Struggling to decide between Strategy& and Kearney (similar comp) - any guidance on reputation, exit ops, wlb, culture is appreciated!

S&:
- PE value creation = strong exits in PE ops or MBB
- Unsure of assoc. w PwC / too focused on ODD / long hours / moderate travel / high turnover

K:
- ATI practice = strong MBB or industry exits
- Slow historical growth / too supply chain & procurement focused / long hours / moderate travel

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

You can never be too supply chain and procurement focused..
I’m in PE ops and this is like 90% of what I focus on now lol

likesmarthelpful

Kearney every day of the week.

Not sure how strong the Strategy& PE practice is, but they did not have one until hiring an ex-Bain Partner 1.5 years ago.

Also the PwC Audit infrastructure creates barriers for strategy consulting in all dimensions of the operating model.

likesmartfunny

Yea what an off base statement. PE has been a strong practice for a long time

like

Also Kearney brand is on the up and up big time. I’d say 4 years ago it was kinda in the pits but the amount of interest from MBA hires is at a 5 year high from my perspective

likehelpful

S& is still part of a big four. K is definitely the way to go.

like

Go K really not close…dealing with B4 independent is a nightmare as you move up

like

Having been with K for 30 years, I can tell you:
- amazing growth in past 5 years
- very diverse work
- great culture, no nonsense + friendly

like

That’s relative… amazing growth when compared to previous years + it’s insignificant when you compare it to the growth of competitors (over 5x only in the last year). K has remained the same size in the last 15 years.

K was a good place, but recently become very political. No sure about no nonsense / friendly part.

like

Kearney ATI has the best culture in the firm IMO - great set of partners and better WLB than other practices from my experience.

like

Kearney’s unique position as a truly independent strategy firm solidified my choice between the two

like

I used to be at Kearney so happy to provide some 3rd party perspective - feel free to DM as well!

Bottom line is both are great options. Would say that S& has a stronger brand but not a huge difference. Also larger alumni network is you count PWC (and legacy Booz as well). Culture at Kearney might be better, but that’s very subjective. There are also IMO very real benefits of being at a true consulting firm through and through as opposed to an audit giant that happens to also do consulting. This matters more if you’re gunning for partner down the road (mostly irrelevant otherwise).


As you note, both will be long hours. Obviously very project dependent. ATI is on the better end of hours though compared to other practices (but ATI DDs are brutal).

ATI is a great practice - great talent and definitely some cool projects. Project type also varies by specific ATI vertical - for example, in auto, I can tell you the work is almost solely procurement / supply chain. There are other ATI verticals with more strategy work though.

Agree on slower historical growth for Kearney, but will say that under Alex’s leadership, the firms been growing well. Not MBB pace but finally more consistent growth in like with the OWs and S&’s of the industry.

Also, would say you’ll be fine going for PE ops down the road from either, so wouldn’t sweat it. The ops experience is definitely helpful for that type of work!

like

Which team did you vibe with harder? Both are solid firms.

like

We send a lot of people to PE Ops as well

like

ATI at Kearney not my practice but great group of people.

Growth in the last few years has been strong

like

They’re both good places. Obviously from the comments above, people here really like it and each other. But if you vibe better at Strategy&, go there. It’s really most important you’re with you’re people. Job is fun in that case, otherwise it can be a drag.

like

Based on your comparative factors I think you answered your own question.

like

If your goal is to work at MBB why don’t you just apply there?

like

Agreed

Not in PEVC, but have a negative opinion of my group’s culture. Want to feel good about the work I do and the hours I put in, but partners and directors make me feel like trash on a daily basis. I did get a great rating and bonus to my surprise, but would sacrifice this for incrementally nicer people and stronger mentorship.

like

I’m guessing you’re in FS?

Avoid PE VC at Strategy&. I'm here and wouldn't recommend it.

I’m also in PEVC and I really like it here. Not to say your opinion is invalid, but it would be more helpful to note what you don’t like. All the pods work differently, so experienced on the team vary dramatically (though I suspect this would be true at any firm)

Work flexibility at s& is pretty great

Related Posts

What's the Hike and Bonus this year for PwC AC (Bangalore)

like

What is the difference between an illegal Hiring Hall Agreement & Software Certification?
For example, a software company issues its own certification that its partners enforce as a requirement to work in the industry by searching that software's website for ensure applicants have certification. To legally recommend who can work, a Hiring Hall is required to be certified by the majority of workers in construction or garment industries. How is software certs able to avoid this law?

