Anyone struggle with “art vs craft”? Sometimes I feel my lessons don’t carry meaningful art rigor, and I’m just hosting craft time. Any suggestions for recourses providing meaningful art lessons?

like
Posting as :
works at
You are currently posting as works at

Sometimes the ‘craft’ lessons are just plain fun! I don’t expect every one of my lessons to hit the ‘art rigor’ nail right on the head. The craft lessons can often act as a review of concepts learned from an ‘art’ lesson. (Review primary/secondary colors, types of lines, texture, etc...) I have found that some parents (and admin) think that the crafty things coming home is an indication of a good art program (☹️!!)
Process is WAY more important than product, but parents and admin usually don’t see the process, so throw them a craft and don’t feel bad about it but also give them lessons that are just pure art and process.

like

I like to think that all artists are craftspeople, but not all craftspeople are artists. Learning and working towards mastery of the “craft” of the different mediums of Art can be a tedious, repetitive process. Sometimes a “craft project” is a good way to zoom in on particular art-making skills and also makes that learning fun, but it is unlikely for this kind of project to produce something that we teachers, the artist, or a neutral observer would call Art unless of course some personal meaning was struck by that project. It’s why I design my students experiences to be fairly open ended as far as the content that they produce, while I focus on teaching the skills that will allow for their personal expressions to be realized.

likesmart

I think it’s easy to avoid the lower aspects of craft by simply considering outcome: will all the projects look alike? Abort that mission.
Seek open ended activities that allow for individual interpretation rather than step by step, standard outcomes.
Example: Mandalas
Students can work from a template that divides the space of a radial into 8 pie slices with 6-8 concentric rings. Examples of geometric and organic patterns can be prior assignments then used to create a sort of inventory for students to use if they are struggling to create their own. ( Many aspects come into play that hit benchmarks :
Radial design, positive and negative space, line, pattern, color, even cultural background of Indian mandalas).

likehelpful

always connect it to an artist, art history, or a state standard! sometimes I love doing cutesy pinterest crafts in my classes. as long as its connected somehow to my curriculum I feel comfortable.

likeuplifting

As a potter I can relate to your frustration. 'Unpack' your state standards, sometimes a quick reflection of the goals and targets helps. include what the craft is about, where did it come from,... history, content and context, audience etc. many simple projects can actually hit upon many standards. Don't be bullied by Math, Science and Eng. they are core, we are fun.

Principles and Elements, craftsmanship, Content and meaning, Critique.

Related Posts

What kind of lesson plan forms do you use?

like

Hello! I’m new at PBL learning. Where can I find already prepared lessons? I’d like to use other teachers’ successful lesson plans before I try to create my own.

like

SOS I’m a first year teacher. I’m at a VERY challenging school district & a different culture than I’ve ever been around before. I cant get through a full day’s lesson! I spend more time disciplining!

like

I taught the math lesson so abominably that the vice principal (who was observing at the back of the classroom) took over my lesson. How do you recover after a terrible day at work?

like

How do you best support your students who do not speak English? I have four ELL’s in my 6th grade ELA class and they don’t receive push-in or pull-out Bilingual support during my class. Do you pull them for small group to provide instruction separately or do you just try to use google translate to translate your lessons and the work? Any best practices? I’d love some help.

likehelpful

Marketing leaders at startups: at what point did you make your first dedicated product marketing hire? What lessons did you learn? Did you do it too early? Too late? Didn’t hire senior enough?

like

You just finished teaching a skill / topic in your lesson. Children are now off to work on that skill independently: who are you targeting first to support, your students in the red or your students in the yellow?

like

How do you earn $500k and still feel average?

likefunnyupliftinghelpful

What to read or watch before first flight lesson to maximize what I get from it? Got one as a gift. 1hr desk, 1hr cesna

Come see a LIVE chemistry lesson on making ICE CREAM !! Day: 11/19/2020; Time: 5:00 pm EST; Place: Facebook Live (Jonte Lee). For more information, please see the flyer below.

Post Photo

I’d like to get golf lessons as a gift for my husband. We live 30 mins north-west of Boston. Any suggestions on how I can find a really great golf instructor?…

like

How do you best support your students who do not speak English? I have four ELL’s in my 6th grade ELA class and they don’t receive push-in or pull-out Bilingual support during my class. Do you pull them for small group to provide instruction separately or do you just try to use google translate to translate your lessons and the work? Any best practices? I’d love some help.

like

Check out my Instagram live Question and Answer about Piano, Flute and Violin lessons Sun June 6 at 7:30 my instagram page is helenes_notes! Last weekend I did a Facebook live on the same subject in case you cant make it in a couple of weeks you can check out my Helene's Notes Facebook page! If your interested in lessons feel free to call me at 516-474-6181

What has been the best lesson you’ve ever taught?

More Posts

Hello Guys,

I joined
Cognizant recently, the project interview calls which I am getting is not from my base location.
I have the location constraint, should I wait for the right opportunity or raise this concern to ADP team so they can look in to it?

As per ADP policy, one should not have any constraints and take the project as FCFS basis.
Cognizant

like

Literally all of my LinkedIn connections are recruiters lmao

likefunny

Is Visa a stingy company?

like

Anybody here (or your spouse) on an L2 EAD and not received the renewal before your current one expires? What did you / your employer do?

like

Guys is it better to join Barclays as a business analyst from Credit Suisse, considering current situation of Credit Suisse? I am clueless right now.

