Two offers, not sure which to choose. Both in NYC, 4YOE. Any insight would be helpful. Peloton IT business analyst role125k base, 110k equity over 4 years. No bonuses. KPMG senior internal role under data strategy and operations. 122k, 0-7% bonus.

likehelpful
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Peloton… this is easy

like

Why would you say it's an easy decision?

Internal role meaning not client facing? If so, I would go with Peloton - you won't have the same progression or exit opportunities at KPMG in an internal role that you would from a client facing role

Yes, but in a company that sells people's time, the internal/non billable roles are much more expendable than in a company that sells products.

like

Main concern is Peloton having lack of structure, and possibility that my role/responsibilities may change due to unstructured procedures / lack of resources. KPMG concern is whether or not I'd like being in an operational role

Are you looking for a super-structured, clear-cut job? Then KPMG may be the better bet. Peloton, being a younger and fast-growing company, may have more step-up or make-your-own-path opportunities. (From reading your initial message - I, like many others, would say Peloton is the obvious choice.)

KPMG serves you better for an exit in a couple years, assuming you don't have B4 experience already.

This isnt necessarily true, I think you're greatly underrating how well received hot tech companies like Peloton are. This isn't MBB its KPMG. OP I don't think you're "better off" one or another here. I would pick the one you want to do right now for the most money right now. This could be YOUR exit op already. D1 you seriously need a refresher on life perspectives

like

Related Posts

If I got offered a position at a big 4 firm for indirect tax. What do you think the appropriate counter offer would be? Do you think they would accept my counter?

like

Anyone who exited to JUUL? Would love to know culture/comp/work

likefunny

How long do I have to stay to get my year end bonus*? (*if it exists)

like

Hey McKinsey Fish! Is there any real luck of applying to a job on the website? I applied to an implementation role that I know I would be qualified for but without any referral. Been a few weeks so was just hoping to atleast see a rejection 😁

like

Have a little less than 1YOE at my firm (started in Sept) - is it a bad idea to apply now or should I wait to the 1YOE mark? Would it be a bad idea to cold apply? Don't want to miss out entirely on the hiring spree but also worried about being dinged due to relatively little experience. I don't have a lot of connections at the firms but can probably pull together a referral in the next few months with some networking.

like

Share instances where you wanted to say “THAT’S WHAT SHE SAID” when something was said on a conference call. Bonus points if you actually did.

like

Have an in-person interview with Guidehouse for their Health Sector Organizational Strategy Management Consultant - Experienced Associate role. What to expect?

like

What is the range of second year Post MBA comp for MBB?

like

On a new project serving in a Product Manager role, any certifications, courses, books etc you’d recommend?

like

If anyone wants a referral to KPMG Federal, DM me.

like

Anyone know anything about Marakon? Post MBA Comp? Culture? I tried the search function and got nothing. I checked Glassdoor but seems like all of the entries are written by the company itself.

like

Going hourly rate for UX/Experience Director? Please add years of experience, city, and awards. Used to charge $145/hr but that was a while ago (then, 12 yrs, NYC and Boston, top agencies and financial institutions exp, top notch portfolio with deep strategic, UX, IA, interaction and usability work, some awards).

like

Anyone else feel like their actual work is very disconnected from their paycheck? If I do a great job and create a ton of value for the client I’ll get a maximum of a 15% TC increase YOY (much less due to covid). Similarly if I do the absolute minimum it’s really hard to be fired since I’m in a hot market and they can’t decrease my TC without cutting my base pay (which I’m 99% sure they won’t do). And my raise/bonus won’t even necessarily be indicative of my performance anyways.

like

I love this group. For those that receive company equity as part of their comp, what’s your strategy? Do you immediately sell it all and put the cash into index funds?

like

What will be salary band for Accenture Strategy and Consulting at Consultant level in HCOL? 3 YOE - 2 in Industry, 1 in consulting. Glassdoor has varied numbers.

like

Can someone help me with interview questions for tax position at Salesforce? Do they ask tax technical questions or it’s just behavioral/ situational?Salesforce

like

EYP or S&? Culture, comp, opportunities, etc. I am currently in cyber.

like

Any fish familiar with Apple's OPD group? Thoughts on potential exit and expected base comp? MBA with 5 YOE, seems like it might be a step down from MBB Associate comp but tempted by tech exit and work life balance...

like

McKinsey Product Manager - inflated title or respected position?

like

Additional Posts

Strongly prefer working in-person (I’m a people person) but potentially have a great too-good-to-turn-down opportunity that would be fully remote. Advice on how to make WFH better?

like

Best books about product management for a good exit to industry? I already have an MBA and PMP but looking for a refreshed perspective since it’s been years since my formal education. Currently reading “Product Managements Sacred Seven” but it’s geared toward the startup world. I am in healthcare and not looking for a startup role. TIA!!!

like

Need advise from moms of 1 kid on what you did/doing to make sure your kids have social life. My SO comes from a big family so my kid has lots of cousins. All my SOs bro and sis have 2 or more kids so they don’t include my son in most things. It has gone to an extend he doesn’t want to meet fam for holidays or even face time. He gets possessive and annoyed around them. We have been trying for 2nd kid and It’s not easy with multiple rounds of IVF etc . Contd..

like

EY supply chain or customer experience consulting practice? Work, Comp, exit opps.

like

Looking for suggestions on this offer with PWC : 1) Designation : Consulting Manager 2) 158k base + 15k sign on bonus 3) Location : New York City

like

Best excuse to take sudden unplanned PTO

like

Currently a sr. analyst at ACN in strategy looking to make a jump. Anyone willing to make a referral to MBB/OW/ATK/LEK?

likefunny

How much do you keep in your checking acct?

like

Anyone looking for a remote senior AD to start on Monday? My schedule opened up.

like

PwC field for my extension in June 2019. At that time my I-140 wasn’t approved and since I was maxing out on H1B they have applied extension till Feb 2020 (Max Out Period). Continued...

Post Photo

is there anything you can do to a previous supervisor who screwed you over due to discrimination ? Reported her to HR but not enough to get her fired.

likeuplifting

Have the MBB, S&, OW, RB pushed the dates for new joinees in Dubai?

like

Does anyone know if there is anything like short term disability coverage for mental health leave of absence from work?

like

Are you union or non-union?

likehelpfulsmart

Currently not in UAE, but want to move there and apply for MBB firms. Anyone here has successfully done so? Any tips

like

What people data do you regularly report on? How are you providing insights to leaders with it?

like

Do other companies have a cap on internal promotion pay increase?

like

Has anyone ever tried negotiating for more vacation rather than a higher salary? I'm applying and interviewing for jobs right now. Some firms have unlimited PTO while others only give a few weeks. Personally, I'm much more interested in getting an additional week of vacation and would rather negotiate for that but usually only hear of people negotiating for salary. Has anyone had experience with this?

like

I'm tired of getting certifications. Anyone else sick of them? Especially if it's just exam cram. So many people have certs but dont know anything when working on engagements

like

B4 🐠 - How does the comp for an Oracle ERP/EPM associate/manager at B4? Will be a manager at year end at a smaller firm and looking to switch over

like

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
Download Fishbowl to see what others are saying
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the Fishbowl app

Get realtime notifications and see
what's happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.