Needing advise. I have been at my new company for 3 months and I hate it. So much to hate too much to type up. So I’ve been applying around and I actually got an interview for my dream position today. How do I explain this current situation? I heard it’s not good to bash other companies but I genuinely do not know how to explain why I want to leave without my current company getting bashed. Should I just put it all out there or keep it vague?

likeuplifting

I have an interview scheduled for Backline Technical Support Engineer- L2. Can someone help me with the salary range for the position. I have 5years of experience

like

So stuck. What do I do? I joined this firm a year ago (4 yrs exp total) to grow/get more court/client exposure. Then 2 more-experienced associates were hired, pandemic, & all cases are divided between the other 2. I have no defined tasks except deficiency letters or the odd pro bono case. Boss claims it's mentoring. I still need to meet bill req.

Last wk Boss said I'll do more & my work was good, but today said I can't 2nd chair bc I don't have experience. I'm doing less now than my prior firm.

like

Hello! I’m chatting with a head of finance about a senior finance manager role reporting to them. How do I know if it’s an l6 or l7? Thank you

like

I am contemplating a new offer for Validation Lead role (non- managerial) at a Big pharma, with 4 years experience -post masters degree. Suggestions on what the compensation should look like ?

like

Employment post college: will internship experience or type of degree earned speak more to employers? I’m a psych major & landed a wealth & investment internship with Wells Fargo. I’m trying to break into consulting fields.

like

Accepted an offer of employment with a mid-sized firm to begin in a couple of months. I’ve always wanted to shoot for big law but haven’t had the opportunity thus far. Overall, I accepted because I didn’t want to take the opportunity for granted in addition to the uncertainty with hiring due to covid. Would it be an issue to shoot for a big law opportunity in the interim? I know how this looks and sounds, so I definitely don’t want to set a precedent that I deal in bad faith.

like

Anyone else having issues booking nights with Marriott rewards? Nothing seems available anywhere for June

like

Is an MBA really worth it for a career pivot?

like

Anyone at KPMG willing to refer to Tech Consulting team? 8 YOE, looking for SM referral in Dubai. Happy to connect on LinkedIn and share cv etc. Thanks in advance

Appreciate for product designer referral

Hi, I’ve just completed some ui/ux courses from udemy and 30% into ux bootcamp. Saving account running dry, would appreciate if anyone could refer me for an entry level product design position. Thanks!

like

Hi Amazonians,
I am looking for guidance.

I am going to start interview process with Amazon next week. Probably all rounds will be done in 1-2 day time frame.

How/what should I prepare for interview?
Am clueless on what kind of ds & algo questions, system design questions are asked in Amazon interviews.

My techstack: javascript developer- react+Angular.

1. Pls guide me on what/how to prepare?
2. Also, will the interview be solely on da & algo and javascript; or on Js frameworks?

Amazon

like

Looking to make a move. Anyone hiring?

helpful

So here is my dilemma:
- based in the UK
- opportunity for lateral internal move (culture&engagement) or stay where I am (reward). I am mid level IC struggling to progress due to flat structure so considering lateral move then hopefully up from there.
- 2 primary aged children, currently have flexibility in current/new role too
- Husband just got accepted on a international rotation which means I will be single parent for the short term.

What to do? Go with the unknown or coast comfortably?

like

Any tips to get smarter about analytics and better at critical thinking as I get more senior in my role? I feel like my media department coworkers ask better questions and have better solutions (as they should). I have substantial knowledge like Google Analytics and various campaign metrics, but feel short compared to colleagues. Curious what courses, newsletters, etc may help.

likesmart

Hello looking to get into a bigger role, looking at hr generalist role, remote. Is anyone hiring?

like

I work at a medical device manufacturing plant as a training coordinator, I have a military background and a degree and am trying to advance but am feeling stuck. I am a literal jack of all trades, and am trying to get out of the hourly life, I’m working an average of 100 hour weeks and have been for at least the last 6 months.

like

Hi All need your valuable inputs i have an offer in hand for BA role with TCS for 16LPA going through the interview process for FIS how much can I ask or expect from FIS?

like

More Posts

More appropriate yesterday but still made me lol.

Post Photo
likefunny

I've just 12 hrs to think about this -- Oracle or Freecharge ?? Work profile with Oracle is development of oracle jet framework and with Freecharge merchant app with freecharge Please help yaaro

what are some technical skills/knowledge i need to get into FDD? i’m a cpa, non audit background

Thoughtworks usa how long after the interview processedo you get the response for me it’s been 2 days still no feedback. I applied for the entry level BA

like

If you are looking to switch jobs in NYC, I can refer you to a great responsive recruiter. Copywriters, digital analysts etc, bunch of roles. Got me a nice sweet gig and process was smooth. Dm me

like

Grieving a long term relationship that just ended … thought it was ending in marriage. For those that have been married for a long time (any age group). Can you please share some of your wisdom towards sustaining a marriage for these many years and handling hard times ?

like

How are SAP projects in PwC?
I have Accenture and PwC
Pls suggest

like

Anyone work in real estate or familiar with the Realogy rebrand to Anywhere? Curious about opinions.

like

Successful hunt with my dad today. Super excited about the Larceny Barrel Proof.