What is the general consensus on online I/O psychology programs? I’m looking to pivot into HC consulting and am strongly considering USC’s online MAPP or Harvard Extension School’s I/O Psychology graduate program.

like

Taking GMAT tomorrow early morning. Any suggestions what I should do now? Keep practicing or getting some rest instead?

like

One of our surgeons is always walking around with a bluetooth headset...not a fan

like

Which luxe car do you own/ lease? I’m gravitating towards leasing a Mercedes.

like

after receiving the portal link to accept the offer letter, what is the deadline to I accept it?

like

I feel like the stereotype about being an introvert and an accountant don't apply to black ppl. Everyone I met that's an accountant is LOUD, okay lol

like

Someone teach me how to flirt! How do I let this guy know I’m into him?

like

Does anyone have recommendations for free or free trial media planning resources that would be helpful to use/reference for a student project?

What should I put in e signature tab in Barclays onboarding portal for accepting the offer? I'm getting validation error - personal data e-signature has failed.

like

Anyone know of labor & employment boutique firms in LA with a good work culture (I currently work for an AM Law 100 L&E specialty firm in SF and looking to move to LA but somewhere where I can still have some semblance of a life)

like

Hi everyone, I work for large startup (300 employees) and I have been asked to develop a Progressive HR manual template. Some examples include gender neutral restrooms, lactation rooms, signing off emails with pronouns, and etc. Any tips/links for resources to help would be appreciated.

like

Anyone looking for a shared apartment? 250 all utilities included and parking

I have mostly passive investments. I was thinking the other day: what if everyone had only passive investments? Wouldn’t this create incredibly high amount of systemic risk? Are we all sheep??

Does PDM get PTO paid out if we leave?

like

Additional Posts in Art Teachers

Any high school art teachers here?

like

How would you write a report card comment that had concrete feedback that was specific and actionable if your time with the student was coming to an end? (I'd love some examples)

Does anyone teach ceramics? I'm looking to buy new wheels with the last of my budget ($2500) but I need 4-5 of them. I want to buy Brent wheels b/c they're the best but need something more economical.

Yay! Someone joined my group!

like

Anyone recognize the artist who created this?

Post Photo
like

2 weeks into school and now I’m back on a cart. 😢

like

Advice request: Any suggestions for meaningful/engaging early finisher art activities or routines? I teach Pre-K - 8th. Sketchbook time just does not engage them as I had hoped (especially 5-8).

like

High school teachers, to get to know your students and get them to open up, do you have any specific activities?

like

What is your yearly per student budget?

like

Anyone else being used as a building sub? My school cut my classes in half and are making me cover classes on my free periods. Academic teachers don't have to cover classes.

like

High School Independent study student: Do you give them a curriculum, due dates, completed project number, projects/processes to choose from, a final show? What does an ideal student look like to you?

We talk about keeping rigor in our classes, however I’m finding my HS students need straight forward instructions. Most students are struggling to meet their Maslow’s needs that to use higher Blooms seems like a stretch. How are you all supporting creativity and originality in artwork when kids are struggling to keep afloat?

like

What do you all do for an opening day activity?

like

How to cope without a partner to team teach for Fine Arts-art, music and theater arts?

Just thought it was funny

Post Photo
likefunny

Does anyone else use Elmer's paper mache paste seriously what is going on? Do you know of a good replacement? Wheat paste almost always turns into a smelly mold habitat for me.

likesmart

My school deliberately cut the number of classes that the specials teachers teach so that we could be building subs for quarantined and sick teachers (we are hybrid). So... I teach fewer classes (which is a relief because specials teachers teach way more classes than core teachers normally) but I'm pulled for most of my planning periods to babysit classes. I need my planning periods so I can redo my ENTIRE curriculum... and I just feel unappreciated, used, and nothing more than a babysitter.

like

What grade level/ classes does everyone teach?

I teach high school
- studio art
- drawing and painting
And starting next year a new graphic design course. 😊

like

I have 2 classes of middle school I see once a week for 30 mins - we barely can get one project done a quarter - any one else have this issue?

It only took me 7 years to figure this system out.... posting in case it helps anyone else! I color coded my classes and printed off numbers according to the number of kids in my classes. I then assign each kid a number that corresponds with my gradebook. When they turn in their projects, they put their number with it. This way, no contact and I can easily see who has and hasn't turned in their projects yet. I take the list down once they remember their number.

Post Photo
likesmart

New to Fishbowl?

Download the Fishbowl app to
unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.
That was just a preview…
Sign Up to see all discussions
  • Discover what it’s like to work at companies from real professionals
  • Get candid advice from people in your field in a safe space
  • Chat and network with other professionals in your field
Sign up in seconds to unlock all discussions on Fishbowl.

Already a user?
Login here

Share

Embed this post

Copy and paste embed code on your site

Preview

Download the
Fishbowl app

See what’s happening in your industry
from the palm of your hand.

A phone with Fishbowl app

Scan your QR code to download
Fishbowl app on your mobile

Download app

Sign up for free to view this conversation on Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in

Sign up for free to continue using Fishbowl

By continuing you agree to Terms of Use(New) and Privacy Policy(New)
Messaging rates may apply

Already have an account? Log in

For account settings, visit Fishbowl on Desktop Browser or

General

Legal