings. The momentum they both demonstrated from previous earnings should continue

funny

Can we claim jio fi data card internet expense under bcp internet expenses?

HR dept during fun events

Post Photo
likefunny

Is it excessive to counter offer 20% more for a job oppy? What's an appropriate range?

like

I thought Martha's vineyard was in Virginia (part of Washington's estate) until i was 20. For reference I'm from the south so never went and would see southern ppl wearing vineyard Vines sometimes and figured it had to be south of the mason Dixon line

funnylikehelpful

I accepted a $115K base salary, 13% bonus, 10k sign on bonus (scientist supervisor) job and two weeks later, got a $135K base, 17% bonus, and 15K sign on bonus (Senior scientist role) offer from another company. Should I accept the new offer ? How do I tell the previous company about this? Also, I’ve already negotiated with the first company and the $115K base is the negotiated salary. I really do not prefer one company over the other. They’re both great! I’m very confused here. TIA🙏

likeupliftingsmart

Has anyone stayed at any of the AC Marriott properties in Italy?

like

HI

I have interview Scheduled at L4 Technical F2F

recuritor said it will be the managerial round

So I am curious what will be asked ?

like

What’s the best food truck park near downtown to bike to?

Who is the ideal candidate for the Democrats in 2020? Please provide a reason based on experience, record, or platform. Nothing regarding gender or race.

smart

Has anyone ever take a leave of absence due to mental health? If so, how did your team/hr react? Did they make you use the pto you had for part of it? Did you go back after or get a new job? Did the break help? Any guidance or experience shared is greatly appreciated! Thank you.

like

Best neighborhood for couple in their late 20s with 3300k budget?

like

No billable work

I’ve had full days but I’m having some ZERO billable days lately (1-3 days). We outsource our discovery work and it’s been slow for me. My colleagues seem to stay busy with other things… I obviously told the partners I can take more work. I’m worried. What do you do?

like

What is the salary range for Real Estate Tax Senior (NYC office) at EY?

I have AUD scheduled on 6/25 but I’m only on A2 (Becker). Is it worth to postpone the exam post 7/1 with the exam changes? I work full time in tax so I know AUD is going to be a hard one..

like

Hi everyone! I’m looking to pivot from change management (2yoe) to product management. Any tips on how to tailor my resume for a product management role at Capital One?

funny

Additional Posts in Consulting

Any recommendations for a good but reasonably priced ergonomic office chair for home?

helpful

Has anyone stayed at any of the AC Marriott properties in Italy?

like

Submitted 7 expense reports yesterday so I'm not frantic at year end on Thursday before my vacation 🙌🏼 little wins in life

like

0 change fees for 24 hour united rebook with my status. can i rebook from thurs to fri, then fri to sat?

I am a Manager in Salesforce practice at D and I have 15 YOE and 5 years in Salesforce and at 145k base at D. Is it reasonable to expect a Senior Manager or Director role at pwc or accenture or other top consulting firms with a 30% hike? I took my current role at D at the start of the pandemic and got myself a bad bargain which is why I am looking to move.

like

Is Accenture's pay structure for strategy now in line with MBB? I think analysts are about the same. What do "consultants" make, without MBA? Engagement manager? Principal?

like

Me on Friday afternoon at the office: 👍😀🍻 Dilly dilly! Me on Monday morning on the way to the airport: 🛑✈️📉😓To the pit of misery, Dilly dilly!

like
like

Ethics: Incorrect vs illegal. Do consulting people you work with characterize their missteps that are illegal as technically incorrect but not illegal to side step punishment? Both unethical?

like

How do reviews work at your firm? What’s the frequency, what questions are asked, etc?

like

Better than a promotion:

Finding out the certain someone you worked with for your entire career and hated, gets fired 😌

likefunnyupliftingsmart