Post Photo
like

MDs in FDD, how much are you making?

like

Do anyone has any idea about doing PGDM course from symbiosis Nagpur?

like

Does anyone know how to break into HR? I have a bachelors degree, 1.5 years management experience over union employees where I did scheduling, payroll, etc and I have 1.5 years of recruiting experience. I feel like all the jobs I see on LinkedIn are requiring an HR degree and certifications.

like

Hi guys...
What salary should I expect in the market currently
I have a total of 5 yoe in python(data analysis,warehousing,pipelines)/ETL and almost same experience in ci/cd tools and databases(single store and Oracle) i have good financial domain knowledge too.
My current CTC is 13.5 all fixed
My current organization wants to retain me and they have confirmed for my Canada on site over mail...
I am not that interested for Canada

Please suggest what package should I be looking for
Thanks

like

My brother is looking to change his bank. Let it be any other bank or finance department in IT company.

Currently he is working in KVB in forex department.

What should be his plan to achieve this? LinkedIn is not working for him.

Any leads would be highly appreciated.

like

Recs for sushi places in dallas!?

like

Happy Monday Lisa everyone!

Post Photo
likefunny

I want a house plant that looks like this. Any ideas or recommendations?

Post Photo
like

Those who left US and kept their US bank, how are you managing accounts abroad without US phone number? Isn’t it requested for every verification process ?? I don’t intend to keep US phone so that’s my concern (I’ll be using capital one)

like

Elementary art teachers. I have been teaching the artabet from Ron Mulvey out of Canada. He teaches 6 basic lines to learn and how to draw using the lines. Round and round, back and forth, up and down, zigzag, wiggle wiggle and dot dot dot. It has been a success for me.

like

I need air pods. For Android. What should I buy?

Additional Posts in Consulting

If your entire team went on strike and stopped showing up/doing work to get higher pay, better "conditions", etc. what would happen to you? Get fired? The firm acquiesces and fulfills your demands?

like

Anyone here have experience, or have any knowledge about, working at an internal strategy team at a Big Law firm? Interested in making a switch into strategy, but unsure if working at law firm is the correct move. Thanks!

like

Any recs for a good quality standing desk that doesn’t break the bank? Ideally looking for something on the larger side (debating if a corner / L shape desk would be better than a standard rectangle, but either way want plenty of room for monitors, 2 laptops, notebooks / paperwork etc). TIA for any recs and/or brands to avoid!

like

Why do people marry?

like

Fucking hate Delta. Missed my flight. I was with my 4 months old 👶 daughter. She was hungry and crying I requested em to let me check in bag early instead waiting in Line. They said no. Morons.

like

Quitting a job after working only 3 months, should I list it on the resume?

like

Is anyone traveling coast to coast every week. How do you make the travel more interesting and less tiring?

like

Where did you learn the most that you use in your professional life? K-12, Undergrad or Grad school?

like

Consulting firms in terms of airlines and their stereotypes? Go! Looking for some humor on Sunday night

like

Better Questions. Better Answers. Better Working World. #SoMuchCoolAid

like

After a year using my home office setup, especially the 27 inch monitor, how can I ever go back to the traveling life with tiny laptop screen? 😔

likesmart

Anyone have any first hand experience of seeing the benefits of putting Big 4 on resume?

like

Do you support video during remote calls? I think sometimes people don’t realize that others aren’t really dressed appropriately and can get on video with no notice

like

May be a stupid question..but how well does the internet work if you buy it on the plane? Flying AA

like

I feel I have less patience with others bs now. I’m finding it hard to deal with bs. I think it’s because my job demands so much out of me and I’m expecting the same out of others?

like

What % of salary does everyone invest in their 401k?

First year consultant in Chicago making $72k, currently investing 18% with a 3% company match. Wondering if this is too much...

like

2017 raises and bonuses at ey

like

How is utilization at PwC calculated? Have been told if I'm hitting my full capacity per week, it hurts utilization to charge internal codes like excess travel, g&a for other work, and training hours

like

You know what I love? Managers that tell you to do one thing and you do it. Then when a Client, SM, or PPMD questions your actions they go SILENT🙃. No support or explanation , and you’re left to defend yourself/actions. You ain’t Casper or a mute, so don’t act like one🗣.

likefunny

Best protein powder?

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Send download link to your phone

OR

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Messaging rates may apply

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal